Hal Draper, Berkeley: The New Student Revolt (1965)


Chapter 1: “A New Generation of Students”

1. Main argument

Draper argues that the Berkeley Free Speech Movement (FSM) of 1964 was a serious, large-scale student movement, not simply a rebellion by irresponsible troublemakers.

He emphasizes that many protesters were academically successful, politically conscious students committed to democratic ideals and civil rights.

Central question: Why did so many capable students, including those previously uninvolved in politics, join the movement?

2. Key notes

Topic

Important information

Significance

Free Speech Movement (FSM)

Student protest movement at UC Berkeley in 1964

Challenged university authority

Timeline

September–December 1964; lull in January 1965

Prolonged confrontation between students and administration

Scale of protests

Mass sit-ins, police blockades, arrests and student strike

Demonstrated the movement's size and organization

Student participation

Many participants were among Berkeley's strongest students

Challenged stereotypes of protesters

Academic achievement

47% of arrested undergraduates had GPAs above 3.0, compared with 20% of undergraduates overall

Evidence that protesters were academically accomplished

Graduate students

71% of arrested graduate students had GPAs above 3.5

Strong participation by high-achieving graduate students

Political beliefs

Students were described as committed to civil rights and democratic ideals

Presented activism as principled rather than disorderly

Anti-Communism

Critics attempted to associate the FSM with Communism

Shows how Cold War accusations were used against protesters

Outcome

Draper describes the FSM as a major student victory

Demonstrated students' ability to challenge established authority

3. Important people

Person

Role / argument

Hal Draper

Author; strongly sympathetic to the FSM

Mario Savio

FSM student leader, targeted by anti-Communist accusations

Henry May

Berkeley history professor; questioned why so many excellent students joined

Roger Stanier

Criticized sit-in tactics but acknowledged protesters were not merely a radical fringe

Joseph Fontenrose

Defended FSM leaders as serious, responsible students

Shana Alexander

Life columnist who described FSM members as intelligent civil rights idealists

Robert Somers

Sociology professor who supervised a student opinion survey

Clark Kerr

University president criticized by Draper for anti-Communist insinuations

4. Important statistics

Undergraduates with GPAs above 3.0

Arrested FSM students

47%

All Berkeley undergraduates

20%

Figures reported by Draper from a survey of students arrested in the December 3 sit-in. These compare academic achievement, not the percentage of each group supporting the FSM.

Another survey found that among students with a B+ average or higher, 45% supported the FSM and 10% opposed it.

Draper's interpretation: higher academic achievement was associated with greater support for the movement.

5. Themes to remember

Student activism: Students increasingly organized collectively to challenge institutions.

Democracy and civil rights: Draper presents the FSM as part of a broader struggle for democratic participation.

Generational change: A new generation of students questioned established authority rather than automatically accepting it.

Cold War anti-Communism: Accusations of Communist influence were used to discredit political movements.

Education and dissent: Academic success did not necessarily produce obedience to authority; in Draper's account, highly accomplished students were often especially supportive of protest.

6. Source analysis

Question

Answer

Type of source

Contemporary political analysis, published in 1965

Author's perspective

Strongly pro-FSM

Main purpose

Defend the movement's legitimacy and explain its significance

Strength

Uses contemporary surveys, statistics and statements from professors

Limitation

Sympathetic perspective; one major statistical report was produced by pro-FSM graduate students

Draper uses highly charged language to criticize the movement's opponents. This is important because the reading shows how supporters understood and defended student protest, rather than offering a neutral account of every side.

7. Quick review questions

Question

Answer

What was the FSM?

Berkeley's Free Speech Movement

When did the protests occur?

Mainly September–December 1964

What is Draper's main argument?

FSM participants were serious, academically strong students defending democratic ideals

Why does he emphasize grades?

To challenge stereotypes that protesters were irresponsible or unintelligent

Who was Mario Savio?

A prominent FSM leader

What political accusation did opponents make?

That the movement was connected to Communism

Why was the movement historically significant?

It demonstrated the scale and potential power of organized student protest

One-sentence takeaway

The 1964 Berkeley Free Speech Movement demonstrated that academically accomplished students could become powerful political activists, challenging university authority and defending democratic ideals.

Week 5 — Reading 1 complete. These notes cover only the first chapter you provided, not the entire book.