The Nuclear Family Was A Mistake - Notes
The Nuclear Family Was A Mistake
Extended Clans (Early American History)
Most people lived in large households: corporate families.
In 1800, 90% of American families were corporate families.
Before 1850, ~75% of Americans over 65 lived with their kids/grandkids.
Extended families strengths:
Resilience: support web.
Socializing force: multiple adults teaching children.
Between 1750 and 1900 extended families living together roughly doubled.
Victorian era: home is a sacred place.
Extended families can be exhausting and stifling (less privacy, choice, mobility).
Victorian era: families were patriarchal.
Rise of Nuclear Family
Late 19th/early 20th centuries: young people left extended families for cities.
1890-1960: average age of first marriage dropped.
Children raised for autonomy, not embeddedness.
By 1920s, nuclear family with male breadwinner became dominant.
By 1960, 77.5% of children lived with two married parents apart from extended family.
The Short, Happy Life of the Nuclear Family
1950-1965: divorce rates dropped, fertility rates rose, nuclear family seemed successful.
Cult of “togetherness.”
Unmarried people seen as “sick,” “immoral,” or “neurotic.”
Ideal: married couple with 2.5 kids in a suburban home.
Era was a freakish historical moment.
Women relegated to the home; corporations barred married women.
Nuclear families were connected to other nuclear families.
High church attendance, unionization, social trust, and mass prosperity.
Men could easily find breadwinner jobs.
1950-1965: Society built around nuclear families (with specific conditions).
Disintegration of Nuclear Family
Mid-1970s: young men’s wages declined.
Society became more individualistic.
Feminist movement increased women's freedom.
1960s/70s: putting self before family became prominent.
.
Eli Finkel: dominant family culture = self-expressive marriage.
Marriage primarily about adult fulfillment, not childbearing.
Fewer relatives to help during stress; divorce increased.
American family had been “coming apart for more than 100 years”.
1970-2012: share of households with married couples and kids cut in half.
1960: 13% of households were single-person; 2018: 28%.
1850: 75% of Americans over 65 lived with relatives; 1990: 18%.
People marrying later, divorcing more.
Families got smaller: birth rates halved since 1960.
More homes with pets than kids.
Physical space between nuclear families widened.
Code of family self-sufficiency prevailed.
Families have grown more unequal.
Family Inequality
Affluent people can “buy extended family” (babysitting, childcare, tutoring, therapy).
These tools reduce stress and time commitments for parents, preserving marriage.
1970: family structures of rich and poor not that different; now there is a chasm.
As of 2005, 85% of children born to upper-middle-class families were living with both biological parents when the mom was 40, compared with only 30% among working-class families.
Differences in family structure have increased income inequality by 25%.
The causes are economic, cultural, and institutional all at once.
People in nuclear families are more individualistic.
Individualistic mindset leads to less willingness to sacrifice for family.
Impact on Vulnerable
Federal/state governments have tried to strengthen nuclear family, but family inequality continues.
In 1960, roughly 5% of children were born to unmarried women; now about 40%.
American children more likely to live in single-parent household than children from any other country.
Children of single/unmarried parents tend to have worse health, mental-health, academic, and behavioral outcomes.
If born into poverty and raised by married parents, 80% chance of climbing out; unmarried mother, 50% chance of remaining stuck.
12% of American kids had lived in at least three “parental partnerships” before age 15.
Impact on Men, Women, and Older People
Single men lack male bonding and female companionship; less healthy, abuse alcohol/drugs, earn less, die sooner.
Women benefit from loosening family structures but face brutal hard/isolating lifestyles in nuclear families.
Women spend more time on housework/child care than men.
35% of Americans over 45 are chronically lonely.
Many older people became “elder orphans."
African Americans suffered disproportionately due to fragile families.
High rate of black incarceration guarantees a shortage of available men to be husbands or caretakers of children.
Shifting Perspectives
Jane Jacobs: families are “rigged to fail”.
Conditions that made stable nuclear families in the 1950s are never returning.
Conservative ideas irrelevant to many family situations.
Progressives: People should have freedom to pick family form.
Progressive elites have strict expectations for their own families.
Sexual revolution left no governing norms of family life or guiding values.
Human beings adapt; when one family form stops working, people seek something new.