Collaborative Governance in Context
GLE 1010G: Collaborative Governance in Context
Our Agenda
Collaborative Governance: Taking Stock, Looking Ahead
GLE: Multidisciplinary Approaches
GLE Case Studies: Workshop
Rise of Collaborative Governance
21st Century Challenges:
The emergence of complex public challenges described as "wicked problems."
Sectoral Expertise:
The expertise, resources, and capabilities of each sector are often insufficient to tackle these problems on their own.
Government Role:
Governments are increasingly convening networks across boundaries to create a common ground for solutions that none could deliver alone.
Complementarity:
Collaborative governance is intended to complement, not replace, representative Parliamentary government.
Process of Collaborative Governance
Key Steps
Initiating Leadership:
Often led by government, but not exclusively.
Participant Recruitment:
Involves engaging stakeholders and/or citizens.
Acknowledge Interdependence:
Building trust among all participants.
Articulate Collective Purpose:
Discovering and defining a shared goal.
Develop Theory of Change:
Clarifying who does what, where, and when.
Implement Solutions:
Solutions are often implemented through pilot projects.
Evaluate Results:
Assessing outcomes to identify successes that can be scaled up.
Public Accountability:
Ensuring transparency in outcomes.
Contexts of Collaborative Governance
Different Forms
Across Sectors:
Often referred to as horizontal cross-sector governance.
Between Governments:
Also known as vertical multi-level governance among different governmental levels.
Among Citizens:
Community-based deliberation emphasizing citizen participation.
Various Settings
Policy Fields:
Applies to areas such as environment, health, artificial intelligence (AI), and human trafficking.
Local Places:
Focuses on governance at city, regional, or neighborhood levels as well as concepts like "just transitions."
Indigenous Communities:
Engaging in discussions about land, services, and treaty negotiations.
Context 1: Across Sectors
Community Sector Council, Newfoundland and Labrador:
Inclusive of four principal sectors: government, business, nonprofits, and Indigenous organizations.
Each sector:
Represents its professional constituency and engages in collaborative work.
Contributes resources based on comparative advantage, including knowledge, funding, and networks.
Transforms conflicts into learning opportunities, fostering resilient commitments and legitimacy of outcomes delivered.
Examples of Collaborative Efforts:
EVOLV
London Whole of Community Response
Just Transitions
Context 2: Between Governments
Four Levels of Government:
Federal, provincial, municipal, and Indigenous levels.
Each government:
Represents its elected constituency and collaborates to tackle public challenges.
Brings in policy tools, resources, and knowledge based on their jurisdictional competence.
Focuses on policy co-responsibility and shared credit rather than political blame.
Implementation through Co-Financing:
Encapsulates collaborative governance agreements that often include co-financing from multiple government levels.
Examples of Agreements:
UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) - Global-Local action plans
Indigenous-Federal Government Sectoral Agreements
Federal-Provincial/Territorial Nation-Building Projects
Context 3: Participatory Governance
Moving Beyond Traditional Roles:
Involves citizens' lived experiences and practical wisdom beyond government officials and sector professionals.
Empowerment of the Underserved:
Focuses on giving a voice to underrepresented and underserved individuals in decision-making processes.
Components of Participatory Governance:
Advisory Roles:
Identify community needs.
Priority Setting:
Advocate for investment in prioritized areas.
Participatory Governance Initiatives:
Engage in processes such as Citizen Science to produce community well-being indicators.
Co-Design:
Involvement in the design of programs and access to services.
Citizen Assemblies:
Facilitate deliberation on public policy options.
Context 4: Metagovernance
Introduction to Metagovernance:
A recent model proposed in collaborative governance research.
Definition:
Metagovernance refers to the coordination of various forms and settings for governance.
Key Considerations:
Selection:
When to select cross-sector, multi-level, or citizen empowerment strategies.
Integration:
How to effectively integrate all three approaches in addressing wicked problems.
Understanding Metagovernance:
Can also be described as "governance of governance" indicating oversight over governance frameworks.
Challenges of Collaborative Governance
No Guarantee of Productive Governance:
Collaborative approaches can have varying success rates.
Challenges by Context:
Across Sectors: Discrepancies between business and nonprofit agendas.
Between Governments: Political competition and partisanship may obstruct cooperation.
Participatory: Governments may overlook or disregard input from citizens.
Metagovernance: Difficulty in finding the right balance of methods for effective governance.
Need for Empirical Research:
Assessment of the relative success or failure of these initiatives necessitates case studies and practical applications.
A Deeper Dive: Huron's GLE
Upper-Year GLE Courses Featuring All Governance Types:
GLE2001 F/G: Introduction to Governance (cross-sector governance)
GLE2003 F/G: Introduction to Leadership (metagovernance)
GLE3001/G: Housing Policy (multilevel governance)
GLE3009F/G: Empowering Citizens (participatory governance)
GLE4011 F/G: Collaborative Governance (involves sectoral, multilevel, citizen, and metagovernance, plus a case study of the Basque Country).
Multidisciplinary Perspectives
Options for Double Majors Combining GLE with Other Disciplines:
Management and Organization Studies:
Examining business roles in society, assessing Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) and Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) practices.
Philosophy:
Addressing ethical questions on defining and advancing the common good and understanding core values.
Political Science:
Investigating the changing roles of governments and studying the interplay of governance models in action.
Importance of a Multidisciplinary Approach in Teaching and Learning
History:
Reflection on historical parallels with modern complex issues and the lessons to draw.
Psychology:
Exploration of human motivations in cooperation versus competition, particularly how individual goals align with communal outcomes.
English and Cultural Studies:
Insights into narratives and storytelling as mechanisms for shaping collective action across diverse cultures.