Oral Exam II Study Guide

Oral Exam II Study Guide

  • Define, Compare and Contrast Confounding, Effect Modification, and Mediation (This one's guaranteed)

Confounding: variables that are associated/causally related with the outcome and correlated with the exposure – can alter the direction of the results and lead to an over or under estimation of the exposure effect

Question: is there another variable whose effect on outcome is blending with exposure effect on outcome

Effect Modification: variables associated with only the outcome, significantly modifies the exposure effect

Question: is there any other variable that is modifying the effect of the exposure on the outcome

Mediation: when the exposure causes the confounder which causes the outcome

  • What sort of things make for a good Randomized Cross-over Trial and Why
  • Explanation: both groups are interventions and everyone receives both interventions
  • Randomization – randomizing participants based on what intervention they receive first
  • Participants act as their own controls
  • Effective washout period to reduce crossover effects from the different interventions
  • Limited time between interventions – period effect
  • Mixed effects modeling to determine the amount of period effect and crossover effects
  • Taking multiple measurements can help identify and/or reduce crossover effects
  • Compare and contrast the strengths, weaknesses and designs of Prospective Cohorts, Retrospective Cohorts, Cross Sectional Studies, and Case Control Studies

Study Design

Explanation

Strengths

Weaknesses

Prospective Cohort

Highest level observational research

Compares outcome incidences to exposed vs non-exposed groups

Similar to RCTs, but observational and no randomization

Temporality, we follow a cohort over time

More robust against selection bias because outcome is unknown

Confounding – as with any observational study

Assumes all patients are at the same risk of the outcome

Misclassification bias

  • Differential misclassification can directionally bias the results

Attribution bias (people who left the study & why) and nonresponder bias

Immortal time bias (when receiving the outcome is not possible)

Retrospective Cohort

Similar to prospective but a bit less reliable

Looking at past data

Low cost

No nonresponder bias

Fast results

Can study multiple outcomes/exposures if data is available

Potentially long latency periods

Best for rare exposures

Same weaknesses as prospective PLUS

Data was not intended to be used in research – information bias

Researchers cannot choose to measure other variables – must work with what they have

Outcome is already known, may introduce selection bias

Cross-Sectional

Members from prespecified population are randomly sampled and simultaneously assessed of prevalence for exposure & outcome

NHANES

Best for assessing prevalence of disease and assess associations between disease and demographics

Randomization reduces selection bias, unless the target population is not well-defined

May require trained interviewers

No temporality – no following people through time

Survivor effect (if participants die prior to the study, they are not counted)

Nonresponder bias

Recall bias (surveys)

Respondent bias (saying what the researcher wants to hear)

We don’t know what came first (reverse causality)

Case Control

Compares exposure prevalence in people with and without the outcome

Can study multiple exposures

Best for rare outcomes

  • Smaller sample size but more power

Smaller sample size

Assumes cases and controls were similar in baseline risk for the outcome at the time of exposure & there is no way to prove or disprove this assumption

Outcome is known – selection bias is common

Information bias depends on if researchers use new cases or anyone with the outcome

Recall bias & differential misclassification bias