American Imperialism: Key Concepts and Events (late 19th–early 20th century)
Global context of late 19th-century imperialism
- Global pattern: European powers build empires; United States follows in late 1800s–early 1900s as a new imperial power.
- Europe’s footprint: scramble for Africa; China divisions and opium trade; Britain’s India empire as a model of economic extraction.
- United States motive: keep a strong sphere of influence, avoid being left behind by peers, and secure trade routes and markets.
- Core ideas shaping policy: Social Darwinism; religious evangelism; belief in republican government as civilizing mission; national security through a powerful navy.
Motives for American imperialism
- Social Darwinism: survival of the fittest among nations justifies stronger nations dominating weaker ones.
- Religious evangelism: duty to spread Protestant Christianity.
- Republican government as exemplar: obligation to civilize and bring liberal government abroad.
- National security and economics: secure sea lanes, trading ports, and overseas outposts; build a blue-water navy.
Open Door and China; Boxer Rebellion
- Open Door Policy (open trade in China) to prevent partition and preserve American access to Chinese markets.
- Other powers (Germany, Britain, France, Russia) seek spheres in China; US aims to avoid being shut out.
- Boxers (Yihokwa) revolt in 1900 against foreign influence; multinational force (including US) suppresses rebellion.
- Outcome: China remains vulnerable to foreign interference; US maintains influence without full colonization.
Key early interventions and the Mexican context
- Hawaii: overthrow of Queen Liliuokalani by private American landowners; annexed in 1898 despite initial American government opposition.
- Mexico under President Huerta (1913–1914): US occupation of Veracruz in 1914; later tensions with Pancho Villa.
- Pershing expedition into Mexico (1916–1917) fails to capture Villa; strains US–Mexico relations for years.
The Spanish–American War and aftermath
- 1898 war triggered by Cuban independence; USS Maine explodes in Havana harbor (likely accidental, press claims blamed Spain).
- Key events: Dewey destroys the Spanish Pacific fleet at Manila Bay; Battle of San Juan Hill in Cuba; Rough Riders led by Theodore Roosevelt.
- Treaty of Paris (1898): Spain surrenders Cuba; US gains Puerto Rico, Guam, and the Philippines; Hawaii also annexed in this period.
- Philippines conflict: fierce and brutal war for independence; atrocities on both sides; Filipino resistance led by Emilio Aguinaldo.
- Taft era in the Philippines (early 1900s) emphasizes governance, public works, hospitals, schools, sanitation to win local support.
Theodore Roosevelt, naval power, and diplomacy
- Alfred Thayer Mahan’s Influence of Sea Power: navy is essential to national power and economic strength.
- Great White Fleet (1907–1909): global naval demonstration of US power painted white; symbol of American reach.
- Roosevelian diplomacy:
- Speak softly, carry a big stick: use force if diplomacy fails.
- Dollar diplomacy: leverage economic power to influence governments, especially in the Americas.
- Roosevelt Corollary (to the Monroe Doctrine, 1904): US can intervene in Latin America to preserve stability and prevent European meddling.
- Panama Canal: US support for Panama’s independence movement (1903) to secure canal rights; demonstrates leverage and strategic interests.
Imperialism, governance, and anti-imperialism debates
- Anti-imperialist League (1899): prominent members (e.g., Mark Twain, Grover Cleveland, Jane Addams, Andrew Carnegie) argue imperialism conflicts with American ideals of self-government and liberty.
- Kipling’s White Man’s Burden: cultural justification for imperial rule; paternalistic notion of civilizing nonwhite peoples.
- War Prayer (Mark Twain, 1904): critique of imperial enthusiasm; questions moral legitimacy of empire-building.
- Platform of the Anti-Imperialist League: imperialism is militaristic, contrary to liberty, and contrary to the Declaration of Independence ideals.
Immigration, nativism, and race in the imperial era
- Nativism rises in late 19th century: fear of immigrant competition for jobs and cultural change.
- Chinese Exclusion Act (1882): ban on Chinese immigration (renewed until 1943).
- 1907 Gentlemen’s Agreement with Japan: informal cap on Japanese immigration to the US.
- Immigration restrictions also target Southern/Eastern Europeans and Catholics; anti-Catholic and anti-Jewish sentiment prevalent.
- Cartoon imagery illustrates fears of “new” immigrant groups altering American society.
- Mamie Tape (1885): Chinese mother’s plea against school segregation; highlights discrimination in education and persistent anti-Chinese policy.
Women, culture, and empire
- Women as missionaries, educators, and physicians abroad; viewed as cultural emissaries of American civilization.
- Margaret MacLeod example: US commercial influence and cultural diplomacy via Heinz brand marketing and global presence.
- Women as promoters of imperial cause at home and abroad; domestic support for expansion often tied to ideals of civilization and reform.
Primary sources and key artifacts
- War Prayer by Mark Twain (1904): satirical critique of imperial triumphalism.
- Kipling’s Take Up the White Man’s Burden (late 19th century): propaganda for civilizing mission, with racialized language.
- Mamie Tape letter (1885): firsthand account of anti-Chinese school exclusion in California.
Notable dates to remember
- Open Door Policy: priors to 1900; Open access to Chinese markets for all powers.
- 1898: Spanish–American War; Treaty of Paris ends war; US gains territories; Hawaii annexed.
- 1903: Panama Canal negotiations and independence support.
- 1904: Roosevelt Corollary to the Monroe Doctrine.
- 1907–1909: Great White Fleet voyage.
- 1907: Gentlemen’s Agreement with Japan.
- 1882: Chinese Exclusion Act.
- 1866: American University of Beirut founded; 1919: American University in Cairo founded.
- 1943: Chinese Exclusion Act finally repealed during WWII.
Quick-reference concepts
- Open Door Policy: keep China open to trade by all powers; avoids partition.
- Big Stick Diplomacy and Dollar Diplomacy: military power vs. economic leverage.
- Monroe Doctrine and Roosevelt Corollary: hemispheric non-interference by Europe; US intervention allowed to protect interests.
- White Man’s Burden: imperialist justification; critique via Twain and anti-imperialist sources.
- Anti-Imperialist League: internal American debate about legitimacy and ethics of empire.
- Immigration policy as domestic control: exclusion and regulation tied to imperial attitudes and racial ideologies.
Contextual takeaways
- Imperialism in this era blends military force, economic power, racial ideologies, and cultural diplomacy.
- Debates over empire reflect deeper tensions in American identity between liberty, self-government, and global power.
- Domestic policies (immigration, education, religion) intersect with foreign policy in shaping American imperial reach.