Exhaustive Study Notes on the Founding, Constitutional Convention, and Ratification Debates
Administrative Roster and Course Logistics
Class Roster Updates:
- May Harrington is no longer enrolled in the course.
- Enrolled students acknowledged: Jacob Barnwell, Gabriel Booze, Zander Cooper, Ainsley Doris, Phoebe Edgerton Kufaul, Zachary Wyasdowski, Geneva Halter, Evan Harrison, Kaitlyn Hansley, Damian Horton, Justice Watson (noted as being from a "good Watson state"), and Samantha Voss ().
Classroom Technology Policy:
- Laptops and computers are not permitted for general use during class unless explicit permission has been requested and granted.
- Students are forbidden from using electronic devices to shop, browse the web, or read non-course materials.
- Using mobile phones or smartwatches during instruction is strictly prohibited due to their potential to distract.
- Students must submit signed policy paperwork; pending paperwork must be handed in immediately as over a week has passed since the deadline.
Philosophical Foundations and the Three-Fifths Compromise
Epistemological Distinctions:
- Normative Statements: Evaluative statements grounded in values, morals, or judgments regarding how things ought to be.
- Empirical Statements: Descriptive, factual statements based on observation, evidence, and objective measurement.
- Enlightenment Values: Core principles centered on human reason, progress, improvement, and the systemic evaluation of political structures.
The Three-Fifths () Compromise:
- Historical Context: Debated and adopted during the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia.
- Electoral Impact: Inflated the voting power and representation of Southern slaveholding states in both the House of Representatives and the Electoral College.
- Electoral Outcomes:
- In the presidential election of , Thomas Jefferson lost narrowly to John Adams.
- In the presidential election of , Thomas Jefferson defeated John Adams directly as a result of the extra electoral votes allocated to Southern states through the compromise.
- Political Consequences: The compromise granted Southern states disproportionate national power for generations.
- Pragmatic Dilemma: Delegates faced a choice between rejecting the compromise—which would have caused the convention to collapse and left the nation under the Articles of Confederation—or accepting an immoral provision to secure a unified national constitution.
- Failure of Alternatives: The Annapolis Convention had previously failed, and attempting a third convention was deemed futile because the South would never abandon its stance on slavery.
Economic and Ideological Realities of Slavery:
- Delegate Demographics: While the majority of delegates in Philadelphia were not slaveholders, a substantial minority—nearly half—did hold slaves.
- Moral Inconsistency: Certain slaveholding delegates explicitly denounced slavery as evil and wrong while simultaneously continuing to own enslaved individuals.
- Systemic Entanglement: Both Northern and Southern states profited directly and indirectly from the slave economy, deeply embedding slavery into the economic structure of the nation.
Constitutional Language on Slavery:
- Euphemistic Phrasing: The word "slavery" or "slave" never appears in the original text of the U.S. Constitution; the framers deliberately used the phrase "other persons" to avoid placing explicit terminology in the document.
- Fugitive Slave Clause: Located in Article IV, this clause legally mandated that any enslaved person escaping into another state to seek freedom had to be returned to their owner upon claim. It remained constitutional law until its repeal by the Thirteenth Amendment in the .
- Slave Trade Moratorium: Delegates avoided resolving the slave trade controversy by establishing a -year moratorium, prohibiting Congress from banning the transatlantic slave trade prior to the year
Modern Political Disputes over the Founding
- Indiana Lieutenant Governor Controversy:
- Political Context: Mike Braun, a Republican from Southern Indiana, won the primary gubernatorial nomination and publicly selected a specific woman candidate as his preferred running mate.
- Convention Action: Delegates at the party convention rejected Braun's choice and nominated an unexpected candidate—a conservative pastor and activist who took office as Lieutenant Governor.
- Public Statement: The Lieutenant Governor released a TikTok video asserting that the Compromise was a "beautiful" and "uplifting" historical agreement that every American and Hoosier should appreciate, arguing that the founders intentionally used it to step toward the absolute abolition of slavery.
- Public and Academic Backlash:
- The Black Caucus of the Indiana General Assembly demanded a formal apology.
- The Baptist Ministers Alliance publicly criticized the statement.
- Academic historians across the nation refuted the claims as historically inaccurate.
- Implication: Debate over the moral legitimacy and political meaning of the Constitutional Founding continues in modern American politics over years later.
The Constitutional Convention of 1787 and Final Vote
Timeline and Attrition:
- The Constitutional Convention convened in Philadelphia in May and concluded in September
- A total of delegates initially attended the convention.
- Due to the prolonged duration and personal obligations, attrition reduced the number of delegates remaining in the room to by final vote day.
Prominent Delegates and Dissidents:
- Benjamin Franklin: Delegate from Pennsylvania; the oldest present; a polymath, scientist, writer, diplomat, and former slaveholder turned prominent abolitionist leader.
- Non-Signers: Of the delegates present at the end, exactly refused to sign the final draft:
- George Mason (Virginia): Expressed extreme distaste for the document, stating he would rather cut off his own arm than sign it.
- Elbridge Gerry (Massachusetts).
- Edmund Randolph (Governor of Virginia): Had initially introduced the Virginia Plan at the start of the convention.
Benjamin Franklin's Closing Address:
- Physical Condition: Due to extreme infirmity and advanced age, Franklin was carried to the convention in a sedan box and was too weak to read his own speech.
- Presentation: Fellow Pennsylvania delegate James Wilson read Franklin's prepared speech aloud to the assembly.
- Key Arguments and Quotations:
- Franklin expressed reservations, stating: "I do not entirely approve of this constitution, but I'm not sure that I shall never approve it."
- He reflected on intellectual humility: "The older I grow, the more apt I am to doubt my own judgment and pay respect to the judgment of others."
- He urged full unanimous adoption despite its flaws: "I consent to this constitution because I expect no better, and because I'm not sure that it's not the best."
- He emphasized that the delegates were unlikely to draft a superior document given their competing interests, framing the outcome as an effort to build "a more perfect union."
Philosophical Perspectives on Constitutional Imperfection
George Washington's Assessment:
- Physical Health: Washington presided over the convention while enduring chronic bodily suffering throughout his adult life, including severe jaw and dental pain as well as chronic intestinal ailments.
- Expectation of Leadership: Delegates designed the executive branch under Article II with the explicit assumption that Washington would serve as the first President of the United States.
- Letter on Imperfection: Washington wrote to a friend analyzing the proposed Constitution, noting that even its strongest supporters would not claim it was free from flaws or imperfections.
- Views on Future Generations: Washington rejected the idea that the founding generation possessed absolute wisdom, stating: "I do not conceive that we are more inspired or have more wisdom or possess more virtue than those people who will come after us."
- Contrast with Thomas Jefferson: While Jefferson famously praised the Constitutional Convention as an "assembly of demigods," Washington viewed the delegates as human beings who created an imperfect mechanism that future generations would need to amend.
Historiographical Framing:
- The framers were not divinely inspired architects; as captured in historic scholarship, they were Plain, Honest Men who produced an imperfect, practical compromise under tense political conditions.
The Mechanics of Constitutional Amendments and Ratification Rules
Amendment Threshold Comparison:
- Articles of Confederation: Required a unanimous vote of all states to enact any constitutional amendment, creating functional paralysis.
- U.S. Constitution: Set the amendment threshold at three-fourths () of the states.
- Historical Record: The U.S. Constitution has been amended times total in national history.
- The Bill of Rights: The first amendments were ratified simultaneously on a single day in
Ratification Procedure and Legality:
- Convention Completion: Delegates finalized and signed the document on September , , and formally reported it to Congress on September ,
- Unilateral Change of Rules: The proposed Constitution declared that approval by only states would be necessary for ratification and implementation, directly violating the amendment rules of the Articles of Confederation.
- Congressional Reaction: Members of Congress initially viewed the proposal as an illegal attempted overthrow of the existing government, debating whether to punish the delegates.
- State Ratifying Conventions: One week after receiving the document, Congress submitted the proposed Constitution to special state ratifying conventions, deliberately bypassing state legislatures which stood to lose power under the new central government.
Anti-Federalist Opposition and Institutional Critiques
Political Factions:
- Federalists: Supported the adoption and ratification of the new Constitution.
- Anti-Federalists: Opposed ratification, advocating for local control, state sovereignty, and strict limitations on central power.
- Political Atmosphere: Debates were intensely polarized, involving mob violence, tarring and feathering, and political assaults (e.g., John Jay's brother-in-law stabbing him over foreign policy disputes).
Key Anti-Federalist Arguments against Centralization:
- Distant Governance: Centralizing power in a far-off national capital mirrored British monarchical rule, stripping citizens of immediate local self-governance.
- Classical Republican Theory: Historical consensus held that republican government could only survive in small, geographically compact territories (such as city-states); applying a republic across the entire Atlantic seaboard was considered structurally impossible.
- Class Interest: Critics argued the Constitution was drafted illegally in secret by wealthy elites ("rich bitches") to safeguard their commercial privileges rather than serve common, low-income citizens, women, enslaved people, or Native Americans.
Branch-Specific Institutional Critiques:
- Article I (Legislative Branch):
- Elastic Clause: The "Necessary and Proper Clause" allows Congress to pass any laws deemed necessary and proper to carry out enumerated powers, creating an potentially unlimited expansion of national power.
- The Senate: Designed as an unelected body (originally selected by state legislatures) serving long six-year terms, granting excessive authority to an aristocratic upper chamber.
- Article II (Executive Branch):
- Created an un-elected single executive chosen by an Electoral College rather than direct popular vote, raising immediate fears of an evolving monarchy.
- Drafted with vague, undefined executive powers because delegates could not agree on explicit limits during the Philadelphia convention.
- Article III (Judicial Branch):
- Established a body explicitly designated as "Supreme."
- Judges are appointed by the executive rather than elected by the public and serve lifetime appointments, making them entirely unaccountable to the citizenry.
- National Security and Federal Supremacy:
- Standing Armies: Anti-Federalists viewed the power to raise standing peace-time armies as an inherent threat to liberty.
- Supremacy Clause: Mandated that federal laws override conflicting state laws, stripping states of control over trade, commerce, and internal regulations.
- Article I (Legislative Branch):
Political Rivalries:
- During elections for the newly formed U.S. House of Representatives in Virginia, James Madison ran directly against James Monroe, despite both later becoming U.S. Presidents.
Debates Over the Bill of Rights
Initial Rejection in Philadelphia:
- Delegates discussed and formally rejected adding a explicit Bill of Rights to the original Constitution before adjourning.
Federalist Arguments Against a Bill of Rights:
- Alexander Hamilton's View: Warning that enumerating specific individual rights was dangerous; if a right was omitted from the list, government authorities would claim the implicit power to violate it.
- James Madison's View: Claimed a Bill of Rights was unnecessary because the federal government only possessed specifically granted powers and would never abuse citizens. He argued that the constitutional system of checks and balances provided sufficient structural protection.
Anti-Federalist Resistance and the Compromise:
- Anti-Federalists and key states (notably Massachusetts) refused to ratify the Constitution without a explicit guarantee of rights.
- To secure approval, Madison capitulated, promising that if states ratified the Constitution, he would immediately draft and introduce amendments establishing a Bill of Rights in the first session of Congress.
State-by-State Ratification Outcomes
- Ratification Order and Vote Tallies:
- Delaware: Ratified unanimously.
- Pennsylvania: Ratified by a lopsided majority.
- New Jersey: Ratified unanimously.
- Georgia: Ratified unanimously.
- Connecticut: Ratified by a lopsided majority.
- Massachusetts: Heavily contested; passed by a vote of to
- Maryland: Ratified easily.
- South Carolina: Ratified by a lopsided vote after securing favorable protections for slaveholding interests.
- New Hampshire: Ratified in by a narrow margin, becoming the crucial state needed to legally bring the Constitution into effect.
- Virginia: Intense debate led by Anti-Federalist Patrick Henry (who famously wore a cape and delivered an impassioned speech against the Constitution during a thunderstorm); ultimately passed narrowly.
- New York: Initial vote failed by a margin of against ratification. Governor George Clinton actively opposed ratification under the pseudonym Cato, prompting Alexander Hamilton, James Madison, and John Jay to publish the Federalist Papers under the joint pseudonym Publius. Alexander Hamilton threatened that New York City would secede from New York State to join the United States independently, forcing a revote that passed narrowly ("by a whisker").
- North Carolina: Voted down ratification initially; was forced to reconsider and ratify after the new government formed, facing economic isolation as a foreign nation.
- Rhode Island: Held out longest; eventually ratified under severe political and economic pressure from the newly assembled national government.