Policy Misrepresentation, Contestability & Age Misstatement — Key Points

Material Misrepresentation

  • Information that would have been of interest to the underwriter and could affect underwriting decisions (decline, exclusion, or rating).
  • Examples:
    • Not material: last doctor visit dated Feb 2017 when actual is Mar.
    • Material: cancer history denied vs. disclosed.
  • When misrepresentation occurs:
    • Depends on when the insurer becomes aware and whether it was fraudulent (intent).

Contestability Period

  • Defined as the first 22 years after policy issue.
  • During this period, the insurer can contest the policy if there is a material misrepresentation, even if innocent.
  • They can cancel the policy and/or deny a claim.
  • Note: misstatement of age is treated differently and not covered here.

Incontestability Period

  • Begins after the 22-year contestability period.
  • Insurer can contest only if there is a material misrepresentation and they can prove fraud.
  • Fraud involves intentional lying; not always easy to prove, depending on the facts.

Misstatement of Age (special treatment)

  • Generally, adjust the coverage amount to reflect the premium actually paid.
  • Example: a $500{,}000 policy, stated age 45, premium 225225; true age 50, premium would have been 250250.
    • Actual premium paid: 225225; correct premium: 250250.
    • Coverage reduced proportionally: 500,000×225250=450,000500{,}000 \times \frac{225}{250} = 450{,}000 death benefit.
  • Exception: if the applicant was above the contractual age limit for issuing a policy, the policy can be canceled.
    • Example: contract limit is 80; applicant is 82; lying to get policy; insurer could cancel if discovered.

Practical notes / Memory aids

  • It is easier for the insurer to contest during the contestability period because they do not have to prove fraud.
  • After 22 years, contestability requires proof of fraud for misrepresentations (except certain age-related cases as above).
  • Real-world example (fraud): undisclosed serious illness discovered post-issue; could lead to denial of a large death benefit if fraud is proven.