UPU0005 Module 1: Introduction to Scientific Method and Process

Fundamental Concepts and the Impact of Science

Science serves as the foundational discipline for asking and answering fundamental questions about the nature of the world and our existence. Through scientific inquiry, we have determined that the universe originated approximately 13.7×10913.7 \times 10^9 years ago. At the biological level, science has revealed that all living organisms encode their developmental blueprint onto a specific chemical molecule known as DNA. This DNA is the critical mechanism that allows for the transmission of traits and characteristics from one generation to the next. Furthermore, science provides an explanation for Earth's prehistoric history, such as the era when supersized reptiles ruled the planet and their subsequent extinction caused by the impact of a vast comet or asteroid.

Beyond theoretical knowledge, science has a tangible impact on the quality of everyday life. Modern technology is a direct byproduct of scientific advancement; for example, current home computers now possess more processing power than the fastest university computers from 1010 years ago. Scientific developments are integral to modern existence, and while they significantly enhance our quality of life through innovations like electricity and modern agricultural methods, they can also have detrimental effects. Key examples of scientific contributions that have shaped the modern world include the creation of plastics, the development of iPads and iPhones, and the advancement of Western medicines.

Objectives and Framework of the UPU0005 Science Unit

The UPU0005 Science unit at Edith Cowan University (ECU) is designed to equip students with a specific set of academic and professional skills. The primary aim is to teach students how to work scientifically and how to communicate their findings through scientific writing using the IMRaD template, which stands for Introduction, Methods, Results, and Discussion. Additionally, the unit encourages critical reflection, helping students identify specific areas within the realm of science where they need to further develop their knowledge base.

In the categorization of knowledge, various topics are identified as being either based on science or outside of its immediate methodology. Scientifically-based subjects include chemical compounds, nutrients, influenza (and other pathogens), mountains (geological structures), organ transplants, and contraception. Other fields mentioned in the context of academic inquiry include economic theory and technology like cell phones. Science itself is divided into several major branches, including Chemistry, Biology, Physics, Astronomy, Geology, Psychology, and Ecology.

The Scientific Method and the Hierarchy of the Scientific Process

Working scientifically is defined as a structured process where an individual plans a course of action, carries out an activity to collect necessary data, organizes and interprets that data, and finally reaches a conclusion that is communicated in a formal manner. This unit emphasizes the scientific method because it is the universal standard used by scientists to investigate the natural world. The scientific process is a multi-stage cycle categorized into four primary phases: Planning, Conducting, Processing, and Evaluating.

In the Planning phase, a scientist must identify and analyze a problem, identify relevant variables, and formulate either a research question or a hypothesis and prediction. This stage also involves operationalizing variables and planning the design and procedure of the study. The Conducting phase involves performing preliminary trials followed by the actual experiment, where the scientist must observe, measure, and record data. During the Processing phase, the data is organized (often through calculations or the construction of graphs) and analyzed to identify patterns, trends, or relationships between variables. Finally, in the Evaluating phase, the researcher must evaluate the experimental design and techniques used, while also comparing the findings against the original problem, question, or hypothesis.

Typology of Scientific Investigations

Most scientific investigations can be classified into five distinct types depending on their methodology and goals. The first is the survey, which involves the measurement of quantities or qualities within collected samples. The second is the experimental investigation, which relies on the manipulation of artificial situations to test solutions to a problem; this approach specifically requires the identification, control, and manipulation of relevant variables.

Third is the descriptive investigation, which involves the observation, measurement, and description of a phenomenon that the researcher cannot or does not wish to manipulate. Fourth is technique or instrument development, a category of research focused on the creation and testing of new technologies or scientific instrumentation. Lastly, data research involves the use of previously collected data from established sources to answer new research questions, rather than gathering primary data from scratch.

Processing, Evaluating, and the IMRaD Framework

The processing of scientific data is a rigorous step where knowledge is applied to develop explanations for observed patterns or relationships. This involves analyzing data to see how variables interact and constructing visual representations such as graphs to make the data interpretable. Evaluation follows, where the scientist critiques the design of the experiment and the methods employed to ensure accuracy. The researcher must determine if the findings support or refute the initial hypothesis or help answer the primary research question. If necessary, methods and techniques are revised, and the problem or hypothesis is reformulated, starting the cycle again.

To communicate these complex processes, the IMRaD (Introduction, Methods, Results, and Discussion) format is used. This is the standard acronym for the structure of academic research papers. While it is the staple of the "hard" sciences like physics and biology, it is also the dominant format for the social and behavioral sciences. The IMRaD format is essentially a more defined version of the general "IBC" (Introduction, Body, Conclusion) format and is synonymous with the APA format, as the American Psychological Association mandates these headings in its stylesheet.

Questions & Discussion: Inductive Reasoning and the Unseen

During the tutorial session, students engage in an activity titled "What's in the box" to explore the concept of inductive reasoning. This exercise serves as a metaphor for how scientists draw conclusions about things they cannot see directly. For instance, astronomers can locate and characterize black holes despite the fact that no light escapes from them, and they can describe properties of faraway galaxies that are invisible to the naked eye.

Research Questions for Discussion:

  • How can scientists explain what they have not seen?

  • If no light escapes from a black hole, how can astronomers locate it?

  • How can scientists characterize things they can't see with the naked eye, like faraway galaxies?

The solution provided in the workshop is the use of indirect observations. By observing how the environment reacts to an unseen object, scientists can determine its contents or properties. In the workshop, students use these indirect observations to determine the contents of a set of mystery boxes, mimicking the process of characterization used in high-level astrophysics and theoretical science.