Criminal Law - Defences (1) - Intoxication

Defences: Intoxication

Introduction to Defences

In criminal law, an offence typically consists of:

AR+MR−Defence=OffenceAR + MR - Defence = Offence

Where:

  • AR stands for actus reus (the guilty act).

  • MR stands for mens rea (the guilty mind).

A defence can negate criminal liability even if the AR and MR are present.

Types of Defences
  1. Specific Defences: Apply only to particular offences.

  2. Partial Defences: Reduce the severity of the charge (e.g., reducing murder to manslaughter).

  3. General Defences: Apply to a wide range of offences, potentially leading to acquittal. Includes self-defence.

Capacity Defences
  • Operate as denials of either AR or MR.

  • Examples: intoxication and insanity.

  • Note: Automatism and Insanity are not assessed in this module.

Intoxication as a Defence

Relevance of Intoxication

Intoxication can be a relevant factor in criminal cases. Statistics from 2022/23 indicate that approximately 384,000 violent crimes were believed by the victim to involve offenders under the influence of alcohol. Alcohol was believed to be a factor in:

  • 38% of all violent incidents.

  • 40% of violent incidents with injury.

  • 37% of violent incidents without injury.

  • 38% of domestic violence offences.

Understanding Intoxication

Intoxication refers to the state where a person's judgment, perceptions, and awareness are impaired due to alcohol or drugs still being in his/her system.

Long-term vs. Immediate Effects

Generally, the rules of intoxication as a defence apply when the intoxication is contemporaneous with the offence (i.e., drugs/alcohol are still in the system). However, R v Taj [[2018] EWCA Crim 1743] suggests that the effects of prior intoxication can sometimes be considered.

General Principle

Intoxication is generally not a defence. Lord Denning in Attorney-General (Northern Ireland) v Gallagher [[1961] UKHL 2] stated that drunkenness is typically not a defence, nor is a defect of reason caused by drunkenness.

Intoxication: Exculpatory vs. Inculpatory

Intoxication can operate both as:

  • Exculpatory: A defence if it prevents the formation of mens rea.

  • Inculpatory: A route to finding D guilty, even without mens rea.

Where D does not form the mens rea of the offence as a result of intoxication, he may have a defence since there is no mens rea proved.
Intoxicated Mens Rea

An intoxicated mens rea is still a mens rea. As per R v Kingston [[1994] UKHL 9], intoxication only becomes relevant if an element of the offence is missing due to the intoxication. For instance:

  • Mens Rea of Intention: If D, even while drunk, subjectively intends an outcome (direct intention) or foresees it as a virtual certainty but goes ahead (oblique intention), mens rea is present.

  • Mens Rea of Recklessness: If D is subjectively aware of an objectively unreasonable risk and takes it, the lowering of inhibitions due to intoxication doesn't negate mens rea.

No Mens Rea Due to Intoxication

If intoxication prevents the formation of mens rea, the general rule is that no mens rea = no offence. For example, if D is so intoxicated that he does not intend the act's outcome or foresee the virtually certain outcome or is not aware of the risk, there is no mens rea = no Offence.

Inculpatory Route: Exception to the Rule

Even if the D did not form the mens rea, if:

  1. He was voluntarily intoxicated.

  2. The offence is one of “basic intent”.

  3. The intoxicant D has voluntarily taken is “dangerous”, AND

  4. He lacked the mens rea at the time of the offence as a result of that intoxication.

Then he may still be found Guilty.

Four-Step Test for Inculpatory Liability

When intoxication leads to no mens rea, D can still be found guilty if the following conditions are met:

  1. D must be voluntarily intoxicated.

  2. D’s offence must be one of basic intent, not specific intent.

  3. The intoxicant must have been dangerous.

  4. D must lack mens rea at the time of the offence because of that intoxication.

1. Voluntary Intoxication
  • Was D intoxicated?

  • Was D’s intoxication voluntary? (i.e., the result of a choice).

R v Allen [[1988] The Times, 10th June]: D's claim of not realizing the wine's strength was irrelevant; the act of drinking alcohol was a voluntary choice.

Involuntary Intoxication
  • If D did not know he was consuming an intoxicant, there is no mens rea, and hence no liability (e.g., Kingston [[1994] UKHL 9]).

  • However, this doesn't apply if D knew he was consuming an intoxicant but underestimated its strength or impact.

  • R v Eatch [[1980] Crim LR 650]: Additives to the drink.

2. Basic vs. Specific Intent
  • These are categories used to assess the impact of intoxication, NOT types of intention (like oblique and direct intention).

  • For basic intent offences, D's voluntary intoxication may replace the lack of mens rea.

  • For specific intent offences, the missing mens rea cannot be replaced, meaning there is no offence.

R v Majewski [[1977] AC 443]

Majewski was charged with assaulting people in a pub and police officers while being arrested. He had consumed a combination of drink and drugs and had almost no recollection of the events. The House of Lords considered whether a defendant could be convicted of assault if, due to self-induced intoxication, he did not intend to do the act constituting the assault.

The judgments in Majewski Assault is a basic intent offence, and therefore the defendant could be found guilty even though he otherwise lacked the mens rea. No clear test exists for determining what makes an offence one of specific or basic intent. Recklessness equals basic intent. Intention equals specific intent. But beyond this the position is unclear.

R v Heard [[2007] EWCA Crim 125]

Suggests specific intent offences require a purpose or consequence going beyond the actus reus. Here, an offence with an element of “intention” was deemed to be an offence of basic intent (sexual assault). But as a test, this is also incomplete and problematic.

Common Examples
  • Basic Intent: Manslaughter, s20 Wounding/causing GBH, s47 ABH, Common assault/battery, Rape, Sexual Assault.

  • Specific Intent: Murder, s18 Wounding/causing GBH with intent, Theft, Robbery, Burglary.

Potential Result

D might have a defence to the offence of specific intent (murder, s18), but have no defence to the offence of basic intent (manslaughter, s20).

3. Dangerous Intoxicant

Did D voluntarily consume a dangerous intoxicant?

  • Commonly known to cause unpredictability and/or aggression.

  • Includes alcohol and most controlled drugs.

  • Valium, due to its sedative effect, is not considered a dangerous drug (R v Hardie [[1984] EWCA Crim 2]). Similarly, failing to eat after taking insulin is not considered a dangerous intoxicant (Bailey [[1983] 2 All ER 503]).

4. Lack of Mens Rea Due to Intoxication

Is the lack of mens rea a result of the voluntary intoxication, or does it have another cause?

  • Prior voluntary consumption of dangerous intoxicant.

  • Lack of mens rea at the time of the offence.

The Problem of “Dutch Courage”

Dutch courage refers to when someone becomes intoxicated to gain the courage to do something.

A-G for Northern Ireland v Gallagher [[1961]]: D decided to kill his wife, and drank whisky to give himself courage. Conviction for murder reinstated.

Summary

  1. Did D have mens rea?

  2. If no mens rea, was intoxication voluntary or involuntary?

  3. If voluntary, is the offence one of basic intent or specific intent?

  4. If basic intent, was the drug “dangerous”?

  5. If it was dangerous, did he commit lack the mens rea for the offence as a result of his voluntary intoxication?

If all tests are met, D may be found GUILTY because the voluntary intoxication replaces the missing mens rea.