Bertrand Russell - On Induction
The Principle of Uniformity and Induction
Principle of the Uniformity of Nature: The assumption that the laws of nature operating in the past will continue to hold in the future, meaning every event is an instance of a general law without exceptions.
Principle of Induction: The broader principle asserting that the future will resemble the past.
Fundamental Question: Whether any number of past cases where a law has been fulfilled provide evidence or proof that it will be fulfilled in the future.
Epistemic Limitations and Circular Reasoning
The "Past Future" Fallacy: Justifying expectations by claiming that past futures always resembled past pasts is question-begging, as it assumes that "future futures" will behave like past futures.
Scope Beyond the Future: The problem of induction is not strictly forward-looking; it applies equally to unobserved past events, such as geological occurrences from millions of years ago or theories regarding the origin of the Solar System and cosmogonies.
Instinct vs. Epistemic Justification:
Frequent repetition of a uniform succession creates an instinctive cause for expecting the same result on the next occasion in both humans and animals.
Crude expectations of uniformity can be misleading, as illustrated when a chicken's neck is wrung by the person who previously fed it.
Scientific and everyday expectations—including the laws of motion, the movement of the sun, and the nourishing value of bread—remain merely probable rather than certain.
Probability and the Reign of Law
Limits of Probability: While a greater number of repeated cases increases the probability that two co-occurring phenomena will be found together in the next instance, the probability can never reach absolute certainty.
Uncertainty of Formulated Laws: Even if a law with no exceptions exists, it cannot be known with certainty whether the law formulated by observation is that true law or one to which exceptions exist.
Foundation of Belief: The overarching belief in the "reign of law" across unexamined past and future cases rests entirely on the Principle of Induction itself.