In-Depth Notes on Teacher-Made Assessment Strategies

Introduction to Teacher-Made Assessment Strategies

  • Kym teaches 6th grade in an urban school, where most students' families live below the poverty line.
  • Majority of students fail statewide tests each year despite following district teaching guides and using direct instruction.
  • Kym takes a summer course on motivation and implements 4 changes:
    • Incremental Approach to Ability: Emphasizes effort; allows for revision of work until criteria met.
    • Choice in Assessments: Offers oral presentations, art projects, creative writing as options for performance assessments.
    • Encourages Responsibility: Students help with classroom tasks (e.g., equipment setup).
    • Cultural Heritage Validation: Encourages reading from their cultural background.
  • Results: Students are more engaged, work harder, and improved testing outcomes.

Key Concepts in Assessment

  • Assessment Definition: Integrated process of gathering information about student learning and making judgments on progress (Linn & Miller, 2005).
  • Types of Information Sources: Includes projects, portfolios, performances, observations, and tests.
    • Measurement: Answers "How much?"
    • Evaluation: Concerns judgments about the assessment information.

Assessment for Learning vs. Assessment of Learning

  • Assessment for Learning:

    • Formative Assessment: Ongoing assessment providing feedback during instruction to enhance learning.
    • Informal assessments: Spontaneous observations, questioning during tasks (e.g., discussions).
    • Formal assessments: Systematic gathering of data (e.g., quizzes/tests).
  • Assessment of Learning:

    • Summative Assessment: Occurs after instruction, focusing on overall mastery (e.g., final exams).
    • Identifies readiness for next learning stages and assigns grades (Airasian, 2005).

Steps in Assessment for Learning

  1. Clear Instructional Goals: Teachers must clearly define what students are to learn and communicate these goals.
  2. Selecting Assessment Techniques: Assessment methods must align with goals and the developmental level of students.
  3. Enhancing Motivation and Confidence: The type of assessment and feedback given profoundly affects student motivation.
  4. Adjusting Instruction: Use assessment data to modify teaching on the spot and during planning stages.
  5. Communication with Parents: Regular updates on student progress through newsletters, meetings, and school websites.

Validity and Reliability in Assessment

  • Validity: Evaluates appropriateness of interpretations and use of assessment results. Includes:

    • Content Validity: The degree to which the assessment content is representative of the domain.
    • Construct Validity: Performance interpretation measures broader concepts often influencing responses.
    • Criterion-related Validity: Predicts performance accurately based on prior assessments.
  • Reliability: Consistency of the assessment results across different conditions and occasions.

    • More items lead to higher reliability.
    • Clear instructions and scoring criteria enhance reliability.

Absence of Bias in Assessment

  • Bias distorts student performance due to personal characteristics (e.g., gender, ethnicity).
  • Assessments must avoid offensiveness and unfair penalization caused by assumptions based on background experiences.

Types of Assessments

  • Informal Techniques: Spontaneous questioning and observational techniques.
  • Formal Assessment Techniques: Lessons planned in advance, including written tests and performance assessments.
Selected Response Items
  • Includes multiple choice, matching, true/false, etc.
  • Strengths: Efficient for assessing factual knowledge; easy to score.
  • Weaknesses: Can lead to guessing and ambiguity in questions.
Constructed Response Items
  • Require recall and elaborate thought (e.g., short answer, essays).
  • Strengths: Assess complex understanding but may vary in scoring.
  • Weaknesses: Subjectivity in grading; time-consuming to assess.
Performance Assessments
  • Require students to demonstrate skills in real-world scenarios.
  • Advantages: Focus on complex skills and processes; align closely with instructional goals.
  • Disadvantages: Time-consuming to evaluate, challenging to ensure reliability in assessment.
Portfolios
  • Meaningful collections of student work demonstrating growth and achievement.
  • Types include: documentation portfolios, showcase portfolios.
  • Advantages: Document progress, encourage self-reflection; encourage student ownership.
  • Disadvantages: Time-intensive to maintain; reliability can be difficult to measure.

Enhancing Motivation and Confidence in Assessment

  • Influences of teacher’s beliefs and assessment practices on student motivation.
  • Effective feedback should be constructive and timely, focusing on effort and specific skills rather than only grades.

Adjusting Instruction Based on Assessment

  • Teachers should be reflective, using assessments to guide future instruction.
  • Changes should be based on observed performance and understanding levels, facilitating responsive learning.

Communication with Parents

  • Effective communication about assessment results enhances student accountability and supports their development.

Summary of Grading Practices

  • Combining various factors (achievement, improvement, effort, social skills) in grading practices leads to hodgepodge evaluation, which varies considerably.
  • Clear, descriptive grading enhances understanding of students' strengths and areas for improvement.
  • Overall focus should be on promoting learning over competition among students.

Action Research

  • Continuous reflection on teaching practices through cycles of planning, acting, and reflecting enhances classroom effectiveness.
  • Ethics in research involve obtaining consent to protect student privacy and ensure voluntary participation.