Preventing Substance Abuse

Types of Prevention

  • Primary Prevention: Programs aimed at young people who haven't tried substances.
    • Pros: Encourages abstinence by educating about drugs and their influence.
    • Cons: May create curiosity about drugs.
  • Secondary Prevention: Programs for those who have tried substances.
    • Goal: Prevent the use of more dangerous substances and prevent dangerous forms of use of substances they are experimenting with.
  • Tertiary Prevention (Relapse Prevention): Follow-up programs.
    • Goal: Help individuals with substance use disorder enter treatment.
  • Universal Prevention: Programs for an entire population (e.g., all school children).
  • Selective Prevention: Strategies for high-risk groups within the general population (e.g., students doing poorly in academics).
  • Indicated Prevention: Strategies targeted at individuals showing signs of developing problems (e.g., a child who started smoking at a young age).

Knowledge, Attitudes, Behavior Model

  • Traditional anti-drug programs relied on police officers sharing "horror stories" about illicit drugs (scare tactics).
  • These programs assumed that providing information would increase knowledge, change attitudes, and decrease drug use.
  • 1971 study and 1973 report showed this model was ineffective and may have increased drug use.

Effective Education

  • Values Clarification Approach: Focuses on the ability to make appropriate decisions rather than factual information.
    • Involves discussing reactions to moral and ethical dilemmas.
    • Teaching students to analyze and clarify their own values in life.
  • Teaching Alternatives to Drug Use: Offering activities to produce "natural highs".
    • Relaxation exercises, meditation, vigorous exercise, sports.

Antidrug Norms

  • In the mid-1980s, concern grew that effective education lacked emphasis on resisting interpersonal pressures to use drugs.
  • In 1986, the federal government launched a program to support drug use prevention in schools and communities.
  • Aimed to shift values, emphasizing that society does not condone drug use or underage alcohol use.

Social Influence Model

  • Evans (1976) introduced the psychological inoculation approach based on the social influence model in a smoking prevention paper.
  • Key elements for effective prevention:
    • Training refusal skills.
    • Public commitment.
    • Countering advertising.
    • Normative education.
    • Use of team leaders.

DARE (Drug Abuse Resistance Education)

  • Based on the social influence model of smoking cessation.
  • Delivered by police officers in uniform, originally in 5th and 6th grade classrooms using interactive techniques.
  • Components:
    • Refusal skills.
    • Team leaders.
    • Public commitment not to use drugs.
    • Self-esteem building.
    • Alternatives to drug use.
    • Decision making.
  • Impact on drug use was marginal, with limited evidence of long-term reductions in self-reported drug use.

Programs That Work

  • Project Alert:
    • Cigarette experimenters were more likely to quit or maintain lower rates of smoking.
    • Experimental groups drank less alcohol soon after the program.
    • Effects diminished over time.
  • Life Skills Training Program:
    • Long-term positive results with a three-year program.
    • Based on the social influence model.
    • Teaches resistance skills, normative education, and media influences.

Peer Programs

  • Occur in school settings and youth-oriented community service programs (e.g., YMCA).
  • Focused on straight youth by using them in group community service projects
  • Two main aspects:
    • Peer influence: Understanding that peer opinions significantly influence adolescent behavior and emphasizes an open discussion to combat it.
    • Peer participation: Involving young people in making important decisions and doing significant work.
  • Data on whether peer programs significantly alter drug use is either unavailable or inconclusive.

Parent and Family Programs

  • Four main approaches:
    • Informational Programs: Provide parents with basic information about alcohol, drugs, their use, and effects.
    • Parenting Skills: Teach communication, decision-making, goal setting, limit setting, and how to say no.
    • Parent Support Groups: Regular meetings to discuss problem-solving, parenting skills, and their perceptions of the problem.
    • Family Interaction: Families work as a unit to examine, discuss, and confront issues related to alcohol and drug use.

Community Programs

  • Allow for coordinated approaches from schools, parents, and civic organizations, increasing impact.
  • Community support and engagement are crucial due to the controversial nature of drug abuse prevention and education.
  • Bring resources together (e.g., enlisting public media to reinforce information).

Prevention in the Workplace

  • The federal government encourages private employers to adopt policies to prevent drug use (e.g., random urine screens).
  • Goal is not to catch and fire drug users, but to prevent drug use by making it not condoned.

What Should We Be Doing?

  • Most states require drug and alcohol abuse prevention education as part of a health curriculum.
  • A sensible, balanced approach combines factual information with social skills training, integrated into health, personal values, and decision-making themes.
  • Avoid inadvertently demonstrating how to do things one would not want students to do.
  • Inform without leading into temptations to use and abuse substances.