Emotions



WEEK 1 - L1 - INTRO, THEORETICAL APPROACHES, & RESEARCH METHODS


Introduction Emotions

Defining emotions

  • one definition:

    • ā€œEpisodic, relatively short-term, biologically based patterns of perception, experience, physiology, action, and communication that occur in response to specific physical and social challenges and opportunities.ā€

  • but not all aspects of this definition are accepted by all scientists (we will see which aspect)

  • there are more definitions (around 150!), all with their own shortcomings

  • therefore, it may be more appropriate to ā€œdefineā€ emotions in terms of their characteristic and their similarities and differences to other affective phenomena

    • see online clip week 1


Emotions

  • relatively brief states

  • arise in response to an object or event

  • motivational states that guide behavior


Theoretical Approaches

where do emotions come from and what do they do?


  1. Basic emotion theories

  2. Psychological constructionist theories

  3. Appraisal theories

  4. Functional theories



Comparing theories

  • universality

    • are emotions the same across cultures / individuals?


  • discreteness

    • how many emotions exist and how distinct are they?


  • coherence

    • do all components of an emotion occur together?


Ā» Basic emotion theories

how natural selection may have caused humans to have the emotions they have


  • emotions are biologically evolved programs that helped ancestors survive

  • each emotion (fear, anger, joy, sadness, disgust, surprise, contempt) has a distinct neural and physiological signature

  • universal across all humans and cultures (Darwin, Ekman)

  • facial expressions correspond to basic emotional states

  • when triggered, all components (feeling, physiology, behavior) cohere automatically


Focus: evolutionary origin and biological mechanisms


Ā» Psychological constructionist theories

How cultural learning causes people to develop the capacity to experience specific emotions


  • emotions are learned psychological constructions

  • formed through development, socialization, and culture

  • only core affect (valence and activation) is universal

    • valence: pleasantness vs unpleasantness

    • activation: high or low intensity

  • emotions are context-dependent and variable

  • emotional experiences exist on continuous dimensions, not discrete categories

  • components of emotion do not always align coherently


Focus: learning, experience, and conceptual variability


Ā» Appraisal theories

which thoughts give rise to which emotions?


  • emotions arise from immediate evaluations (appraisals) of circumstances

  • appraisal is a mental process that detects events and evaluates their significance for well-being

  • appraisals are dimensional (e.g., valence, novelty/originality, control, norms)

  • they occur on a continuum and often unconsciously

  • primary appraisals: fast and automatic

  • secondary appraisal: slower, learned

  • distinct emotions emerge from specific appraisal patterns

  • partial coherence: appraisal patterns predict some but not all components


Focus: cognitive mechanisms that trigger and shape emotional experiences



Ā» Functional theories

how people’s goals and situations they are in make one emotion more useful than other


  • focus on the function of emotion - what do emotion do for people right now?

  • emotions regulate behavior, decision-making, and social connection

  • emotional intelligence (Salovey & Mayer, 1990): ability to recognize, understand, and use emotions adaptively

  • emotional patterns can be learned through environmental interaction, not only evolved

  • Oatley & Johnson-Laird (1987): emotions adjust behavior to regulate goals

  • Fredrickson’s broaden-and-build theory: positive emotions broaden attention and build long-term resources

  • expressions vary, but each emotion maintain a consistent functional goal (e.g., love → closeness)


focus: immediate adaptive purpose and goal regulation


Summary

Theory

Universality

Discreteness

Coherence

Basic Emotion

very HIGH - innate and universal across cultures

HIGH - distinct biologicalĀ ā€œpackagesā€

HIGH - components cooccur automatically

Psychological constructionist

LOW - only core affect is universal

LOW - emotions are dimensional blends

LOW - components vary independently

Appraisal

MODERATE - universal appraisal dimensions

MODERATE - discrete emotions from patterns of appraisal

MODERATE - partial coherence depending on context

Functional

MODERATE to HIGH - shared functional goals

MODERATE - defined by goal or consequences

MODERATE to HIGH - coherence through purpose, not identical form


Research Methods

how can we conduct research on emotions?


How do we measure emotions?

emotional responses:

  • subjective feelings

  • facial expressions

  • central nervous system CNS

  • peripheral nervous system PNS

    • somatic

    • autonomic (sympathetic and parasympathetic)


link emotional responses to measures:

  • subjective feelings → questionnaires

  • facial expressions → objective coding systems

  • CNS → neuroimaging methods

  • PNS → physiological methods


however, to measure emotional responses, we first need to ensure that emotions are elicited → that’s why researchers use emotion induction methods ↓

Tools to induce emotions

  • film clipsĀ 

  • emotion-inducing images (e.g., IAPS)

  • recall of emotional memories

  • music

  • scripted social interaction

  • naturally occurring emotions (daily questionnaire app)


DISCUSSION: INDUCING EMOTIONS WITH VIDEO


what are the advantages of using video clips to induce emotions?

  • easy to standardize across participants

  • strong emotional impact

  • cost-effective and easy to administer


what are the limitations or potential risks of this method?

  • emotions may not be equally induced for everyone

  • cultural variation in emotion perception

  • ethical concerns (e.g., sadness, fear)

  • possible habituation if reused


how could we measure whether the induction was effective?

  • manipulation check (e.g., self-report emotion questionnaire)


Things to consider when designing an emotion experiment

  • what do I manipulate?

    • independent variable - e.g., type of stimulus, emotional intensity, context


  • how do I induce emotion?

    • video clips, music, images, social stress, recall, etc.


  • what do I measure?

    • dependent variable - what changes as a result of your manipulation?


  • which measures do I use?

    • self-report scales, physiological data, behavioral indicators, neural activity, etc.


  • within or between-subject design?

    • do participants experience one or several conditions?


  • how do I verify that the induction worked?

    • manipulation check - e.g., post-task emotion rating or physiological response


  • who are my participants?

    • sample size, demographics, individual differences in emotion reactivity


  • any ethical considerations?

    • potential distress, informed consent, debriefing, right to withdraw


WEEK 1 - CLIP 1 - WHAT ARE EMOTIONS & WHY DO WE HAVE THEM?

Affective Phenomena

emotions are effective phenomena, but there are also other affective phenomena that are not emotions↓


  • preferences

    • never fully reasoned, there are feelings involved

    • different from emotions


  • attitudes

    • cognition is involved but there are feelings involved

    • again different from emotions


  • moods

    • unlike emotions, moods don’t have a clear reason

    • moods last longer than emotions


  • affective predispositions

    • they are personality traits

    • predisposition to show a certain emotion

    • for example, being a grumpy person


  • interpersonal stances

    • friendliness, shyness, anxiousness

    • not emotions


  • aesthetic emotions

    • scientist can’t explain

    • art, music, etc.

    • no need for something important to happen


  • utilitarian emotions

    • evolutionary

    • something important has to happen


Features of Emotions


  • reaction to a stimulus → there’s a concrete trigger


  • appraisal → we consider the event important


  • experience and expression → I can be angry but also don’t express it


  • limited duration


  • Motivation to display specific behaviors


  • capacity to regulate emotions → we are not defenseless victims of our emotionsĀ 


  • effect on the individual AND OTHERS

    • social information

    • when we see someone get emotional it gives us information about that person


  • adaptive

    • they prioritize our reactions

    • anticipation plays a role


Timeline

↳ self-reported emotions


Function of Emotions

emotions help us to display optimal behavior in a certain situation


Conditions for Adaptive Emotions


  • accurate appraisal → if you are angry at nothing than it’s not adaptive


  • proper degree of importance attached to situation


  • prioritizing goals corresponds with importance → if you have a fight with your bf during exam week you should be able to postpone the argument


  • reactions make sense for the situation


  • high emotional intelligence



ā€œAnybody can become angry - that’s easy, but to be angry at the right person, and to the right degree, at the right time, and for the right purpose, and the right way - that’s not within everybody’s power and isn’t easyā€

Aristotle


WEEK 1 - CH1 - INTRO TO EMOTION

Defining Emotion

Affect:

  • general term for any psychological process that involves evaluation

  • having a positive or negative response

  • Emotions fall under this umbrella. But so do other psychological constructs like

  • also attitudes

    • Your dislike of cilantro is affective, because for you, cilantro is bad.

  • Moods also fall under the affect umbrella, but scientists generally view them as different from emotions.

    • Moods are longer-lasting and less goal-directed than emotions.

    • Moods bias how people interpret and respond to situations, so they can nudge people towards particular emotions


Theorizing About Emotion

affective science → research about emotions


4 theories:

  1. basic emotion theories

  2. psychological constructionist theories

  3. appraisal theories

  4. functional theories


  • attempting to answer the question, ''What causes emotions?''

  • However, they each focus on a different meaning of the word ''cause.''

    • Basic emotion theories focus on how natural selection, over millions of years, may have caused humans to have the emotions they have.

    • Psychological constructionist theories argue that cultural learning causes people to develop the capacity to experience specific emotions.

    • Appraisal theories ask which thoughts cause or give rise to, which emotions

    • functional theories focus on how people's goals, along with different types of situations people find themselves in, cause one emotion to be more useful ( functional) than another

  • They are all wrong, to some extent, but some are useful


The four major emotion theories map loosely onto behavioral ethologist Niko Tinbergen's four questions:

  • argued that all questions about animal (and human) behavior fall into one of four categories:

    • evolution → How did the behavior emerge over many generations

    • development → How does the behavior emerge within an individual over time

    • mechanism →How does the behavior work and what causes it in the moment

    • function → How is the behavior adaptive for the organism


Comparing Theories

Universality: Do all humans in all cultures have similar emotional experiences?

Discreteness: How many emotions are there and how distinct are they from one another?

Coherence: When a person experiences an emotion, do all the components occur together?


Summary

  • Western philosophers once thought emotions should be tamed by rational thought, but modem-day affective scientists believe emotions are necessary for survival.

  • Emotions are motivational states that guide behavior. We start with the following definition, ''episodic, relatively short-term, biologically based patterns of perception, experience, physiology, action, and communication that occur in response to specific physical and social challenges and opportunities.''

  • The four major emotion theories each emphasize a different question according to Tinbergen's framework

  • The theories disagree the most on the issues of universality, discreteness, and coherence.

  • Affective science is an ever-evolving field. We encourage you to be a critical consumer of science, including the science in this book. Go read the original scientific studies if they interest you, confuse you, or make you cringe


WEEK 1 - CH2 - THEORIES OF EMOTION

Basic Emotion Theories

Universality

criteria to classifying an emotion as basic:

  • Expressions that are produced and recognized across cultures and that may involve more than just the face (e.g., the voice)

  • Distinct patterns of physiology.

  • Automatic activation of the associated action tendency.

  • Presence in other primates.


Discreteness and coherence

  • All the components of an emotion happen together (or "cohere") because they are integrated in an affect program

  • Affect programs: innate brain systems that are preset to tell the body what to do when faced with a particular event

    • there is a separate program for each of the basic emotions

      • does not mean that everyone's anger looks and feels exactly alike

    • develop similarly for all people (they are innate), they can change to include knowledge gained through individual experience


  • action tendencies: part of the affect program which make the person ready to perform specific behaviors to successfully address challenges and take advantage of opportunities


  • action is not inevitable → It could be adjusted to best fit the specific situation, or even prevented from occurring if necessary.


  • but an emotion's action tendency should have been adaptive in the ancient past, not just the present day.


  • possible action tendencies by looking at animal behavior: What do animals face in their environment, and what actions do they take to survive?

    • For instance, anger evolved to address obstacles through the action tendencies of biting and hitting with the adaptive outcome of destroying the obstacle.

    • Fear evolved to address threats through the action tendency of running away with the adaptive outcome of escape.

    • anticipation evolved to address opportunities of new territories through the action tendencies of examining and exploring with the adaptive outcome of acquiring new information.

→ These ancient action tendencies persist even if they are no longer adaptive in the present


Developmental detail - why study emotion development?

  • A complete developmental theory associates the unfolding of the components of emotion with that of many other skills and capacities.

  • These include maturation of the visual and motor systems and the acquisition of complex cognitive capacities, such as the ability to represent the self as an object of thought.

  • the behavioral and physiological components of fear rely on having a body with response systems that are mature enough to detect danger and run away.

  • envy and pride require the cognitive abilities of self-reflection and social comparison

  • initial attachment relationship with a caretaker


Psychological Constructionist Theories

Universality

core affect: the innate and universal component of emotion

  • Core affect is generally thought to be composed of two fundamental dimensions of conscious experience.

    • degree to which a state is pleasant versus unpleasant → valence

    • and the degree to which a state is activated versus deactivated → activation


Discreteness and coherence

Categorization: the mental process that takes experience and gives it structure and meaning

  • The emotion categories people learn by interacting with others and with the world are associated in memory with information about the probable causes of feelings, the relationships among the bodily changes, and predictions about what behavior tends to follow


Appraisal Theories

Appraisal: mental process that allows an individual to detect objects and events in the environment and evaluate their significance for the individual's immediate well-being

  • Circumstances can be appraised along many dimensions, and it is the pattern of appraisals that gives rise to particular emotions

  • in terms of how positive, novel, relevant to current goals, and congruent with norms their circumstances are, as well as whether the self or someone else was the initial cause of those circumstances

  • appraisals are not on and off; they are a matter of degree

    • this type of continuum is known as a dimension

  • unconsciously and unintentionally.

  • different appraisals lead to different emotions, an experimenter gave ambiguous, negative feedback to participants as they engaged in a difficult task.

    • The feedback caused different emotions across participants.

    • Some felt shame, some guilt, some anger, and some reported experiencing sadness.

    • Appraisals of the feedback situation, especially in terms of how important it was for the self, who caused it, and whether or not it was expected, predicted which of those negative emotions the participants reported feeling


Discreteness and coherence

biopsychosocial model: an appraisal theory about how appraisal of stressful circumstances impacts physiology and behavioral performance

  • When confronted with a stressful situation, like a difficult final exam, you may feel that you have the resources to cope with the situation. You have the time to study and the confidence that, even if the exam is hard, you have done well on past exams and will probably do well on this one.

    • challenge appraisal

    • your heart pumps more blood and the blood can flow efficiently to your limbs, improving performance in whatever task is at hand

  • Your friend, meanwhile, appraises the same exam differently. They are convinced that no amount of studying will be enough and if they fail this exam, their future will be ruined.

    • threat appraisal

    • your friends heart doesn't work as efficiently, and blood vessel constriction prevents the blood from fully oxygenating your muscles


⭐Notice that this appraisal-focused model does not predict that physiology will cohere with emotions, instead, it predicts physiology will cohere with appraisals.


Functional Theories

emotional intelligence → capacity to pay attention to and understand one's own emotions and those of others, and subsequently to use those emotions to guide behavior and decisions


Universality

Different functional theories focus on different functional consequences of emotions.


cognitive theory of emotions: views emotions as serving a regulatory capacity in terms of managing people's goals.

  • emotions come about when individuals, consciously or unconsciously, note that their behavior requires some adjustment.

  • specific emotions occur when progress on specific types of goals -which happen to be universal and highly repetitive- is interrupted.

  • the emotion then reorganizes and redirects the individual's activity in the service of a new goal, or at least in such a way as to deal with what has just occurred



broaden-and-build theory: describes the ways in which the positive emotions such as joy, interest, and contentment help an individual respond to opportunities to thrive.

  • first, that positive emotional states temporarily broaden the individual's repertoire of thoughts and actions.

  • Fredrickson notes, for example, that positive emotions are associated with an expansion, or widening, of the focus of visual attention

  • Instead of focusing exclusively on details, individuals in positive emotional states consider a wider number of cues and meanings from the environment

  • people in happy states explore visual scenes more extensively, pay more attention to the periphery of the scene and generally show greater flexibility of visual and semantic attention

  • more easily change their focus of attention and more easily access new or unusual word meanings. People's bodily movements are even broader, or more expansive, when they are in positive states


Revisiting our Definition of Emotion

"episodic, relatively short-term, biologically-based patterns of perception, experience, physiology, action, and communication that occur in response to specific physical and social challenges and opportunities"


  • Basic emotion definition: "episodic, relatively short-term, biologically-based, affect programs with consistent effects on perception, experience, physiology, action, and communication that occur in response to specific physical and social challenges and opportunities encountered repeatedly by humans over evolutionary history."

  • Psychological constructionism definition: "episodic, relatively short term, biologically-based patterns of perception, experience, physiology, action, and communication that occur in response to specific physical and social challenges and opportunities the person conceptualizes as an emotion, bringing order to an otherwise unique and context-dependent experience."

  • Appraisal theory definition: "episodic, relatively short-term, biologically-based patterns of perception, experience, physiology, action, and communication that occur in response to specific physical and social challenges and opportunities map onto cognitive appraisals about the situation."

  • Functional theory definition: "episodic, relatively short-term, biologically-based patterns of perception, experience, physiology, action, and communication that prepare the person for context-specific, goal-directed behavior, occur in response to specific physical and social challenges and opportunities."


Summary

  • Basic emotion theories hold that emotions are evolved and programmed responses to certain opportunities and challenges posed by the environment. One of the key predictions of the basic emotion theory of emotion, which we will revisit several times in this book, is that a set of universally recognized facial expressions of emotion exists.

  • The psychological constructionist theory of emotion states that emotions are phenomena that are given shape by the process of categorization. Emotions are not stable biological entities, but rather elaborated within linguistic and cultural contexts.

  • The major contribution of appraisal theories of emotion is the idea that emotions are elicited and differentiated by evaluations (appraisals) of the environment with respect to the current goals and interests of the individual experiencing the emotion.

  • Functional theories of emotion agree with basic emotion theories that emotions drive adaptive behavior. However, they define a category of emotions (e.g. "anger") not by its expression (scowl) or by a specific behavior (punch), but instead by its functional consequence (correcting a perceived injustice).

  • Appraisal, functional, and constructionist theories agree that the different components of emotion can be quite separate and have separate time courses and that an inevitable set of components does not accompany all emotional episodes. They usually do not endorse the basic emotion idea of affect programs.


WEEK 1 - CH3 - METHODS FOR THE SCIENCE OF EMOTION

Tools for Inducing Emotional Responses

Scripted social interaction

  • cover story (deception) about the experimental hypothesis and the use of a scripted social interaction involving the…

  • …experimenter or a fake participant (a confederate) who is working with the experimenter


Developmental detail - Getting little ones emotional (ethically)

  • the mother is often enlisted to help generate emotional responding.

    • For instance, to look at the effects of facial expressions on the emotional expression of infants, instructed mothers to make happy, sad, and angry facial expressions at their ten-week-olds while saying sentences that conveyed the same emotion.

    • One difficulty with this procedure is that not all caretakers are good actors.

    • Nevertheless, this study and others found evidence that the babies were likely to match their facial expressions to their mothers


  • At a slightly later age, scripted interactions can also be used to elicit emotions.

    • For example, elicited anger responses in seven-month-old babies by having the mother or the experimenter give their baby a Gerber teething biscuit and then take it away (and out of reach!).

    • Because babies at this age are usually not independently mobile, manipulations such as this, successfully induce frustration and anger


Study Designs

Quasi-experimental design

  • experimental and control conditions

  • but participants are not randomly assigned to them

  • enhances ecological validity → phenomenon occurs in daily life


Correlational designs

experience sampling: online, app, daily questionnaires


Induction methods are not all the same

there are ways in which the methods can be compared that can help you choose which is the best for your specific research question

most important dimensions are:

  • Experimental demand

  • Standardization

  • Complexity

  • Ecological validity


Experimental demand: how easy it is for experimental participants to guess what a study is designed to test.

  • Experimental demand is high if the participant can very easily guess

  • undesirable in cases in which the participant is motivated and able to change their behavior to either help or hurt the experimenter.

  • Exposure to clearly happy or sad films, images, or music can seem to participants like obvious attempts to manipulate mood or emotional response


Standardization: the extent to which the method used to induce emotions has been pilot-tested for effectiveness and reliability across people and contexts


Complexity and ecological validity are related ideas:

  • Whereas complexity refers to invoking many components of the emotion in the laboratory experience,

  • ecological validity is the extent to which the experience is similar to what might be experienced in daily life.

  • The emotional experience in the laboratory is influenced and sometimes constrained by the methods being used by the experimenter

    • For instance, when participants are lying in a magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scanner viewing IAPS images, the complexity and ecological validity of the emotional response must be viewed as limited

    • Not only do the images not produce a complex state, but the fact that the participant may not move limits the extent to which the body can be involved in the experience of the emotional response


Measuring Emotions

Facial expressions

component method: induced contraction of facial muscles with the use of electric currents and took pics → developed as the widely used anatomically based coding system , the Facial Action Coding Scheme (FACS) → FACS measures the appearance of changes in the face caused by muscular movements


judgement method: information that an observer can infer from facial expressions


Central nervous system

systems of the brain that are active in response to an emotional event, such as a reaction to the sight of two puppies playing


Peripheral nervous system

Somatic nervous system (SNS) innervates skeletal muscles, including those of the face, that are under voluntary control

  • execute plans to make the movements that are necessary to walk, run, get dressed, and pick up a coffee cup or a cell phone


Autonomic nervous system (ANS) internal balance of your body when you are faced with changing circumstances and adjusting innervation of smooth muscles-such as the heart-and glands

→ sympathetic

→parasympathetic


Assessment methods are not all the same

Just as available methods for inducing emotions do not all accomplish the same thing, neither do methods for measuring emotions

The important considerations for choosing a way to measure emotions in research are whether the method is:

  • Language-based.

  • Subjective versus objective.

  • Measuring discrete or more global states of emotion

  • invasive.

  • Expensive.

Summary

  • We described many ways to (ethically) induce emotional states in the laboratory, including the use of film, music, scripted interaction, and the presentation of emotional images.

  • We noted that emotions can also be studied by harnessing naturally occurring emotions. Outside of the laboratory, experience sampling techniques can be used to collect reports about emotions as they occur in real-life situations.

  • There are also many techniques for measuring individuals' emotional states, including the use of questionnaires, the assessment of facial expressions, and recordings from the brain and physiology.

  • By using many methods and assessing many parts of the whole elephant that we call an emotion, we can start to get closer to some truths about the components of emotion and their harmony or disharmony; about the involvement of all of "human nature"-the processes of the mind and the body -that make up an emotional experience; and about the role that emotions play in social life, the topic of the remainder of the book.

WEEK 2 - L2 - EMOTION REGULATION & EXPRESSION

Content & Learning Goals & Focus of this Lecture


  1. Emotion Regulation in Context

  2. Emotion Expression & Recognition


  • understand emotion regulation as a context-sensitive, dynamic process rather than a fixed skill

  • analyze how goals, context, and relationships shape regulatory choices

  • recognize the flexibility and polyregulation required in real-world settings

  • connect regulation to implicit and interpersonal processes

  • explore how emotion regulation shapes expression (what we show or hide)

  • understand multimodal emotion recognition and its contextual nature

  • critically reflect on technological emotion detection (e.g., FaceReader)

  • connect expression, recognition, and regulation as a social feedback loop


  • emotion as a dynamic process

    • regulated inside, expressed outside, and shaped in context


The emotional feedback loop


1) Emotion Regulation in Context

when and why does emotion regulation work (or not)?


Process model Gross

see clip 2 (below)


Other examples of emotion regulation strategies

strategy

definition

rumination

repetitively and passively thinking about your feelings and problems

distraction

redirecting attention within a situation or shifts attention away from the situation

enhancement

up-regulation or accentuation of feelings

catastrophizing

thoughts of explicitly emphasizing the terror of what you have experienced

self-blame

thoughts of putting the blame on yourself

other-blame

thoughts of putting the blame on the environment or another person

putting into perspective

emphasizing the relativity of the event when comparing it to other events (to make yourself feel better)

acceptance

thoughts of accepting what you have experienced and resigning yourself to what has happened


Scenario: Possible emotion regulation strategies?

a student receives unexpected critical feedback from the professor right after a group presentation. She feels embarrassed and defensive.


putting into perspective ā†’Ā ā€œother students also got bad feedbackā€


Beyond ā€œgoodā€ or ā€œbadā€ strategies

no strategy is universally adaptive

→ effectiveness depends on context, timing, and motivation


example:

  • distraction may help in acute stress, but hinder processing in the long term

  • suppression may protect relationships short-term, but reduce authenticity over time


Short-term vs Long-term effects

strategy

short-term effects

long-term effects

reappraisal

reduces immediate negative affect; promotes composure

builds resilience and learning orientation; associated with better academic outcomes

suppression

maintains professionalism; prevents escalation

increases physiological stress, reduces authenticity, can harm group relationships

distraction

temporarily eases distress

avoids reflection; emotions may resurface later

social support

offers emotional relief and perspective

strengthens relationships; promotes adaptive coping

rumination

intensifies negative emotion

maintains shame/defensiveness; impairs self-confidence


Emotion regulation goals


different goals/motives for regulating emotions

  • hedonic motives: aiming to feel better (comfort, pleasure, calm)

  • instrumental motives: aiming to feel useful emotions (e.g., stress for focus, anger for assertiveness)

  • prosocial motives: to protect the feelings of others

  • self-protective motives: protect their safety or to elicit helpful reactions from others

  • impression management motives: the fear of being judged negatively by others


Emotion regulation goals in context


goal conflicts require strategic choice, based on:

  • how you value your emotions

  • your repertoire of emotion regulation strategies

  • your emotion regulation abilities

  • your effort to employ a strategy


Emotion regulation flexibility and polyregulation


  • flexibility: matching strategies to situational demands

  • polyregulation: using multiple strategies together or in sequence

  • adaptive regulation = context sensitivity x repertoire x responsiveness


Case: Emotion regulation flexibility


It's a regular working day for Pete. He is in the office with 4 colleagues. Recently a new colleague joined. This guy has an irritating voice. Pete tends to roll his eyes when the new colleague talks. The other colleagues don't seem to be bothered by it. Because Pete doesn't want to show his colleagues how irritated he is, he tries to suppress the tendency to look annoyed. The colleague also can't help having an irritating voice. Pete thinks that if he worked somewhere else, there would always be something he didn't like. He has heard from friends that they work with 15 people in one room. He would go completely crazy!


Pete is glad that his work is done. Tonight, he is having friends over for dinner! He bikes home but is in the middle of a rainstorm on the way home. He doesn't want to let it ruin his good mood and thinks of the nice evening he has ahead of him. Now that he is getting wet, this is actually a good opportunity to jump into the shower before his friends arrive.


When his friends arrive, they have a great time. They laugh like crazy, and Pete tells tall tales. His face speaks volumes.


  • suppression of expression

  • reappraisal

  • putting into perspective

  • distraction

  • reappraisal


Implicit and interpersonal regulation


  • implicit regulation: automatic, learned emotion control (habits, attentional biases)

  • interpersonal regulation: influencing or being influenced by others’ emotions

    • co-regulation in teams, families, or couples

    • emotional contagion and empathy


2) Emotion Expression & Recognition

what do our expressions reveal - and what do others actually see?


From regulation to expression

  • regulation shapes what we show

  • we might suppress, exaggerate, or mask emotions depending on goals and context

  • expression itself can regulate emotion (smiling can lift mood)


Expression as communication

  • expression communicates internal states, intentions, and social meaning

  • display rules: learned norms about when to show or hide emotion

  • expressions serve both personal and relational goals


Multimodal emotion recognition

  • emotion is perceived through multiple channels

    • facial expression

    • vocal tone and prosody

    • body posture and movement

    • context (social and cultures)


  • recognition depends on integration of cues - and is influenced by our own state and biases

  • embodied simulation

    • we simulate others’ expressions using our own emotion and motor systems, giving us access to their underlying feelings


Automated emotion detection

Noldu’s FaceReader:

  • software that classifies basic emotions based on facial Actions Units

  • estimates valence and arousal, useful for research and training


strengths:

  • objective

  • fast

  • consistent


limitations:

  • lack context sensitivity

  • sensitive to lighting and angles

  • struggles with mixed or regulated expressions

  • cannot infer intentional regulation


Key Takeaways

concept

deep insight

example

emotion regulation is contextual

no one strategy fits all

suppression may help socially but harms authenticity

flexibility is key

match strategy to situation

distraction → reappraisal sequence

regulation can be social

we regulate with and for others

comforting a peer

expression is part of regulation

what we show influences what we feel

smiling to stay calm

recognition is multimodal

context and cues matter

facial + vocal + body signals

recognition closes the loop

what others see reshapes what we feel

feedback loop



WEEK 2 - CLIP 2 - EMOTION REGULATION

Gross (1998,2015)

defines emotion regulation as: process by which individuals influence what emotions they have, when to have them, how they experience and express them

→ people choose to reduce, strengthen, or maintain the experience of positive / negative emotions depending on their goals and their regulation efforts


Tamir (2016)

distinguished between 2 emotion regulation goals:

1. Hedonic

  • short-term desires to feel better

  • increasing positive emotions

  • reducing negative emotions


2. Instrumental

  • social or performative motives that canĀ  be aided by emotion regulation

  • for example, you may choose to not express your anger in order to maintain a good relationship with your friend



⭐Hedonic goals may not match instrumental goals → you can reduce positive emotions in order to focus on studying


Process Model by Gross

  • explains emotion regulation process over time

  • 5 emotion regulation strategies

  • these 5 strategies in the model affect each other (for example, expressing your happiness → makes the situation more pleasant)


1. Situation selection

  • you select a situation to influence your emotions

  • antecedent-focused (applied before the emotional response is generated)


2. Situation modification

  • you alter the situation you are in to alter it’s emotional impact

  • antecedent-focused (applied before the emotional response is generated)


3. Attention deployment

  • you direct your attention to influence your emotions

  • antecedent-focused (applied before the emotional response is generated)


4. Cognitive change

  • you modify your appraisal / interpretation of a situation to modify it’s emotional impact

  • antecedent-focused (applied before the emotional response is generated)


5. Response modulation

  • you directly change your behavioral, experiential, or psychological emotional response

  • response-focused (after the emotional responses are activated)



2 most researched emotion regulation strategies by Gross:


1) Reappraisal

  • cognitive change strategy (4) aimed at modifying the emotional meaning and impact of an emotional situation

  • being bullied → stronger


→ Reappraisal = adaptive (+)

  • higher self-esteem, life satisfaction, well-being

  • lower psychopathology (anxiety, and depressive symptoms…)


2) Expressive suppression

  • response modulation strategy (5) → inhibition of emotional expression

  • hold your tears to show that it doesn’t bother you


→ Expressive suppression = maladaptive (-)

  • lower self-esteem, life satisfaction, well-being

  • higher psychopathology (anxiety, and depressive symptoms…)


Other Strategies


Adaptive (+)

  • distraction

  • enhancement

  • putting it into perspective

  • acceptance


Maladaptive (-)

  • rumination

  • catastrophizingĀ 

  • self-blame

  • other-blame



however according to the process model:

  • emotions don’t need to be regulated all the time, but just when they interfere with goals

  • and whether strategies are adaptive or maladaptive depends on the context of the situation

  • for example, expressive suppression can be adaptive in the short-run



Emotion Regulation Flexibility

using different strategies based on the current situations demands


emotion poly-regulation: using multiple strategies at the same time


WEEK 2 - L3 - MINDFULNESS

Overview

  • what is happiness?

    • its effects and how to promote it


  • what is mindfulness?

    • mindfulness and stress/ emotions

    • mindfulness-based interventions

    • efficacy

    • mindfulness and emotion regulation


Happiness

  • historic overview of the book not always correct → skip!

    • e.g. ancient hedonism was not about seeking momentary pleasure, but avoiding pain, including mental pain caused by desire…


  • definition happiness:

    • Lyubomirsky et al: subjective well-being = having frequent positive and infrequent negative emotions + life satisfaction (last two often aren’t included in research)


  • positive effects happiness:

    • happy behavior = attractive to others → easier connection and collaboration (also in experimental research)

    • better health (better cardiac and immune function, healthier lifestyle)

    • occupational success (also better performance)


What determines happiness?

  • 50% set point → genetics

  • 40% intentional activity → daily life

  • 10% circumstances → sociodemographic


this is hypothetical! (book ā€œwho is happyā€ is misleading)

empirical studies show variable results → intentional activity interventions <10%


what predicts happiness?

  • limited evidence for money or whether (only limited correlations)

  • affective forecasting (ability to predict our future emotions): people are poor at it, why?

    • impact bias (expected impact inflated), perhaps because of focalism (cognitive bias where people overemphasize one specific piece of information)

    • hedonic adaptation (tendency to quickly return to a stable, baseline level of happiness), plausibly because of survival value of novel information

    • social comparison: downward vs upward


So, what boosts happiness?

  • gratitude

    • randomized trials of interventions show modest positive effects (small effects on average, 1% explained variance)


  • expressing kindness to others

    • randomized trials of interventions show modest positive effects (small effects on average, 3% explained variance)


  • talking to strangers → only some individual studies show some positive effects


  • mindfulness

    • book provides only references on decreases of negative emotions (medium-sized effects), but:

    • randomized trials of interventions on well-being show modest positive effects (small effects on average, 3% explained variance)

    • book is incorrect that we know the mechanism of mindfulness


  • and large interindividual differences! →possible effects of differences in baseline well-being - should get more attention


Mindfulness

  • paying attention in a particular way: on purpose, in the present moment, and non-judgmentally

  • to:

    • anything that enters consciousness, sensory, proprioceptive, mental phenomena


  • attention:

    • open

    • direct → voluntary and pre-reflexive → prior to judgment

    • judgment-free


  • ā€œthe clear and single-minded awareness of what actually happens to us and in us at the successive moments of perceptionā€

  • ā€œit offers a bare display of what is taking placeā€


judgement → appraisal


West vs East

  • western psychology

    • Ā focused on parts of self, which one does not like and tries to change, for a better future


  • ancient eastern psychology facets:

    • acceptance of reality (including oneself as totality) at it is in the moment


  • integration

    • mindfulness (acceptance) concepts in western psychology


  • 3rd wave of CBT interventions:

    • Mindfulness Based Stress Reduction (MBSR)

    • Mindfulness Based Cognitive Therapy (MBCT)

    • Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT)

    • Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT)

    • Meta-Cognitive Therapy (MCT)


Mindfulness misconceptions

  1. ā€œyou need to make your mind emptyā€

→ No, thoughts are ok, you just don’t have to take them seriously all the time


  1. ā€œmindfulness strives for a "pink sunglasses world and is vagueā€

→ full catastrophe living

→ take reality for what it is


  1. ā€œmindfulness leads to passivityā€

→ No, reality includes ones own inner signals!

→ more healthy and authentic action


Emotion regulation paradox

  • mindfulness stance:

    • emotion (experience) does NOT need to get regulated

      • just mental phenomenon

      • ACT: not negative emotions per se are unfavorable, but experiential avoidance of negative emotions

      • ā€œjust feel feelings as feelings, think thoughts as thoughts, fully and without defense, and get on with the business of livingā€


  • mindfulness paradox:

    • people want their emotion (experience) regulated →

    • in MBSR they learn it is not necessary, just accept them as they appear →

    • emotions get regulated… how?


The RICH model of mindfulness and psychological well-being



Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR)

  • dual processing: usually noticing thinking → redirecting attention to…

    • interoceptive phenomena: breathing (mediation), body (body scan, mindful yoga), emotion


  • but also introspection: watching thoughts

  • phenomena are acknowledged/ accepted as they are!

  • in daily life practicing mindful attention

  • 8 groups sessions of 2 hours (+ 35 min homework every day!)


Psychological correlates

  • self-reported mindfulness correlates with:

    • general distress ↓

    • anxiety, depressive symptoms ↓

    • Neuroticism ↓

    • Extraversion and openness ↑


BUT:

  • correlation =/==/= causation

  • chicken-egg paradox


Psychological effects: intervention

  • Scientific evidence for beneficial psychological effects of MBSR is accumulating:

    • General distress ↓

    • Anxiety, worry, rumination ↓

    • Depressive symptoms ↓

    • Pain ↓

    • Sleep quality ↑

    • Quality of life (QoL) ↑



  • Meta-analysis 1 → on symptoms of anxiety and depression: mean effect size of d=.6d = .6 (overall) āˆ’.9- .9 (in psychol. patients),


  • Meta-analysis 2 → mean effect size Hedges g=.53g = .53 ; vs. other psychological therapies g=.22g = .22 , except CBT/BT: same


Effect on self-reported mindfulness

interaction effect → MBSR was successful in increasing mindfulness


Example: effect on feelings of distress

interaction effect → MBSR successfully reduced distress


Effect on overall quality of life

interaction effect → MBSR successfully increased quality of life


Brain mechanism: prefrontal cortex

prefrontal cortex areas such as MPFC, RVLPFC, and VMPFC are responsible for emotion regulation

→ Higher mindfulness is associated with greater recruitment of prefrontal control regions during emotional processing


And negative correlation with amygdala activity

amygdala → negative emotions

→ As mindfulness increases amygdala activity decreases during emotional processing


Does it work for everyone equally?

→ less effective in male diabetic patients on depressive symptoms


[usually there is no sex differences

in this study men dropped out because they usually aren’t open to it and they didn’t know when signing up that they were gonna do manfulness

but usually no sex differences when participants volunteer knowing there is mindfulness involved]



→ less effective in high extraverted diabetic patients on depressive (left) and anxiety (right) symptoms


[these two are exceptions!

No moderators found]


Is mindfulness responsible?

  • in > 130 patients with diabetes

  • positive effects of mindfulness therapy on perceived stress

  • ā€œstatistically mediatedā€ by mindful non-reacting (letting go)


Is mindfulness the mechanism?

mindfulness predicts less negative mood the next day, but not vice versa


Buffer effect mindfulness

  • in > 200 patients with rheumatoid arthritis:

mindfulness → less stress a year later, even when the disability is high


Mindfulness: conclusions

  • mindfulness is a cognitive attitude/skill

  • correlates with adaptive psychological constructs

  • seems to buffer against psychological stress

  • forms basis for new (3rd wave) therapies

    • which are effective for emotional problems and increase quality of life compared to waitlist and active interventions, but equally effective to CBT

  • moderators only beginning to be examined: role of sex and extraversion needs to be researched more

  • change in mindfulness mediates the effects and may indeed be the mechanism of action

  • future research should examine more for whom mindfulness vs content-oriented therapies help best


WEEK 3 - L4 - MENTALIZATION BASED TREATMENT

Patient: Wendy

background:

  • 22 years old, alone, quit with her studies

  • she was raised up by a very dominant mother

  • Wendy felt extremely rejected by her mother

  • sexual abuse by her father, which has been a secret till now


Problematic Interaction Patterns

  • attitude:Ā ā€œeverything is all right, there is nothing wrong with meā€ → this way she keeps distance from other people, but she feels very lonely

  • she does everything people ask her to do → people-pleaser

  • she is very anxious for critics and rejection


Situation:

  • in the previous session the therapist asked Wendy:Ā ā€œWhy do you still do everything you’re mother asks you?ā€

  • it was the end of the session and Wendy was overwhelmed by emotion she started crying and it didn’t stop

  • the therapist had to stop the session and Wendy went home crying


Wendy 1

ā€œYou don’t even care about me, we should stop therapy, this isn’t working for me, I just cry all week and you let me go like nothing happened, you don’t careā€


What does Wendy experience?

  • thoughts and feelings areĀ ā€œtoo realā€

  • extreme rigid, everything is absolute

  • reading people’s thoughts

  • no room for perspectives

  • suspicious and hostile


What kind of response do feel as a therapist?

  • you don’t know how to react or what to say

  • you yourself will be overwhelmed by emotions

  • you nod and you hope it will pass

  • you become irritated because of her attitude


Psychic equivalence mode

internal reality = external reality


  • specific understanding (ā€œI feel this, which means it’s the truthā€)

  • extremely rigid thinking, absolute convictions, etc.

  • being able to read the thoughts of others,Ā ā€œknowingā€ what they are like, etc

  • no room for other perspectives

  • negative cognitions about oneself are viewed as the absolute truth

  • internal experiences can be frightening (flashbacks)

  • distrust and hostility are often the affect


THOUGHTS & FEELINGS OF CLIENT

  • rigid

  • no doubt

  • security

  • absolute

  • certainty

  • ā€œwhat I feel is realityā€

ā†’Ā ā€œThis therapy won’t help me, It’s simply a fact that I AM crazy. I know you think so too, but you’re too much of a coward to tell me. I should just end it allā€¦ā€


THOUGHTS & FEELINGS OF THERAPIST

  • hopeless:Ā ā€œthis will never workā€

  • powerless:Ā ā€œI don’t know what to sayā€

  • angry:Ā ā€œnot this shit againā€

  • anxious:Ā ā€œ how do I talk him out of this?ā€

  • amazed/surprised:Ā ā€œhuh? what did he just say?ā€


Wendy 2

ā€œI can’t breath, please give me new medication, this therapy isn’t working, I need meds, please, please help meā€


What does Wendy experience?

  • ā€œI feel this, which means it’s the truthā€

  • asking for action of the therapist

  • demanding


What kind of response do you feel as a therapist?

  • guilty → you feel like you can’t do it right

  • you want to do something

  • give her practical tips, arrange things for her

  • angry or helpless


Teleological mode

  • intentions are only seen when someone else does something (action)

  • states of mind are recognized and believed only if their outcomes are physically observable


THOUGHTS & FEELINGS OF CLIENT

  • self-destructive behavior

  • It’s about what you DO and not what do you sayā€

  • ā€œonly what I see is realityā€

ā†’Ā ā€œ Something has to be done, why don’t you see that I feel so awfully bad. I have to have some medication, I have to speak to a psychiatrist. How are you going to arrange this?ā€


THOUGHTS & FEELINGS OF THERAPIST

  • fear

  • insecurity

  • uncertainty

  • ā€œI have to do somethingā€

  • ā€œmaybe it will help if I call her tonightā€

  • ā€œhow can I show her that I am involved?ā€

  • ā€œshe’s trying to manipulate meā€


Wendy 3

ā€œI feel great, I cried all week, you know I went to chakra therapy and I felt everything, it was great, I feel greatā€


What does Wendy experience?

  • not lively

  • emptiness

  • doesn’t show any feelings

  • absence of emotions

  • there is no meaning in what she says

  • looks like she is keeping distance

  • what she says is not consistent


What kind of response do you feel as a therapist?

  • you are very bored

  • go along with not feeling like how the client is doing → identifying with the model

  • detachment

  • sometimes working hard onlyĀ ā€œcognitiveā€

  • you think there is a lot of progress in the treatment


Pretend mode

the internal world has been disconnected from the external world


  • linked to emptiness, meaninglessness, and dissociation

  • in the session, endless and inconsistent (unimportant) discussion of thoughts and feelings → meaningless

  • risky behaviors such as drug use, impulsive purchases, binge eating, self-harm → patients want to feel again

  • the inner mental world is not experienced as dependent on the physical existence: self-harm, suicide attempts


  • emptiness

  • meaningless

  • dissociation

  • no change

  • absence of joy

  • lack of emotion


THOUGHTS AND EMOTIONS OF THE THERAPIST - Pretend Mode

  • boredom

  • detachment

  • illusion of progress


What Is Mentalizing

inside out trailer


Definition of mentalizing

ability to understand actions of oneself and others, explicitly and implicitly, in terms of intentional mental states (feelings, thoughts, intentions, wishes and desires)


Characteristics of mentalizing

  • mental states (emotions, thoughts, etc.) occur on the inside, barely visible

  • we draw our ā€œconclusionsā€ (make assumptions) about mental states

  • mistakes are easily made when drawing these conclusions

  • the core principle in this process is to adopt a ā€œnot knowing standā€ and open attitude, with a willingness to learn


Mentalizing - Self and the other relationship

  • to view ourselves ā€œfrom the outsideā€ and other people’s inner worlds

  • the normal ability to ascribe meaning and intent to human behavior

  • the ability to understand emotions, thoughts, intentions, and desires

  • mentalizing creates a meaningful self

  • helps us understand ourselves and others

  • mentalizing allows us to understand why mix ups occur

  • essential for human interaction and relationships


How and When Does the Ability to Mentalize Develop?

gradual development process starting at birth:

  • intentionality (shared attention) → age 1

  • play pretend and language use to refer to internal conditions → early childhood

  • sophisticated understanding of emotions → early childhood

→ ⭐broccoli-cracker experiment


pre-mentalizing modes:

  • teleological mode (+/- 1.5 years)

    • object constancy: ā€œif i can’t see it, its not thereā€


  • psychic equivalence mode (+/- 2 years)

    • internal reality = external reality

    • still no realization that others enjoy different things than him → own reality = only reality


  • play pretend mode (+/- 3 to 4 years)

    • internal reality becomes separated from external reality

      • chair = train


  • mentalizing → integration of the modes above (around 4 years)

    • mental states are only 1 representation of multiple perspectives on reality



2 important factors:

  • secure attachments

  • and within that secure attachment relation, the marked mirroring


Core processes in developing mentalizing

Core process: Attachment

  • In order to survive, every child has an innate capacity to look for closeness and protection in others (Bowlby)

  • Attachment is regulation of emotions in interaction with others

  • Children develop the ability to mentalize in relation to attachment figures


ATTACHMENT STRATEGIES IN CHILDHOOD


  • Feeling secure: anxiety and sadness at separation, immediate recovery of closeness when reunited, then continues playing and exploring

  • Avoidance: demonstrates little fear upon separation, avoids parent when reunited

  • Ambivalence: Anxious at separation, clingy, angry and tense at reunion

  • Disorganized: no coherent strategy


ATTACHMENT STYLES IN ADULTS (PARENTS)


  • Autonomous: explains in a clear, coherent and nuanced manner

  • Reserved: idealizes parents without substantiation, parents unimportant, lack of concrete memories

  • Preoccupied: confused and non-objective, passive, angry-conflicted or angry-confused

  • Unprocessed/disorganized: unprocessed pain of loss or memories of abuse come flooding back


DISTRIBUTION AMONG AVERAGE POPULATION


  • secure (60%)


  • insecure (40%)

    • avoidant (20%)

    • ambivalent (15%)

    • disorganized (5%)


PSYCHOPATHOLOGY


  • insecure attachment does NOT automatically lead to psychopathology

  • disorganized attachment does lead to psychopathology at a later age

  • the ability to mentalize is less in people with an insecure attachment style than with people with a secure attachment style

  • stress and trauma reduce the ability to mentalize

  • reduced ability to mentalize makes it harder to interact with others


Core process: Mirroring

Congruent mirroring (same action)

  • Observer’s brain activity matches the same action/emotion they’re seeing.

  • Example: you see someone smile → your ā€œsmileā€ system lights up.

  • Same movement, same emotion, same neural pattern.

  • Direct matching. No translation.

→ ā€œI see it, I internally do it.ā€


Incongruent mirroring (no matching)

  • The observer’s response does NOT match the other person’s emotion or action.

  • Can be opposite, mismatched, or emotionally off-beat.

  • Often regulated, defensive, or socially strategic.

Examples:

  • Someone is sad → you smile or laugh (awkward coping, not villain arc).

  • Someone is angry → you stay overly calm or emotionally flat.

  • Therapist stays neutral while client is emotional.

ā†’ā€œI see your emotion… and I’m not matching it.ā€


Marked mirroring (same emotion)

  • The observer mirrors the emotion, not the exact action.

  • Different expression, same feeling.

  • Example: someone cries → you don’t cry, but your sadness/emotion circuits activate.

  • Think of it as emotional tagging, not copy-paste.

→ ā€œI get how you feel, even if I’m not doing what you’re doing.ā€


Unmarked mirroring (automatic)

  • Automatic, unconscious, and literal copying of another person.

  • No emotional ā€œtranslation,ā€ no regulation, no context check.

  • Same action, same expression, same timing.

Example:

  • Someone yawns → you yawn.

  • Someone crosses their arms → suddenly you’re doing it too.

  • Baby sticks out tongue, adult sticks out tongue back (iconic).

→ ā€œI saw it. I did it. No thoughts.ā€


Contingent mirroring (situational)

  • The response is context-dependent, not automatic.

  • You mirror only when it’s socially relevant or appropriate.

  • Example: comforting someone who’s upset vs staying neutral in a professional setting.

  • Involves higher-level regulation and social cognition.

→ ā€œI could mirror, but let me read the room first.ā€



HOW DO YOU LEARN TO DEAL WITH AFFECT? - Marked and Congruent Mirroring

  • child in state of arousal

  • parent notices the child’s mental state and understands what is happening → resonance

  • parent shows that they are thinking about the child → reflection

  • parent responds, not in a state of arousal themselves → marked expression

  • child understands that it is understandable, can be calmed down, starts to understand own feelings


THE EFFECTS OF UNMARKED MIRRORING

  • parent resonates accurately, but not markedly (too realistic)

  • escalation because no containment takes place

  • child’s feelings remain intense and frightening


⭐unmarked mirroring → no distinction between own experiences and those of others → no secondary representation of the emotion → psychic equivalence mode

[internal reality = external reality


  • specific understanding (ā€œI feel this, which means it’s the truthā€)

  • extremely rigid thinking, absolute convictions, etc.

  • being able to read the thoughts of others,Ā ā€œknowingā€ what they are like, etc

  • no room for other perspectives

  • negative cognitions about oneself are viewed as the absolute truth

  • internal experiences can be frightening (flashbacks)

  • distrust and hostility are often the affect]


THE EFFECTS OF INCONGRUENT MIRRORING

  • parent does not resonate appropriately in relation to the child’s experience

  • inner experience not rooted in reality → false self, emptiness


⭐incongruent mirroring → mirrored feelings do not match internal feelings → non-matching secondary representations → incoherence and fragmentation of self image (unstable self image) → pretend mode

[the internal world has been disconnected from the external world


  • linked to emptiness, meaninglessness, and dissociation

  • in the session, endless and inconsistent (unimportant) discussion of thoughts and feelings → meaningless

  • risky behaviors such as drug use, impulsive purchases, binge eating, self-harm → patients want to feel again

  • the inner mental world is not experienced as dependent on the physical existence: self-harm, suicide attempts]


Mental representation: Development of regulated affect


Affect regulation

safe:

  • modulate and calming of painful

→ mentalizing


avoidant:

  • over-regulation of the affect

→ pretend mode


preoccupied:

  • under-regulation of the affect

→ psychic equivalent mode


disorganized:

  • over/under-regulation

→ pretend mode

→ psychic equivalent mode


Bio-behavioral ā€œSwitchā€ Model

ā€œThe bio-behavioral switch model proposes that caregiver presence suppresses children’s physiological stress responses, shifting regulation from biological to social systems.ā€


  • Secure → switch flips easily

  • Insecure → switch is unreliable or broken


What does Good Mentalizing look like?

with respect to the feeling and thoughts of others:

  • realization of being barely visible

  • absence of paranoia

  • contemplation and reflection

  • place things in the right perspective

  • sincere interest

  • be open to new discoveries

  • forgiveness

  • predictability


  • the perception of own psychological functioning

    • positive appreciation of changeability

    • development-oriented

    • realistic doubts

    • understanding of the existence of preconscious content


  • general standards and attitudes, for example, a degree of researchability and moderation



WEEK 3 - CLIP 3 - COGNITIVE PREOCESSES

  • what does the cognitive emotion model entail?

  • what is appraisal?


Cognitive Emotion Model Magda Arnold & Richard Lazarus

  • cognitive therapies are based on this model

  • basic premise of the model: event itself does NOT cause emotions but its the appraisal that matters

    • how do I view the situation?

    • how important is it?

    • do I find it positive or negative?

    • is it a challenge or a threat?

    • who do I consider responsible?


for example → something very serious happens and I think…

  • …I caused that: guilt

  • …my neighbor caused that: anger

  • …it was bound to happen: sadness

→ who I consider responsible determines my emotion

→ what the event is does NOT matter (it can be sometimes)


⭐appraisal is important for therapy because bad situations are bound to happen in someone’s life, we can’t stop that but we can change how we look at those situations!



So, the cognitive emotional model states that → appraisal precedes feelings

  • but is that the case all the time?

  • for example, when you are disgusted by a food you first react then cognitive processes and appraisal kicks in


Kinds of Appraisal

  • there’s 2 kinds of appraisal

  • but there are different models, what one considers primary and secondary appraisal differ between them

  • but in general…

1. Primary appraisal

immediate, automatic, and partly unconscious evaluation of whether a stimulus / situation is…

  • good or bad

  • relevant or irrelevant

→ and whether if we want to avoid or approach the person / situation


2. Secondary appraisal

  • appraisal in relation to more specific goals and/or ego involvement

  • for example, moral values, important ideals

  • has 2 categories ↓


→ DISCRETE APPROACHES

appraisal gives rise to a distinct emotion (Lazarus)


→ DIMENSIONAL APPROACHES

focuses on components of appraisal that can relate to several emotions (Smith & Ellsworth)


Ā» Secondary Appraisal: Discrete Approaches

Core relational theme (Lazarus)

  • summary of different classes of events that elicit emotions

  • situation / emotions that are critical for human evolution

  • for example, survival, reproduction, collaboration → benefit, harm or loss, threat, coping potential, blame


EMOTION

CORE RELATIONAL THEME

anger

a demeaning offense against me and mine

anxiety

facing uncertain, existential threat

fright

facing an immediate, concrete, and overwhelming physical danger

guilt

having transgressed a moral imperative

shame

having failed to live up to an ego-ideal

sadness

having experienced an irrevocable loss

envy

wanting what someone else has

jealousy

resenting a third party for loss or threat to another's affection or favor

disgust

taking in or being too close to an indigestible object or idea

happiness

making reasonable progress toward to realization of a goal

pride

enhancement of one’s ego-identity by taking credit for a valued object or achievement, either our own or that of someone or group with whom we identify

relief

a distressing goal-incongruent condition that has changed for the better or gone away

hope

fearing the worst but yearning for the better

love

desiring or participating in affection, usually but not necessarily reciprocated

compassion

being moved by another’s suffering and wanting to help



so the correlational themes indicate the kinds of situations that trigger those emotions

→ very limited: emotions can involve more than hat is stated in those themes


Ā» Secondary Appraisal: Dimensional Approaches

Smith & Ellsworth

distinguished 8 different dimensions of meaning that capture the appraisal processes that lead to different emotions:


  1. PLEASENTNESS → good or bad

  2. ATTENTIONAL ACTIVITY → whether it attracts attention

  3. CONTROL → to what extent can we control this situation

  4. CERTAINTY → how confident you are in the situation

  5. GOAL-PATH OBSTACLE → to what extent are your goals hindered

  6. LEGITIMACY → fair or unfair

  7. RESPONSIBILITY → are you responsible or not

  8. ANTICIPATED EFFORT → none or much


Scherer

distinguished 8 different evaluation checks that always occur in a fixed order:


  1. Expectation: did you expect that event to occur?

  2. Pleasantness: did you find the event pleasant or unpleasant?

  3. Goal conduciveness: did the event help or hinder you in the achievements of your goals?

  4. Fairness: was the event just or unfair?

  5. Causation: who caused the event?

  6. Coping ability: were you able to cope effectively with the event improper or immoral?

  7. Morality: was your behavior in the event immoral?

  8. Self-consistency: did the event have a positive or negative influence on your self-worth?


Third Phase of Appraisal: Social Sharing

  • when we experience emotions (especially strong ones) we have a tendency to share it with others

  • why…↓


MOTIVES FOR SOCIAL SHARING (RimƩ)


  • Rehearse → to remember or re-experience the event

  • Vent → to express or alleviate pent-up emotions, to attempt catharsis

  • Obtain help, support, and comfort → to receive consolation and sympathy

  • Legitimization → to validate one’s emotions of the event and have them approved

  • Clarification and meaning → to clarify certain aspects of the event that were not well understood, to find meaning in the happeningsĀ of the event

  • Advice → to seek guidance and find solutions to problems created by the event

  • Bonding → to become closer to others and reduce feelings of loneliness

  • Empathy → to emotionally arouse or touch the listener

  • Draw attention → to receive attention from others, possibly to impress others

  • Entertain → to engage others and facilitate social interactions


Responses of TargetsĀ 

  • Social support: attempts at comforting, expressing unconditional support, showing empathy and understanding

  • Physical gestures: non-verbal comfort or consolation, such as hugging, kissing, or touching

  • Concrete actions: talking about or attempting to do something outside of the emotional situation (distraction)

  • De-dramatization: putting the situation in perspective, telling the person that it also happens to other people, that it is not so bad

  • Questioning: asking more information or clarifying things about the experience


→ happens in everyday life, but also therapy sessions (more systematically)


⭐sharing leads to a closer bond, especially when the information is more private


WEEK 4 - CLIP 4 - EMOTIONAL DISORDERS AND THERAPY

  • what is the role of emotions in mental disorders?

  • what is the role of emotions in psychotherapy?


Individual Differences in Emotions

  • in the kind of situations that evoke specific emotions

    • same situation evokes different emotions in different people


  • in the tendency to appraise situations in a certain way

    • some might find a situation threatening while others don’tĀ 


  • in the tendency / (in)capacity to experience (certain) emotions

    • some people tend to respond with anger


  • in the intensity and duration of the experienced emotions


  • in the intensity and duration of the expression of emotions

    • this related to emotion regulation tendencies

      • the way emotions are (not) regulated and (not) expressed


  • in the (in)capacity to recognize one’s own specific emotionsĀ 

    • alexithymia: having no words for emotions

      • a personality trait, people differ in the dimension (men score higher)


    • secondary alexithymia: due to trauma

      • NOT a personality trait


  • in the (in)capacity to recognize emotions in others

    • autism spectrum disorder (ASD)


  • in the specific relation between different emotions

    • women often relate anger with powerlessness which accompanies with crying

    • in men this is less often


  • in the specific relation between valence (+ / -) and arousal

    • some people feel more arousal when they experience negative emotions


⭐scoring high on a dimension does not necessarily mean that you have a mental disorder (unless of course it’s considered a criteria)


Emotions & Psychopathology

emotion and emotion regulation play a role in:

  • the development (etiology) of psychopathology

  • the consequences/manifestations of psychopathy

  • the impact of therapy

    • people who seek therapy usually withhold information that is crucial for therapy because they are ashamed of it


Emotional Problems

  • one emotion may become very prominent

    • anxiety disorders

    • depressive disorders


  • one reacts to events with deviant emotional responses

    • violence


  • emotions are not properly regulated → emotions are more intense, last longer or interfere strongly with daily lives

    • generalized anxiety disorder


  • deviant behavior is used to regulate emotions

    • OCD


  • a more general incapacity to experience and express emotions

    • emotional numbness → depersonalization and derealization disorder


  • incapacity to experience certain very specific emotions (empathy, love, guilt)


  • emotions of others are not recognized

    • ASD


Proof that emotions differ between healthy people and mentally ill people - Antisocial personality criteria


Proof that emotions differ - Dual threshold anger model

⭐best choice → middle, between expression threshold and impropriety threshold (you can apply this to other emotion as well)


Psychotherapy

Psychoanalysis (Freud)

  • becoming aware of transference of emotion schemas to present moment

    • how the client behaves now has to do with emotion schemas that have become maladaptive in the pastĀ 


  • new-form: Mentalization-Based Treatment (MBT)

    • borderline personality disorder (BPD)

    • based on knowing what’s going on inside yourself and others and interpreting what motives are likely behind


Rogerian counseling (Rogers)

  • person-centered

  • non-directive

  • providing a safe, empathetic, nonjudgmental space for self-examination

  • not used much because it takes long


Cognitive-Behavioral therapy (CBT)

  • changing irrational/maladaptive thinking/behavior

  • newer forms:

    • Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy (MBCT)

    • Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT)

    • Dialectical-Behavioral Therapy (DBT)


Emotion-Focused therapy (EFT)

  • emotions help clarify goals and values

  • change is achieved by replacing an emotion by another emotion


WEEK 5 - CLIP 5 - INDIVIDUAL DIFFERENCES

Content

  • how does the development of emotions occur?

  • what is the influence of person and environment on emotional development?


Paul Ekman (Evolutionary Emotion Theory): Nature vs Nurture

humans like animals are equipped at birth with behaviors for survival and the ability to learn.

Do emotions also belong to these inner behavior?


basic emotions:

  • happiness

  • sadness

  • fear

  • disgust

  • anger

  • surprise

  • contempt


learned/ self-conscious emotions:

  • love

  • guilt

  • shame

  • regret

  • pride

  • empathy

  • …


Basic Emotions


what do these basic emotions have in common:

  • a distinct subjective or phenomenological quality

    • we know the difference between feeling sad and happy (same goes for learned emotions)


  • a specific innately determined neural substrate

  • a characteristic facial expression / neuro-muscular expressive pattern

  • independent of language and culture

  • also displayed by blind and deaf children


Universality of Emotions (Ekman)


  • most emotions are about social circumstances, but an exception is disgust

  • the earliest expression of emotion is disgust

    • it can be observed in newborns in response to sour taste

  • physical disgust (with food and germs: crucial for survival) → moral disgust (when norms of the group)

    • oral to moral


Lisa Feldman Barrett: Criticisms / Questions

  • aren’t the specific emotional expressions not just posed expressions, not real ones from daily life?

    • emotions by Ekman are post-facial expressions

    • they don’t occur like that in real life

    • no ecological validity


  • are these expressions really recognized worldwide, in all cultures?

  • aren’t bodily expressions important as well?

    • Ekman only focuses on the face


  • is every specific emotion associated with a specific physiological pattern?

    • she thinks we need specific context to determine what type of physiological response comes with a particular feeling

    • anxiousness in one context might be associated with a different physiological response than in another context


Self-conscious Emotions: Mirror Test

  • The idea is that the basic emotions are there from birth, but the self-conscious emotions develop later.

  • There's more doubt about universality culture plays a bigger role.

  • They would occur from the moment a person recognizes himself in the mirror.

  • So, as soon as you put a baby in front of the mirror, and he knows, well, that's me, and not another baby.

  • From that moment, a child can start experiencing emotions like shame, guilt, regret, and pride. This is true not only for children, but also for animals


Development of Emotions

disgust is the first



Individual Differences

  • temperament

  • personality

  • negative life events

  • parenting

  • attachment

  • siblings

  • peers

  • broader social context



WEEK 6 - CLIP 6 - EMOTIONS IN COMMUNICATION

Content

  • what emotion expressions can be distinguished?

  • what effects do emotion expressions have on other people?


Modes to Transmit Information

  • facial expressions

  • gestures

  • vocal information

  • verbal information

  • touch

  • via music/ art

  • pheromones (?) → And there's growing evidence that the number of emotions, such as fear, disgust and sexual router, are associated with the emission of camo signals. For example, certain odors, and as other people can smell our emotions. And this is a new field.

Imperfect Communication

miscommunication: the meaning attributed to an intentional message by the receiver is different than that intended by the sender


attempted communication: a process by which a sender a conveys a message that is not received by the receiver


misinterpretation: the sender unintentionality sends a message that a receiver interprets as conveying a specific intent


Kinds of Information that can be Transmitted

  • about the expresser’s internal state

  • about the expresser’s appraisal of the situation

  • about his/her goals, desires, and motives

  • about his/her behavioral intentions, social predispositions

  • about his/her personality

  • about his/her norms and values


Facial Expressions: Affective Reactions in Others

reciprocal reactions:

  • emotional contagion or effective (true) empathy

  • e.g., anger triggers anger


complementary reactions:

  • e.g., anger triggers fear



Kinds of Nonverbal Behavior

emblems: nonverbal gestures that directly translate to words (e.g., peace sign)

illustrators: gestures that accompany our speech to make it vivid, visual, and emphatic (e.g., waving your arms)

regulators: nonverbal behaviors that we use to coordinate conservation (e.g., turn to or away from a person, pointing)

self-adaptors: nervous behaviors that lack intention, meant to release energy (e.g., chew on your lip)

display of specific emotion: face (muscles, tears, blushing, sweat), body


expression via art/music

physiological reactions that can be perceived - pheromones?



The expression of an emotion is not merely an expression, but also the transmission of information.