Untitled
Articles Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology 43(2) 171–197
© The Author(s) 2012
Reprints and permission: sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav
DOI: 10.1177/0022022110388563
jccp.sagepub.com
Emotional Relationships in Mothers and Infants:
Culture-Common and Community-Specific Characteristics of Dyads From Rural and Metropolitan Settings in Argentina, Italy, and the United States
Authors: Marc H. Bornstein, Diane L. Putnick, Joan T. D. Suwalsky, Paola Venuti, Simona de Falco, Celia Zingman de Galperín, Motti Gini, Marianne Heslington Tichovolsky
Abstract
- This study utilizes country and regional contrasts to explore culture-common and community-specific variations in mother-infant emotional relationships.
- Sample Size: 220 mothers from Argentina, Italy, and the United States with children observed at 5 months of age in home settings.
- Findings:
- Most dyads scored in the adaptive range in terms of emotional relationships, indicating that healthy emotional relationships are a critical universal characteristic of infant development across cultures.
- Community-specific differences were noted, such as:
- Italian mothers showed greater sensitivity and Italian infants displayed more responsiveness than Argentine and U.S. mothers and infants.
- Rural mothers exhibited more intrusive behaviors compared to metropolitan mothers.
- Conclusion: Emotional relationships may be a fundamental aspect of human development but are influenced by community and cultural contexts.
# Keywords
- cultural psychology
- child/adolescent development
- social development
Study Goals
- Examine culture-common and community-specific psychological processes in emotional relationships between mothers and infants.
- Background Theory:
- Establishing adaptive emotional relationships is essential for child development universally (Barnard & Solchany, 2002).
- The study's approach includes variations based on country (Argentina, Italy, USA) and region (rural and metropolitan).
Cultural Context
Interplay of Biology and Culture
- Human psychology is shaped by both biological evolution and a transmitted culture.
- Evolutionary psychology (common genome) suggests universality in certain psychological processes.
- Cultural psychology focuses on variability stemming from sociocultural contexts.
Key Concepts
Universal vs. Community-Specific Psychological Constructs
- Construct such as attachment and language illustrate both universality and cultural specifics:
- Attachment: Common evolutionary need; however, its expression varies culturally (Van IJzendoorn & Sagi, 1999).
- Language: Evidence of universal traits tempered by contextual input in linguistic developments (Pinker, 2007).
Mother-Infant Emotional Relationships
- Emotional relationships form an essential part of human interaction, influencing parenting and child development (Biringen & Robinson, 1991).
- Maternal emotional expressions contribute to the infant's social interaction, engage affection, and mark important developments.
- Infants send cues regarding their emotional states and needs, emphasizing the bidirectional nature of emotional exchanges.
Research Design
- The study observed mother-infant interactions during the first six months post-birth using the Emotional Availability Scales (EA Scales) designed to evaluate interaction quality.
- Components assessed:
- Four aspects of maternal emotional availability and two for infants, focusing on behaviors and reciprocal interactions.
- Framework allows identification of both adaptive and maladaptive behaviors within emotional relationships.
Cross-Cultural Comparisons
Country Specific Findings
Argentina
- Parenting style tends towards authoritarianism with high collectivist values, emphasizing respect and obedience (González-Ramos et al., 1998; Harwood et al., 2002).
- Observations reported higher demands in parenting style affecting emotional availability (Facio & Resett, 2008).
Italy
- Emotional expressiveness is prioritized, with mothers exhibiting socially-oriented interactions, fostering the development of strong emotional connections from infancy (Attili et al., 1997).
- Studies indicate Italian mothers display higher levels of affection and synchronous engagement in interactions compared to U.S. mothers (Hsu & Lavelli, 2005).
United States
- Parenting is highly individualistic, focusing on promoting autonomy and self-reliance in children (Bellah et al., 1985; Tamis-LeMonda & McFadden, 2009).
- U.S. mothers demonstrate less social-emotional engagement and affection compared to mothers from Argentina and Italy (Richman et al., 1988).
Rural vs. Metropolitan Context
- Distinction impacts parenting styles; rural mothers may exhibit more traditional and directive parenting behaviors compared to metropolitan mothers.
- Metropolitan environments tend to have more educational and social resources, influencing differences in parenting practices and expectations (Bradley, 2002).
Methodology
Sample Characteristics
- Total of 220 mother-infant dyads across three countries, with demographic equality controlled for in analyses.
- Observations captured natural interactions; coders were trained on EA Scales to ensure reliability in assessments.
Findings
Emotional Availability Scores
- Overall, most dyads functioned within adaptive ranges, supportive of healthy development.
- Italian mothers rated more sensitive; infants corresponded with higher responsiveness levels.
- Rural dyads faced challenges relating to higher parental intrusiveness compared to metropolitan dyads (Kruskal-Wallis tests).
Discussion
Importance of Context
- Emotional relationships, while universal across cultures, reveal differing expressions based on ecological and cultural needs.
- Despite the generality of findings indicating adaptive emotional functioning, particular cultural nuances dictate behavioral variations in mother-infant interactions.
Limitations and Future Directions
- Further research needed to explore emotional relationships across more diverse populations and contexts, understanding the variability in emotional expressions in parenting practices.
- Importance of continued investigation into how cultural values shape parenting, emotional exchanges, and child development outcomes.
Conclusion
- This study contributes essential insights into the cross-cultural dynamics of mother-infant emotional relationships.
- Future studies should focus on in-depth explorations into how variations manifest across different cultural settings.