Dispute Resolution and Crisis Management Study Guide

Conceptual Foundations of Dispute Resolution and Conflict Management

  • Definition of Dispute Resolution: It is conceptualized as the methods and processes involved in facilitating the peaceful ending of conflict and retribution. The term conflict resolution may also be used interchangeably with Dispute Resolution.

  • Behavioral Dimensions in Conflict: In conflict situations, an individual’s behavior can be described along two primary dimensions:     * Assertiveness: The extent to which the person attempts to satisfy his own concerns.     * Cooperativeness: The extent to which the person attempts to satisfy the other person’s concerns.

  • Conflict Resolution Strategies:     * Avoiding: This strategy is unassertive and uncooperative. The person neither pursues his own concerns nor those of the other individual.     * Competing: This is assertive and uncooperative. An individual pursues his own concerns at the other person’s expense. Competing means ’standing up for your rights.’     * Accommodating: This is unassertive and cooperative, representing the complete opposite of competing. The individual neglects his own concerns to satisfy the concerns of the other person, involving an element of self-sacrifice.     * Collaborating: This is both assertive and cooperative, being the complete opposite of avoiding. It involves an attempt to work with others to find a solution that fully satisfies the concerns of all parties.     * Compromising: This is moderate in both assertiveness and cooperativeness. The objective is to find some expedient, mutually acceptable solution that partially satisfies both parties.

Legal Framework of Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) in the Philippines

  • Republic Act No. 9285: Known as the ’Alternative Dispute Resolution Act of 2004.’

  • Definition of Alternative Dispute Resolution System: Any process or procedure used to resolve a dispute or controversy, other than by adjudication of a presiding judge of a court or an officer of a government agency (as defined under RA 9285), in which a neutral third party participates to assist in the resolution of issues. This includes arbitration, mediation, conciliation, early neutral evaluation, mini-trial, or any combination thereof (Sec. 3, par. a, RA 9285).

  • State Policy on ADR: Enacted on 2 April 2004, the law embodies the pro-ADR policy of the State to ’actively promote party autonomy in the resolution of disputes or the freedom of the party to make their own arrangements to resolve their disputes.’

  • Office for Alternative Dispute Resolution (OADR):     * Mandate: To promote, develop, and expand the use of ADR in private and public sectors; monitor, study, and evaluate ADR use; and recommend statutory improvements to Congress to align ADR practices with global standards.     * Composition of the Advisory Council: Created under Department Circular No. 98 (s. 2009), the council is composed of representatives from:         1. Mediation profession         2. Arbitration profession         3. ADR organizations         4. Integrated Bar of the Philippines (IBP)         5. Academe     * Appointment: Members are appointed by the Secretary of Justice.

  • Importance of ADR:     * Cheaper than litigation.     * Resolution is faster.     * Offers greater involvement of both parties.     * Confidentiality of the process.

  • Exceptions to the Application of RA 9285:     * Labor disputes (covered by Presidential Decree No. 442, Labor Code of the Philippines).     * Civil status of persons.     * Validity of a marriage.     * Any ground for legal separation.     * Jurisdiction of courts.     * Future legitime.     * Criminal liability.     * Disputes which by law cannot be compromised.

Principal Modes of Alternative Dispute Resolution

  • Negotiation:     * Almost always attempted first to resolve a dispute.     * Allows parties to meet to settle a dispute.     * Main Advantage: Allows parties themselves to control the process and the solution.     * Flexibility: Much less formal than other ADR types.     * Decision is made entirely by the parties through verbal interaction on their own terms.

  • Mediation:     * Definition: A voluntary process in which a mediator, selected by the disputing parties, facilitates communication and negotiation and assists parties in reaching a voluntary agreement (Sec. 3, par. q, RA 9285).     * Mediator: A person who conducts mediation (Sec. 3, par. r, RA 9285).     * Mediation Party: A person whose consent is necessary to resolve the dispute (Sec. 3, par. s, RA 9285).     * Role of Mediator: Helps parties come to their own consensus; works with both sides to explore interests. The role involves asking questions rather than suggesting solutions.     * Right to Select: Parties have the freedom to select a mediator and can request a roster from the OADR.     * Qualifications: As a rule, RA 9285 does not require special qualifications by background or profession unless required by the mediation agreement (Sec. 13).     * Waiver of Participation: A party may waive the right to participate or designate a lawyer. A waiver of legal representation must be made in writing and can be rescinded (revoked) at any time (Sec. 14).     * Stages of Mediation:         1. Opening statement of the mediator         2. Individual narration by parties         3. Exchange by parties         4. Summary of issues         5. Generation and evaluation of options         6. Closure (concluded by execution of settlement, withdrawal of a party, or written declaration by the mediator).     * Confidentiality: All information obtained is privileged and confidential. Exceptions include:         1. Agreement authenticated by all parties.         2. Information available to the public or in an open session.         3. Threat of bodily injury or crime of violence.         4. Information used to plan or commit a crime.         5. Evidence for professional misconduct/malpractice claims against the mediator or parties.

  • Conciliation:     * A voluntary, flexible, confidential, and interest-based process.     * The neutral third party is the Conciliator.     * The Conciliator gives advice or suggests solutions but has no authority to enforce the resolution.     * Used for disputes on contracts, legal relationships (custody), and pecuniary liability.

  • Arbitration:     * Definition: A voluntary process where one or more arbitrators, appointed per agreement or RA 9285 rules, resolve a dispute by rendering an award.     * Award: Any partial or final decision by an arbitrator.     * Arbitral Tribunal: Refers to a sole arbitrator or a panel/board/committee of arbitrators.     * Appointing Authority: Person or institution named in the agreement. In ad hoc arbitration, the default appointment is made by the National President of the IBP.     * Ad Hoc Arbitration: Administered by the arbitrator and/or parties themselves rather than a permanent institution.     * Decisions: In a panel, decisions are made by majority. Questions of procedure may be decided by the presiding arbitrator if authorized.     * Rules of Evidence: The rules of evidence under Criminal Law are applicable.     * Place of Arbitration: Free for parties to agree; if not specified, it is Metro Manila unless the tribunal decides otherwise for convenience.     * Default of a Party:         * If claimant fails to communicate claim: proceedings are terminated.         * If respondent fails to communicate defense: proceedings continue without treating it as an admission.         * Failure to appear: Award is made based on evidence before the tribunal.

Court-Related and Special ADR Forms

  • Judicial Dispute Resolution (JDR): A process where a judge employs conciliation, mediation, or early neutral evaluation at the pre-trial stage. If JDR fails, a different judge (trial judge) hears the case.

  • Early Neutral Evaluation: Parties and lawyers receive a non-binding assessment from an experienced neutral person with expertise in the subject matter.

  • Mini-Trial: Merits of a case are argued before a panel of senior decision-makers (with or without a neutral third person) to seek a negotiated settlement.

  • Mediation-Arbitration (Med-Arb): A two-step process (mediation then arbitration). A person who acted as mediator cannot act as arbitrator in the same dispute unless expressly authorized in writing by the parties.

  • Court-Annexed Mediation (CAM): Mediation conducted under the umbrella of the court after it has acquired jurisdiction. It is mandatory for most civil cases, including:     * Ordinary civil cases and counterclaims (except those in Art. 2035 of New Civil Code).     * Special civil actions (except Rules 63, 64, 65, 66, and 71).     * Settlement of estates.     * Family Code issues (support, custody, property).     * Intellectual property and commercial/environmental cases.

  • CAM Process: Parties are referred after pre-trial; must be completed within 3030 calendar days. If settlement is reached, the judge evaluates and approves/disapproves.

  • JDR Procedures: Conducted within a non-extendible 1515 calendar days. The JDR judge acts as mediator/conciliator/neutral evaluator.

  • Sanctions for Non-Appearance in CAM/JDR:     * Dismissal of the case (if plaintiff fails to appear).     * Ex parte presentation of evidence and dismissal of counterclaim (if defendant fails to appear).

Katarungang Pambarangay (Barangay Justice System)

  • Legal Basis: PD 1508 (1978) was the first KP law; currently under Local Government Code (Sec. 399 - 422).

  • Father of Katarungan Pambarangay: Alfredo Flores Tadiar.

  • Lupon Tagapamayapa: The body tasked to administer KP.     * Composition: Barangay Captain (Chairman), Barangay Secretary (Lupon Secretary), and 1010 to 2020 members.

  • Pangkat ng Tagapagkasundo: A conciliation panel of 33 members chosen from the Lupon by the parties. If they cannot agree, members are chosen by drawing lots.

  • Jurisdiction Exclusions: Lupon has no authority over:     * Criminal cases with imprisonment > 11 year or fine > 5,000–extpesos5,000 – ext{pesos}.     * Cases involving government entities or public officers in official functions.     * Parties in different cities/municipalities (unless adjoining and they agree).     * Offenses with no private offended party.     * Real property in different cities/municipalities.

  • Venue:     * Same barangay: Before that Lupon.     * Different barangay/same municipality: In the respondent's barangay.     * Real property: Where the property is located.     * Workplace: Where the work involves the parties.

  • Mediation Procedure:     * Complaint filed with Barangay Secretary and fee paid.     * Summons issued within 33 days.     * Mediation lasts for 1515 days.     * If no settlement: Case proceeds to conciliation (Pangkat).

  • Conciliation Procedure:     * Pangkat meets to find settlement within 1515 days (extendible by another 1515).     * Successful settlement: Put in writing; becomes final after 1010 days.     * Repudiation: Settlement can be challenged within 1010 days for fraud, violence, or intimidation.

  • Arbitration in KP: Parties agree in writing to abide by the award. Decision is handed down within 1515 days (but not earlier than 66) after the last hearing.

  • Execution of Settlement: Enforced by the Lupon within 66 months. After 66 months, it must be enforced via motion in the Municipal Trial Court.

Crisis and Emergency Management

  • Definitions:     * Emergency: A sudden condition or state of affairs calling for immediate action.     * Crisis: An unstable and dangerous social condition characterized by an impending disruption in society (economic, military, political, police, personal) approaching emergency level.     * Crisis Management: Actions undertaken to unify/coordinate resources to control a criminal/life-threatening situation; expert handling to reduce danger.

  • Crisis Management Committee (CMC): Established at all levels (human-induced crisis). Local CMC is headed by the local chief executive as Responsible Officer (RO), who designates the Incident Commander (IC).

  • Responsibility Division:     * Human-Induced (Man-made): Responsibility of the National and Local Peace and Order Council (NPOC).     * Natural Calamities/Disasters: Responsibility of the National and Local Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Council (NDRRMC).

  • PNP Role: Organizes its own Critical Incident Management Committee (CIMC) and task groups:     * Critical Incident Management Task Group (CIMTG): For man-made incidents.     * Disaster Incident Management Task Group (DIMTG): For natural disasters.

  • Incident Command System (ICS): Template for response. Six major functional areas: Command, Operations, Planning, Logistics, Finance, Administration, and Intelligence/Investigation (Intelligence/Investigation is established on a case-to-case basis).

  • Disaster Management Stages:     * Pre-Disaster Stage: Pro-active assessment, risk mapping, drills, capability audit (55 Ms: Man-power, Machines, Materials, Money, Methods), and awareness campaigns.     * Disaster Response Stage: Activation of CIMTG/DIMTG, pre-emptive evacuation, search and rescue.     * Post-Disaster Stage: Support to recovery, Rapid Damage Assessment and Needs Analysis (RDANA) reports, relief operations, deactivation of task groups.

  • Victim Identification (MDM):     * PNP Crime Lab (CL): Lead in identifying remains during human-induced disasters.     * NBI: Lead in identifying remains during natural calamities.

  • PNP Alert Levels (Man-Made):     * Level 1 (Low): No specific threat info.     * Level 2 (Moderate): Incident possible but not likely.     * Level 3 (High): Strong possibility within a short time.     * Level 4 (Extreme): Incident just occurred, preempted, or expected.

  • Phases of Crisis Management (The 5 Ps):     1. Predict: Horizon scanning and strategic forecasting to identify threats.     2. Prevent: Deliberate action to avoid future harm; operational prevention includes "target hardening."     3. Prepare: Essential for response. Includes Plan, Organize, Train, Equip, Exercise, and Evaluate/Improve.     4. Perform: Actual implementation of contingency plans (Reactive Phase).     5. Post-Action and Assessment: Returning to business as usual after the situation is clear.

Hostage Situation and Operational Procedures

  • Definition: People held against their will by force/coercion with demands being made.

  • Characteristics of Negotiable Incidents:     1. The hostage taker must have a need to live.     2. There must be a threat of force by authorities.     3. There must be demands by the hostage taker.     4. The negotiator must be seen as someone who can hurt the hostage taker but is willing to help.

  • Negotiation Priorities: Preserve lives, apprehend captors, recover/protect property.

  • Key Responders:     * First Responders (FR): Secure scene, establish perimeter, update TOC, reroute traffic, establish Advanced Command Post (ACP).     * Incident Commander (IC): Senior rank/experienced; prepares plans (Emergency Response, Breakout, Delivery, Surrender, Release, Collection). The IC designates the spokesperson; if none, the IC/Ground Commander speaks to the media.     * Hostage Negotiation Team (HNT): Includes Team Leader, Primary Negotiator, Secondary Negotiator (support/intel), Intelligence Officer, Scribe (documentation), and Logistics/Communication.

  • Tactical assault: Resorting to force if the hostage-taker poses imminent danger or peaceful means fail.

  • Cardinal Rule: The Hostage Negotiator does not command; the Incident Commander should not negotiate.

  • Stages of Hostage Situation:     1. Alarm: Most traumatic and dangerous stage.     2. Crisis: Hostage takers consolidate positions; hostages experience isolation/claustrophobia.     3. Accommodation: Longest and most tranquil stage; Stockholm syndrome likely to occur.     4. Resolution: Fatigue sets in; tension decreases; intervention techniques increase.

  • I-C-E-R Methods:     * Isolate: Keep onlookers beyond the safety line.     * Contain: Restrict HT mobility to the smallest location; begins in the inner perimeter.     * Evaluate: Gather cursory information and confirm circumstances.     * Report: Identify all circumstances and inform responding officers.

Questions & Discussion

  • Q: How many members are in the OADR Advisory Council?     * A: Reps from Mediation, Arbitration, ADR organizations, IBP, and Academe (Total: 55 positions listed).

  • Q: What is the ADR principle regarding options over methods and third parties?     * A: Party Autonomy.

  • Q: Who is authorized to speak to the media if no spokesperson is designated?     * A: Incident Commander or Ground Commander.

  • Q: Which agency identifies victims in natural calamities?     * A: NBI.

  • Q: What are the stages of hostage situations in order?     * A: Alarm, Crisis, Accommodation, Resolution.

  • Q: What happens if a complainant fails to appear in a Lupon mediation?     * A: The complaint is dismissed and the party is barred from filing in court.

  • Q: What is the prompt procedure upon receipt of a bomb threat?     * A: Treat all threats as serious, determine location, conduct visual search, alert EODT/K9, and provide security.

  • Q: What is the term for a non-binding assessment by an expert in pre-trial?     * A: Early Neutral Evaluation.