Hal Draper, Berkeley: The New Student Revolt (1965)
Chapter 1: “A New Generation of Students”
1. Main argument
Draper argues that the Berkeley Free Speech Movement (FSM) of 1964 was a serious, large-scale student movement, not simply a rebellion by irresponsible troublemakers.
He emphasizes that many protesters were academically successful, politically conscious students committed to democratic ideals and civil rights.
Central question: Why did so many capable students, including those previously uninvolved in politics, join the movement?
2. Key notes
Topic | Important information | Significance |
|---|---|---|
Free Speech Movement (FSM) | Student protest movement at UC Berkeley in 1964 | Challenged university authority |
Timeline | September–December 1964; lull in January 1965 | Prolonged confrontation between students and administration |
Scale of protests | Mass sit-ins, police blockades, arrests and student strike | Demonstrated the movement's size and organization |
Student participation | Many participants were among Berkeley's strongest students | Challenged stereotypes of protesters |
Academic achievement | 47% of arrested undergraduates had GPAs above 3.0, compared with 20% of undergraduates overall | Evidence that protesters were academically accomplished |
Graduate students | 71% of arrested graduate students had GPAs above 3.5 | Strong participation by high-achieving graduate students |
Political beliefs | Students were described as committed to civil rights and democratic ideals | Presented activism as principled rather than disorderly |
Anti-Communism | Critics attempted to associate the FSM with Communism | Shows how Cold War accusations were used against protesters |
Outcome | Draper describes the FSM as a major student victory | Demonstrated students' ability to challenge established authority |
3. Important people
Person | Role / argument |
|---|---|
Hal Draper | Author; strongly sympathetic to the FSM |
Mario Savio | FSM student leader, targeted by anti-Communist accusations |
Henry May | Berkeley history professor; questioned why so many excellent students joined |
Roger Stanier | Criticized sit-in tactics but acknowledged protesters were not merely a radical fringe |
Joseph Fontenrose | Defended FSM leaders as serious, responsible students |
Shana Alexander | Life columnist who described FSM members as intelligent civil rights idealists |
Robert Somers | Sociology professor who supervised a student opinion survey |
Clark Kerr | University president criticized by Draper for anti-Communist insinuations |
4. Important statistics
Undergraduates with GPAs above 3.0
Arrested FSM students
47%
All Berkeley undergraduates
20%
Figures reported by Draper from a survey of students arrested in the December 3 sit-in. These compare academic achievement, not the percentage of each group supporting the FSM.
Another survey found that among students with a B+ average or higher, 45% supported the FSM and 10% opposed it.
Draper's interpretation: higher academic achievement was associated with greater support for the movement.
5. Themes to remember
Student activism: Students increasingly organized collectively to challenge institutions.
Democracy and civil rights: Draper presents the FSM as part of a broader struggle for democratic participation.
Generational change: A new generation of students questioned established authority rather than automatically accepting it.
Cold War anti-Communism: Accusations of Communist influence were used to discredit political movements.
Education and dissent: Academic success did not necessarily produce obedience to authority; in Draper's account, highly accomplished students were often especially supportive of protest.
6. Source analysis
Question | Answer |
|---|---|
Type of source | Contemporary political analysis, published in 1965 |
Author's perspective | Strongly pro-FSM |
Main purpose | Defend the movement's legitimacy and explain its significance |
Strength | Uses contemporary surveys, statistics and statements from professors |
Limitation | Sympathetic perspective; one major statistical report was produced by pro-FSM graduate students |
Draper uses highly charged language to criticize the movement's opponents. This is important because the reading shows how supporters understood and defended student protest, rather than offering a neutral account of every side.
7. Quick review questions
Question | Answer |
|---|---|
What was the FSM? | Berkeley's Free Speech Movement |
When did the protests occur? | Mainly September–December 1964 |
What is Draper's main argument? | FSM participants were serious, academically strong students defending democratic ideals |
Why does he emphasize grades? | To challenge stereotypes that protesters were irresponsible or unintelligent |
Who was Mario Savio? | A prominent FSM leader |
What political accusation did opponents make? | That the movement was connected to Communism |
Why was the movement historically significant? | It demonstrated the scale and potential power of organized student protest |
One-sentence takeaway
The 1964 Berkeley Free Speech Movement demonstrated that academically accomplished students could become powerful political activists, challenging university authority and defending democratic ideals.
Week 5 — Reading 1 complete. These notes cover only the first chapter you provided, not the entire book.