Process of Science
Forms of science
experimental science- use of experimentation to test hypotheses (scientific method )
Historical science - analysis of data sets or physical evidence of past events
epidemiological science- use of data ( usually for medical trials) in which a control group is unethical
Scientific Method
1. observe some aspect of universe
2. develop a tentative explanation for what has been observed called a hypothesis, that is consistent with observations
3.use hypothesis to make predictions
4. test those predictions by experiments or further observations and modify the hypothesis in light of your results
5. repeat steps ¾ until there are no discrepancies between hypothesis and experiment and/or observation
Hypothesis
a proposal intended to explain certain facts or observations that can be tested
can help answer “what if”
can also fail
Fact
somehting known to be true; something that can be shown to be true, to exist, or to have happened
Theory
A model of realit, or some aspect of realit, it is an explantion of phenomena and is supportedly by observational ( facts) and laws of nature and is logical
can answer why or how
Law
a descriptio of what occur;s law of gravity
can answer what
your inability to invalidate my hypothesis
4 premises of science
1. world is real
we don’t create physical reality and can’t change it by wishful thinking
the physical universe exist independently of our minds, whether we sense it or not.
2. it is possible for humans to understand physical universe
3. natural processes are sufficient to explain the natural world
4. knowledge is available to everyone
not based on subjective states of mind
science has..
a body of facts
a bunch of facts, divorced from any meaningful context is a bit like …
can’t see a meaningful pattern and can not see what is missing
a way of thinking
method of learning about natural world
organizes facts into meaningful pattern of information
science helps us make sense of world by seeing how facts are connected.
The nature of science: E.S.S.C.M.O
empiricism
goal? to gain greater understanding of reality
method? to make systematic observations
what do they observe ?
def: its that knowledge is based on sensory experience; it must be observable or measurable (e.g. experiements, studies, systematic observations) foundation
contrasts with pure logic and gut feelings
does NOT study pehnomena that cannot be observed and/or controlled- there is no way to test them
supernatural: gods, spirtual beings or miracles
cannot study a religion and decide if it is true or not (in a science class)
Faith= belief in absence of empirical evidence
different domains: Non-overlapping Magisteria (NOMA)
stephen J Gould- evoltionary biologist
Magisterium- refers to different domains of human experience/ thoughts
what the universe is made of (fact) and why it works a certain way (theory)
Magisterium of religion deals with questions of ultimate meaning/ moral value
according to gould, these 2 magisteria do not overlap, nor does each itself, encompasses all inquiry
Skepticism
scientists are skeptic
skepticism: a form of critical thinking that uses reason/ evidence to determine the likelihood that something is true
scientist combine skepticism with the scientific method to try to better understand the world
DOES NOT MEAN
nothing can be known, science specifically attempts to learn things
scientist are close minded, new evidence can refute any previous conclusion
Are you a scientific skeptic
do you believe every ad you see ?
do you believe everything you read ?
do you automatically trust everything a car dealer says to you ?
do you buy into the latest weight loss/ health trend ?
We are ALL skeptics - ability to analyze claims by:
improves ability to think critically / scientifically (scientific reasoning )
teach you basic facts from several different disciplines of science which you can use to make informed decisions
Why are both necessary:
reason something well, but do not the facts=wrong answer
and if,
know facts , but cant reason with them/ organize them in a meaningful way=wrong answer
Critical thinking+ facts = better chance of making correct decisions; improves quality of our lives
Self- correcting
so why does science work so well ?
empirical- not wishful thinking and irritational thoughts
objective/ repeatable= testable
personality/ persuasiveness are irrelevant
method is universal
self correcting : elimination of wrong ideas= progress
Critical Thinking
the process of evaluating validity and soundness of claims basis of well-supported evidence
FiLCHeRS
Falsifiable- can it, or has it been tested
Logical is the argument for or against reasonable, no logical errors
Comprehensiveness- is the evidence presented entirely exhausting? presents both success/failure
Honesty- no deception to self or others
Respectability- When tested or used as a treatment are the same results repeatable
Sufficiency- overwhelming evidence to support claim ( personal testimony is not admissible )
Multi-working Hypotheses
CT- FiLCHeRS
Def: cultivate many testable / plausible hypotheses- whatever survives disproof is more likely to be the right answer
comprehensiveness- consider all relevant evidence
ask: what evidence is available to support the claim ? is it reliable
Occam’s Razor
the idea that 1 should not make more assumptions than the minimum needed to explain something
Is often called the principle of parsimony
underlies ALL scientific theory building
keep it simple
William Occam- an English Franciscan friar/scholastic philosopher. He is considered to be 1 of the major figures of medieval thought in 14th century
Suffciency
the evidence for a claim must be sufficuient to establish truth ( soundness of claim )
3 corollaries:
burden of proof is on the person making the claim. it’s not up to someone to disprove the claim; it’s up to the claimant to provide evidence
extraordinary claims requires extraordinary evidence - the more extraordinary or unusual the claim; the more evidence that is needed to support it.
Anecdotal evidence/ testimony are NEVER sufficeient to establish the truth of a claim
why ?
people cna mispercieve things and potientially lie
people can mispercieve what they experienced , they make mistakes
expertise is not guarantee against making mistakes
rules are related to suffiency and replicability are designed to reduce or eliminate error
expertise in 1 are does not qualify a person as an expert in another
expert - person with high degree of skill or knowledge derived from training and/or experience
academia = master’s degree to teach in that field
doctorate degree for faculty/tenure/research
criteria to consider when evaluating the reliability of an authority:
does the authority use the criticial thinking skills discussed in this course
have the proper credential
appropriate affiliations
financial stake in the claim being made? if so, be careful
has their work been subjected to peer review? is not, be suspicious
are arguments based on unsupported or untenable claims? does the authority offer sufficient evidence to evauluate his/her claim.
so in general it is best to accept conclusions of experts because:
they have more information about a topic
better judges of releveant information
there is good reason to doubt a claim if it conflicts with expert opinion
be aware opposing opinions on tv and radio are usually not balanced
the opinions of experts is superior to our own only in their areas of expertise