Process of Science

  • Forms of science

    • experimental science- use of experimentation to test hypotheses (scientific method )

    • Historical science - analysis of data sets or physical evidence of past events

      • epidemiological science- use of data ( usually for medical trials) in which a control group is unethical


  • Scientific Method   

    • 1. observe some aspect of universe

    • 2. develop a tentative explanation for what has been observed called a hypothesis, that is consistent with observations

    • 3.use hypothesis to make predictions

    • 4. test those predictions by experiments or further observations and modify the hypothesis in light of your results

    • 5. repeat steps ¾ until there are no discrepancies between hypothesis and experiment and/or observation


  • Hypothesis   

    • a proposal intended to explain certain facts or observations that can be tested

    • can help answer “what if”

    • can also fail


  • Fact

    • somehting known to be true; something that can be shown to be true, to exist, or to have happened


  • Theory

    • A model of realit, or some aspect of realit, it is an explantion of phenomena and is supportedly by observational ( facts) and laws of nature and is logical

    • can answer why or how


  • Law

    • a descriptio of what occur;s law of gravity

    • can answer what


  • your inability to invalidate my hypothesis


  • 4 premises of science

    • 1. world is real

      • we don’t create physical reality and can’t change it by wishful thinking

      • the physical universe exist independently of our minds, whether we sense it or not.

    • 2. it is possible for humans to understand physical universe

    • 3. natural processes are sufficient to explain the natural world

    • 4. knowledge is available to everyone

      • not based on subjective states of mind


  • science has..

    • a body of facts

    • a bunch of facts, divorced from any meaningful context is a bit like …

    • can’t see a meaningful pattern and can not see what is missing

    • a way of thinking

    • method of learning about natural world

    • organizes facts into meaningful pattern of information

    • science helps us make sense of world by seeing how facts are connected.


  • The nature of science: E.S.S.C.M.O

    • empiricism

      • goal? to gain greater understanding of reality

      • method? to make systematic observations

      • what do they observe ?

        • def: its that knowledge is based on sensory experience; it must be observable or measurable (e.g. experiements, studies, systematic observations) foundation

          • contrasts with pure logic and gut feelings

      • does NOT study pehnomena that cannot be observed and/or controlled- there is no way to test them

        • supernatural: gods, spirtual beings or miracles

        • cannot study a religion and decide if it is true or not (in a science class)

        • Faith= belief in absence of empirical evidence

      • different domains: Non-overlapping Magisteria (NOMA)

        • stephen J Gould- evoltionary biologist

      • Magisterium- refers to different domains of human experience/ thoughts

        • what the universe is made of (fact) and why it works a certain way (theory)

      • Magisterium of religion deals with questions of ultimate meaning/ moral value

      • according to gould, these 2 magisteria do not overlap, nor does each itself, encompasses all inquiry

    • Skepticism

      • scientists are skeptic

      • skepticism: a form of critical thinking that uses reason/ evidence to determine the likelihood that something is true

        • scientist combine skepticism with the scientific method to try to better understand the world

        • DOES NOT MEAN

        • nothing can be known, science specifically attempts to learn things

        • scientist are close minded, new evidence can refute any previous conclusion

      • Are you a scientific skeptic

        • do you believe every ad you see ?

        • do you believe everything you read ?

        • do you automatically trust everything a car dealer says to you ?

        • do you buy into the latest weight loss/ health trend ?

      • We are ALL skeptics - ability to analyze claims by:

        • improves ability to think critically / scientifically (scientific reasoning )

        • teach you basic facts from several different disciplines of science which you can use to make informed decisions

      • Why are both necessary:

        • reason something well, but do not the facts=wrong answer

        • and if,

        • know facts , but cant reason with them/ organize them in a meaningful way=wrong answer

        • Critical thinking+ facts = better chance of making correct decisions; improves quality of our lives

    • Self- correcting

      • so why does science work so well ?

        • empirical- not wishful thinking and irritational thoughts

        • objective/ repeatable= testable

          • personality/ persuasiveness are irrelevant

          • method is universal

        • self correcting : elimination of wrong ideas= progress

    • Critical Thinking

      • the process of evaluating validity and soundness of claims basis of well-supported evidence

      • FiLCHeRS

        • Falsifiable- can it, or has it been tested

        • Logical is the argument for or against reasonable, no logical errors

        • Comprehensiveness- is the evidence presented entirely exhausting? presents both success/failure

        • Honesty- no deception to self or others

        • Respectability- When tested or used as a treatment are the same results repeatable

        • Sufficiency- overwhelming evidence to support claim ( personal testimony is not admissible )

    • Multi-working Hypotheses

      • CT- FiLCHeRS

      • Def: cultivate many testable / plausible hypotheses- whatever survives disproof is more likely to be the right answer

      • comprehensiveness- consider all relevant evidence

      • ask: what evidence is available to support the claim ? is it reliable

    • Occam’s Razor

      • the idea that 1 should not make more assumptions than the minimum needed to explain something

        • Is often called the principle of parsimony

        • underlies ALL scientific theory building

        • keep it simple

          • William Occam- an English Franciscan friar/scholastic philosopher. He is considered to be 1 of the major figures of medieval thought in 14th century

    • Suffciency

      • the evidence for a claim must be sufficuient to establish truth ( soundness of claim )

      • 3 corollaries:

        • burden of proof is on the person making the claim. it’s not up to someone to disprove the claim; it’s up to the claimant to provide evidence

        • extraordinary claims requires extraordinary evidence - the more extraordinary or unusual the claim; the more evidence that is needed to support it.

        • Anecdotal evidence/ testimony are NEVER sufficeient to establish the truth of a claim

          • why ?

            • people cna mispercieve things and potientially lie

            • people can mispercieve what they experienced , they make mistakes

            • expertise is not guarantee against making mistakes

            • rules are related to suffiency and replicability are designed to reduce or eliminate error

            • expertise in 1 are does not qualify a person as an expert in another

        • expert - person with high degree of skill or knowledge derived from training and/or experience

          • academia = master’s degree to teach in that field

          • doctorate degree for faculty/tenure/research

          • criteria to consider when evaluating the reliability of an authority:

            • does the authority use the criticial thinking skills discussed in this course

            • have the proper credential

            • appropriate affiliations

            • financial stake in the claim being made? if so, be careful

            • has their work been subjected to peer review? is not, be suspicious

            • are arguments based on unsupported or untenable claims? does the authority offer sufficient evidence to evauluate his/her claim.

              • so in general it is best to accept conclusions of experts because:

                • they have more information about a topic

                • better judges of releveant information

                • there is good reason to doubt a claim if it conflicts with expert opinion

                • be aware opposing opinions on tv and radio are usually not balanced

                • the opinions of experts is superior to our own only in their areas of expertise