Working Capital Management Performance in Air Asia, Malaysia Airlines and Qantas

Study Overview and Research Objectives

  • Study Title: Working Capital Management Performance in Air Asia, Malaysia Airlines and Qantas.

  • Authors: Abu Thahir Abdul Nasser, Omar Samat, and Ahmad Marzuki Amiruddin Othman (Universiti Teknologi MARA).

  • Core Purpose: To benchmark working capital management (WCM) performance among three major airlines (Air Asia, Malaysia Airlines, and Qantas) to identify best practices for enhancing operational efficiency in cash flow from operations.

  • Key Research Scopes:     * Generic Benchmarking: Comparing Air Asia (low-cost airline) with Malaysia Airlines and Qantas (full-service airlines).     * Operational Efficiency: Measured via "Cash Conversion Efficiency" (CCE), a financial indicator.     * Investment and Financing Policies: Identified through "Days of Working Capital" (DWC), a non-financial indicator.

  • Broad Findings:     * The low-cost airline (Air Asia) outperforms full-service airlines in WCM.     * Government and private full-service airlines lack sufficient funds for working capital requirements.     * An inverse relationship exists between aggressive working capital financing and cash conversion efficiency.     * Existing working capital in all three studied airlines has not been utilized with maximum efficiency.

The Global Airline Industry Context

  • Economic Impact:     * Transports more than 2×1092 \times 10^9 passengers annually.     * Handles more than 35%35\% of global merchandise trade by value (Khan, 2004).     * Supports 32×10632 \times 10^6 jobs and USD 3.5×1012\text{USD}\,3.5 \times 10^{12} (trillion) in economic activity (IATA, 2008).

  • Financial Reality:     * Invested capital is approximately USD 380×109\text{USD}\,380 \times 10^9.     * The industry suffered net financial losses exceeding USD 40×109\text{USD}\,40 \times 10^9 between 2001 and 2005 (IATA, 2006).     * Despite travel demand growth, existing capital use efficiency must improve to attract new investment (Bisignani, 2006).

  • Evolution of Local Competition:     * Liberalization of the EU air transport (1988–1997) fueled the rise of low-cost carriers (LCCs).     * LCCs prioritize simplicity, productivity, and high asset utilization to offer low fares (O'Connell and Williams, 2005).     * However, even LCCs collectively failed to generate returns sufficient to cover the cost of capital during certain periods (IATA, 2006).

Literature Review: Foundations of Working Capital Management

  • Predicting Success and Failure:     * Successful financial performance is heavily influenced by WCM (Vijayakumar and Venkatachalam, 1996; Shin and Sonen, 2000).     * WCM aims to balance risk and return by managing inventory, receivables, and payables (Anand, 2001).     * Large, profitable firms with efficient WCM and R&D/advertising uniqueness are historically the most successful (Johnson and Soenen, 2003).

  • Cash Flow Significance:     * Cash flow is the "life blood" of growing businesses and the primary health indicator (Majumdar, 1996).     * Effective WCM provides more cash flow to repay bankers and reward investors (Strischek, 2001).     * Efficient use of short-term assets maximizes investor wealth (Havoutis, 2003).

  • Industry-Specific Data (IATA Economic Briefing No. 4, 2006):     * Airline investors take significant risks but often receive sub-normal returns.     * Between 1996 and 2004, the annual average shortfall in returns was USD 11.7×109\text{USD}\,11.7 \times 10^9 (Actual return USD 16.8×109\text{USD}\,16.8 \times 10^9 vs. expected USD 28.5×109\text{USD}\,28.5 \times 10^9).     * Cost of capital estimated at 7.5%7.5\%.     * The 2001–2004 downturn saw average annual returns drop to 2%2\%.

Institutional Background of Studied Airlines

  • Malaysia Airlines (MAS):     * Full-service national flag carrier based in Kuala Lumpur.     * In 2006, announced property sales (including KL headquarters) to raise RM 1.5×109\text{RM}\,1.5 \times 10^9 due to cash crunch risks (Zulaifah, 2006).     * Planned to raise a further RM 1.6×109\text{RM}\,1.6 \times 10^9 through a one-for-three rights issue of shares (Reuters, 2007).

  • Air Asia:     * First private LCC entrant in Malaysia and Asia, starting December 2001.     * Managed by Conor McCarthy (ex-Ryanair director).     * Market share grew to 30%30\% within the first three years of operation.     * Benchmarking Stats: World's lowest unit cost of USD 0.023/ASK\text{USD}\,0.023/\text{ASK} (Available Seat per Kilometer); break-even load factor of 52%52\%.     * Operational Efficiency: turnaround time of 25 minutes25\,\text{minutes}; crew productivity triple that of MAS; aircraft utilization of 13 hours/day13\,\text{hours/day} compared to MAS's 8 hours/day8\,\text{hours/day}.

  • Qantas:     * Established in 1920; flag carrier of Australia.     * Privately registered company committed to profit-making, despite the Australian government being the sole shareholder (historically) and appointing directors.     * Remained a major profitable full-service airline following the 2001 collapse of Ansett.

Research Methodology and Formulas

  • Data Period:     * MAS and Qantas: 9 years (1999–2007).     * Air Asia: 4 years (2004–2007) following listing.

  • Primary Metrics:     1. Cash Conversion Efficiency (CCE): Measures the ability to convert sales into operating cash flow.         CCE=(Cash Flow from OperationsNet Sales)×100\text{CCE} = \left( \frac{\text{Cash Flow from Operations}}{\text{Net Sales}} \right) \times 100     2. Days of Working Capital (DWC): Measures the investment in working capital in terms of days of sales.         DWC=Raw Material Inventory+Finished Goods Inventory+Receivables−CreditorsDay’s Sales\text{DWC} = \frac{\text{Raw Material Inventory} + \text{Finished Goods Inventory} + \text{Receivables} - \text{Creditors}}{\text{Day's Sales}}

  • Sub-components (Non-financial leading indicators):     * Days Sales Outstanding (DSO): Measures debtor exposure.         DSO=Sundry DebtorsDay’s Sales\text{DSO} = \frac{\text{Sundry Debtors}}{\text{Day's Sales}}     * Days Inventory Outstanding (DIO): Measures how long inventory is tied up.         DIO=InventoryDay’s Sales\text{DIO} = \frac{\text{Inventory}}{\text{Day's Sales}}     * Days Payable Outstanding (DPO): Measures liability payment time.         DPO=Current Liabilities PayableDay’s Sales\text{DPO} = \frac{\text{Current Liabilities Payable}}{\text{Day's Sales}}

Results: Performance Analysis (1999–2007)

  • Cash Conversion Efficiency (CCE) Findings:     * Air Asia: Average CCE of 19.31%19.31\%. Fluctuated between (0.04)%(0.04)\% (2005) and 37.21%37.21\% (2007).     * Qantas: Average CCE of 14.19%14.19\%. Consistently positive, ranging from 10.10%10.10\% to 17.74%17.74\%.     * Malaysia Airlines: Average CCE of 6.64%6.64\%. Negative in 2001, 2005, and 2006.

  • Days of Working Capital (DWC) Findings:     * Malaysia Airlines: Most aggressive/risky financing with an average DWC of −112 days-112\,\text{days}. High of 33 days33\,\text{days} (2003) and low of −282 days-282\,\text{days} (2002).     * Qantas: Aggressive financing with an average DWC of −74 days-74\,\text{days}, ranging from −30-30 to −106 days-106\,\text{days}.     * Air Asia: Moderate financing approach with an average DWC of 62 days62\,\text{days}, ranging from −28-28 to 213 days213\,\text{days}.

  • Current Asset Metrics:     * DSO (Receivables): Air Asia average is highest at 218 days218\,\text{days} (needs urgent review); Qantas at 82 days82\,\text{days}; MAS at 68 days68\,\text{days}.     * DIO (Inventory): MAS at 14 days14\,\text{days}; Qantas at 10 days10\,\text{days}; Air Asia at 3 days3\,\text{days}.     * DPO (Payables): MAS average at 194 days194\,\text{days}; Qantas at 166 days166\,\text{days}; Air Asia at 159 days159\,\text{days}. High DPO suggests firms are stretching liabilities to finance assets.

Discussion and Practical Implications

  • The Inverse Relationship: Data suggests an inverse relationship between average DWC (risk) and CCE (return). Air Asia, with the least aggressive (moderate) DWC, achieved the highest efficiency in generating cash flow.

  • Financing Strategies:     * Aggressive (MAS, Qantas): Defined by negative DWC. Relies on short-term borrowing and stretching creditors. Drawbacks include high interest rates, reduced cash generation, and potential insolvency risk.     * Moderate (Air Asia): Utilizes long-term funds to finance optimum requirements. Advantages include eliminated high-interest payments and better commitment fulfillment to stakeholders.

  • Asset Management Issues:     * Air Asia has exceptionally high DSO (218 days218\,\text{days}), suggesting capital is locked in aging invoices.     * MAS and Qantas need to unlock excess capital from inventories (DIO).

  • Public vs. Private Performance: The study confirms that private sector airlines (Air Asia) tend to outperform public sector counterparts (MAS), often due to bureaucratic goals taking precedence over productivity in public firms (Niskanen, 1971; Alchian, 1965).

Conclusions and Limitations

  • Strategic Recommendations:     * Full-service airlines must secure additional long-term capital to eliminate the need for high-risk aggressive financing.     * All airlines require formal current asset investment and financing policies.     * Productivity must improve to enhance the cash conversion cycle and reduce the cost of capital.

  • Study Limitations:     * Does not account for all factors (like specific cost reduction programs) that impact cash flow.     * Findings as a case study may not be generalized to the entire global airline industry.     * The study suggests results from CCE and DWC averages can be used as tools for ongoing operational benchmarking.