River Flooding Notes 1.4 pt 2
Flood Risk at Moreton Hall, Shropshire, UK
- Figure 1.44 illustrates flood risk with areas marked as significant (1-75 year flood) and moderate (76-200 year flood) risk.
Flood Prediction System
- Rainfall Radar: Plots the approach of rain-bearing weather systems; data is fed into the Agency's computer system.
- Tipping Rain Gauges: Monitor rainfall throughout the drainage basin, feeding data into the system.
- River Discharge Gauges: Automatic gauges monitor rising river levels along the river, adding data to the system.
- System Database: Includes a model of the drainage basin's behavior based on past flood events (storm hydrographs).
- Computer System Prediction: Compares incoming data with past events to predict river levels at different points, including flood peak height and arrival time.
- Environment Agency Warnings: Issues detailed flood warnings based on predictions, allowing people time to prepare.
River Flooding: Causes, Impacts, and Management
- River flooding causes death, damage, and disruption (economic and social).
- Management involves prediction, prevention, and amelioration.
- Successful management requires understanding the causes of flooding.
Causes of River Flooding
- Flooding occurs when overland flow exceeds the river's capacity.
- Natural factors affecting overland flow:
- Heavy, persistent, and/or intense rainfall.
- Rapid snowmelt.
- Impermeable soil and bedrock.
- Lack of vegetation in the drainage basin.
- Cold temperatures reducing evapotranspiration.
- Human activities worsen flooding:
- Deforestation
- Urbanization
- Mechanized farming
- Acid rain (destroys forests)
- Global climate change
Impacts of River Flooding
- Death of people and animals
- Damage to buildings, infrastructure, and farmland
- Disruption to people's lives (social, e.g., homelessness; economic, e.g., damage to businesses)
- In HICs, economic costs are typically higher, while LICs often experience higher death tolls.
Management of River Flooding
- Success depends on:
- Level of economic development (influences emergency services, infrastructure, recovery ability).
- Willingness to spend money on preparation and alleviation.
Three Gorges Dam Project
Advantages
- Water supplies to Shanghai (13 million people) are secure.
- Generates 10% of China's electricity (equivalent to 15 nuclear power stations) - clean energy, reduces air pollution and impact to climate change.
- Boosts economic growth in central and eastern China (Wuhan, Shanghai).
- The Chang Jiang is navigable by ships up to 10000 tonnes up to Chongqing.
- Expected 500% increase in river traffic will boost economic growth.
Disadvantages
- Reservoir flooded 150 towns/cities and 1300 villages.
- 1.2 million people resettled (compensation insufficient).
- Reservoir heavily polluted by toxins from flooded mines/factories, damaging the ecosystem and endangering species (White Flag River Dolphin, Siberian Crane).
- Landslides are expected due to water seeping into valley sides (earthquake risk).
- Silt deposition in the reservoir reduces capacity; dredging or flushing will be needed.
- Loss of downstream farmland fertilization by silt; increased need for chemical fertilizers.
Afforestation as a Soft Engineering Solution (Upstream of Chongqing)
- Deforestation in the 1960s for fuel, timber, and farmland led to soil erosion.
- Reforestation program:
- Advantages:
- Trees encourage interception, evapotranspiration, and infiltration, reducing flooding.
- Reduced soil erosion, benefiting local areas and reducing sedimentation in the Three Gorges reservoir.
- Trees can be harvested for food, fodder, fuel, and timber.
- Disadvantages:
- Local farmers lose arable/grazing fields.
- Fast-growing conifers are less useful than natural forests; reduced biodiversity.
Chang Jiang Floods - Causes and Impacts
Human Causes of Flooding
- More buildings on the floodplain reduce space for floodwater to flood, increasing flood levels.
- Deforestation in the headwaters (1960s) reduced interception, evapotranspiration, and infiltration, increasing surface runoff and flood peaks.
- Mismanagement of deforested land (overgrazing) led to soil erosion and siltation of the river channel.
- Canalization straightened the river, speeding up flow, reducing lag time, and increasing flood peak.
- Flood protection embankments constrain the river, leading to rapid and deadly flooding when breaches occur.
- Loss of Dongting and Poyang Lakes as safety valves due to farmland reclamation (polders), increasing flood peak levels.
- Potential increased rainfall due to global warming.
Impacts of the 1998 Chang Jiang Floods
- 240 million people affected in seven provinces.
- 4000 people drowned.
- Thousands of farm animals died.
- Huge areas of crops (rice, cotton) destroyed.
- Deliberate breaching of flood protection embankments to protect Wuhan, flooding countryside areas.
- 14 million people homeless for months.
- People out of work due to factory repairs.
- Thick layers of clay deposited on the fertile fields.
- Enormous cost to China's economy.
Management of Flooding on the Chang Jiang
- Combination of hard and soft engineering projects used.
Three Gorges Dam: A Hard Engineering Solution
- Located at Sandouping in a deep, narrow section of the valley (Three Gorges).
- Reservoir is 660 km long and 1 km wide, extending upstream almost to Chongqing.
- Largest hard engineering project ever undertaken on a river.
- Construction started in 1994 and completed in 2006; reservoir filled in 2009.
- Dam is 2.3 km long and almost 200 meters high.
- Gigantic ship locks built at the northeast end, and an 18000 megawatt H.E.P. station built inside the southwest end.
- Cost in excess of US$ 38 billion.
Flood Management Strategies
- Flood risk assessment looks at probability and impacts of flooding.
- Flood management strategies are grouped into three categories:
- Forecasts and warnings to allow behavioral strategies (adjusting lifestyles and taking personal responsibility).
- Hard engineering solutions (building something).
- Soft engineering strategies (working with nature).
Forecasts and Warnings (Behavioral Strategies)
- Ensure understanding of flood forecasting and warning services to allow time to move animals, furniture, and evacuate people.
- Have an emergency plan at the household and town level.
- Organize at-risk houses with tiled floors, moveable mats, drains, cupboards/plug sockets above flood level, wide stairs, and storage space upstairs.
- Take out insurance; premiums depend on flood risk.
Hard Engineering Strategies
- Dams and reservoirs can store floodwaters (if not already full).
- Platforms can be built on the floodplain to raise buildings above flood level.
- Embankments along the river are effective but expensive.
- Dredging the river lowers the bed but is not a permanent solution.
- Straightening the river speeds up flow but causes bigger floods downstream.
- Retention basins divert floodwaters at times of crisis with restrictions on land use.
- Flood relief channels take away excess water around a town, but cause worse flooding downstream.
Soft Engineering Strategies
- Floodplain zoning restricts land use to things less affected by floods (e.g., sports pitches); avoids building houses in high-risk areas.
- Rely on washlands. Land upstream is allowed to flood to protect towns.
- Plant trees in the upper drainage basin to encourage interception, evapotranspiration, and infiltration.
- Wetland and riverbank conservation schemes protect natural floodplain areas.
- River restoration schemes return rivers and floodplains to their natural state.