The Election of 1860 and the Secession of the South

  • Political Climate
      - Second party system in the United States died out by 1854.
      - By the election of 1860, primary political competition was between Democrats and the Republican Party.
      - Parties were sectional:
        - Republican Party: Represented the interests of the North.
        - Democratic Party: Represented the interests of the South.
      - Analogy: Division akin to a child refusing to eat if food touches another part—no overlap between sectional interests.
      - Formation of the Republican Party:
        - Coalition of two main groups:
          - Anti-slavery Whigs
          - Free Soil advocates
      - Republican Stance on Slavery:
        - Opposed the expansion of slavery into new western territories.
        - Clarified had no intention to outlaw or diminish slavery in existing states.
      - Republican Candidate Selection:
        - Chose Abraham Lincoln, a Senator from Illinois.
        - Gained notoriety during 1854 congressional debates with Stephen Douglas regarding slavery and popular sovereignty.

  • The Fragmentation of the Democratic Party
      - Democrats divided into factions, leading to defeat in 1860 election.
      - Northern Democrats: Nominated Stephen Douglas advocating for popular sovereignty.
      - Southern Democrats: Nominated John Breckinridge, sitting Vice President.
      - Constitutional Union Party: Nominated John Bell, offered no concrete solutions to slavery.

  • Election Results and Consequences
      - Lincoln won the election, exacerbating sectional divisions.
      - Electoral College Statistics:
        - Lincoln: 180 electoral votes.
        - Other candidates: 123 electoral votes combined.
        - Lincoln received no electoral votes from Southern states.
      - Factors for Republican Victory:
        - Democratic vote split among three candidates.
        - Admissions of Minnesota (1858) and Oregon (1859) as free states.
        - Free states outnumbered slave states 18 to 15.
        - Northern free states had much larger populations than Southern slave states.

  • Southern Perspectives on Secession
      - Election results indicated to the South a lack of political home in the U.S.
      - Realization that they could no longer protect slavery within a political system.
      - Decision made to address slavery through secession.
      - Mistrust of Lincoln:
        - Believed Lincoln would interfere with slavery despite his claims otherwise.
        - John Brown's raid on Harper's Ferry and popularity of Uncle Tom's Cabin heightened tensions.
      - Southern belief: Only through westward expansion could slavery survive; their political efficacy was shattered.

  • Secession Crisis and Formation of the Confederacy
      - December 1860: South Carolina seceded from the U.S.
      - Justifications for Secession:
        - Allegations of Republican Party hostility toward slavery.
        - Belief North planned to wage war against slavery.
        - Claim that secession was necessary to protect slavery as a constitutional right.
      - First Wave of Secessions:
        - Six states: Mississippi, Florida, Alabama, Georgia, Louisiana, Texas.
      - Second Wave of Secessions:
        - Four states: Virginia, Arkansas, North Carolina, Tennessee by June 1861.
      - These states formed the Confederate States of America.
      - All seceding states' articles of secession cited slavery and state rights as justifications.

  • Confederate Constitution and Leadership
      - New constitution ratified to fix perceived U.S. Constitution errors:
        - Established the Confederacy as a Christian nation, invoking God's guidance.
        - Explicit legality and “perpetual protection” of slavery included.
      - Confederate Leadership:
        - Jefferson Davis as President.
        - Alexander Stephens as Vice President.

  • Cornerstone Speech
      - Alexander Stephens' speech defined the Confederate ideology.
      - Contrasted Confederate government with U.S. government—claims U.S. based on racial equality.
      - Verbatim quotes from Stephens:
        - Confederacy founded on the belief that the negro is not equal to the white man.
        - Slavery is the natural condition for the negro.
      - Lincoln viewed Southern acts as unconstitutional; preparations for Civil War began.