The Case for Abstraction

Early Art & Representation

  • Historically, art aimed to represent scenes and figures from the real world.
  • About a century ago, artists began to deviate from this representational style.
  • This shift was initially shocking and disorienting, lacking a clear framework for interpretation or appreciation.

The Challenge of Abstraction

  • The central question is how to engage with art that doesn't depict recognizable objects.
  • More importantly, why should we even bother with this abstract art?

The Gradual Shift Towards Abstraction

  • The transition to complete abstraction was gradual.
  • JMW Turner's landscapes hinted at abstraction, showing how real-world subjects could appear abstract.
  • James McNeil Whistler's Nocturne and Victor Hugo's ink drawings also demonstrated abstract qualities.

Influence of the Industrial Revolution

  • The 19th-century Industrial Revolution and the invention of photography transformed life in European and American cities.
  • This transformation influenced artistic representation.
  • Artists began depicting subjects in non-naturalistic ways, abstracting them through stylization, simplification, and flattening.

Early Pioneers of Abstraction

  • Matisse and Derain: Painted familiar subjects with intense colors and broad brushstrokes, leading to the term "Fauves" (wild beasts).
  • Picasso and Braque (Cubism):
    • Broke down still life subjects into geometric shapes.
    • Fragmented the picture plane.
    • Showed multiple sides of an object simultaneously.
    • Revealed more than the eye could see by using multiple perspectives and moments in time.
    • Drew attention to the flatness of the canvas.
  • Italian Futurists: Sought to capture the speed and stimulation of modern urban life, collapsing space and time into single images.
  • German Expressionists (Ernst Ludwig Kirchner): Used unreal colors and abstraction to depict the chaos and anxiety of city streets.

Kandinsky and Spiritual Abstraction

  • Contemporaries like Franz Marc and Vasily Kandinsky drew inspiration from various sources:
    • Tribal art from Africa.
    • Medieval German woodcuts.
    • Russian folk art.
    • Art Nouveau.
    • Children's art.
  • Marc used abstraction to connect with nature.
  • Kandinsky aimed to connect with the spiritual realm.
  • Kandinsky believed art should evoke emotions and feelings through form and color combinations.
  • He argued abstraction wasn't opposed to realism, but a form of realism itself, representing unseen realities like emotion and consciousness.

Malevich and Suprematism

  • Kazimir Malevich developed suprematism, using geometric elements to reach the "zero of form."
  • Suprematism aimed for the "supremacy of pure artistic feeling."

Emergence of Abstraction Before World War I

  • Abstraction emerged through an international network of artists.

Hilma af Klint

  • Swedish painter Hilma af Klint created abstract works as early as 1905.
  • She belonged to "the five", a group that conducted seances to communicate with spirits through pictures.
  • Klint's abstractions were influenced by spiritualism, the occult, science, and the depiction of invisible forces like electromagnetic fields, X-rays, and infrared light.

Theosophy and Thought Forms

  • Theosophist Annie Besant published "thought forms" in 1901.
  • These images illustrated the belief that ideas, emotions, and sounds manifest as visual auras.
  • Kandinsky and others were influenced by this work.

Music as Inspiration

  • Music served as an important parallel to abstraction, being an art form free from representing worldly objects.
  • Kandinsky admired Wagner and Schoenberg.
  • Paul Klee loved Bach.
  • Frantisek Kupka saw a connection between music and painting, believing art could directly affect the soul without the distraction of subject matter.

Other Approaches to Abstraction

  • Robert Delaunay focused on the immediacy and pictorial realities of color and contrast.
  • He was "horrified" by music and noise.
  • His "first disc" was considered the purest abstraction at the time.
  • Sonia Delaunay illustrated a poetry book, blending abstraction and typography, later extending this style into painting and fashion.
  • Piet Mondrian translated subjects into gridded arrangements, replacing spatial illusion with "truth."
  • Mondrian reduced everything to horizontal and vertical lines, revealing the world's structure through binary oppositions.

Abstraction During World War I

  • Paul Klee turned away from the material world during the traumatic years of World War I.
  • Serving in the German army, Klee wrote in 1915 that the more horrifying the world becomes, the more abstract art becomes.

Bauhaus School

  • After World War I, Klee and other abstract artists taught at the Bauhaus School.
  • Founded in 1919 in Weimar, Germany.
  • The school promoted the idea that crafts were equal to art.
  • It aimed to improve the quality of life through architecture, objects, and art.

De Stijl Group

  • Theo van Doesburg and the Dutch De Stijl group advocated a simplified geometric style.
  • They called this "a new plastic art", intended as a universal aesthetic language for everyday life.

Dada and Chance

  • Dada artists like Hans Arp explored chance, creating collages by dropping squares arbitrarily onto paper.

Abstract Sculpture

  • Abstract sculpture gained prominence in Russia, with the work of Vladimir Tatlin.
  • Tatlin emphasized "truth to materials."
  • Alexander Rodchenko exhibited monochromatic paintings in 1921 and declared "it's all over", denouncing painting and fine art.
  • Rodchenko and the productivists aimed to integrate art into life, focusing on poster and ad design.

Continued Evolution of Abstract Painting

  • Abstract painting continued with diverse motivations among artists like El Lissitzky, Marsden Hartley, Joan Miró, and Alexander Calder.

Influence of European Artists in the US

  • During World War II, many European artists fled to the US, including Joseph and Anni Albers, Fernand Léger, Mondrian, Jacques Lipchitz, Hans Hofmann, André Masson, and Max Ernst.
  • Their presence brought new approaches to abstraction.
  • This influx of avant-garde thinking was an important precondition for the success of the abstract expressionists in New York in the 1940s and 50s.
  • Abstract Expressionists drew inspiration from ancient myths, archaic cultures, Jungian psychology, and jazz.

Abstract Expressionism

  • Abstract expressionism was largely improvisational.
  • It aimed to provoke strong emotional responses through large scale and dynamic gesture or expansive fields of color.

Other Developments in Abstraction

  • The Gutai group in Japan embraced the canvas as an arena for action; Kazuo Shiraga painted with his feet.
  • Post-painterly abstraction (Helen Frankenthaler, Morris Louis).
  • Hard-edge abstract painting (Ellsworth Kelly, Kenneth Noland, Belrath, Himes, Agnes Martin, Ad Reinhardt).
  • Op art.
  • Minimalism reduced art to its basic materials.
  • Post-minimalism emphasized unconventional materials and physical processes.
  • Neo-expressionism in the 1980s.
  • Conceptual abstraction in the 1990s.

Abstraction Today

  • Abstraction has been used by many artists for countless purposes.
  • It is no longer an iconoclastic choice but remains a productive field.
  • Contemporary abstract work often builds on past traditions, recycling and reinterpreting approaches to create something new.
  • Abstraction is used to think about technology, its forms and functions, and also to deny technology through tactility and physical presence.
  • Abstraction continues to question how art should be made and how to intrigue the eye and mind.

The Art Market and Abstraction

  • There is some criticism about the art market favoring abstract painting.
  • Abstraction is versatile, acting as a mirror or a window, shifting with the viewer's perspective.
  • Its openness makes it market-friendly and international.
  • Good abstraction rewards extended viewing and evolves with the viewer.
  • This expansiveness can be both beneficial and overwhelming.

The Broader Significance of Abstraction

  • Many core ways of interacting with the world are abstract, such as religion, markets, and currency.
  • Humans have always engaged with abstractions.
  • Abstract patterns appear in cave carvings, pottery, and textiles.
  • Geometric marks and forms have been present throughout history, often dismissed as decoration or relegated to craft.

A Different Perspective on Abstraction

  • The traditional narrative of abstraction is a farce when considering its long history.
  • Abstraction was not so much invented as discovered or accepted.
  • Perhaps the period when humans did not embrace abstraction is the anomaly.