Enlightenment Thinking and the British, American, and French Revolutions

European Governance During the Era of Exploration

  • Nature of Rule: During the era of exploration, every European country was governed by an all-powerful monarch. The title of the monarch varied, including King, Queen, Emperor, Duke, and others.

  • Method of Succession: These rulers were not elected. Power was typically inherited, passed down through specific family bloodlines.

  • Lack of Accountability: Monarchs operated with no accountability; they possessed the absolute authority to act as they pleased.

  • Influential Advisers: Rule was influenced by a small, elite group of wealthy advisers. These individuals were typically significant landowners and maintained close institutional ties to religious authorities.

  • Social Class Structure: Societies were defined by a small group of wealthy elite ruling over a massive population of impoverished people.

  • Lack of Social Mobility: Mobility was almost impossible within this system. If a person was born into wealth, they remained wealthy; if born into poverty, they remained poor.

Intellectual Foundations: Ancient Greece, Rome, and Rationalism

  • Renaissance Influences: During the Renaissance, Europeans returned to the principles of ancient Greece and Rome. This shift emphasized asking critical questions, seeking empirical proof, and refusing to accept traditions unless they were thoroughly researched and reasoned through.

  • Rationalism: This is the core belief that reason must be the central component of all decision-making. Concepts and actions must "make sense" through logical evaluation.

  • Emergence of Human Agency: People began to believe that human beings were capable of making intelligent, autonomous decisions without the direct influence of a higher power (God).

  • Shift in Religious Thought: While religion remained a vital aspect of daily life, a new idea emerged: humans could make independent decisions, and religious belief did not necessarily have to dictate every specific decision made by an individual or a state.

Defining the Enlightenment Era

  • Timeframe: The Enlightenment was a historical period in Europe spanning from the end of the 1600s1600\text{s} (17th century) to the beginning of the 1800s1800\text{s} (19th century).

  • Core Objectives: The era was defined by a critical rethinking of government structures, individual freedoms, and the rejection of tradition as a sufficient justification for social norms.

  • Influence of Philosophers: The movement was driven by Enlightenment philosophers who, similar to ancient Greek thinkers, focused on the human capacity to make choices based on what was "rational"—meaning what made sense for both the individual and the "greater good" of the larger group.

  • Early Origins: Thinkers in the late 1500s1500\text{s}, influenced by the Renaissance, began questioning established ways of doing things. Their writings formed the foundation for later revolutions by calling for changes in how governments treated their citizens.

Key Enlightenment Philosophers

  • Thomas Hobbes (Britain, 15881588-16791679):

    • Social Contract Theory: Hobbes is most famous for the idea that people and their government exist within an unspoken "contract." Both parties have rights and responsibilities that must be respected for the agreement to remain valid.

    • Rational Agreement: He believed this contract was entered into by rational people who understood the implications of their agreement.

    • Impact on Government: This theory introduced the idea of accountability. If a leader fails to fulfill their side of the contract, the people believe they have the right to remove that leader.

  • John Locke (Britain, 16321632-17041704):

    • Government Responsibility: Locke argued that governments must promote the "public good" (ensuring life is good for most people) and protect the "life," "liberty," and "property" of the citizenry.

    • Right to Revolt: If a government fails to protect these rights or actively harms them, the people have a right to remove their leaders.

    • Primary Concept: Government exists solely to serve the people; the people do not exist to serve the government. Leadership is a privilege, not an inherent right, and can be revoked.

  • Charles Louis de Secondat (Montesquieu) (France, 16891689-17551755):

    • Separation of Powers: Montesquieu believed no single person (like a King or Queen) should hold all government power. He proposed a "division of powers" into separate, disconnected branches with distinct responsibilities.

    • Preventing Self-Interest: The goal was to prevent leaders from acting in self-interest, such as creating laws to benefit themselves or controlling courts to pardon their own wrongdoings.

    • Global Influence: This vision prompted people across Europe and North America to push for systems where power was divided rather than centralized.

The Glorious Revolution in England (16881688)

  • Pre-Revolution Leadership: In the 1500s1500\text{s} and 1600s1600\text{s}, England was ruled by absolute monarchs, some Catholic and some Protestant. Subjects had no say in governance.

  • Role of Parliament: Unlike most of Europe, England had a Parliament since 12151215. It consisted of wealthy male landowners who advised the King. However, the King could still ignore them and act unilaterally.

  • The Conflict: In 16881688, a conflict arose between the Catholic minority King, James II, and the Protestant King William of the Netherlands. William sought control over England.

  • The Overthrow: With the support of Parliament, King William overthrew King James. This was the first time a monarch's absolute power was successfully challenged and limited.

  • The Bill of Rights (16891689): Parliament required King William to sign this document to limit royal power and establish new parliamentary rights. Key provisions included:

    • Members of Parliament could be elected without the King's approval.

    • Freedom of speech within Parliament.

    • Freedom from royal interference in the law (Parliament could pass laws without the King's approval).

    • Freedom from cruel and unusual punishment.

    • The King could not impose taxes without Parliamentary approval.

    • No Catholics were permitted to serve as King or Queen.

The American Revolution

  • Defining a Revolution: A period of massive, often quick and violent change to social, political, and economic "norms" (the previously standard way of being).

  • Early Tensions (1770s1770\text{s}): The British government enacted laws that angered the Thirteen Colonies. Key grievances included giving land the Americans wanted to Quebec and unfair treatment by British rulers.

  • The Boston Tea Party: As a rebellion against unfair treatment, Americans dumped tons of British tea overboard. Britain viewed this as an act of war by "Revolutionaries."

  • Taxation Without Representation: A primary cause of the war. Americans, influenced by the Enlightenment, demanded a voice in the decision-making process. England refused to allow them seats in the British Parliament. The Americans' slogan became: "No Taxation Without Representation."

  • American Goals: Control over their own country, the right to control trade, the right to elect representative officials, and an end to being governed by people in a distant country.

  • Leadership: The American Congress chose George Washington, a military leader who had previously fought for the British against the French in Quebec, to lead the revolt.

  • Declaration of Independence (July 4, 1776July\,4,\,1776): Representatives met in Philadelphia to issue this statement, declaring the colonies a free country. Britain rejected the document, leading to a 55-year war that ended after the Battle of Yorktown.

Consequences and Contradictions of the American Revolution

  • First Modern Democracy: The United States became the first country to gain independence from its "mother country" and the first modern democracy with elected leaders (President, Congress) and no monarch.

  • The American Constitution: This document described the political organization and the "separation of powers" among three branches:

    • Legislative: Congress (House of Representatives and Senate).

    • Executive: President and Vice President.

    • Judicial: Supreme Court (judges are appointed, not elected).

  • Inherent Flaws: Thomas Jefferson wrote in the Declaration of Independence that "all men are created equal," yet the application of this ideal was highly limited.

  • Slavery during Independence: There were approximately 36,00036,000 slaves in the U.S. at the time of independence. Thomas Jefferson personally owned approximately 175175 slaves at that time and roughly 600600 over his lifetime.

  • Economic Divide: Between 17771777 and 18041804, Northern states outlawed slavery. However, the Southern economy was entirely dependent on slave labor for agriculture, particularly tobacco and cotton.

  • The American Civil War (1860s1860\text{s}): Triggered by the North's ultimatum to end slavery. The South separated to form their own country. The war ended in 18651865, resulting in the abolition of slavery.

  • Scale of Slavery: When slavery ended, there were 4,000,0004,000,000 slaves in the United States. The legacy of slavery continues to affect American culture and language today (e.g., terms like "sold down the river" or "master bedroom").

The French Revolution

  • Connections to America: France and the U.S. were allies due to a shared dislike of England. Thomas Jefferson spent significant time in France, and the Marquis de Lafayette fought in the American Revolution before returning to France to spread revolutionary ideas.

  • Financial Crisis: France was in deep debt following the Seven Years War and the American Revolution. The monarchy attempted to solve this by taxing the poor.

  • Social Structure (The Ancien R\u00e9gime): The population was divided into three "Estates":

    • First Estate: The Catholic Church (Clergy). They owned vast land and businesses, collected a "Tithe" (10%10\% of income) from people, and paid zero taxes.

    • Second Estate: The Nobility (King, family, friends). They held all the power and money, lived off taxes/rent from the lower class, and comprised about 2%2\% of the population along with the First Estate.

    • Third Estate: Everyone else (98%98\% of the population), including farmers, intellectuals, and the bourgeoisie (middle class). They were the source of all economic activity but had no political power.

  • Divine Right of Kings: The King's authority was believed to be granted by God, cementing the tie between the Crown and the Catholic Church.

  • Immediate Causes: Years of bad harvests and drought led to food shortages. The price of wheat rose, making bread unaffordable. While bread was a "public service necessity," its scarcity became a symbol of the struggle of the poor.

Evolution and Outcome of the French Revolution

  • Estates General (17891789): The King called a meeting of all three estates. Despite being 98%98\% of the population, the Third Estate had the same number of representatives as the others, who always voted together against them.

  • National Assembly: The Third Estate broke away to form the National Assembly, joined by some members of the other estates, to write a fairer Constitution.

  • Storming of the Bastille (July 14July\,14): A crowd armed with muskets and swords captured the Bastille prison, a symbol of royal control. This marked the end of the Ancien R\u00e9gime and is now France's national holiday.

  • Declaration of the Rights of Man and the Citizen (17891789): A document outlining ideals of freedom and equality, including:

    • Men are born free and equal.

    • Liberty is the freedom to do anything that does not injure others.

    • Innocent until proven guilty.

    • Freedom of opinion and religion.

  • Limited Rights: Initially, voting rights were limited to males over 2525 who were in the army and paid a specific amount in contributions. Women and the poor remained excluded.

  • End of the Monarchy: The revolutionaries eventually replaced the limited monarchy with a Republic. King Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette were tried and executed.

  • The Reign of Terror: Led by Robespierre (head of "public safety"), this period saw the execution of thousands suspected of ties to the old regime. Robespierre was responsible for 1,4001,400 executions before he himself was guillotined.

  • Napoleon Bonaparte: Following the chaos, Napoleon rose to power as Emperor. While this returned France to a monarchical style of rule, Napoleon was instrumental in spreading French culture across Europe.

  • Legacy: The Enlightenment era officially ended with the end of Napoleon's reign in 18211821. The revolution established a strict separation of Church and State in France.

Questions & Discussion

  • Philosophical Influence: In what ways does the British Bill of Rights (16891689) specifically reflect the ideas of Enlightenment philosophers like Hobbes or Locke?

  • Ideology vs. Reality: Thomas Jefferson wrote that "all men are created equal." Given that he owned hundreds of slaves, what does this tell us about his specific vision for the country? Does this contradiction change how people should view the Declaration of Independence?

  • The Nature of Revolutions: The French Revolution ended with Napoleon as an Emperor, effectively returning to a single powerful leader. Does this make the French Revolution redundant or a failure?

  • Religious Comparison: How is the Catholic dependency in pre-Revolution France different from the Protestantism that influenced the English Glorious Revolution?