Experimental Design: Quick Reference Notes

Hawthorne Effect

  • Participants ideally unaware of group assignment to avoid behavior change due to awareness.
  • Hawthorne effect: simply being part of a study can alter outcomes.
  • Use random assignment to groups to reduce biases from knowledge of condition.
  • In drug studies, use a placebo for control group to compare against the active treatment.
  • Independent variable (IV) is the drug; the observed outcome is the dependent variable (DV).
  • Placebo can lead to perceived improvement even without an active drug (placebo effect).
  • Example: antidepressants often take 4–6 weeks to enter the bloodstream; early improvements may be placebo-driven.

Independent and Dependent Variables

  • IV: the drug (the treatment being tested) IV=drug\text{IV} = \text{drug}
  • DV: the outcome measured (e.g., headache relief) DV=headache relief\text{DV} = \text{headache relief}
  • Operational definitions are required to specify exactly how variables are measured.

Operational Definitions

  • Define what you mean by each variable in real-life terms so others can replicate.
  • Example hypothesis: chocolate causes violent behavior.
  • Operationalize chocolate: e.g., use a specific chocolate bar (e.g., Hershey) and a defined amount.
  • Operationalize violent behavior: a specified set of actions (e.g., kicking, fighting, scratching).
  • Clear operational definitions improve validity and reliability by enabling replication.

Replication, Validity, and Reliability

  • For a hypothesis to become a theory, results must be replicated across studies with the same methods and results.
  • Define variables precisely to ensure other researchers can replicate the experiment.
  • Validity and reliability depend on clear definitions and consistent procedures.

Confounding Variables

  • A confounding variable is anything that causes the DV other than the IV.
  • Confounds threaten the internal validity of an experiment.
  • Examples of potential confounds:
    • An argument with a parent before the study.
    • Alcohol consumption.
    • Not eating breakfast (affects mood/behavior).
  • In a smoking-and-heart-issues study, confounds include genetics, diet, lifestyle, and overall health.

Example: Chocolate and Violent Behavior

  • Hypothesis: chocolate causes violent behavior.
  • Operationalize:
    • Chocolate = a specified type/brand (e.g., Hershey bar).
    • Violent behavior = defined set of actions (e.g., kicking, fighting, scratching).
  • Why: ensures different researchers use the same measurement and can replicate results.

Quick Takeaways

  • Random assignment helps minimize Hawthorne effects and bias.
  • Use a placebo when a drug is involved to isolate the drug effect (IV) on the DV.
  • Clearly define operational definitions to enable replication and assess validity.
  • Watch for confounding variables that could explain the DV.