Abortion

Abortion: The Battle Over Rights


Abortion Statistics

  • Global Statistics (WHO, Sept 25, 2020)

    • Average of 73.3 million induced (safe and unsafe) abortions per year (2015-2019).

    • 39 induced abortions per 1000 women aged 15–49.

    • 29% of all pregnancies and 61% of unintended pregnancies ended in abortion.

    • Over half of unsafe abortions globally occurred in Asia (most in South and Central Asia).

    • 75% of abortions in Africa and Latin America were unsafe.

    • 45% of all abortions were unsafe (estimates from 2010-2014), primarily in developing countries.


The Legal State of Abortion

  • International Status (as of Jan 4, 2021)

    • Legally allowed for:

      • Saving the woman's life.

      • Preserving health.

      • Socioeconomic grounds.

    • Broadly prohibited: entirely in some regions.

    • Without restriction: in others.


Supportive or Hostile to Abortion Rights?

  • State Policies (2019)

    • 30 states demonstrate hostility to abortion rights.

    • 14 states demonstrate support for abortion rights.

  • Support Spectrum:

    • Very supportive

    • Supportive

    • Leans supportive

    • Middleground

    • Leans hostile

    • Hostile

    • Very hostile


Barriers to Accessing Safe Abortion

  • Major barriers include:

    • Restrictive laws.

    • Poor availability of services.

    • High costs.

    • Stigma associated with abortion.

    • Conscientious objection by healthcare providers.

    • Requirements like mandatory waiting periods, counseling, misleading information, third-party authorization, medical tests, which delay access.


Abortion in the Ancient World

  • Historical Context:

    • First documented abortifacients in China (4500 years ago).

    • Elite women used abortifacients to avoid childbearing, shifting biological duties onto concubines/maidservants.


Egyptian Ebers Papyrus (1550 BCE)

  • Content:

    • Most extensive surviving record of ancient Egyptian medicine (700 magical formulas and folk remedies).

    • Contains remedies and incantations to combat diseases and evidence of a long tradition of empirical healthcare practices.


Code of Hammurabi (1772 BCE)

  • Significance of the Code:

    • Oldest known laws; depicted Hammurabi receiving laws from the sun god.

    • Contains 282 laws, providing transparency and clarity that laws were accessible to men, women, and slaves, unlike unwritten laws in other civilizations.


Legal Penalties for Causing Miscarriage (Hammurabi's Code)

  • Laws on miscarriage penalties:

    • If a man causes a free woman to miscarry, he pays 10 shekels.

    • If the woman dies, the perpetrator's daughter is killed.

    • Varied fines based on the woman's social status (plebeian or slave).


Criminalization of Abortion in the 1800s

  • Historical Shift:

    • Prior to the 19th century, abortion was widely practiced and legal.

    • As medicine advanced, many places began outlawing abortion at all pregnancy stages due to increasing medical professional involvement and social backlash against women's rights.


Canada: A Timeline Towards Legalized Abortion

  • 1892: First Criminal Code in Canada; prohibits abortion and contraceptives.

  • 1969: Abortion allowed under specific conditions determined by a committee of doctors.

  • 1970: Dr. Henry Morgentaler opens an abortion clinic—spurs legal battles.

  • 1975: Petition against abortion rights with over one million signatures.

  • 1982: Charter of Rights and Freedoms enacted; challenge to abortion funding based on this framework.

  • Jan 28, 1988: Supreme Court strikes down abortion law as unconstitutional, reaffirming women's rights.


Further Developments in Canadian Abortion Law

  • 1989: Ruling states a man has no legal right to veto a woman's abortion decision.

  • 1990: Bill C-43 proposes jail sentences for doctors performing non-life-threatening abortions; ultimately fails to pass.

  • 1994: Dr. Garson Romalis shot for performing abortions; marks increased violence against abortion providers.


Media Coverage of Abortion Issues

  • Article Title:

    • "A Day of Reckoning: Abortion on Trial"

    • Discusses new rulings and intensified debates surrounding abortion rights.