purged
Journal of Hispanic Higher Education Overview
Title: Purged: Undocumented Students, Financial Aid Policies, and Access to Higher Education
Authors: Daysi Diaz-Strong, Christina Gómez, Maria E. Luna-Duarte, and Erica R. Meiners
Published in: Journal of Hispanic Higher Education, 2011
DOI: 10.1177/1538192711401917
Pages: 107–119
Abstract
This article explores the constraints undocumented students face in pursuing higher education due to the denial of financial aid.
It emphasizes the relationship between federal immigration and higher education policies.
Key findings include:
Undocumented students often finance their education through work, family contributions, limited scholarships, and strategic approaches like working more hours and taking fewer classes.
The stress on undocumented students and their families correlates to Latino retention and graduation rates.
Resumen
Un análisis similar en español sobre la negación de ayuda financiera para estudiantes sin documentos y cómo esto afecta su educación superior y sus tasas de graduación.
Keywords
undocumented students, Latina(o), Hispanic, retention, financial aid, access, higher education policy, low-income, social justice, immigration policy
Financial Aid & Its Impact
The overhaul of the federal student loan process in 2010 has highlighted the costs of postsecondary education.
66% of all undergraduates received some form of financial aid (Wei et al., 2009).
65,000 students from low-income backgrounds lack eligibility for federal financial aid and most scholarships due to unauthorized immigration status (Passel, 2003).
Federal immigration policies do not provide pathways to citizenship, affecting many undocumented students who have lived in the U.S. for years.
Historical Context of Education Access
The article discusses how denying financial aid represents a systemic method of exclusion historically used against marginalized communities:
Examples include the access limitations experienced by African Americans seeking higher education.
Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs) emerged due to racial discrimination in education.
Supreme Court Case: Plyler v. Doe
The 1982 case ruled that states cannot discriminate against students based on legal status in K-12 education.
However, it left ambiguities regarding public education access beyond high school.
Individual states created their frameworks and regulations for undocumented students accessing higher education, leading to inconsistencies nationwide.
State Policies Affecting Undocumented Students
Only 10 states allow undocumented students who graduate from in-state high schools to pay in-state tuition rates. These states are:
California
Illinois
Kansas
Nebraska
New Mexico
New York
Texas
Utah
Washington
Wisconsin
Conversely, some states deny in-state tuition or access to community colleges to undocumented students:
Arizona, Colorado, and Georgia have laws against in-state tuition for undocumented students.
South Carolina and Alabama prohibit undocumented students from attending community colleges altogether.
Changing Dynamics of Access and Support
Low-income Latino families face disproportionate challenges with median income at $34,300 compared to the national average of $50,000. The report indicates a poverty rate of 22.2% for Latinos.
Undocumented students are often constrained by immigration status, which renders them ineligible for federal, most state, and many scholarship opportunities.
Data on Undocumented College Enrollment
Recent Urban Institute data indicates only 7,000 to 13,000 undocumented students enroll in college annually.
Students often demonstrate significant resourcefulness in navigating limited educational access and financial burdens.
Implications for Future Education Policy
Acknowledging the intersection of federal and state immigration and financial aid policies is critical for creating fair access to education.
Proposals such as the DREAM Act attempt to provide pathways to legality and education, though these proposals are currently stalled in Congress.
Methodology of the Study
Research conducted over three years involving 40 oral histories from undocumented Latino students in various academic stages.
Participants self-identified due to the sensitive nature of their immigration status.
Interviews averaged from 30 minutes to 2 hours focusing on educational experiences, family contexts, and future plans.
Coding and analysis of themes were conducted by at least two researchers.
Findings on Financial Contributions and Family Support
Undocumented students often rely on family support, with many contributing financially to tuition costs.
Despite the emotional and financial backing, many families struggle, exerting pressures on students.
Various students shared their challenges in sourcing funds for tuition, resulting in diverse strategies for paying for higher education:
Working part-time jobs
Attending community colleges
Limiting hours taken per semester to manage costs
Impact of Financial Limitations on Educational Decisions
The costs of education weigh heavily on undocumented students, influencing their choice of institutions, reduced class loads, and reliance on part-time study.
Community colleges emerge as key players for accessibility due to lower costs compared to public universities ($2,544 at community colleges vs. $7,020 at public 4-year universities).
Stress Associated with Financial Burden
Students express anxiety over financial obligations, often feeling responsible for easing their families’ economic burdens:
Statements reveal fears of seeking help due to their families already facing financial strain.
Conclusion and Call for Equity
The study stresses that institutions of higher education must adopt transparent policies and proactive measures to support undocumented students.
Partnerships with community resources are essential to pave pathways for educational access.
The overarching call is for immigration reform alongside educational policy improvements to establish systematic equity and resource availability for Latino and undocumented students.
Declaration of Conflicting Interests
Authors declared no conflicts of interest regarding the publication of their findings.
Funding Acknowledgment
Research supported by a faculty research grant from Northeastern Illinois University.
References
A comprehensive list of references supporting the study, including statistical data sources and prior research on immigration and education disparities.
The main argument of the article is that undocumented students face significant barriers in accessing higher education due to financial aid restrictions stemming from federal immigration policies. The methodology involved conducting over three years of research featuring 40 oral histories from undocumented Latino students, exploring their educational experiences and strategies for financing their education. The findings reveal that undocumented students often depend on family support and employ various strategies to fund their education, such as working part-time jobs and attending community colleges, while also experiencing considerable stress related to financial burdens and family obligations.