Mass Communication Theory: Selective Processes, Attitude Change, and Media Representation
Historical Context and Development of Attitude Change Theory
World War II and Mass Communication Theory Development
- The limited effects perspective and the theories it supported gained strong entrenchment during and after World War II, influencing mass communication research and theory well into the 1960s.
- World War II served as a vital catalyst for mass communication theory development, driven in part by vivid lingering memories of World War I and widespread American reluctance to enter another seemingly remote global conflict.
- Armed forces recruits and draftees typically possessed little to no knowledge regarding their fellow service members coming from different geographic regions and diverse socio-cultural backgrounds.
- German wartime propaganda appeared to confirm the claims of mass society theorists, who posited that mass media possessed extraordinary, direct power over audiences.
- The U.S. government established the Office of War Information (OWI) with three primary objectives:
- To alter public opinion regarding the wisdom and necessity of entering the war.
- To educate military personnel about their fellow soldiers and sailors.
- To counter Nazi propaganda.
- Initial communication attempts failed: traditional speeches, formal lectures, and informational pamphlets proved ineffective in changing attitudes.
- The OWI adapted by enlisting media creators and public personalities with broad audience appeal:
- Filmmakers such as Frank Capra.
- Radio personalities such as singer Kate Smith.
- Social scientists commissioned to measure and evaluate the empirical effectiveness of these media campaigns.
The Army Experimental Section and Hovland's Attitude Change Theory
- The U.S. Army established the Experimental Section within its Information and Education Division.
- The section was staffed with psychologists specializing in attitude change and was led by Carl Hovland.
- Researchers systematically tested the effectiveness of government mass communication campaigns on military personnel.
- Following the war, Hovland and his research group continued their studies at Yale University, producing foundational mass communication research.
- This work culminated in the development of attitude change theory (Hovland et al., 1949), which explains how human attitudes are formed, shaped, and altered through communication, and how those attitudes subsequently influence behavior.
Cognitive Dissonance and the Selective Processes
Dissonance Theory Foundations
- Dissonance theory states that when individuals are confronted with new or conflicting information, they experience psychological discomfort, known as dissonance.
- To manage and reduce this discomfort, individuals consciously and subconsciously engage in three interrelated selective processes.
- These selective processes enable individuals to filter, retain, and interpret consumed information in personally important and idiosyncratic ways.
The Three Interrelated Selective Processes
- Selective Exposure (or Selective Attention):
- Definition: The process by which individuals expose themselves to or attend exclusively to messages that align with their preexisting attitudes and beliefs.
- Political Context: Readers routinely select online political pundits who occupy the same place on the political spectrum as themselves to confirm established views.
- Consumer Behavior Context: Purchasing an expensive item (such as a new car or electronic device) generates cognitive dissonance; consumers subsequently pay increased attention to advertisements for that product to validate the wisdom of their purchase and reduce dissonance.
- Selective Retention:
- Definition: The psychological tendency for individuals to remember best and longest those messages that are consistent with their preexisting attitudes and beliefs.
- Broadcast Context: Television viewers recall significantly more detailed information from political party convention broadcasts of the party to which they are philosophically closer than from broadcasts of competing political parties.
- Selective Perception:
- Definition: The concept predicting that individuals interpret incoming messages in a manner consistent with their preexisting attitudes and beliefs.
- Political Framing Example: When favored politicians change positions on an issue, supporters interpret them as "evolving and heeding the public's will"; when unfavored politicians make identical changes, supporters label them as "flip-flopping and have no convictions."
- News Outlet Example: American Democrats overwhelmingly trust the cable news channel MSNBC, whereas Republicans distrust it just as thoroughly, even when viewing the exact same channel broadcasts (Orth & Bialik, 2024).
Media Effects: Informational versus Symbolic Content
Limited Effects Paradigm vs. Contemporary Mass Communication Theory
- During the initial development of dissonance theory, limited effects theory was the dominant paradigm; selective processes were seen as constraining media impact by filtering content to minimize attitude change.
- Contemporary mass communication theorists agree that selective processes effectively limit media impact when content is primarily informational.
- When content is primarily symbolic rather than informational, many theorists view selective processes as relatively unimportant in explaining the media's contribution to significant cultural effects (reflecting the distinction between transmissional and ritual views of mass communication).
Comparative Analysis: Informational vs. Symbolic Content
- Overt Informational Content Scenario:
- If a television station aired a lecture program openly espousing the racist opinion that people of color are genetically more prone to commit crime, selective processes would actively intervene:
- Viewers would change the channel (selective exposure).
- Viewers who watched would interpret the ideas as racist or sick (selective perception).
- Viewers would quickly forget the speaker's arguments (selective retention).
- Contemporary Broadcasting Reality:
- Traditional media rarely broadcast overtly racist informational statements.
- Standard news production conventions, economic constraints, and time demands lead news programs to routinely portray working-class people and people of color as more likely to be involved in crime and violence.
- Even though the vast majority of felonies in the United States are nonviolent, urban violent crime is cheaper and easier for broadcasters to cover because it is handy, highly visual, and requires no significant research or writing.
- Because these news reports rely on symbolic portrayals rather than structured factual information, selective processes do not have the opportunity to reshape the message.
- The interesting visual images themselves interfere with the intake of any factual information that may have been included in the report (Lull & Bushman, 2015).
Media Perception Bias, Stereotyping, and Systemic Disparities
The 1945 Allport and Postman Rumor Study
- Psychologists Gordon Allport and John Postman conducted a famous 1945 experiment demonstrating perception bias regarding criminals and the operation of selective processes.
- Experimental Procedure:
- Participants were asked to pass a verbal description of a drawing from person to person via whispering.
- The original drawing depicted a Black man being menaced by a white man holding a razor.
- Only the first participant in the chain saw the actual image.
- Findings: As the story was passed sequentially from person to person, the razor repeatedly shifted from the left hand of the white aggressor to the hand of the Black man.
Official Government Statistics and Media Power
- Cultural theorists point to official government statistics as evidence of the media's power to shape public attitudes toward race.
- Drug Offense Disparities:
- Black Americans account for of illegal drug users in the United States and use drugs at rates similar to white Americans.
- Despite equal usage rates, Black Americans represent of those arrested and of those incarcerated for drug offenses.
- The imprisonment rate of Black Americans for drug charges is almost that of white Americans ("Criminal Justice," 2025).
- Law Enforcement Traffic Stops:
- Although there is no evidence that Black people are worse drivers than white people, Black drivers stopped by police on U.S. roads are more likely than white drivers to experience the threat or use of force, more likely to be shouted at, and less likely to be let off with a warning (Morrison et al., 2024).
- Fatal Police Encounters:
- Black Americans are killed by police at more than the rate of white Americans ("Rate," 2025).
- Theoretical Questions:
- Cultural theorists challenge the assumption of racial neutrality in legal and criminal justice systems by examining persistent disparities:
- Why do racial disparities in arrests and incarcerations continue to exist under supposedly neutral laws?
- Why does "the razor still change hands" in social perception?
- Why are Black Americans killed by police at disproportionately higher rates than white Americans?