3.2.2 Cultural Dimensions

↳


Key Definitions


Cultural dimensions: general factors underlying cross-cultural differences in values and behavior; they have been identified on the basis of massive cross-national surveys

Emic approach: examining a specific culture from within; enable an in-depth understanding of the unique culture without “imposed etic”, but comparison with other cultures is difficult

Etic approach: studying cultures from an outside perspective; enables cross-cultural comparison, but requires the identification of universal phenomena that will serve as comparison criteria


Essential Understanding


→ Each culture is unique, so to compare them on a large scale is not an easy task

↳ One needs to identify universal phenomena that are present in every individual culture which will then become criteria for comparison


→ Geert Hosfstede (1973) conducted an extensive study involving participants from more than 70 countries and identified 5 such universal phenomena or cultural dimensions


↳Cultural dimensions have a wide range of influences on behavior


→Individualism-collectivism may influence rates of conformity

→ Individualism-collectivism may influence volunteering

→ Power distance influences patterns of patient-donor communication

→ Power distance influences people’s reactions to empowerment in the workplace


Hofstede’s 1973 Multinational Survey


Aim: identify dimensions underlying cultural differences in values, attitudes, and behavior


Participants: 117,000 IBM employees (he founded the personnel research department of IBM Europe)


Method and Procedure:

→ a worldwide survey of values was done between 1967 and 1973

↳ results of the survey were statistically analyzed to identify hidden dimensions underlying observed patterns of responses (a statistical technique called factor analysis)

→ To conform to original findings and generalize them to other populations, a series of follow-up studies were done between 1990 and 2002

↳ Sample had commercial airline pilots, students, civil service managers

→ Around this time, countries were also profiled against the value dimensions (made by each country)


Results:

↳ originally Hofstede identified four dimensions:

↳ Individualism vs. collectivism

↳ Uncertainty avoidance

↳ Power distance index

↳ Masculinity vs. femininity

→ would then added in two more:

↳ long-term vs. short term orientation

↳ indulgence vs. self-restraint


Hofstede’s Cultural Dimensions


  • Individualism vs. collectivism

    ↳ in individualist cultures, people define their personality in terms of their own personal characteristics, successes, and unique features

    ↳ the strongest values in society are personal autonomy, competitiveness, and self-sufficiency

    ↳ in collectivist cultures, identity is linked with the social group, and values are associated with a group which is prioritized over personal values


  • Power distance index (PDI)

    ↳ higher PDI score shows that hierarchy between the less and more powerful is firmly established in the society (rarely questioned)

    ↳ lower PDI score shows that people question authority and believe that authority figures are not particular support to themselves


  • Masculinity vs. femininity

    ↳ masculinity values→ include achievement, autonomy, and competitiveness

    ↳ femininity values→ caring, cooperation, modesty, and compassion


  • Uncertainty avoidance index

    ↳ refers to the extent to which people tolerate ambiguity

    → Cultures that rank high on this index tend to avoid risks and are intolerant to unexpected or unknown events

    → Cultures that rank low are more tolerant of uncertainty and embrace new situation more easily


  • Long-term vs. short-term orientation

    → Cultures that rank low on this dimension are conservative and rely on the past for guidance and value traditions heavily

    → Cultures that rank high indicates a future that is pragmatic and oriented towards the future and future challenges


  • Indulgence vs. restraint

    → Societies that promote indulgence allow a free gratification of basic and natural human desires like having a holiday or just having fun

    → Societies that promote restraint regulate gratification of needs with strict social norms


    Researches


  • Berry and Katz (1967)→ Influence of Individualism and Collectivism on Conformity


↳key: collectivism is associated with higher conformity to group


Aim: investigate whether cultural differences in individualism vs. collectivism affect conformity


Participants: Temne people of Sierra Leone and Inuit people of Northern Canada

→ Inuit: hunting and fishing society that promotes individualism

↳ people are responsible for their own survival on a daily basis with little accumulation of food

→ Temne: food-accumulating society that promotes collectivism

↳rice farmers who harvest crop once a year and rely on this while sharing the food to group members


Procedure:

→ Researchers measured conformity using Asch’s Paradigm

↳ they also tricked the participants to think that most of the other participants picked a specific line to answer (even if it’s not equal to the target line)


→ Measure of conformity in this procedure is whether they will accept the incorrect suggestion since most people picked it


Results:

↳ Temne were more likely to accept the suggestion (incorrect response)

↳ Inuit were mostly unaffected by the suggestion of the majority


Conclusion:

→ concluded that individualist Inuit conform less often than collectivist Temne

↳ this is because conformity to group norms is ingrained as a cultural value to the Temne society, which depend on tight social relations


  • Finkelstein (2010)→ Effect of individualism and collectivism on volunteer behavior


    ↳key: people in individualist societies volunteer for different reasons from people in collectivist societies

    Aim: examine the effect of culture on volunteer behavior


    Method: online self-report questionnaires that measured a variety of possible reasons for volunteering including:

    → altruistic motivation to help

    → desire to strengthen social ties

    →role identity (volunteering for the sake of consistency with one’s self-image)

    → career-related reasons


    Participants: 194 undergraduates at a US university who participated in exchange for extra course credit


    Results:

    ↳ collectivism was more strongly related than individualism to altruistic motivation and desire to strengthen social ties

    ↳ collectivism, not individualism, correlated with helping in order to sustain role identity

    ↳ on the other hand, individualism was more closely associated with engaging in volunteering for career-related reasons


    Conclusion:

    ↳concluded that individualists and collectivists differ in why they choose to volunteer, but not in the willingness to volunteer itself


  • Meeuwesen, van den Brink-Muinen and Hofstede (2009)


    ↳key: patient-doctor communication in cultures with greater power distance is more one-sided


    Aim: investigate how cross-national differences in medical communication can be understood from Hofstede’s cultural dimensions


    Method and Procedure:

    → Patient-doctor communication sessions were videotaped and analyzed against a checklist (structured observation)

    ↳ additional context information was gathered by using questionnaires


    Participants: 307 general practitioners (GPs) and 5,807 patients from 10 European countries (i.e. Belgium, Estonia, Germany, UK, Netherlands, Poland, Romania, Spain, Sweden, and Switzerland)


    Results:

    ↳ a large nation’s PDI was associated with less unexpected information exchange and shorter consultation sessions

    ↳ communication was more one-sided, with the doctor speaking and patient listening

    ↳ in countries with a low PDI score, doctors shared more information, were more open to questions, and were generally more flexible in their communication style

    ↳ sessions were usually longer


    Conclusion:

    → Nations with a high PDI score, the roles between doctor and patient were more clearly described and fixed with a more protocol-based communication

    ↳ understanding these differences is important to prevent intercultural miscommunication and, at a larger scale, to pursue integration of European healthcare policies


  • Eylon and Au (1999)


    ↳key: individuals from cultures with high PDI scores don’t perform well when empowered as when disempowered


    Aim: investigate the relationship between power distance and empowerment in the workplace


    Participants: 135 MBA students from a Canadian university


    Procedure:

    ↳Participants were divided into high power-distance and low power-distance groups based on their language and country of origin

    →They then participated in a management simulation

    → At different points of the simulation, all participants found themselves where they were either empowered or disempowered


    Results:

    ↳regardless of their cultural background, participants were more satisfied with their job in the empowered condition and less satisfied in the disempowerment condition

    → individuals from cultures with high PDI scores didn’t perform well when empowered as when disempowered

    → individuals from cultures with low PDI scores performed similarly regardless of condition


    Conclusion:

    → High and low power-distance groups react differently to empowerment in the workplace (in terms of performance, not work satisfaction)

    → High PDI may perform better when disempowered

    ↳ in this context, being disempowered means more structured tasks and well-defined responsibilities


Extra PowerPoint Notes


→Is it possible to see personality traits correlate with cultural dimensions?

↳ this is answered in Hofstede and McCrae (2004)


→ used a five-factor model of personality and found that average personality scores of 33 different countries positively correlated with cultural dimension scores


→ the five factors were:

i. Neuroticism: tendency towards unstable emotions like rage, worry, frustration with little sympathy to others

ii. Extraversion: tendency towards gregarious personalities (i.e. talkative, outgoing, enjoyment with other people)

iii. Openness to experience: tendency to be open to new ideas, values, cultures, and behaviors

iv. Agreeableness: tendency of a person to follow others and avoid asserting one’s own values, opinions, and choices over others

v. Conscientiousness: tendency of a person to be cautious, hardworking, and follow the rules of society


Results:

→ Individualism was correlated with extraversion

→ Uncertainty avoidance correlated with neuroticism

→ High PDI score correlated with consciousness and extraversion

→ Masculinity tended to correlate with neuroticism and tended to be more open to experiences than feminine cultures


Conclusion:

→ culture in which one lives in can play a key role in how individual behaves

↳ while it’s not the only factor, it can play a role as seen by correlation