Collaborative Governance in Context

GLE 1010G: Collaborative Governance in Context


Our Agenda

  1. Collaborative Governance: Taking Stock, Looking Ahead

  2. GLE: Multidisciplinary Approaches

  3. GLE Case Studies: Workshop


Rise of Collaborative Governance

  • 21st Century Challenges:

    • The emergence of complex public challenges described as "wicked problems."

  • Sectoral Expertise:

    • The expertise, resources, and capabilities of each sector are often insufficient to tackle these problems on their own.

  • Government Role:

    • Governments are increasingly convening networks across boundaries to create a common ground for solutions that none could deliver alone.

  • Complementarity:

    • Collaborative governance is intended to complement, not replace, representative Parliamentary government.


Process of Collaborative Governance

Key Steps
  1. Initiating Leadership:

    • Often led by government, but not exclusively.

  2. Participant Recruitment:

    • Involves engaging stakeholders and/or citizens.

  3. Acknowledge Interdependence:

    • Building trust among all participants.

  4. Articulate Collective Purpose:

    • Discovering and defining a shared goal.

  5. Develop Theory of Change:

    • Clarifying who does what, where, and when.

  6. Implement Solutions:

    • Solutions are often implemented through pilot projects.

  7. Evaluate Results:

    • Assessing outcomes to identify successes that can be scaled up.

  8. Public Accountability:

    • Ensuring transparency in outcomes.


Contexts of Collaborative Governance

Different Forms
  1. Across Sectors:

    • Often referred to as horizontal cross-sector governance.

  2. Between Governments:

    • Also known as vertical multi-level governance among different governmental levels.

  3. Among Citizens:

    • Community-based deliberation emphasizing citizen participation.

Various Settings
  1. Policy Fields:

    • Applies to areas such as environment, health, artificial intelligence (AI), and human trafficking.

  2. Local Places:

    • Focuses on governance at city, regional, or neighborhood levels as well as concepts like "just transitions."

  3. Indigenous Communities:

    • Engaging in discussions about land, services, and treaty negotiations.


Context 1: Across Sectors

  • Community Sector Council, Newfoundland and Labrador:

    • Inclusive of four principal sectors: government, business, nonprofits, and Indigenous organizations.

  • Each sector:

    • Represents its professional constituency and engages in collaborative work.

    • Contributes resources based on comparative advantage, including knowledge, funding, and networks.

    • Transforms conflicts into learning opportunities, fostering resilient commitments and legitimacy of outcomes delivered.

  • Examples of Collaborative Efforts:

    • EVOLV

    • London Whole of Community Response

    • Just Transitions


Context 2: Between Governments

  • Four Levels of Government:

    • Federal, provincial, municipal, and Indigenous levels.

  • Each government:

    • Represents its elected constituency and collaborates to tackle public challenges.

    • Brings in policy tools, resources, and knowledge based on their jurisdictional competence.

    • Focuses on policy co-responsibility and shared credit rather than political blame.

  • Implementation through Co-Financing:

    • Encapsulates collaborative governance agreements that often include co-financing from multiple government levels.

  • Examples of Agreements:

    • UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) - Global-Local action plans

    • Indigenous-Federal Government Sectoral Agreements

    • Federal-Provincial/Territorial Nation-Building Projects


Context 3: Participatory Governance

  • Moving Beyond Traditional Roles:

    • Involves citizens' lived experiences and practical wisdom beyond government officials and sector professionals.

  • Empowerment of the Underserved:

    • Focuses on giving a voice to underrepresented and underserved individuals in decision-making processes.

  • Components of Participatory Governance:

    1. Advisory Roles:

    • Identify community needs.

    1. Priority Setting:

    • Advocate for investment in prioritized areas.

    1. Participatory Governance Initiatives:

    • Engage in processes such as Citizen Science to produce community well-being indicators.

    1. Co-Design:

    • Involvement in the design of programs and access to services.

    1. Citizen Assemblies:

    • Facilitate deliberation on public policy options.


Context 4: Metagovernance

  • Introduction to Metagovernance:

    • A recent model proposed in collaborative governance research.

  • Definition:

    • Metagovernance refers to the coordination of various forms and settings for governance.

  • Key Considerations:

    1. Selection:

    • When to select cross-sector, multi-level, or citizen empowerment strategies.

    1. Integration:

    • How to effectively integrate all three approaches in addressing wicked problems.

  • Understanding Metagovernance:

    • Can also be described as "governance of governance" indicating oversight over governance frameworks.


Challenges of Collaborative Governance

  • No Guarantee of Productive Governance:

    • Collaborative approaches can have varying success rates.

  • Challenges by Context:

    • Across Sectors: Discrepancies between business and nonprofit agendas.

    • Between Governments: Political competition and partisanship may obstruct cooperation.

    • Participatory: Governments may overlook or disregard input from citizens.

    • Metagovernance: Difficulty in finding the right balance of methods for effective governance.

  • Need for Empirical Research:

    • Assessment of the relative success or failure of these initiatives necessitates case studies and practical applications.


A Deeper Dive: Huron's GLE

  • Upper-Year GLE Courses Featuring All Governance Types:

    • GLE2001 F/G: Introduction to Governance (cross-sector governance)

    • GLE2003 F/G: Introduction to Leadership (metagovernance)

    • GLE3001/G: Housing Policy (multilevel governance)

    • GLE3009F/G: Empowering Citizens (participatory governance)

    • GLE4011 F/G: Collaborative Governance (involves sectoral, multilevel, citizen, and metagovernance, plus a case study of the Basque Country).


Multidisciplinary Perspectives

  • Options for Double Majors Combining GLE with Other Disciplines:

  1. Management and Organization Studies:

    • Examining business roles in society, assessing Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) and Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) practices.

  2. Philosophy:

    • Addressing ethical questions on defining and advancing the common good and understanding core values.

  3. Political Science:

    • Investigating the changing roles of governments and studying the interplay of governance models in action.

Importance of a Multidisciplinary Approach in Teaching and Learning
  • History:

    • Reflection on historical parallels with modern complex issues and the lessons to draw.

  • Psychology:

    • Exploration of human motivations in cooperation versus competition, particularly how individual goals align with communal outcomes.

  • English and Cultural Studies:

    • Insights into narratives and storytelling as mechanisms for shaping collective action across diverse cultures.