Types of Second-Hand Evidence and Fallacies
Second-Hand Evidence Overview
- Definition: Evidence accessed through research, reading, and investigation rather than personal experience; involves citing what others know.
- Rhetorical Appeal: Primarily appeals to logos (reason and logic), while also building a writer's ethos and occasionally appealing to pathos.
- Major Types: Comprises historical information, expert opinion, and quantitative data.
- Role: Verifiable facts obtained through research that provide background and context for ongoing debates.
- Ethos: Demonstrates that the writer has invested effort to become knowledgeable on the topic.
- Precaution: Historical events are complex; explanations must remain brief without distorting or misrepresenting the facts.
- Applications:
- Establishing historical patterns: Samuel Walker's Hate Speech: The History of an American Controversy (1994) cites 1920s intolerance, including the Ku Klux Klan marching en masse in the capital, the 1921 congressional immigration restrictions targeting southern and eastern European Catholics and Jews, university admission quotas, and the Sacco and Vanzetti case.
- Establishing points of comparison: Charles Krauthammer's op-ed "The 9/11 'Overreaction'? Nonsense" compares the War on Terror in Iraq and Afghanistan to earlier American conflicts, citing specific struggles in the Civil War and the World War II Pacific campaign.
Expert Opinion
- Definition: Perspectives cited from individuals who have published research, work in a relevant field, or possess specialized experience.
- Scope: Can range from nationally prominent researchers to local figures (such as a teacher or student government officer regarding school policy).
- Key Standard: The expert must be perceived as credible by the intended audience to effectively strengthen the argument.
- Application: Peggy Orenstein's "Just a Little Princess" critiques commercial princess culture by citing historian Miriam Forman-Brunell of the University of Missouri - Kansas City, who explains that princess mania and savior tropes historically emerge during periods of acute crisis, uncertainty, and social upheaval (such as Frances Hodgson Burnett's original Little Princess during rapid urbanization or Shirley Temple films during the Great Depression).
Quantitative Evidence
- Definition: Data that can be represented numerically, such as statistics, surveys, polls, and census figures; operates as a strong appeal to logos.
- Numerical Statistics: Direct data used to support a claim, such as Amy Domini citing fast-food habits (the average American eats fast food more than 150 times a year; 2007 sales for the 400 largest U.S.-based chains reached $277 billion, an increase of 7 percent from 2006).
- Comparative Quantitative Data: Can establish quantitative contrasts without an overload of figures, as demonstrated by Fareed Zakaria in "When Will We Learn?":
- South Korean students attend school for nearly two more years than American students by the time they finish high school.
- Finland requires master's degrees for teachers and admits only 1 in 10 applicants to teacher-training programs.
Bandwagon Appeal (Ad Populum Fallacy)
- Definition: A logical fallacy that asserts because "everybody's doing it," a course of action or belief is automatically valid or desirable.
- Misuse of Data: Statistics and polling figures are frequently misapplied to give a bandwagon appeal the appearance of factual evidence.
- Example: Urging voters to elect Rachel Johnson because she holds a wide lead in the polls confuses popularity with candidate quality.