Comprehensive Notes on the Civil War Reconstruction Era
Competing Visions for Post-Civil War Reconstruction
- Post-War Reality: Following the conclusion of the Civil War, the era of Reconstruction began. Rather than unifying the nation smoothly, intense political and social conflicts emerged over how to reintegrate the Southern states and secure rights for formerly enslaved people.
- Core Ideological Disagreement: The central divergence between competing Reconstruction proposals centered on the legal status and characterization of the defeated Southern states.
- Lincoln's 10% Plan (Proclamation of Amnesty and Reconstruction - 1863):
- Legal Basis: Abraham Lincoln maintained that Southern secession was constitutionally impossible. In his view, the Southern states had never legally left the Union, but were instead rebellious states that remained part of the United States throughout the war.
- Policy Goal: Re-enter Southern states into the Union quickly through lenient conditions and a low operational threshold.
- Key Requirements:
- A state could restore its rightful place in the Union once 10% of its eligible voter population from the 1860 presidential election swore a formal oath of loyalty to the United States.
- The state was required to officially abolish slavery.
- Radical Republican Plan and the Wade-Davis Bill (1864):
- Legal Basis: Radical Republicans in Congress viewed Southern states not as misguided former family members, but as conquered enemies that required stern punishment. Radical Republicans strongly favored full abolition and civil rights guarantees for Black Americans.
- Policy Goal: Execute Reconstruction using assertive federal power at the expense of state authority.
- Wade-Davis Bill Requirements:
- Required Southern states to formally abolish slavery.
- Mandated that a full majority—specifically 51%—of Southern voters take an oath of allegiance to the United States before state governments could be restored.
- Lincoln's Pocket Veto:
- Lincoln killed the Wade-Davis Bill using a presidential pocket veto.
- Rationale: Lincoln sought to preserve delicate political alliances with moderates and protect relationships with the border states.
- The Border States: Consisted of four slave states that remained loyal to the Union. Lincoln considered keeping these slave states within the Union essential to Northern victory, leading him to avoid overly aggressive anti-slavery policies that might push them toward the Confederacy.
Presidential Reconstruction Under Abraham Lincoln and Andrew Johnson
- Assassination of Abraham Lincoln:
- In April 1865, exactly six days after the Civil War ended, Abraham Lincoln was assassinated while attending a play at Forge Theater by John Wils Booth, a Confederate sympathizer. Lincoln died the following morning.
- Succession of Andrew Johnson:
- Under the U.S. Constitution, Vice President Andrew Johnson assumed the presidency.
- Political Background: Johnson was added to Lincoln's 1864 re-election ticket as a strategic gesture to satisfy border states and Southern Unionists. Johnson was a pro-Union Southern Democrat from Tennessee who had been an enslaver.
- Socioeconomic Resentment: Johnson grew up poor and deeply resented the social, political, and economic control long exercised by the Southern planter elite.
- Executive Reconstruction Governance:
- Johnson lacked political negotiation and persuasion skills, leading to an immediate, bitter rivalry with Congressional Republicans.
- Treated Reconstruction as an annoyance to be completed as rapidly as possible so Southern states could govern their internal affairs independently.
- Targeted the planter elite for personal vengeance: While extending mass pardons to ordinary Southerners who swore loyalty oaths, Johnson required wealthy planters to petition him personally to secure executive pardons, forcing elite planters to beg for citizenship.
- Declared Reconstruction completed only 8 months after the war ended.
Southern Resistance and the Rise of Black Codes
- Southern Political Defiance:
- Under Johnson's lenient framework, newly formed Southern state legislatures elected former Confederate leaders back into state and federal offices.
- The state of Georgia elected Alexander Stevens to the United States House of Representatives. Stevens was the former Vice President of the Confederacy who had delivered the "Cornerstone Speech," asserting that the fundamental principle of the Confederacy was the inequality of the white and Black races.
- Enactment of Black Codes:
- Southern state legislatures systematically passed Black Codes that severely curtailed the civil rights of Black Americans.
- In many cases, the legal restrictions imposed by Black Codes recreated conditions functionally equivalent to slavery.
- Presidential Acceptance vs. Radical Disapproval:
- President Johnson approved these Southern developments, viewing the South as adequately restored.
- Radical Republicans rejected Johnson's conclusions and moved decisively to assume complete control over Reconstruction.
Congressional Radical Reconstruction and Martial Law
- Congressional Supermajority in 1866:
- In the 1866 midterm elections, Radical Republicans won overwhelming majorities, capturing 2/3 of the seats in Congress.
- Under Article 1, Section 7 of the U.S. Constitution, a 2/3 majority gives Congress the power to override presidential vetoes.
- With veto-proof control, Congress stripped control of Reconstruction from President Johnson and transformed it into a congressional mandate.
- Congress consolidated power by refusing to seat newly elected former Confederate leaders sent by Southern states.
- Military Reconstruction Act of 1867:
- Divided the South into 5 military districts governed under federal martial law.
- Stationed federal occupation troops throughout the South to enforce Reconstruction mandates and prevent civil rights violations stemming from Black Codes.
- Forcefully ensured that all former Confederate states complied with federal criteria, leading to all Southern states re-entering the Union by 1870.
Post-War Constitutional Amendments
- 13th Amendment (Ratified 1865):
- Formally abolished slavery across the entire United States.
- Ratification was made a strict prerequisite for Southern states seeking re-entry into the Union.
- Southern states circumvented its intent by passing Black Codes to restrict freedmen's freedoms.
- 14th Amendment (Ratified 1868):
- Guaranteed birthright citizenship to all individuals born in the United States, explicitly including formerly enslaved people.
- Prohibited state governments from infringing upon the civil rights of citizens.
- Significance: Prior to the 14th Amendment, civil liberties listed in the Bill of Rights protected citizens against federal intrusion, but did not protect them against state government intrusion.
- Constitutional Protection: Congressional Republicans embedded key statutory protections—previously passed in two Civil Rights Acts that defined citizenship and banned racial discrimination—directly into the U.S. Constitution to prevent President Johnson or Southern states from undermining them.
- 15th Amendment (Ratified 1870):
- Protected and guaranteed voting rights for Black men against racial discrimination.
Debate and Division in the Equal Rights Movement
- Background of Women's Suffragists and Abolitionism:
- Women advocates contributed significantly to the pre-war abolitionist movement.
- After the war, abolitionists and women's rights advocates established the American Equal Rights Association to secure full civil rights for emancipated Black citizens.
- Schism Over the 15th Amendment:
- The 15th Amendment explicitly prohibited franchise restrictions based on race, but omitted protections based on gender.
- Opposing Faction (Elizabeth Katie Stanton and Susan B. Anthony):
- Elizabeth Katie Stanton opposed the 15th Amendment, arguing that advancing voting rights for Black men without securing rights for women would further marginalize women's political standing.
- Stanton deployed nativist and racial arguments, stating it was unacceptable that the poorest and least educated Black, Irish, Chinese, or German male citizens could vote while educated white women remained disenfranchised.
- Stanton and Susan B. Anthony broke away from the American Equal Rights Association to form the National Women's Suffrage Association, an all-female organization that actively campaigned against the 15th Amendment and fought for a women's suffrage amendment (which took roughly 50 years to be ratified).
- Supporting Faction (Frederick Douglas and Allies):
- Frederick Douglas maintained that securing immediate voting rights for Black men was an urgent, vital necessity.
- Douglas argued that establishing voting rights for Black men would create critical momentum that would eventually assist in securing voting rights for women.