Notes on Severe Weather and Tornadoes: Lecture 4/30
Sunstorms and Severe Thunderstorms
- Sunstorms are more tolerable and lead to heavy rain.
- Long life cycle of storms increases rain totals and hail size.
- Damaging winds and tornadoes are also related to longer life cycles.
- Mystery: What contributes to the long life of these storms?
- Answer: Vertical shear in the environment and separation of precipitation production.
- The vertical shear controls the separation, contrasting with MS thunderstorms that arise from daytime heating.
Tornadoes
- Tornadoes are intense, Earth-oriented vortices rotating under thunderstorms.
- The rotation source is a key question.
- It's not just random swirling but organized and on a larger scale.
- Severe thunderstorms that spawn tornadoes develop in environments with vertical wind shear.
- Vertical wind shear means wind speed changes with height.
- Horizontal temperature contrasts often cause vertical wind shear at mid-latitudes.
Vertical Wind Shear Effects
- Vertical wind shear creates horizontally oriented vortices.
- These vortices are always present with vertical shear.
- Updrafts in severe thunderstorms can distort these horizontal tubes.
- Intense, localized updrafts bend the horizontally oriented tube.
- Initial State: Horizontally oriented tube of air.
- Updraft Influence: Intense updraft distorts the tube.
- Vertical Orientation: Parts of the tube become vertically oriented.
- Vorticity Increase: The distortion leads to increasingly vertical vorticity, resembling a tornado.
- Low Pressure: Localized low-pressure regions form, drawing in surrounding air.
- Spin Up: Inrushing air increases rotation, similar to a figure skater pulling arms in.
Mesocyclones
- The exact transition from mesocyclone to tornado funnels is still under debate.
- Difficulty in modeling and observing at relevant scales contributes to the uncertainty.
- Pressure differences near the tornado center can be intense (10-20 millibars over a mile).
- These intense pressure differences cause very high winds.
- Even without a tornado, a rotating mesocyclone can sometimes be visually identified by a dark, rotating cloud base.
- Vortex Rings: Paul Markowski and Yvette Richardson's theory involves 3D vortex tubes and vortex rings ingested into the updraft, leading to localized vorticity.
- Vortex Sheets: Colleague Greg's retired theory on vortex sheets adjusted and rearranged in the updraft.
Funnel Clouds vs. Tornadoes
- Funnel clouds are tornadoes that don't reach the ground.
- Whether a funnel cloud becomes a tornado depends on intensity and randomness.
- Larger initial "oomph" may allow some tornadoes to sustain themselves, but this is not well understood.
Global Distribution of Tornadoes
- Tornadoes occur in many places worldwide, but frequency and intensity vary.
- The United States and Southern Canada are primary locations.
- Other regions include the maritime continent, parts of Japan, South Korea, China, Europe.
- Many land masses never experience tornadoes.
Tornado Probability
- Central United States has the highest frequency and intensity of tornadoes.
- Southern Brazil and Argentina have a secondary hotspot.
- East Coast of Australia shows slightly enhanced probability.
Tornadoes in Canada and Europe
- Canada: Concentration in Southern Plains and along the Great Lakes.
- Europe: Most intense tornado on the border of France and Belgium (F4). Tornadoes occur along the coasts of Italy, Croatia, and Serbia.
Annual Tornado Rate
- The Central Plains of the U.S. experience the highest rate (5-10 per 10,000 square miles).
- Central Florida also has a high frequency, though not as intense.
Why the Central United States?
Key Ingredients:
- Gulf of Mexico: High dew point temperatures (70s °F) due to warm water (75-80°F) leading to high humidity.
- Mexican Plateau: High elevation (10,000 feet) bringing dry air.
- Upper Level Trough: Divergence aloft leading to surface convergence and cyclone development.
- Surface Cyclone: Develops east of the upper-level trough.
Convective Instability
- Warm, dry air aloft over moist air creates convective instability.
Temperature and Dew Point Structure
- Dry air aloft causes a significant dew point depression.
- Inversion often present because air off the plateau is warm.
Example Scenario:
Parcel A: Temperature = 20^"{C}, saturated.
Parcel B: Temperature = 21^"{C}, Dew point = 11^"{C}, bone dry.
If an upper-level trough causes both parcels to rise by 1 kilometer:
- Parcel A (moist ascent): cools at moist adiabatic lapse rate (approximately 6^"{C}/km). Final temperature: 20^"{C} - 6^"{C} = 14^"{C}.
- Parcel B (dry ascent): cools at dry adiabatic lapse rate (approximately 10^"{C}/km). Final temperature: 21^"{C} - 10^"{C} = 11^"{C}.
Lapse Rate
The lapse rate between the lifted Parcels A & B would be \frac{14^"{C}-11^"{C}}{0.25 km} = 12^"{C}/km at this point, greater than dry adiabatic lapse rate (10^"{C}/km). This indicates an unstable condition.
Initially stable due to inversion, lifting and differential cooling create instability.