CAPE CHEMISTRY: Difference Between Reactivity Series And Electrochemical Series

Overview of Metal Reactivity and Reductant Strength

Metals generally react by losing electrons to form positive ions. The ease with which a metal loses its electrons determines both its chemical reactivity and its strength as a reductant:

  • The more readily a metal loses electrons, the more reactive it is.

  • A greater tendency to lose electrons corresponds to a greater strength as a reductant.

  • Metals placed higher in a series can reduce the ions of metals positioned lower down.

Basis of Comparison: Solid-State vs. Aqueous Conditions

Both the reactivity series and standard electrode potentials (EoE^o) measure the reducing ability of metals, but they are evaluated r diffeunderent physical conditions:

  • Standard Electrode Potential (EoE^o): Indicates a metal's strength as a reductant. A more negative EoE^o value signifies a stronger reductant.

  • Reactivity Series: Based on observing a range of general reactions, such as displacement reactions between solid metals and solid metal oxides.

  • Electrochemical Series: Ranks metals according to their standard electrode potentials (EoE^o) specifically in aqueous solution.

Because the reactivity series reflects solid-state and direct observation reactions, while standard electrode potentials (EoE^o) refer specifically to aqueous solutions, discrepancies arise between the order of metals in the two series.

Anomaly Between Sodium and Calcium

A notable discrepancy between the reactivity series and the electrochemical series occurs with sodium (NaNa) and calcium (CaCa):

  • Based on standard electrode potential (EoE^o) values in aqueous solution, calcium (CaCa) is a stronger reductant than sodium (NaNa).

  • However, the metal reactivity series indicates that calcium (CaCa) is less reactive than sodium (NaNa).

  • Cause of Discrepancy: Calcium (CaCa) reacts at a significantly slower rate in displacement reactions because two electrons must be removed from calcium (CaCa), whereas only one electron must be removed from sodium (NaNa).

Passivation and the Behavior of Aluminium

Aluminium (AlAl) displays anomalous chemical behavior due to surface oxidation:

  • Aluminium (AlAl) reacts readily with oxygen in the air, forming a layer of stable aluminium oxide on its surface.

  • This impervious oxide coat protects the underlying metal.

  • As a result, the oxide layer often causes aluminium (AlAl) to exhibit lower reactivity than its true position in the metal reactivity series indicates.