Company Law: Derivative Action Notes

Company Law: Enforcement by Derivative Action

Directors' Duties

  • Directors have duties under the CA 93, s 128 related to the management of the company.
  • These duties include good faith, loyalty (acting in the best interests of the company), and care.
  • Duties are owed within the Company structure: Shareholders -> Directors' duties.

Company Actions Against Directors (CA 93, s 169(3))

  • Shareholders or former shareholders may bring an action against a director for breach of duty owed to them as shareholders.
  • Duties owed to shareholders:
    • s 90: Duty to supervise the share register.
    • s 140: Duty to disclose interests.
    • s 148: Duty to disclose share dealings.
  • Duties owed to the company:
    • s 131: Duty to act in good faith and in the best interests of the company.
    • s 133: Duty to exercise powers for a proper purpose.
    • s 135: Duty to avoid reckless trading.
    • s 136: Duty not to agree to a company incurring certain obligations.
    • s 137: Duty of care.
    • s 145: Duty to not use company information.

Common Law Principle: Foss v. Harbottle

  • If a right is enjoyed by the company alone, the proper plaintiff is the company, not the shareholder.
  • This embodies the principle of majority rule.
  • Shareholders can only exercise the company's right (derivative action) if the board could not have ratified the breach.
  • The board cannot ratify a