Public Policy Study Guide
HAP 334: Public Policy and Healthcare
Topics to Study for Exam 1
67 QUESTIONS, MC, FIB, T&F, MATCHING (150 POINTS OVERALL)
The four major challenges facing healthcare and, therefore, health policymakers
1. Access and equity
Ensuring everyone can obtain affordable, timely, and high quality healthcare
Challenges include unequal access based on income, geography, race/ethnicity, insurance status, and other social factors
2. Rising costs and financial sustainability
Healthcare spending continues to place pressure on governments, insurers, employers, and individuals
Policy makers must balance controlling costs with maintaining quality and encouraging medical innovation
3. Quality, safety, and effectiveness of care
Healthcare systems must ensure that care is safe, evidence-based, coordinated, and produces good outcomes
Issues include medical errors, variations in quality, unnecessary treatments, and difficulty measuring outcomes
4. Changing health needs and healthcare workforce
Aging populations, chronic diseases, emerging infectious diseases, technological change, and changing patient expectations are increasing demands on healthcare systems
Definitions of health, policy, and health policy
Health: physical, mental, social wellbeing, not just the absence of disease
Policy: authoritative decisions made in government mean to direct/influence actions of others
Health policy: authoritative decisions regarding health or the pursuit of health made in legislative, executive, or judicial branches of government that are intended to direct or influence the actions, behaviors, or decisions of others
Different forms that policies may take and how those forms are related to the branches of government
Laws: legislative passes it then enacted
Rules/regulations: parameters of laws
Decisions: judicial, supreme court, rules/regulations in line
Programs: medicare, medicaid, elaborative processes and agencies
Categories of health determinants
Physical environment
Behavior and biology
Social factors
Health services
Relationship between health, health determinants, and health policy
Health policy → health determinants → health status
Indirect relationship because its not on the individual itself its on the environment
Impact health determinants:
Physical/social environment
Biology
Behavior
Health services
Policy makers impact health that change the health determinants to be better
Ideal conditions for economic markets and whether the U.S. healthcare market meets those conditions
1. Market: buyers and consumers, rehealm, of exchange, insurance, healthcare is a market
2. High levels of competition
3. Sufficient information to make decisions (supply and demand)
4. Buyers bare consequences directly for their purchases
Health insurance buffers you from your consequences
5. Low barriers: anyone can sell in markets
6. US health care doesn't work well as a market, policies exist to correct market deficiencies.
The relationship between economic markets and policy intervention
Healthcare is a market like no other market
Licensing laws (making it not a good market)
Policy exists to help with the healthcare market
Passing laws
An important role of policy is to aid markets like ours
Correct market deficiencies.
The basic models of healthcare systems and how the countries in “Sick Around the World” fit into these models.
Beverage: UK, public finance, public hospitals
Good preventive care, bonuses for chronic disease management
going to primary before specialists (gatekeeper)
highly centralized but lower administrative costs
financed through tax payments
private and public employes
Low costs per capita because the government (sole payer) controls what doctors do and what they charge
Bismark: Germany, Japan, France, Switzerland, private finance, private hospitals
Switzerland shows reform can happen
Standardizing prices is a primary need
Go through negotiations for 1 standard price
Payer negotiate together
Representing 100% of the market gives power
Japan= standardized prices through government, every 2 years they have a meeting to talk about the prices
Germany is the negotiation= both getting set prices
Sickness funds: insurance system financed by employers and employees through payroll reduction
Has to cover everyone who cant profit
Non-profit: they do not make money based off insurance
Doctors cannot be flexible about the value of their service because the prices are set
Not a single payer: sickness funds making it a multi payer system
NHI (National Health Insurance): Taiwan, South Korea, Canada, private hospitals, public finance
Very low administrative costs
One health insurance and no opting out (single payer)
Government is setting those costs
Same overall prices
Used private sector providers, but payment comes from a government run insurance program every citizen pays into (universal)
Controls costs by limiting the medical sources they will pay for or by making patients wait to be treated
Similar to medicare- one huge public insurance option that is still being paid for by the government
Tremendous power on payer side
Out of Pocket Model: no good examples
Experiencing healthcare like a 3rd world country
Rich get medical care while the poor stay sick or fie
People without insurance can pay bills out of pocket at the time of treatment or if still sick enough to be admitted as an emergency
Cost control mechanisms in the various healthcare models described in “Sick Around the World”
Beverage/UK
Gatekeepers system- do primary, preventive, basic care that is cheaper and valuable to keep costs down
No insurance company profit
Take taxes from citizens
NHI/Taiwan/Canada
Ration medical sources/machines- Canada and Japan
Make patients wait for services- Canada
smart card system to diminish administrative costs- Taiwan
Fixed price for everything- regulated by government- Japan
Short appointment times to see many patients
Bismark/Germany
Set prices, negotiation between hospital and sickness funds
Standardizing prices
Free medical school
Non profit
Very available services
Preventative care is cheap, so there is less expensive long term care
Common features of high-functioning healthcare systems (3 limits these systems have been willing/able to impose).
Insurance: Insurance must cover everyone and is nonprofit
Doctors: must have fixed prices, standardized
Patients: everyone has to buy insurance but the government will aid of necessary
Features that make the U.S. healthcare system distinct from other rich, free-market democracies.
Insurance is for profit (not common outside of the US)
Less willingness to allow government intervention in health care
Fragmentation: not a centralized one, very different strategies for achieving outcomes
The concept of universal healthcare and where it exists/doesn’t exist in the world
All people and all communities can get access without being scared of bankruptcy
Equity and health care serves
Care must be good, worth it
access , cost, quality
US doesn't have
Canada, Japan, UK, do
How each of the three big programs (Medicare, Medicaid, ACA) is financed and which levels of government (state, federal) are responsible for funding and implementing them
Medicare funded: payroll taxes and federal taxes
Medicaid funded: combination of state and federal
ACA funded: federal and state
half the costs are offset by projected savings in Medicare payments
Quarter is offset by added taxes on medical-device and pharmaceutical industry
Other major source is medicare payroll tax increases on those incomes, >$250k
Who is eligible for benefits of each program
Medicare: people over 65, people under 65 receiving social security disability income, people with end stage renal disease, people with ALS
Medicaid: low income
What the different Parts (A-D) of Medicare cover
Part A: inpatient coverage
hospital insurance (HI) program
Covers inpatient, home health, skilling nursing home in hospice
Part B: outpatient coverage
supplemental medical insurance (SMI)
Outpatient, physician visits
90% of beneficiaries have A + B
ER, ambulance, some home health, physicians visit, preventive care, outpatient
Part C: Medicare Advantage Program
Allows beneficiaries to enroll in private health maintenance organization (HMO) or preferred provider organization (PPO) plan, as an alternate to traditional medicare
Medicare pays these plans per beneficiary rate to cover hospital, outpatient, and usually prescription benefits
Introduces some competition between HMO’s
HMO’s offer some more then what medicare offers
Part D: drugs
Covers prescription drugs
Passed in 2003, implemented in 2006 (medicare modernization act)
Offered through private plans (medicare pays them)
Added this because, huge percentage of people health care market and technology have changed: HMO and PPO can cover vision, dental, other services medicare does not cover already
Cost sharing in each of the programs
Medicare
Beneficiaries pay pay premiums for parts B and D, deductibles for each part, and co-insurance payments for many services
Set premiums based off income
Ne premiums for part A
Medicaid
Beneficiaries pay a very small cost sharing for some
Medicare reforms initiated by the ACA
Can’t screen people out due to health risks
Took away individual mandate: receive a fine if you don't have health insurance
Plans need to cover the 10 essential benefits
Can stay on parents insurance til 25
Reductions in payment to medicare advantage (part c) plans
Reduction in payments to hospitals and providers (ex. Bundle payments)
Promote integrated models of care, such as accountable care organizations (ACO’s) to coordinate care for high need beneficiaries
Pay out performance programs (ex. Hospital readmission standards), better quality means more money
Key mechanism is incentivising value based care: using provider side incentives to reduce costs by boosting quality
Prospective payment system
Payer (medicare or insurance) decided what services are worth and should cost
The purpose of CHIP and how it relates to Medicaid
Children who make too much for medicaid but may lack affordable private insurance
Moderate income
Crowd-out: public insurance replaces private coverage
Federal state partnership
Most states cover children under 200%
How does the ACA represent an attempt at “comprehensive” healthcare reform?
1. Increase access to health insurance coverage
2. Control health care costs
3. Manage workforce needs
4. Direct resources toward population health and prevention (healthcare disparities)
Medicaid expansion under the ACA—including the story of Medicaid expansion in NE
ACA law required states to expand medicaid benefits to eligible adults less than 133% federal poverty level (FPL)
Helps people who are single and poor (with no dependant children)
Essentially makes it a blanket umbrella: if you meet the income threshold you are eligible for medicaid
Major problem they're trying to solve is access
The other thing the ACA does to help access is establish insurance market places
Market places make a pool of customers, same companies that give private health ace insurance to employers
Self employed people benefit off this, people who need help paying the premium
Young single people: incentivised
People with pre-existing conditions: they aren't getting screen meaning they are more likely to get accepted and get a good plan
Federal gov. Covered 100% of the cost initially and phased down to 90% by 2020
Supreme court ruling: must give states the option to expand medicaid (cannot withhold medicaid funding from states that don't expand)
In NE
2011-2017, failed attempts to expand through legislature
2018, expansion passed, 94k new beneficiaries
Signatures force it onto a ballot (fails through legislature)
2019 NE department of health and human services (DHHS) submitted a proposal/waiver to center for medicare and medicaid (CMS) for two tiered plan (ex. rules) including work requirements
Pushbacks by groups who supported the expansion initiative, but CMS approved it
Implemented October 2020
Specific ways that the ACA reformed health insurance cover
employer -based plan for medicaid or medicare
Those not covered could buy an individual plan on the private insurance market
prohibiting discrimination based on preexisting conditions, establishing essential health benefits, and expanding public and private coverage access
The purpose and features of the ACA individual health insurance marketplaces
How ACA tried to solve problems
Establish insurance marketplaces (essentially websites) to make it easier to find an acceptable plan (bronze, gold, silver, platinum)
These marketplaces create a new pool of consumers (increase demand) which gives incentives for insurers to offer competitive plans
Plans must cover “essential benefits” (ADD MORE)
No more screening bases on pre existing conditions, insurance must set rates based only on age, location, tobacco use
Help low and middle income families with subsidies
Requires everyone to get insurance in order to compensate for more sick people in the risk pool
Roles of the three branches of government in policymaking, and how these relate to different forms of “policy” (i.e., be able to connect chapter 2 back to the content in chapter 1).
Legislative:
Make new laws and modify existing law
Establish budget, levy taxes, borrow money
Executive:
enforce /implement the law
Department of health and human services (DHHS)
RFK jr
Judicial:
Interpret law
All make policies: laws, rules, regulations, its not ONLY laws
Major agencies associated with health policymaking at the federal level
NIH→ health related research
FDA→ food and drug administration
CDC→ center for disease control
AMA→ american medical association
CMS→ center for medicare and medicaid
The concept of federalism; and why federalism can create differences in healthcare and health outcomes across states.
Federalism: shared responsibility between multiple layers of gov.
Responsibility is shared between the federal and state governments and to a lesser degree, the local government
Big idea: sharded task
Different responsibilities of federal, state, and local government in health policymaking
Federal; Medicare, some extend Medicaid (paying for half), CDC, research, EPA, etc.
State: Medicaid, licensing/accreditation, safety net, health insurance
Local: STD screenings, immunizations, community organizing
The logic of the “Policymaking Market”
market = realm of exchange
Commodity: health policy, policy policy change, policy to state the same
Health policies are authoritative decisions
specifically: health policy that satisfy a particular groups preferences
In exchange people are giving:money, favors, information, votes, power, connections
The commodity, demanders, and suppliers in the policymaking market
Commodity: health policy, policy policy change, policy to state the same
Demanders: buyers
Individual/group who seek policies in pursuit of their own health or health of others
Individual groups who see policies as means to some other end (economic gain, competitive advantage)
Examples: employers, hospitals, AARP, pharma groups, interest groups, diabetes association, investors, AHA, professions (doctors)
Supplies: sellers, supplying the commodity (different for different people)
Branches of gov:
Legislative: making laws
Want money, support of their agenda, things they try to accomplish, results for people and self, public opinion
Motivated by pride
Executive: president/governor
Career bureaucrats→ high level people
Want re-election, money, policy wins, public opinion, funding (playing both sides so they can get money)
Judicial: judges that are appointed
Alignment with parties they support and ideology
Less motivated by what the other 2 branches want, simply put they should just judge
The four theoretical approaches that address the question of who has power in policymaking
Majoritarian Electoral Democracy
Who rules: ordinary/average people
Downs and his Median Voter Theorem
Try to capture vote in the middle
What most ordinary people want should influence policy
Assumption: people will be more middle grounded, people are educated on topics
Singales what voters opinions are
Economic Elite Domination
Who rules: wealthy people
Assumptions of why wealthy people have influence: influence the non wealthy to follow them, connections, financing, money
Money directly influences: lobbying (being in the ear of the policy maker themself)
Suppliers tend to come from the wealthy class (culturally similar)
Perspective on interest groups: people/organized groups trying to influence policy, pluralist: distributed power (spread out), James Maddison→ no factions → no interest groups, meaning lots of interest groups with competition
Majoritarian Pluralism (Pluralist view)
Who rules: mass based interest groups, like AARP, interest of all people
Competing
Ordinary citizens views are expressed through interest groups
David Truman:
Politicians need to respond to potential interest groups not just the ones straight in front of them
Collective action
Objection: unlikely for potential groups to organize so we’ll listen to who’s barking the loudest
Biased Pluralism (Elitist View)
Who rules: businesses, corporations
More organized
More resources
Unified in preferences on big issues
Hospital systems, insurance industries, nurses, doctors, etc.
Understand the major findings of Gilens and Page, what they mean, and the implications for policymaking (i.e., what do they tell us about who has power at various stages in the policymaking process).
The puzzle is who has influence: who governs? Who rules, specifically over policy change?
The research question is: Do the preferences of different sets of actors influence the likelihood of congress adopting new policies?
How do they test this hypothesis? (the independent variable)
1,800 different survey about policy issues: each of them are a case/unit for their research
Majoritarian electoral democracy: preferences of people in the middle selection, 50%
Economic elite domination: preferences of people in the top 10%
Majoritarian pluralism: 25 powerful groups and industries, 1800 surveys websites, anything they could get their hands on
Policy change (federal law changes) → dependant variable
Major findings: ordinary people don't have a significant impact, business interest groups have 2 times the amount of influence
Ordinary citizen preferences and wealthy citizens preferences do correlate, overlap allowing ordinary people to get their stuff put on the agenda
When they diverge wealthy people will still get their way
Biased pluralism has the pull
Pluralist vs. elitists view of interest groups
Key tenant on Pluralist Interest Groups:
Interest groups concentrate resources of individuals
They provide constitutes with more opportunity to participate in market because of links
They compete with counter balancing interests
Assumes fair competition
Similar to medicare (insurance companies compete for clients)
Key tenants on elitist interest groups
Huge differences
Near consensus on private property, individual rights, basics on policy
Incremental change
Assumes protection of power
They push back on pluralist because power needs to be taken into account
The three “faces” (or dimensions) of power, and how these apply to the policymaking model discussed in the textbook.
1. Ability to win in a head to head conflict.
A has power over B by prevailing in a key issue
2. The exclusion the people/issues all together
A has power over B by not letting B be heard
Interest groups are very good at this
3. Ability to shape wants/desires of others.
A has power over B by changing B’s opinion to align with mine
Realm of ideology and myths (they'll tell you this is aimed towards what you want! Even if its not)
The theory of punctuated equilibrium
In the politics you have long periods of sameness but punctuated
political systems experience long periods of stability with minor adjustments, interrupted by brief moments of major, rapid change
Usually there's not much radical change in policy
Sudden change could consist of: whenever the conditions are right they'll get put on the agenda (WINDOW OF OPPORTUNITY)
ACA, medicare, medicaid
Factors that are part of the external environment
formulation, implementation, and modification are done in an external environment
Interest groups: effect all stages
Geopolitical: our relationship w/ other countries
Current events: mass school shootings, wild fires, immigration
Demographics: age
States: Roe v. Wade
Technology: AI, availability of data
The three variables and the basic logic of the “Window of opportunity” concept, and how this helps us understand the agenda setting step of policymaking
1. Problems: nearly limitless number of problems to be solved
Classical theoretical model: Price 1978
Combination of salience and conflict determines the likelihood of legislative activity on a given issue
Reasons problems rise attention of policy makers
Problems reach unacceptable level
Widespread nature (medicare)
Sharp focus on small but powerful group that is directly affected
2. Potential solutions
These come from research and policies found in other places
policies found in other places: political strategy
Research: 2nd hand smoke = smoking age raised
Problem solution sets
Application to HPV with bills and laws
3. Political Circumstances
Political means: external interest groups, political power, relevance, public attitudes, opinions, how people act if interested in problem or how its addressed
The salience-conflict approach to understanding agenda-setting
Importance, prevalence at the time
SALIENCE + CONFLICT
High salience and little conflict is whats get put on the agenda
HPV is low salience but high conflict
The mechanisms that allow interest groups to exert disproportionate influence on the agenda setting state (e.g., unity, concentrated interests, greater supply of resources, etc.)
Unity:
makes it easier for policy makers to know preference
Diffuse v. concentrated interests:
more motivated/incentive to be involved, interest groups
Greater supply of various resources:
organizations, connections, political knowledge (negotiation), infrastructure, motivated resources intangible (status)
The different tactics interest groups use to influence policymaking
Lobbying:
Communicating with policy makers, direct influence
Electioning:
If you can get people in office who are on your side, you do less lobbying
Mobilizing voters: influence of church about abortion
Litigation:
Challenge existing policy
Lawsuit
Shaping public opinion:
George Bush with the AMA and telling spouses about the ACA
The role of the chief executive/President in agenda setting
Disproportionate influence on agenda setting
President: left v. right, command resources for visibility, shape agenda for full party
Similar with governor
The logic of the “social construction of social problems” perspective
Definition: the actual nature of the problem isn't sufficient to trigger anything, it is the claims that make it heard
What's actually happening and whether or not the truth is being heard
The actual reality of climate change
Helps us to see that in order for something to get on the agenda it truly has to be defined as an issue
What is puzzling about U.S. inaction on climate change in the late 1990s?
Significant
Policy about climate change comes to the font, people see it, but they retract
McCright and Dunlap’s argument about why the US failed to pass legislation related to climate change in the late 1990s (especially the role of framing, mobilizing structures, and political opportunity)
Framing:
1. Climate evidence: weak/uncertain
2. Warming could have benefits
3. Climate policies could do more harm than good
Sometimes strikes a cord and other times it doesn’t
Ex: mandated vaccines= government controlling health
Not persuasive till 2016 in california when they had strictest mandates
Persuasive v. unpersasive
Mobilizing structures:
Generally: organizational resources, get ideas and frames pushed out to the public
Think tanks have agenda (the organizational resources):
Skeptics v. experts
Ability to get skeptics to express findings
TV, Radio, connections (know elected officials), public events
Want to increase visibility of skeptics so their POV is heard and it creates uncertainty
Raise fear about economies to decrease fear about climate change
1994: Party control shifts (political opportunity)
General shift towards rightward ideas (political opportunity)
37 different hearings focussed on climate change
287 testimonies from experts
News articles, counting frequency of skeptics vs. scientists
Key outcome here: prominence or visibility of climate skeptics in those 2 spheres
Political opportunity:
Congressional hearings
Committees: controlling party decides committee chairman
Republicans get to make decisions → allowing think tanks to have big influence
Easy → political opportunity because republicans have majority of house, they're going to invite people to testify that agree with them
Creates more visibility creating success
Media balancing:
Equal time to debate
Makes one side more credible because one side is still invited
This teaches us:
1. Powerful interest groups can mobilize
2. Shifts in holding political power
3. Broad cultural shifts allow certain claims to resonate even if they’ve fallen short before
4. Not always tied to social problem