Untitled

Where power comes from: natural rights, the social contract, and popular sovereignty

In plain words: People have rights by birth. They set up a government to protect those rights. The power belongs to the people.

Think of neighbors who hire a security guard. They pay the guard to protect their homes. If the guard starts breaking into their homes, the deal is off. They can fire him. That is the core of Locke's idea.

Natural rights. John Locke (1632–1704) was an English thinker. He wrote Two Treatises of Government (1690). He imagined a "state of nature," a time before any government. Even then, he said, reason teaches that "no one ought to harm another in his life, health, liberty, or possessions." These are natural rights.

The social contract. Why form a government at all? In a state of nature, no one can safely protect those rights. So people agree to create a government to protect them. That agreement is the social contract. Locke wrote that "the great and chief end" of government "is the preservation of their property." By property he meant much more than land. He meant "lives, liberties and estates."

The right of revolution. What if the government attacks the very rights it should protect? Then, Locke said, the people "are thereupon absolved from any farther obedience." In plain words, they no longer have to obey. That is the right of revolution.

Locke's Social ContractPeople have natural rights(life, liberty, property)They agree to form agovernment (consent)Government protectstheir rightsIf government destroysrights: right of revolutionTHE SOCIALCONTRACT(Locke, 1690)only when it failspeople may alteror abolish itDeclaration (1776): "to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men,deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed"

Locke in the Declaration. Thomas Jefferson put Locke's ideas at the heart of the Declaration of Independence (1776):

Locke (1690)

Declaration of Independence (1776)

Natural rights to "life, health, liberty, or possessions"

"unalienable Rights … Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness"

People unite under government to preserve their rights

"to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men"

Government rests on the people's agreement

"deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed"

People are freed from obeying a government that destroys their rights

"it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it"

Popular sovereignty. This means all government power comes from the people. You can see it in two famous lines:

  • The Constitution begins: "We the People of the United States … do ordain and establish this Constitution."

  • Lincoln spoke of "government of the people, by the people, for the people."

No one is above the law: rule of law and limited government

In plain words: No one is above the law. And government can do only what the people allow.

Think of a referee in a game. The referee must follow the rulebook too. If the referee breaks the rules, the game is not fair. That is the rule of law.

Rule of law. Laws apply the same way to everyone. That includes the people who make and enforce them. The idea goes back to the Magna Carta (1215) in England. Nobles called barons forced King John to make a promise. Free men would not be jailed or lose their property except by lawful judgment or the law of the land. From then on, even the king was under the law.

Limited government. Government has only the powers the people give it. Some rights are off-limits. In 1689 the English Bill of Rights set new limits on the king or queen:

  • no taxes without Parliament's consent,

  • no army in peacetime without Parliament's consent,

  • no "cruel and unusual punishments." The U.S. later copied this phrase into the Eighth Amendment.

Limited government in the U.S. Constitution:

  • a written list of the powers given to Congress (Article I, Section 8),

  • clear bans on some actions. For example, Congress may not pass ex post facto laws. These are laws that punish something that was legal when it was done.

  • the Bill of Rights (1791), which protects freedoms such as speech, religion, and a fair trial,

  • the Tenth Amendment, which keeps all other powers for the states or the people ("to the States respectively, or to the people").

Examples:

  • A court orders a President to turn over evidence, and he obeys. → rule of law

  • Congress cannot pass a law that sets up an official national religion. → limited government (First Amendment)

Dividing power: separation of powers and checks and balances

In plain words: Split the power into three parts. Then let each part keep an eye on the others.

Think of a family business. One person orders supplies. Another pays the bills. A third checks the books. No one person can steal without someone else noticing. That is the idea here.

Separation of powers. Baron de Montesquieu was a French writer. In The Spirit of the Laws (1748), he warned: "When the legislative and executive powers are united in the same person, or in the same body of magistrates, there can be no liberty." The framers took his advice. They created three separate branches:

Branch

Main job

Constitution

Legislative (Congress)

Makes laws

Article I

Executive (President)

Carries out laws

Article II

Judicial (Supreme Court and federal courts)

Interprets laws

Article III

Checks and balances. James Madison wanted more than separate branches. In The Federalist No. 51 (1788), he wrote that each branch needs "the necessary constitutional means and personal motives to resist encroachments of the others. … Ambition must be made to counteract ambition." In plain words, each branch must be able to push back when another grabs too much power. So the Constitution gives each branch tools to limit the others. These tools are checks and balances.

Checks and Balances Among the Three BranchesLEGISLATIVE BRANCHCongress: makes laws(Article I)EXECUTIVE BRANCHPresident: carries out laws(Article II)JUDICIAL BRANCHCourts: interpret laws(Article III)Executive checks Legislative:• can veto billsLegislative checks Executive:• can override a veto(2/3 of each house)• Senate approvesappointments, treaties• can impeach and removethe PresidentJudicial checks Legislative:• can declare lawsunconstitutionalLegislative checks Judicial:• Senate confirms judges• can impeach judges• sets size oflower courtsExecutive checks Judicial: nominates federal judgesJudicial checks Executive: can ruleexecutive actions unconstitutional

Keep these straight:

  • Separation of powers = power is divided into three branches.

  • Checks and balances = each branch can limit the others. Examples: veto, override, approving judges, impeachment, and judicial review.

Example: The Senate rejects a President's pick for the Supreme Court. Which principle? One branch is limiting another, so checks and balances.

Sharing power with the states: federalism

In plain words: Power is shared between the nation and the states.

Think of a big store chain. The head office sets prices and runs national ads. Each local store sets its own hours and hires its own staff. Some jobs, like paying taxes, both do. That is federalism.

Why the framers chose it. The first plan of government, the Articles of Confederation (1781–1789), made the national government too weak. It could not collect taxes or control trade. So the framers split power between two levels: the national (federal) government and the state governments.

Type of power

Who has it

Examples

Delegated (enumerated)

National government

declaring war, coining money, making treaties, controlling trade between states

Reserved

States

running schools and elections, issuing driver's licenses, setting up local governments

Concurrent

Both

taxing, borrowing, setting up courts

The Tenth Amendment protects reserved powers: "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people."

What if a federal law and a state law truly clash? The Supremacy Clause (Article VI) settles it. The Constitution and federal laws are "the supreme Law of the Land."

When Laws Clash: The Supremacy ClauseU.S. ConstitutionFederal laws and treatiesState constitutionsState lawsLocal laws and ruleswins ina conflictSupremacy Clause (Article VI): the Constitution and federal laws are "the supreme Law of the Land."

Federalism vs. separation of powers:

  • Federalism splits power up and down (nation ↔ states).

  • Separation of powers splits power sideways (Congress ↔ President ↔ courts).

Two Different Splits of PowerSeparation of powers: SIDEWAYSCongressmakes lawsPresidentenforces lawsCourtsinterpret lawsthree branches of ONE levelof governmentFederalism: UP AND DOWNNational (federal) governmentwar, money, treatiesshare powerState governmentsschools, licenses, electionstwo LEVELS of governmentAsk: branch vs. branch (separation / checks) or nation vs. state (federalism)?