Working Capital Management Performance in Air Asia, Malaysia Airlines and Qantas
Study Overview and Research Objectives
Study Title: Working Capital Management Performance in Air Asia, Malaysia Airlines and Qantas.
Authors: Abu Thahir Abdul Nasser, Omar Samat, and Ahmad Marzuki Amiruddin Othman (Universiti Teknologi MARA).
Core Purpose: To benchmark working capital management (WCM) performance among three major airlines (Air Asia, Malaysia Airlines, and Qantas) to identify best practices for enhancing operational efficiency in cash flow from operations.
Key Research Scopes: * Generic Benchmarking: Comparing Air Asia (low-cost airline) with Malaysia Airlines and Qantas (full-service airlines). * Operational Efficiency: Measured via "Cash Conversion Efficiency" (CCE), a financial indicator. * Investment and Financing Policies: Identified through "Days of Working Capital" (DWC), a non-financial indicator.
Broad Findings: * The low-cost airline (Air Asia) outperforms full-service airlines in WCM. * Government and private full-service airlines lack sufficient funds for working capital requirements. * An inverse relationship exists between aggressive working capital financing and cash conversion efficiency. * Existing working capital in all three studied airlines has not been utilized with maximum efficiency.
The Global Airline Industry Context
Economic Impact: * Transports more than passengers annually. * Handles more than of global merchandise trade by value (Khan, 2004). * Supports jobs and (trillion) in economic activity (IATA, 2008).
Financial Reality: * Invested capital is approximately . * The industry suffered net financial losses exceeding between 2001 and 2005 (IATA, 2006). * Despite travel demand growth, existing capital use efficiency must improve to attract new investment (Bisignani, 2006).
Evolution of Local Competition: * Liberalization of the EU air transport (1988–1997) fueled the rise of low-cost carriers (LCCs). * LCCs prioritize simplicity, productivity, and high asset utilization to offer low fares (O'Connell and Williams, 2005). * However, even LCCs collectively failed to generate returns sufficient to cover the cost of capital during certain periods (IATA, 2006).
Literature Review: Foundations of Working Capital Management
Predicting Success and Failure: * Successful financial performance is heavily influenced by WCM (Vijayakumar and Venkatachalam, 1996; Shin and Sonen, 2000). * WCM aims to balance risk and return by managing inventory, receivables, and payables (Anand, 2001). * Large, profitable firms with efficient WCM and R&D/advertising uniqueness are historically the most successful (Johnson and Soenen, 2003).
Cash Flow Significance: * Cash flow is the "life blood" of growing businesses and the primary health indicator (Majumdar, 1996). * Effective WCM provides more cash flow to repay bankers and reward investors (Strischek, 2001). * Efficient use of short-term assets maximizes investor wealth (Havoutis, 2003).
Industry-Specific Data (IATA Economic Briefing No. 4, 2006): * Airline investors take significant risks but often receive sub-normal returns. * Between 1996 and 2004, the annual average shortfall in returns was (Actual return vs. expected ). * Cost of capital estimated at . * The 2001–2004 downturn saw average annual returns drop to .
Institutional Background of Studied Airlines
Malaysia Airlines (MAS): * Full-service national flag carrier based in Kuala Lumpur. * In 2006, announced property sales (including KL headquarters) to raise due to cash crunch risks (Zulaifah, 2006). * Planned to raise a further through a one-for-three rights issue of shares (Reuters, 2007).
Air Asia: * First private LCC entrant in Malaysia and Asia, starting December 2001. * Managed by Conor McCarthy (ex-Ryanair director). * Market share grew to within the first three years of operation. * Benchmarking Stats: World's lowest unit cost of (Available Seat per Kilometer); break-even load factor of . * Operational Efficiency: turnaround time of ; crew productivity triple that of MAS; aircraft utilization of compared to MAS's .
Qantas: * Established in 1920; flag carrier of Australia. * Privately registered company committed to profit-making, despite the Australian government being the sole shareholder (historically) and appointing directors. * Remained a major profitable full-service airline following the 2001 collapse of Ansett.
Research Methodology and Formulas
Data Period: * MAS and Qantas: 9 years (1999–2007). * Air Asia: 4 years (2004–2007) following listing.
Primary Metrics: 1. Cash Conversion Efficiency (CCE): Measures the ability to convert sales into operating cash flow. 2. Days of Working Capital (DWC): Measures the investment in working capital in terms of days of sales.
Sub-components (Non-financial leading indicators): * Days Sales Outstanding (DSO): Measures debtor exposure. * Days Inventory Outstanding (DIO): Measures how long inventory is tied up. * Days Payable Outstanding (DPO): Measures liability payment time.
Results: Performance Analysis (1999–2007)
Cash Conversion Efficiency (CCE) Findings: * Air Asia: Average CCE of . Fluctuated between (2005) and (2007). * Qantas: Average CCE of . Consistently positive, ranging from to . * Malaysia Airlines: Average CCE of . Negative in 2001, 2005, and 2006.
Days of Working Capital (DWC) Findings: * Malaysia Airlines: Most aggressive/risky financing with an average DWC of . High of (2003) and low of (2002). * Qantas: Aggressive financing with an average DWC of , ranging from to . * Air Asia: Moderate financing approach with an average DWC of , ranging from to .
Current Asset Metrics: * DSO (Receivables): Air Asia average is highest at (needs urgent review); Qantas at ; MAS at . * DIO (Inventory): MAS at ; Qantas at ; Air Asia at . * DPO (Payables): MAS average at ; Qantas at ; Air Asia at . High DPO suggests firms are stretching liabilities to finance assets.
Discussion and Practical Implications
The Inverse Relationship: Data suggests an inverse relationship between average DWC (risk) and CCE (return). Air Asia, with the least aggressive (moderate) DWC, achieved the highest efficiency in generating cash flow.
Financing Strategies: * Aggressive (MAS, Qantas): Defined by negative DWC. Relies on short-term borrowing and stretching creditors. Drawbacks include high interest rates, reduced cash generation, and potential insolvency risk. * Moderate (Air Asia): Utilizes long-term funds to finance optimum requirements. Advantages include eliminated high-interest payments and better commitment fulfillment to stakeholders.
Asset Management Issues: * Air Asia has exceptionally high DSO (), suggesting capital is locked in aging invoices. * MAS and Qantas need to unlock excess capital from inventories (DIO).
Public vs. Private Performance: The study confirms that private sector airlines (Air Asia) tend to outperform public sector counterparts (MAS), often due to bureaucratic goals taking precedence over productivity in public firms (Niskanen, 1971; Alchian, 1965).
Conclusions and Limitations
Strategic Recommendations: * Full-service airlines must secure additional long-term capital to eliminate the need for high-risk aggressive financing. * All airlines require formal current asset investment and financing policies. * Productivity must improve to enhance the cash conversion cycle and reduce the cost of capital.
Study Limitations: * Does not account for all factors (like specific cost reduction programs) that impact cash flow. * Findings as a case study may not be generalized to the entire global airline industry. * The study suggests results from CCE and DWC averages can be used as tools for ongoing operational benchmarking.