Study Notes on Behavior, Social Norms, and Influence
BEHAVIOR, SOCIAL AND CULTURE
ROLE OF SOCIETY AND NORMS
Society is governed by norms which are essential to regulate social life. These norms can be classified as:
- Explicit Laws: Formalized rules that are codified into legal statutes.
- Implicit Cultural Conventions: Informal practices that arise from shared cultural understandings.Norms are reinforced through:
- Reward Systems: Positive reinforcement for adherence to norms.
- Punishment Threats: Consequences for violations of norms.
SOCIAL ROLES
Individuals fulfill various social roles, which are defined by sets of norms regarding expected behavior.
Understanding when a social role requirement is in effect is crucial.
CULTURAL VARIATIONS IN NORMS AND ROLES
The differences in norms and roles across cultures provoke questions about morality and tradition.
Example: The acceptance of cousin marriage in some cultures versus its taboo nature in Western societies.
THE MILGRAM OBEDIENCE EXPERIMENT
STUDY OVERVIEW
The experiment was designed to measure the degree of obedience in participants when instructed to perform seemingly harmful actions.
- There are three main roles in the experiment:
1. Subject: The individual who administers shocks to another participant.
2. Fake Test Subject: The individual who feigns suffering due to shocks.
3. Experimenter: The authority figure who urges the subject to continue administering shocks.
OUTCOME OF THE EXPERIMENT
The experiment sought to determine under what circumstances participants would disobey the authority figure, noting several critical moments of disobedience, including:
- When the authority figure left the room.
- When the victim was physically present.
- When there were conflicting demands from multiple authority figures.
- When the instructions came from an ordinary man rather than an authority figure.
MILGRAM’S CONCLUSION
Milgram concluded that obedience is more heavily influenced by situational factors rather than intrinsic personality traits of the participants. Participants often saw themselves as mere executioners of authority, which highlights how ordinary individuals can commit acts of atrocity under social pressures.
ETHICAL QUESTIONS ABOUT OBEDIENCE
The societal implications of obedience raise questions about moral responsibility and the nature of authority. This leads to reflections on whether obedience is inherently good or bad, and under what conditions individuals are willing to obey.
SOCIAL INFLUENCES ON BELIEFS AND BEHAVIOR
ATTRIBUTION THEORY
Attribution is the cognitive process whereby individuals explain the causes of their own and others' behaviors.
- Situational Attribution: Attributing behavior to contextual factors.
- Dispositional Attribution: Attributing behavior to inherent personality traits.
EXAMPLES OF ATTRIBUTIONAL BIASES
Situational factors could explain an individual's behavior. For instance, if a Teaching Assistant snaps at a student:
- Situational Attribution: "She is under pressure."
- Dispositional Attribution: "She is mean and rude."The overemphasis on personal attributes while ignoring situational influences is a common form of bias known as the Fundamental Attribution Error.
PERCEPTIONS OF INTERACTIONS
Different contexts can change the attributions made about people's behaviors:
- If an unknown person neglects your question in class versus a friend doing the same, perceptions change with context.
- Learning the reason behind someone’s behavior (e.g., they had an accident) can reshape initial judgments.
FUNDAMENTAL ATTRIBUTION ERROR
This phenomenon denotes the tendency to overestimate personality traits in explaining others' behaviors while underestimating situational influences. An expression of this may be:
- "Sorry I'm late, there was traffic."
- Countered by: "You are flawed as a human!" demonstrating bias against the individual’s circumstances.
SELF-SERVING BIAS
This bias refers to the inclination to attribute our successes to internal factors while blaming external factors for our failures. Hence, we see ourselves as better, smarter, and kinder than others.
Believing in fairness reflects a self-serving bias, which can distort perceptions of morality and social justice.
ATTRIBUTION IN RELATIONSHIPS
IMPACT OF ATTRIBUTIONS
Attributions in personal relationships can have significant consequences:
- Negative attributes about a partner’s behavior can lead to relationship strain.
- Conversely, attributing the partner’s shortcomings to situational factors may foster understanding and empathy.
COGNITIVE DISSONANCE
DEFINITION
Cognitive dissonance refers to the psychological discomfort experienced when conflicting attitudes or behaviors exist. To alleviate such dissonance, individuals often adjust their attitudes.
- Example: Someone might rationalize cheating by minimizing its moral implications when they feel the pressure of academic performance.
UNDERLYING MENTAL PROCESSES
The presence of dissonance leads individuals to reevaluate their attitudes regarding behaviors which in turn influences future actions and beliefs.
BELIEF INFLUENCES
FAMILIARITY EFFECT
Familiarity increases the likelihood of positive feelings toward someone or something. The more exposure, the more positive the reception.
VALIDITY EFFECT
The tendency to accept repeated statements as valid or true merely because of their repetition.
EXTREME FORMS OF INFLUENCE
Brainwashing is a process involving a sudden change of beliefs, wherein an individual's agency is compromised and replaced with a singular, often harmful narrative.
MECHANISMS OF BRAINWASHING
Entrapment and loss of identity, along with controlled access to disconfirming information, are critical methods used in brainwashing.
GROUP INFLUENCES ON BEHAVIOR
CONFORMITY
Individuals have a tendency to conform to group norms in order to maintain social acceptance and gain information.
GROUPTHINK
Groupthink leads to homogenized thinking and often suppresses dissent, resulting in collective errors of judgment. This tendency can diffuse individual responsibility, contributing to effects like the bystander phenomenon.
DEINDIVIDUALIZATION
In group settings, individuals may lose their sense of self-awareness, leading to an "Us Vs Them" mentality. This phenomenon can exacerbate conflicts and contribute to group polarization.
QUESTIONS OF HUMAN NATURE
The presentation ends with a call to reflect on the fundamental questions related to human nature, particularly concerning social behaviors, conformity, and the factors shaping our perceptions and actions in social contexts.
BEHAVIOR, SOCIAL AND CULTURE
ROLE OF SOCIETY AND NORMS
Society is governed by norms which are essential to regulate social life. These norms can be classified as:
- Explicit Laws: Formalized rules that are codified into legal statutes.
- Implicit Cultural Conventions: Informal practices that arise from shared cultural understandings.
Norms are reinforced through:
- Reward Systems: Positive reinforcement for adherence to norms.
- Punishment Threats: Consequences for violations of norms.
SOCIAL ROLES
Individuals fulfill various social roles, which are defined by sets of norms regarding expected behavior.
Understanding when a social role requirement is in effect is crucial.
CULTURAL VARIATIONS IN NORMS AND ROLES
The differences in norms and roles across cultures provoke questions about morality and tradition.
Example: The acceptance of cousin marriage in some cultures versus its taboo nature in Western societies.
THE MILGRAM OBEDIENCE EXPERIMENT
STUDY OVERVIEW
The experiment was designed to measure the degree of obedience in participants when instructed to perform seemingly harmful actions.
- There are three main roles in the experiment:
1. Subject: The individual who administers shocks to another participant.
2. Fake Test Subject: The individual who feigns suffering due to shocks.
3. Experimenter: The authority figure who urges the subject to continue administering shocks.
OUTCOME OF THE EXPERIMENT
The experiment sought to determine under what circumstances participants would disobey the authority figure, noting several critical moments of disobedience, including:
- When the authority figure left the room.
- When the victim was physically present.
- When there were conflicting demands from multiple authority figures.
- When the instructions came from an ordinary man rather than an authority figure.
MILGRAM’S CONCLUSION
Milgram concluded that obedience is more heavily influenced by situational factors rather than intrinsic personality traits of the participants. Participants often saw themselves as mere executioners of authority, which highlights how ordinary individuals can commit acts of atrocity under social pressures.
ETHICAL QUESTIONS ABOUT OBEDIENCE
The societal implications of obedience raise questions about moral responsibility and the nature of authority. This leads to reflections on whether obedience is inherently good or bad, and under what conditions individuals are willing to obey.
SOCIAL INFLUENCES ON BELIEFS AND BEHAVIOR
ATTRIBUTION THEORY
Attribution is the cognitive process whereby individuals explain the causes of their own and others' behaviors.
- Situational Attribution: Attributing behavior to contextual factors.
- Dispositional Attribution: Attributing behavior to inherent personality traits.
EXAMPLES OF ATTRIBUTIONAL BIASES
Situational factors could explain an individual's behavior. For instance, if a Teaching Assistant snaps at a student:
- Situational Attribution: "She is under pressure."
- Dispositional Attribution: "She is mean and rude."
The overemphasis on personal attributes while ignoring situational influences is a common form of bias known as the Fundamental Attribution Error.
PERCEPTIONS OF INTERACTIONS
Different contexts can change the attributions made about people's behaviors:
- If an unknown person neglects your question in class versus a friend doing the same, perceptions change with context.
- Learning the reason behind someone’s behavior (e.g., they had an accident) can reshape initial judgments.
FUNDAMENTAL ATTRIBUTION ERROR
This phenomenon denotes the tendency to overestimate personality traits in explaining others' behaviors while underestimating situational influences. An expression of this may be:
- "Sorry I'm late, there was traffic."
- Countered by: "You are flawed as a human!" demonstrating bias against the individual’s circumstances.
SELF-SERVING BIAS
This bias refers to the inclination to attribute our successes to internal factors while blaming external factors for our failures. Hence, we see ourselves as better, smarter, and kinder than others.
Believing in fairness reflects a self-serving bias, which can distort perceptions of morality and social justice.
ATTRIBUTION IN RELATIONSHIPS
IMPACT OF ATTRIBUTIONS
Attributions in personal relationships can have significant consequences:
- Negative attributes about a partner’s behavior can lead to relationship strain.
- Conversely, attributing the partner’s shortcomings to situational factors may foster understanding and empathy.
COGNITIVE DISSONANCE
DEFINITION
Cognitive dissonance refers to the psychological discomfort experienced when conflicting attitudes or behaviors exist. To alleviate such dissonance, individuals often adjust their attitudes.
- Example: Someone might rationalize cheating by minimizing its moral implications when they feel the pressure of academic performance.
UNDERLYING MENTAL PROCESSES
The presence of dissonance leads individuals to reevaluate their attitudes regarding behaviors which in turn influences future actions and beliefs.
BELIEF INFLUENCES
FAMILIARITY EFFECT
Familiarity increases the likelihood of positive feelings toward someone or something. The more exposure, the more positive the reception.
VALIDITY EFFECT
The tendency to accept repeated statements as valid or true merely because of their repetition.
EXTREME FORMS OF INFLUENCE
Brainwashing is a process involving a sudden change of beliefs, wherein an individual's agency is compromised and replaced with a singular, often harmful narrative.
MECHANISMS OF BRAINWASHING
Entrapment and loss of identity, along with controlled access to disconfirming information, are critical methods used in brainwashing.
GROUP INFLUENCES ON BEHAVIOR
CONFORMITY
Individuals have a tendency to conform to group norms in order to maintain social acceptance and gain information.
GROUPTHINK
Groupthink leads to homogenized thinking and often suppresses dissent, resulting in collective errors of judgment. This tendency can diffuse individual responsibility, contributing to effects like the bystander phenomenon.
DEINDIVIDUALIZATION
In group settings, individuals may lose their sense of self-awareness, leading to an "Us Vs Them" mentality. This phenomenon can exacerbate conflicts and contribute to group polarization.
QUESTIONS OF HUMAN NATURE
The presentation ends with a call to reflect on the fundamental questions related to human nature, particularly concerning social behaviors, conformity, and the factors shaping our perceptions and actions in social contexts.