THET110 lecture
Western Theater: Context, Origins, and Core Concepts
Focus of the course: Primarily Western theater; Greek beginnings heavily influence later European art forms (theater, but also music, architecture, painting). Renaissance revivals in Europe, England, and later North America borrow these ideas; contemporary TV/film/plays are shaped by them.
Comparative lens: The instructor uses film as a contrast to highlight how narratives and form evolve differently across cultures (e.g., silent-era Western cinema versus Japanese cinema). A key example is the Benshi in Japan, who provided live narration and character voices during silent films, influencing directors to emphasize space/time over plot, and shaping the later Japanese cinema landscape (Kurosawa, Ozu).
Core claim: Aristotelian Western theater did not have to be inevitable; alternative paths of performance existed. The lecture traces a particular Western trajectory defined by plot/character emphasis, largely due to Aristotle.
Practical implication: Much of what we think of as a “movie” or “play” (emphasis on plot and character, narrative-driven) comes from these Greek conventions, but other cultures developed different emphases (e.g., space/time in Japanese cinema).
Early Cross-Cultural Comparisons: Cinema as a Lens
Silent Western cinema initially relied on pantomime; words appeared only as intertitles. With sound, dialogue replaced some pantomime functions, shifting emphasis toward plot and character.
In Japan (1910s–1920s), silent films were internationally legible because intertitles could be localized, but a benshi (live narrator) would appear beside the screen to provide dialogue, narration, and tone. This meant directors did not rely solely on character development in the same way as Western cinema did; instead, they explored space and time.
Benshi impact: Directors anticipated not needing explicit plot explanations, since a live performer would narrate. This fostered different cinematic concerns—space, time, and natural cycles (weather, time passage)—which informed later Japanese directors (e.g., Kurosawa, Ozu).
Takeaway: Different cultural contexts create different cinematic and theatrical priorities (plot/character versus space/time), which informs how we read Western theater as a canonical path rather than the sole possibility.
Origins of Western Theater: Geography, Politics, and Religion in Classical Greece
Geographic cradle: Greece sits in the Mediterranean with the Aegean and Adriatic seas, a cluster of islands, and nearby civilizational influences (Egyptian, Mycenaean, Babylonian). The era of unified Greece had not yet formed; city-states dominated (Athens, etc.).
Delian League (Delos treasury): Greek city-states pooled funds for defense against Persia; Athens eventually inhabited the treasury after taking the Delian funds and used them to build the Acropolis and to attract artists and scholars, centralizing cultural power in Athens.
Acropolis complex: Temple to Athena (Athens’ eponym), civic treasury, and a theater space (Theater of Dionysus) on or near the Acropolis—illustrating the triad of temple, treasury, and theater in Greek civic life.
Spring festival and tax-season convergence: The arrival of warmer weather enabled safe sea travel; taxation collection (tribute from the Delian League) coincided with a seven-day Dionysian festival—the city Dionysia—where theater would be born and celebrated.
Dionysus festival as theatrical cradle: Dionysus (god of wine, fertility, and unbridled passion) provided a climate of ecstatic ritual that contributed to the birth of theater in which civilized order coexists with primal impulse.
Nietzsche’s reading: The Birth of Tragedy contrasts Apollonian (order, rationality) and Dionysian (chaos, primal emotion) impulses; Greek tragedy embodies a tension between these impulses, not their eradication. Philosophy and theater intersect with cultural values about rationalism, emotion, and the social meaning of art.
From Dithyrams to Tragedy: The Formal Evolution of Greek Theater
Dithyrams: Early choral performances with up to 50 dancers and singers, in which city-states competed in divisions (youth, martial song, and narrative topics). These were the precursors to formal plays.
Emergence of individual actors: A chorus member gradually stepped out to perform a solo, leading to dialogue between two or more characters and the chorus commenting on the conflict. This evolution moved toward multi-character interaction while preserving a chorus.
Dramatic structure: Greeks did not extend beyond three performers on stage at a time; a chorus of 12 or 24 provided commentary. The initial three performers plus chorus defined classical Greek tragedy.
The theater space on the Acropolis: Theatres used a distinctive setup that influenced modern theater architecture:
Theatron (seeing place): the audience’s viewing space; named from Greek word for “seeing.”
Orchestra (dancing place): the circular or semi-circular performance area for the chorus and actors.
Proscenium (front wall area): a wall in front of the skene that separated audience from the stage.
Skene (scene building): the back-stage structure with doors for entrances/exits.
Peridus/Parodos (entrance passage): the side passage used for actors’ arrivals; an exodus was the actors’ exit from the stage.
Scenic practices: No modern scenery; stagecraft relied on movable wagons to suggest locations or battles, with off-stage action implied by a pile of bodies on a wagon rolled onto stage.
Concept of the deus ex machina: Greek tragedy’s crane device allowed a god to appear to resolve the plot; symbolized a god arriving at the end to fix the conflict.
Origins of the dramatic form: Plays were presented as part of the City Dionysia festival and became a competition among three playwrights (trilogies) sponsored by the city.
Chorus and mask usage: A chorus, typically 12–24 members, provided commentary and functioned as a communal voice; actors wore masks to indicate character identity when entrances/exits were rapid or multiple roles were performed by the same actor.
Aristotle’s Poetics: What Makes a Great Play? The Six Elements
Aristotle’s six essential elements of a good play:
Plot (the sequence of events)
Character (agents with moral weight)
Thought (themes and ideas)
Diction (word choice and metrical structure; not simply pronunciation)
Spectacle (visual aspects; what is seen)
Song (musical aspects; integral to drama but not the writer’s concern)
Practical note: Aristotle assigns spectacle and song to others’ domains (scenic design and music), focusing the playwright on Plot, Character, Thought, and Diction.
Hamartia: Commonly translated as “tragic flaw,” but historically misinterpreted. The original sense (from archery) is “to miss the mark” due to factors beyond the actor’s control. The modern notion of a flaw tied to sin is a later medieval/renaissance misreading.
Correct understanding: Hamartia is a flaw or error that leads to a fall, but it is not simply a moral defect; it may arise from circumstance or incomplete information.
Example: Oedipus’s actions are rational given his knowledge; he does not intend harm and is constrained by missing information.
Other Aristotelian concepts:
Peripeteia: reversal of fortune; the turning point when things go from good to bad for the protagonist (e.g., Oedipus’s rise and subsequent fall).
Anagnorisis: moment of recognition or insight when a character realizes a crucial truth about themselves or their situation (e.g., Oedipus discovering his true parentage and the incestuous nature of his marriage).
Catharsis: purgation or emotional release experienced by the audience through pity and fear; Aristotle’s idea is that tragedy enables this shared emotional cleansing.
Origin of the term: from medical contexts (cathartics) that purge the body of harmful substances; the theater purges pity and fear in the audience.
Dramatic structure in tragedy:
Typically three actors on stage with a chorus; stories drawn from history or myth; plays performed as trilogies in annual festival cycles; audiences likely already knew some endings from tradition.
Overall function of tragedy (Aristotle): A civic and moral education, modeling virtuous conduct and offering a tested path to coping with fate through understanding, empathy, and shared emotion.
Plato versus Aristotle: The Philosophical Debate on Art’s Value
Plato’s Republic: A foundational critique of the arts
Art as dangerous and potentially corrupting because it evokes powerful emotions and can manipulate beliefs by presenting falsehoods as emotionally compelling; art is difficult to control or govern.
Vision of “philosopher kings”: rational, enlightened governance by those who think deeply; suspicion of the arts’ ability to contribute to virtuous civic life if left uncontrolled.
Platonic Forms: the ideal version of objects (e.g., an ideal table) exists in a realm of forms; art creates imperfect representations and can mislead by appealing to appearances rather than truth.
Core worry: emotions stirred by art can lead citizens away from rational, fact-based judgment, risking tyranny and manipulation through myth-making.
Aristotle’s counterpoint: Civic value of theater when used to model virtue and civic behavior
Art has a legitimate role when it presents moral and civic ideals, showing people how to behave (tragedy highlights virtuous models; comedy lampoons vice for societal instruction).
Defense of tragedy: through catharsis and identification with characters, audiences learn to navigate moral choices and understand human fallibility in a controlled, communal setting.
Contemporary tensions: The lecture notes that sympathy for Aristotle’s view often arises, but concerns about censorship and rationalism persist; Plato’s critique remains relevant in discussions about media manipulation and public opinion.
Real-world cautionary examples used in class: films or narratives that plausibly manipulate emotion to convey false histories or propagandistic messages (e.g., Pearl Harbor retellings with invented lines) illustrate the risk Plato warned about; similarly, popularizing myths in history (e.g., Hamilton’s romanticized historical narrative) shows how emotions shape perception.
Synthesis: While the arts can be dangerous if left unchecked, they can also serve social and civic ends when integrated with reason and public values, a position that Aristotle defends in the context of theater’s public function.
Oedipus and the Aristotelian Toolkit: A Case Study
Why Oedipus is central to Aristotle’s framework:
Plot-driven catastrophe: Oedipus’s life moves from high status to downfall due to a confluence of fate, information gaps, and self-righteous pursuit of truth.
Hamartia clarified: Oedipus’s fall is not a moral defect; rather, it results from circumstances and limited knowledge he cannot overcome.
Peripeteia: A dramatic reversal from kingly happiness to exile and punishment.
Anagnorisis: The revelation of Oedipus’s true parentage and the nature of his marriage, accompanied by a profound crisis of self-awareness.
Catharsis: The audience experiences a deep emotional release as pity and fear are engaged and resolved through the resolution of the play’s moral ambiguity.
The broader moral: Aristotle’s theory expects the audience to be morally moved and to gain insight about human vulnerability, not merely to entertain.
Terminology and Formal Notes from the Greek Stage
Dithyrams: Early choral performances that served as the seedbed for tragedy; groups from each Greek city-state competed in song and dance; included a mix of military-style movement and storytelling.
The evolution to three actors: The chorus remained central, but a solo performer emerged, eventually leading to a configuration of three actors on stage plus chorus.
Stock elements of the Greek theater architecture and terminology:
Theatron: the audience space (seeing place).
Orchestra: the circular or semi-circular dancing space for the chorus and performers.
Proscenia: the area in front of the skene (the stage’s front) often acting as a frame or barrier; it’s not a proscenium arch as in later theaters, but a front-facing area.
Skene: the stage building behind the actors; provided entrances/exits and sometimes storage or backdrops.
Peridos (parodos): the entrance corridor used by the chorus; an exodus is the collective exit of actors and chorus at the end of a performance.
Scenic devices: no modern scenery; use of wagons (mekane) to suggest locations (e.g., battlefield) and simple stage machinery to imply events beyond direct depiction.
Deus ex Machina: literally “god from the machine”; a crane or similar device lowering a deity to resolve the plot.
Role of masks: Actors wore masks to indicate character identity and facilitate multiple roles with a limited cast.
The Roman Aftermath and the Medieval Gap
Roman theater: Heavily borrowed from Greek models; added more routine violence and a greater emphasis on spectacle and comedic forms; yet, largely a continuation of Greek forms rather than a new conceptual revolution.
Fall of Rome and its two interpretive takes:
View A: The fall freed regions from centralized Roman control, enabling independent cultural development, languages, and artistic expression (e.g., what would become England, France, Iberia, the Balkans).
View B: The fall caused a collapse of a unified cultural market, a decline in centralized knowledge, and a power vacuum that the Catholic Church would later fill as the dominant economic and spiritual force in medieval Europe.
The theater drought: Roughly 500–900 AD there was little or no organized theatrical performance in Europe due to church opposition to pagan/plays; other forms persisted (bards, minstrels, jugglers, acrobats) but not “theater” as a structured performing art.
The Rosvita revival: Rosvita, a German nun, wrote the first Western play after nearly a millennium of absence, a Latin play for her nuns and students, signaling a revival that would ultimately fuel the Renaissance.
Prelude to the Renaissance: What Comes Next
The Renaissance (and beyond): The instructor previews a rapid movement from Renaissance revival to twentieth-century theater, outlining that a few major movements will shape modern Western theater and set the stage for contemporary performance.
Practical takeaway: The next session will expand on how Renaissance innovation and subsequent centuries reinterpreted classical forms, leading to the 20th century’s experimentation and modernization of theater.
Key Concepts and Terms (Glossary-style quick references)
Theatron: seeing place; audience seating and vantage point in Greek theaters.
Orchestra: dancing place; the main performance circle for chorus and actors.
Skene: backdrop/scene-building area; later sources describe its function as a stage house;
Proscenia: front-area structure that framed the stage; not the modern proscenium arch, but a front boundary.
Peridos (Parodos): entrance passage for the chorus; exodos is the collective exit from the stage.
Dithyrams: early choral performances that evolved into plays; competition among Greek city-states.
Hamartia: originally “to miss the mark” in archery; misinterpretations in later ages as “tragic flaw”; not the same as a sin; can arise from circumstance or information gaps.
Peripeteia: reversal of fortune; the turning point in tragedy.
Anagnorisis: moment of recognition or insight.
Catharsis: purgation of pity and fear; emotional release for the audience.
Deus ex Machina: “god from the machine”; a god or deus-figure resolved into the plot via stage machinery.
The six elements (Aristotle): Plot, Character, Thought, Diction, Spectacle, Song.
Apollonian vs. Dionysian: Rational order versus primal, ecstatic force of emotion in Greek culture; a lens for understanding tragedy.
City Dionysia: the major spring festival in Athens that housed the birth of Greek theater.
Delian League: alliance that funded Greek theater development (and Athens’ rise as a cultural capital after commandeering the treasury).
Oedipus: a canonical tragedy illustrating hamartia, peripeteia, anagnorisis, and catharsis; used as a concrete illustration of Aristotle’s theory.
Timeline Snippet (Key Dates and Milestones)
Ancient Greece: Classical theater emerges during the Delian League era; City Dionysia festival and theater on the Acropolis establish foundational forms (roughly 5th century BCE).
Greek tragedy’s peak: Three actors, chorus, and a trilogic festival format; plays originated from myth/history rather than purely invented plots.
Aristotle’s Poetics: Composed about two centuries after Greek tragedy’s heyday, articulating a systematic theory of drama and its civic value.
Plato’s Republic: Earlier than Aristotle’s methodological treatise; critiques the arts’ role in the ideal state and the dangers of emotion-driven belief.
Hellenistic and Roman periods: Greek drama adapts to Roman tastes; Greek models influence Roman theater; later decline of classic theater.
500–900 AD: The medieval period sees a near-complete hiatus in “theater” as structured performance in Europe, driven by church authority.
9th–11th centuries: Occasional plays by religious communities (Latin plays) surface; Rosvita’s mid-medieval contribution marks a revival that will lead into the Renaissance.
Connections, Implications, and Real-World Relevance
Thematic throughlines: The tension between rational social order and primal human impulse (Apollonian vs. Dionysian) continues to inform literary and cinematic storytelling across cultures.
Civic function of art: Aristotle’s insistence on virtue-formation and civic education through stage drama has influenced civic institutions, education, and the role of theater as a space for public reflection.
Ethics of representation: Plato’s caution about art’s influence on emotion and belief remains relevant for media literacy, political communication, and the ethics of storytelling in modern media.
Cross-cultural influence: The Japanese silent-to-sound cinema tradition and its emphasis on space/time foreshadowed a broader, global discussion about how different cultures structure narrative experience.
Methodological takeaway for exams: Be ready to identify the six Aristotelian elements, explain hamartia as a miscue rather than a moral flaw, describe peripeteia and anagnorisis, and articulate catharsis as a shared emotional experience. Recognize the role of chorus, masks, and stage machinery in Greek theater, and understand how these details distinguish ancient Greek practice from later operatic, medieval, and Renaissance forms.
Illustrative Takeaways and Examples Mentioned in the Lecture
The City Dionysia festival as the birthplace of theater; early dithyrams transitioning to plays with solo actors and a chorus.
Oedipus as a canonical demonstration of hamartia, peripeteia, anagnorisis, and catharsis, illustrating Aristotle’s theory in a concrete narrative.
The concept of a Deus Ex Machina used in Greek tragedy to resolve intractable plot challenges via divine intervention.
The Benshi in Japanese cinema as a live, performative narrator who could reduce reliance on explicit on-screen dialogue; influenced Western directors’ attention to spatial and temporal dimensions.
Modern misrepresentations in history and media (e.g., Pearl Harbor film line of a “sleeping giant”) used in class to illustrate the power of emotion over factual accuracy and to discuss Plato’s concerns about manipulated beliefs.
Rosvita’s medieval play: a key marker of Western theater’s revival after a millennium-long hiatus, illustrating the medieval-to-Renaissance transition in dramatic production.
Quick Reference: Core Terms for Study
Theatron, Orchestra, Proscenia, Skene, Peridos, Exodus
Dithyrams, Tragedy, Comedy
Hamartia, Peripeteia, Anagnorisis, Catharsis
Deus Ex Machina, Deus Ex Machina device
Apollonian vs. Dionysian impulse
City Dionysia, Acropolis, Temple to Athena, Delian League
Aristotle’s Poetics: six elements; three-actor rule; trilogy competition
Plato’s Republic; philosopher-king critique; Forms concept
Rosvita’s medieval play; Renaissance revival
If you want, I can tailor these notes further for a particular exam prompt or convert any section into a concise study-card format. Let me know your preferred focus or any areas you want deep-dived with more examples and practice questions.