Briggs

Study Overview

  • Title: Further investigation of differential reinforcement of alternative behavior without extinction for escape-maintained destructive behavior

  • Authors: Adam M. Briggs, Claudia L. Dozier, Amber N. Lessor, Bertilde U. Kamana, Rachel L. Jess

  • Purpose: To explore the effectiveness of differential reinforcement of alternative behavior (DRA) in reducing escape-maintained destructive behavior without the use of extinction.

  • Key Research Questions:

    • (a) Under what conditions can DRA without extinction reduce and maintain low levels of destructive behavior?

    • (b) Can treatment effects persist during reinforcement schedule thinning?

Background

  • Differential Reinforcement of Alternative Behavior (DRA): A method used to teach alternative behaviors while reducing destructive behaviors, particularly those maintained by social-negative reinforcement (escape).

  • Escape-Maintained Destructive Behavior: Behavior that occurs as a means to escape from demands or unwanted situations.

  • Previous Research:

    • Extinction is typically a standard procedure in DRA; however, it can present risks and challenges such as increased destructive behavior and compromised treatment integrity.

    • Previous studies explored manipulating various dimensions of reinforcement to favor alternative responses over destructive behaviors.

Methodology

  • Participants: 4 individuals diagnosed with intellectual and developmental disabilities, engaged in escape-maintained destructive behaviors:

    • Anna: 4-year-old, limited expressive language

    • Queenie: 5-year-old, capable of following complex instructions

    • Brock: 16-year-old, limited expressive language

    • Janice: 14-year-old, capable of following complex instructions

  • Settings: Conducted in various controlled environments (therapy rooms, classrooms) with protective measures for participants.

  • Dependent Variables:

    • Latency to the first occurrence of destructive behavior, rate of destructive behavior, percentage of compliance with demands.

Procedures

  • Functional Analysis: Evaluated the functions of destructive behaviors under various conditions: no interaction, divided attention, play, escape, and tangible conditions.

  • Evaluation Phases:

    • Initial conditions including magnitude and quality of reinforcement were introduced sequentially to ensure comprehensive assessment.

    • Reinforcement schedule thinning was employed after establishing stable treatment effects.

Findings

  • Effective Treatment Development: Treatments using quality of reinforcement for compliance led to reductions in destructive behavior for Anna and Janice, while combinations of magnitude and quality worked for others.

  • Maintenance of Treatment Effects: Thinning schedules required significant adjustments; maintaining effects often required the combination of reinforcement dimensions.

  • Discrepancies Among Participants: Different responses led to varying levels of behavior change, with some participants maintaining higher compliance and lower destructive actions under specified conditions.

Conclusions

  • Clinical Implications: The study supports DRA without extinction as a viable treatment method for escape-maintained destructive behavior.

  • Future Directions: Recommendations for future research include:

    • Exploration of optimal reinforcement dimensions.

    • Examination of the role of escape extinction in treatment settings.

    • Assessment of alternative strategies for thinning schedules and mitigating resurgence of destructive behavior.

References

  • Study cites multiple studies highlighting the evolution and practical applications of DRA and functional communication training in behavioral analysis.