Module 9 Summary Notes Flashcards

Discharge of Contracts by Agreement & Breach

This module focuses on the discharge of contracts, specifically by agreement and by breach. It covers conditions precedent, conditions subsequent, types of contract terms, and both anticipatory and actual breaches.

Required Reading

  • Chapter 23 of Textbook and Casebook = Discharge by Agreement

  • Chapter 24 of the Textbook and Casebook = Discharge by Breach

Learning Objectives

  • Basic knowledge of the general rule of contract discharge.

  • Exceptions to the general rule of contract discharge.

  • Understanding of conditions precedent and subsequent.

  • Classification of contract terms.

  • Meaning and impact of anticipatory breach.

  • Effect of breach of contract.

Introduction

Contracts can be discharged (ended) by:

  • Performance

  • Agreement

  • Breach

  • Frustration

The contract remains enforceable until discharged. This week's focus is on discharge by agreement and breach. Discharge by performance and frustration will be covered next week.

Topic 1: Discharge of Contracts by Agreement

Contracts can end in several ways, including:

  • Bilateral performance: Both parties satisfactorily perform all terms.

  • Agreement: Parties mutually agree to end the contract.

Contracts often contain terms allowing termination upon specific events:

  • Conditions subsequent: Right to terminate upon the occurrence of an event.

  • Conditions precedent: Right to terminate upon non-performance of a condition.

An aggrieved party may elect to terminate, but the other party may dispute the cause, requiring court determination.

Two general situations for election to terminate:

  1. Contract frustrated by a supervening event (e.g., flooding of a mine pit).

  2. Contract repudiated by the other party.

Topic 2: Discharge of Contracts by Breach

This section addresses situations where contracts are not performed, leading to potential legal redress for the innocent party.

A breach of contract is a failure to perform according to its terms, including:

  1. Non-performance

  2. Defective performance

  3. Late performance

Another category is anticipatory breach (repudiation).

Anticipatory Breach/Repudiation

Anticipatory breach occurs when the promisor repudiates the contract, preventing performance by the promisee.

Key points on repudiation:

  1. A party repudiates if their conduct demonstrates:

    • A definitive decision against fulfilling contractual obligations.

    • An intention to fulfill the contract in a manner substantially inconsistent with their obligations.

  2. The innocent party must elect to terminate the contract.

    • A contract is not terminated until the innocent party elects to do so. This election can be express or implied through conduct indicating the contract is at an end.

  3. Communication of the election to terminate is not always necessary.

    • The right to terminate due to repudiation must be accompanied by unequivocal conduct demonstrating an election to terminate and sue for damages.

Disagreements often arise over whether the contract has been performed. The court assesses performance against a standard defined by the contract terms.

The courts acknowledge different standards of care, depending on the parties' intentions:

  1. Strictly defined duty: e.g., iron ore must not exceed $$0.05%$ clay.

  2. Duty to use reasonable care and skill: e.g., a barrister preparing an opinion.

Service contracts often fall under the second category. Contracts for the payment of monies or supply of goods generally require strict performance to meet all contractual expectations. Arguing