5. Individual and Class Evidence Summary

Principles of Forensic Evidence

  • Evidence Definition: That which tends to support something or show something is the case.

  • Forensic Evidence: Evidence obtained by the use of science, whose value depends on the ability to interpret information discovered at a crime scene.

  • Physical Evidence: Any material items present at the crime scene, on the victim, or found in a suspect's possession.

  • Trace Evidence: Physical evidence found in small but measurable amounts.

  • Legal Weight: The importance and contribution of physical evidence are ultimately determined by the jury in the courtroom.

Trace Evidence Dynamics

  • Locard's Exchange Principle: It is impossible to do anything violent without leaving a trace.

  • Evidentiary Limitations: Trace evidence is not sufficient to make a case entirely on its own.

  • Trace Quantities:

    • 1 milligram=1/1,000 gram≈1 sugar crystal1\text{ milligram} = 1/1,000\text{ gram} \approx 1\text{ sugar crystal}

    • 1 microgram=1/1,000,000 gram≈1 cm of silk fibre1\text{ microgram} = 1/1,000,000\text{ gram} \approx 1\text{ cm of silk fibre}

    • 1 nanogram=1/1,000,000,000 gram≈1 dust spec1\text{ nanogram} = 1/1,000,000,000\text{ gram} \approx 1\text{ dust spec}

  • Collection & Analysis: Techniques include vacuuming and tape lifting; analytical approaches include microscopy and chemical methods, supported by comparison databases (e.g., DNA, fingerprints).

  • Contamination & Handling: Small sample sizes increase risks of sampling errors, contamination, or evidence loss. Known and control materials must never contact suspect materials and must be packaged separately using negative controls to verify collection purity.

Crime Scene Processing and Search Methods

  • Investigation Protocol: Standard progression follows a structured scientific flow:   Identify scene→secure scene→walk-through→documentation→evidence collection→processing\text{Identify scene} \rightarrow \text{secure scene} \rightarrow \text{walk-through} \rightarrow \text{documentation} \rightarrow \text{evidence collection} \rightarrow \text{processing}

  • Search Patterns: Systematically deployed to avoid destruction or compromise of physical evidence:

    • Outward Spiral

    • Parallel

    • Grid

    • Zone

Analytical Framework: Identification vs. Comparison

Comparison microscope showing 100% comparison match vs no match
  • Identification:

    • Determines the physical or chemical character of a substance with near-absolute certainty permitted by modern analytical techniques.

    • Requires characteristic test procedures specific to evidence type to exclude all other possibilities.

  • Comparison:

    • A two-step procedure: (1) Select specific properties to compare between a suspect specimen and a standard/reference specimen; (2) Determine whether they share a common origin.

    • Differing characteristics prove specimens originate from different sources.

    • Shared characteristics introduce probability rather than definitive proof of common origin.

Class and Individual Characteristics

Footwear tread showing matching individual wear marks and cuts
  • Class Characteristics:

    • Shared across a broad group of objects or persons (e.g., blood type, paint chips, general shoe impressions).

    • Cannot link evidence to a single origin with high probability on their own.

    • Provide vital corroboration; collective presence of >1>1 type of class evidence dramatically increases certainty.

  • Individual Characteristics:

    • Specific details associating evidence with a single source to an extremely high probability (e.g., fingerprints, specific footprints, broken objects).

    • Cannot be stated with mathematical accuracy, but the probability of alternative origins is so infinitesimally small as to defy human comprehension.

Types of Physical and Impression Evidence

Reconstructed reflector demonstrating a fracture match
  • Categories of Evidence:

    • Biological/Physiological: Blood, semen, saliva, bodily fluids.

    • Chemical: Narcotics, prescription drugs, firearm powders.

    • Physical: Fingerprints, footprints, tyre marks, tool marks, firearms/ammunition.

    • Non-specific/Miscellaneous: Photography, dye marks, voice analysis.

  • Fracture Matches: Mechanical fit between broken fragments along fracture lines (e.g., glass, tape edges, paint, paper, rope, broken blade segments) establishing that items originated from the exact same object.

  • Impression Evidence:

    • 2D Impressions: Formed on hard surfaces using transferring materials such as blood or dust.

    • 3D Impressions: Depressions made in soft materials (soil, sand, snow).

    • Documented via in situ photography prior to lifting or casting.

    • Class features determine general manufacturer/model; individual imperfections (cuts, wear, nicks) isolate the specific tyre or shoe.

Bolt cutter striation match on soft lead compared with crime scene toolmark
  • Tool Marks: Microscopic striations left on surfaces through the mechanical action of tools. Wear and chipping over time generate unique individual characteristics; tools may also carry biological trace evidence (blood, DNA, fingerprints).