Memory Notes

The Nature of Memory

  • Memory is the ability to retain and retrieve information.
  • It encompasses the structures that account for this capacity.
  • Memory is fallible and deceptive because it is influenced by present events.

Why We Need Memory

  • To retain useful skills, knowledge, and expertise.
  • To recognize familiar people and places.
  • To build our capacity to use language.
  • To enjoy, share, and sustain culture.
  • To build a sense of self that endures: beliefs, values, memories, and understanding.
  • To go beyond conditioning by learning from experience, including lessons from one’s past and the experiences of others.
  • Without memory:
    • Everyone would be a stranger.
    • Every language would be foreign.
    • Every task would be new.
    • You yourself would be a stranger.

The Story of H.M. (Henry Gustav Molaison)

  • H.M. underwent experimental surgery that destroyed his ability to form long-term memories.
  • He could recall major historic events of his childhood, such as the stock market crash in 1929.
  • He could recall the gist of activities like roller skating that he loved as a boy.
  • After his death, H.M.’s brain was removed and frozen.
  • Researcher Jacopo Annese cut H.M.’s frozen brain into 2,401 slices, each 0.07 millimeters thick.
  • The slices were stained and mounted on slides.
  • The surgery involved removing most of his hippocampus and adjacent tissues in the medial temporal lobe from both hemispheres of his brain, along with the amygdala.
  • After surgery, H.M. was largely homebound and performed simple chores.
  • He retained a sense of humor and a positive outlook.
  • He enjoyed crossword puzzles and the TV sitcom "All in the Family."

Types of Memory

  • Declarative (explicit) memory: Conscious recollection of facts and events.
  • Procedural (implicit) memory: Learning demonstrated through performance (e.g., tracing a star or reading faster).

Biological Causes of Memory Loss

  • Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI)
    • Retrograde amnesia: Loss of memories of events before the accident; no trouble remembering things afterward (old memories lost).
    • Anterograde amnesia: Inability to form new memories for events after the accident (new memories lost).
      • Can result from surgical injury (as in H.M.'s case) or diseases like chronic alcoholism.

Memory as a Constructive Process

  • Memory is not like a digital recorder or video camera.
  • Memory is selective; we remember what we want to remember.
  • Recovering a memory is like watching flashes of a film and figuring out the rest of the scene.
  • We manufacture or "construct" our memories.
  • In reconstructing memories, people draw on many sources:
    • Family stories
    • Photographs
    • Home videos
    • Television

The Manufacture of Memory

  • Human memory is:
    • Highly selective
    • Often drawn from many sources
    • Reconstructive
  • We alter memories to make sense of the material, based on what we already know, which can lead to memory errors.

Sir Frederick Bartlett

  • Rejected the idea of long-term memory where material is stored unchanged until retrieval.
  • Saw memory as an active and often inaccurate process.
  • Conducted studies under natural conditions.
  • Said that past experiences help reconstruct the material that an individual is trying to remember.
  • Used the Native American fable "The War of the Ghosts."
  • Discovered that people found it difficult to recall the story exactly, even after repeated readings.
  • Parts of the story that failed to fit into the listener's understanding were omitted or transformed into more familiar forms.
  • The more time elapsed, the less reliable and accurate the recollections became.
  • Memory is largely a reconstructive process.

Source Misattribution

  • Source misattribution (source confusion): The inability to distinguish what you originally experienced from what you heard or were told later about an event.

Emotional Arousal and Memory

  • Emotional arousal can "sear" certain events into the brain.
  • Stress hormones signal the brain that something important has happened.
  • Events that triggered the arousal make an indelible impression.
  • Clear memories may repeatedly occur spontaneously, as if they were "burned" in the mind.
  • It is adaptive for strong emotional experiences to create strong, more reliable memories (James McGaugh).

Emotions, Stress Hormones, the Amygdala, and Memory

  • Intense emotion causes the brain to form intense memories.
  • Emotions can trigger a rise in stress hormones.
  • These hormones trigger activity in the amygdala.
  • The amygdala increases memory-forming activity and engages the frontal lobes and basal ganglia to "tag" the memories as important.
  • Memories are stored with more sensory and emotional details.
  • Details can trigger rapid, unintended recall of the memory.
  • Relates to PTSD: Traumatized people can have intrusive recall that feels like re-experiencing the event.
  • Memories may feel vivid but are not necessarily accurate; they get altered every time we recall them.
  • Trauma therapy depends on this "reconsolidation."

Flashbulb Memories

  • Unusual, shocking, or tragic events hold a special place in memory.
  • Called flashbulb memories because of their surprise, illumination, and photographic detail.
  • These memories may feel vivid but are not necessarily accurate; they get altered every time we recall them.
  • Trauma therapy depends on this "reconsolidation."

Six ‘Canonical’ Categories of Flashbulb Memories

  • Location: Remembering where you heard the news.
  • Ongoing event: Remembering what you were doing at the time you heard the news.
  • Informant: Remembering who told you about the event.
  • Emotional affect in others: Noticing the emotional reactions of others.
  • Emotional affect in self: Noticing the emotional reactions of oneself.
  • Aftermath/consequentiality: Remembering what you did after you heard the news.

Characteristics of Flashbulb Memories

  • Detailed and vivid memory stored and retained for a lifetime.
  • Associated with important historical or autobiographical events.
  • More detailed than ordinary memories, including characteristics like:
    • Where were you?
    • What were you doing?
    • Who was with you?
    • How did you feel?
    • How did those around you feel?
    • What happened next?
  • Require the participation of the amygdala and possibly other parts of the brain that regulate mood and alertness.

The Conditions of Confabulation

  • Confabulation: Confusion of an event that happened to someone else with one that happened to you, or a belief that you remember something when it never actually happened.

Confabulation Examples

  • Memory: "I went surfing at sunrise when we took a family trip to California."
  • Actual event: "I watched other people surf at sunrise when we took a family trip to California."
  • Having strong feelings about a memory does not mean that the memory is accurate.

Likelihood of Confabulation

  • The image of the event contains many details that make it feel real.
  • The event is easy to imagine.
  • You have thought, heard, or told others about the event many times (imagination inflation).

Time-Gap Experience

  • Engaging in a fairly complicated task (such as driving a car) and upon completion of the task, you realize that you have no conscious recollection of the task you just completed.
  • Effortful tasks can trigger this gap.
  • Automatic processing

Cryptomnesia

  • Cryptomnesia (unintended plagiarism): Unintentionally copying someone else’s melody.

Sensory Memory

  • Iconic Memory: Visual memory
  • Echoic Memory: Auditory memory

Iconic Memory

  • To demonstrate the duration of visual or iconic memory, swing a flashlight in a dark room.
  • Because the image lingers for a fraction of a second after the flashlight is moved, you see the light as a continuous stream, rather than as a succession of individual points.

Echoic Memory

  • A weaker “echo” (echoic memory) of auditory information can last up to 4 seconds.

The Eyewitness On Trial

  • Eyewitnesses are not always reliable.
  • Factors influencing accuracy:
    • Differing ethnicity
    • Leading Questions
    • Misleading information
  • The reconstructive nature of memory makes it vulnerable to suggestion.
  • Memories are also influenced by the way in which questions are put to the eyewitness and by suggestive comments made during an interrogation or interview.

Constructed Memories

  • It is more common that there is mistaken testimony than intentional lying.
  • People are overconfident about their fallible memories, not realizing that their memories are constructions.
  • We tend to alter our memories to fit our current views.

Schema Influence

  • Using schemas is a useful mental shortcut but can lead us to make mistakes in memory if we use them too much.