Briggs
Study Overview
Title: Further investigation of differential reinforcement of alternative behavior without extinction for escape-maintained destructive behavior
Authors: Adam M. Briggs, Claudia L. Dozier, Amber N. Lessor, Bertilde U. Kamana, Rachel L. Jess
Purpose: To explore the effectiveness of differential reinforcement of alternative behavior (DRA) in reducing escape-maintained destructive behavior without the use of extinction.
Key Research Questions:
(a) Under what conditions can DRA without extinction reduce and maintain low levels of destructive behavior?
(b) Can treatment effects persist during reinforcement schedule thinning?
Background
Differential Reinforcement of Alternative Behavior (DRA): A method used to teach alternative behaviors while reducing destructive behaviors, particularly those maintained by social-negative reinforcement (escape).
Escape-Maintained Destructive Behavior: Behavior that occurs as a means to escape from demands or unwanted situations.
Previous Research:
Extinction is typically a standard procedure in DRA; however, it can present risks and challenges such as increased destructive behavior and compromised treatment integrity.
Previous studies explored manipulating various dimensions of reinforcement to favor alternative responses over destructive behaviors.
Methodology
Participants: 4 individuals diagnosed with intellectual and developmental disabilities, engaged in escape-maintained destructive behaviors:
Anna: 4-year-old, limited expressive language
Queenie: 5-year-old, capable of following complex instructions
Brock: 16-year-old, limited expressive language
Janice: 14-year-old, capable of following complex instructions
Settings: Conducted in various controlled environments (therapy rooms, classrooms) with protective measures for participants.
Dependent Variables:
Latency to the first occurrence of destructive behavior, rate of destructive behavior, percentage of compliance with demands.
Procedures
Functional Analysis: Evaluated the functions of destructive behaviors under various conditions: no interaction, divided attention, play, escape, and tangible conditions.
Evaluation Phases:
Initial conditions including magnitude and quality of reinforcement were introduced sequentially to ensure comprehensive assessment.
Reinforcement schedule thinning was employed after establishing stable treatment effects.
Findings
Effective Treatment Development: Treatments using quality of reinforcement for compliance led to reductions in destructive behavior for Anna and Janice, while combinations of magnitude and quality worked for others.
Maintenance of Treatment Effects: Thinning schedules required significant adjustments; maintaining effects often required the combination of reinforcement dimensions.
Discrepancies Among Participants: Different responses led to varying levels of behavior change, with some participants maintaining higher compliance and lower destructive actions under specified conditions.
Conclusions
Clinical Implications: The study supports DRA without extinction as a viable treatment method for escape-maintained destructive behavior.
Future Directions: Recommendations for future research include:
Exploration of optimal reinforcement dimensions.
Examination of the role of escape extinction in treatment settings.
Assessment of alternative strategies for thinning schedules and mitigating resurgence of destructive behavior.
References
Study cites multiple studies highlighting the evolution and practical applications of DRA and functional communication training in behavioral analysis.