Bartlett, Vavrus 2017 - Rethinking case study research Ch.2
The Value of Process-Oriented Approaches in Comparative Case Studies
Case studies are a widely used methodology across multiple disciplines. The concept of a case study can be complex, as it may involve a single setting, place, or institution, or even an individual within a broader context. The definition of case study research depends on the epistemology and methodology engaged by the author. There are three main approaches to case study research: variance-oriented, interpretivist, and process-oriented. This text provides an overview of these approaches and discusses the limitations of traditional models of case studies, emphasizing the value of a process-oriented approach for comparative case studies.
"Expanding Methodological Horizons: The Foundations and Comparisons of the CCS Approach"
The text discusses the methodological foundations of the CCS approach, distinguishing it from other orientations. It highlights the influence of extended case methods, multi-sited and multi-scalar ethnography, and actor network theory. Key ideas underpinning the CCS approach include examining power relations, reconceptualizing space, scale, and context, focusing on processes, and understanding interactionally-produced meanings. It also compares the CCS approach with variance-oriented, interpretivist, and process-oriented case studies, noting limitations of existing approaches.
The Limitations of Yin's Definition and Logic in Case Study Research
The text criticizes Yin's definition of case study research, arguing that it limits the importance of history, conflates case and context, and promotes a narrow understanding of context. It also highlights concerns with Yin's variance logic, which assumes complex case studies can be created through the amalgamation of variables. Despite these criticisms, the text acknowledges Yin's positive contribution to the field of naturalistic inquiry.
The Complexity and Critique of Case Studies
The text discusses the complexity of case studies and argues that they are not merely a single 'data point' but involve multiple variables. This complexity raises doubts about the usefulness of conventional variable-based methods, leading to a preference for holistic approaches. Yin's emphasis on bounding the case is also criticized for being more aligned with a neo-positivist and variance-oriented design.
The Limitations and Divergence of Yin's Variance-Oriented Approach to Case Study Research
Yin's variance-oriented approach to case study research emphasizes construct and internal validity, external validity (generalizability), replication, and structured design. However, it understates the value of case studies in social science research, focusing on exploratory and descriptive cases rather than explanatory ones. This perspective offers a distinct view on case study research, emphasizing its shortcomings and areas of divergence.
"Exploring Comparative Research in Case Studies: Historical Context, Design, and Trustworthiness"
The text discusses the perspective on comparative research in case studies. It highlights the importance of historical comparison, context, and research design. It also questions the need to "bound" the case and critiques Yin's concepts of validity, reliability, and generalizability, suggesting a focus on trustworthiness instead. It contrasts variance-oriented and interpretivist case studies and emphasizes understanding participants' sense-making in interpretivist studies.
"Examining Knowledge Construction and Power Relations in Interpretivist Case Studies"
Interpretivist approaches to case studies, exemplified by Robert Stake's work, emphasize the construction of knowledge, focus on meaning, and value the unique and particular aspects of cases. Stake's methods prioritize understanding the case rather than generalizing beyond it. However, there is a need to consider power relations and social structures, as well as the potential for generating theoretical insights that transfer to other cases, rather than completely forsaking generalizability.
Limitations and Considerations in Stake's Approach to Case Studies
The text discusses the limitations of Stake's approach to case studies, including falsification, rich theoretical insights, power dynamics in data selection, politics of representation, and the notion of a bounded and coherent case system. It highlights the importance of context, comparison, and the need for ethical engagement and reflexivity in the research process.
"Exploring the Power of Quintain: Comparative Case Studies in Understanding Diverse Contexts"
The text discusses the concept of "quintain" in comparative case studies, as presented by Stake. It highlights the importance of multiple case studies, emphasizing the value of examining different cases, parts, or members. The quintain represents the large-scale phenomenon being investigated across diverse contexts. The text suggests substituting "quintain" with "phenomenon" or "policy" and advocates for comparison across three axes: horizontal, vertical, and transversal comparisons.
Exploring Multiple Realities: The Significance of Merriam's Interpretivist Shift
Interpretivist stance prioritizes understanding multiple interpretations of reality in qualitative research. Merriam emphasizes bounded case studies, inductive reasoning, and process-oriented questions. However, her approach is limited in addressing dynamic historical and cultural meanings, and aspiration for greater theoretical import is reduced. Merriam's shift towards an interpretivist approach is significant.
Reconsidering Holism: A Contingent Tracing of Factors and Context in Qualitative Case Studies
Scholars often describe qualitative case studies as holistic, focusing on the relationship between phenomenon and context. However, this notion of holism can be limited and conflates case and context. Instead, an iterative and contingent tracing of relevant factors, actors, and features is proposed to better understand the case's social and historical context.
"Exploring Interconnections: The Flexibility of the Comparative Case Study Approach"
The Comparative Case Study (CCS) approach focuses on a process-orientation, examining how situations and events influence each other, rather than just considering causation. This method involves an emergent design, adapting methods, theory, and data as the research progresses. This contrasts with traditional case study literature, which emphasizes bounding the case, but the degree of flexibility depends on various factors, such as the study's aims and available resources.
"Understanding Shared Identities: Exploring Comparative Case Studies and Social Actors' Perspectives"
Comparative case studies (CCS) avoid defining culture, place, and community in a problematic way, and instead focus on tracing relevant factors, actors, and features. They aim to understand historical and contemporary processes that have produced shared identities. CCS seeks to understand and incorporate social actors' perspectives and is guided by critical theory, which is concerned with power and inequality.
Exploring Power and Inequality: The Critical Case Study Approach
The critical case study (CCS) approach focuses on power and inequality, aiming to provide rich descriptions of cultural phenomena and explore the cultural politics of policy. Unlike neo-positivist and interpretivist case study approaches, CCS seeks to integrate comparison more centrally into its work, utilizing horizontal, vertical, and transversal comparisons. This approach is influenced by extended case methods, multi-sited ethnography, and actor network theory.
Navigating the Tension: Unveiling the Dynamics of Global Systems in Local Contexts
Contemporary social research aims to address the local-global dilemma by understanding that global systems operate within specific contexts and are shaped by local-global interactions. Anna Tsing's metaphor of "friction" highlights the unequal and unstable nature of cross-cultural connections. Comparative case studies (CCS) focus on multi-level research, examining national, international, and local connections, and the goal of CCS research is to develop a thorough understanding of policy, problems, or phenomena under study.
"Globalization and Conceptual Developments in Methodology: Exploring Extended Case Methods, Multi-sited Ethnography, and Actor Network Theory"
The text discusses the influence of globalization and other conceptual developments on the methodology approach, including extended case methods, multi-sited ethnography, and actor network theory. The extended case method, rooted in anthropology and sociology, emphasizes individual strategies and tactics in everyday life, with four distinct dimensions: participant observation, spatial and temporal extension, macro forces, and theoretical extension. The text also mentions the increasing use of multi-sited ethnography in qualitative social science research over the past 20 years.
"Uncovering Interconnectedness: Tracing Cultural Formations and Translocal Linkages"
Multi-sited ethnography involves tracing cultural formations across multiple sites, examining interconnectedness across dispersed locations, and addressing distributed knowledge systems. This research method rejects holism and redefines context to include socially-produced places across scales. It aims to establish translocal linkages and connections between local bundles of relationships during the data collection process.
"Redefining Translocality: Exploring Connections, Comparisons, and Continuity"
The text discusses the concept of translocal, which is redefined in three ways: horizontal comparison, vertical comparison, and transversal comparison. The approach involves studying multiple sites at a single scale, examining commonalities through national or international policymaking, and exploring historical connections. This involves various research techniques and methods, emphasizing multiple levels and locales. A key aspect of this approach is its iterative and contingent nature, meaning it is responsive to evolving cultural, political, and material conditions, with changes made regularly throughout the research process.
New Approaches for Ethnography: Emphasizing Multi-Scaled Perspectives
The text discusses the shift towards multi-scalar ethnography, a method that considers how social phenomena are constituted through actions at different scales. This method challenges the traditional ethnographic method and calls for new approaches. It emphasizes the importance of paying attention to the beliefs and claims about scales, being reflexive about one's scalar positionality, and maintaining a critical reflexivity about the research process and its impact on the findings.
"Exploring Actor Networks: Shifting Dynamics and Non-Human Influences"
Actor Network Theory (ANT) provides a conceptual approach to studying across and through networks, considering how actors and resources shift and dissolve, and how social acts influence future actions. This theory emphasizes the role of non-human actors, focusing on interactions within a network rather than their location, and directly contradicts the need to "bound the case" in contemporary case study methodologies.
Exploring Methodological Approaches in Comparative Case Studies: The Role of Actor Network Theory and Historical Comparison
Fieldwork is a mutable and challenging practice due to the emergence of fields and anthropological interests. Adequate case studies depend on the quality of questions and methods, not just time in the field. Comparative case studies should look across scales, consider intersections, and follow the phenomenon. Actor network theory can be used to enhance comparative case studies, but the CCS heuristic promotes historical comparison.
Understanding Context and Culture: Shaping Case Studies and Comparison
The text discusses the concept of context, which should be considered as spatial and relational rather than merely defined by location. It also emphasizes that culture should be viewed as an ongoing, contested production instead of a static and bounded notion. These ideas impact how case studies and comparison are conceptualized. The text highlights the influence of various methods, such as extended case method, multi-sited and multi-scalar ethnography, and actor network theory, on the CCS approach. The next chapters will further elaborate on the CCS approach by addressing its three central axes: horizontal, vertical, and transversal.
Exploring the Extended Case Method in Ethnography: Contributions and Perspective
The text discusses the extended case method in ethnography, a research approach that focuses on events and their outcomes, considering causal antecedents and critical actions. It highlights various books, articles, and authors who have contributed to the understanding and practice of this method, including Becker, Burawoy, Burawoy, Coleman, and Falzon.
"Exploring the Interplay of Globalization, Transnationalism, and Education: A Cross-Disciplinary Approach"
The text discusses various aspects of globalization, transnationalism, and education, with a focus on case studies, ethnography, and actor-network theory. Key authors include Y.S. Lincoln, G.E. Marcus, and M.Q. Patton.
Case study methodology
•Case study methodology is widely used across multiple disciplines and fields.
•Researchers use the word "case" with relatively little consideration of the theories and metatheories embedded in these terms or in the methods that use cases.
•A case can be defined as a place, setting, institution, or unit of analysis and may be used interchangeably with "units of analysis," but that can be problematic.
•Cases need to be similar enough and separate enough to permit treating them as comparable instances of the same general phenomenon.
•The relationship between a case and a variable, and the difference between case-driven studies and variable-driven case studies have implications for how a researcher thinks about and uses case studies.
•The definition of case study research depends on the epistemology and methodology engaged by the author, and it is important to discuss the distinction between variance-oriented, interpretivist, and process-oriented approaches to case study research.
•Process-oriented approaches are favored for comparative case studies (CCS) due to their appropriateness and the limitations of traditional models of case studies.
•The traditional models of case studies have limitations and narrow notions of culture, context, and comparison, while a process-oriented approach offers value.
Methodological Foundations of the CCS Approach
•The CCS approach is influenced by the extended case method, multi-sited and multi-scalar ethnography, and actor network theory
•Key ideas of the CCS approach include a critical approach to power relations; reconceptualizing space, scale, and context; focusing on the processes through which events unfold; distinct, critical approach to thinking about causality; understanding the imperative to look at interactionally-produced meanings of events and interactions
•Existing case study approaches can be categorized as variance-oriented, interpretivist, and process-oriented
•Variance-Oriented Case Studies focus on variables, correlations, and causal factors using scientific methods and statistical analysis
•Neo-positivism is the epistemological stance for case study research in variance-oriented approaches, which views the world as operating by laws of cause and effect
•Popular texts on research methodologies adopt some elements of variance approaches, with the influential work of Robert Yin shaping research methods for decades, providing a definition of a case study as an empirical study focus on contemporary events or phenomena in real-life contexts.
Critique of Yin's Definition of Case Study Methods
•Case study research involves investigating a contemporary phenomenon in-depth, within its real-world context
•Yin's definition of case study methods focuses on "contemporary phenomena," but he warns against extending back to the "dead" past
•Yin's limitation of the value of history contrasts with the transversal element of the CCS approach
•Yin struggles with conceptualizing context and its relationship to delineating a "case"
•He distinguishes case study from experiments and surveys, but blurs the boundaries between phenomenon and context
•His notion of context risks promoting a "context as container" idea, limiting the aspiration to generate theory or insights that will generalize to other cases
•Yin assumes that a complex case study can be created through the amalgamation of variables, and suggests using multiple methods of data collection for verification
Case Study Methodology
•The term "data points" refers to the complexity of the case and its context, with a multitude of variables, raising doubts about the usefulness of conventional variable-based methods in analyzing case study data.
•Yin contended that a case is not a single 'data point' and suggested that any good case study will present a multitude of data about a phenomenon of interest.
•Yin criticized conventional variable-based methods while questioning their usefulness in case study analysis.
•"Holistic approaches" refer to the ability of the case study method to retain the holistic and meaningful characteristics of real-life events, emphasizing the irreducibility of context, leading to a sense that "context" must be taken as a whole, which in turn makes analysis difficult and leads the researcher toward mere description.
•The essential step of defining the study according to Yin involves "bounding the case," which refers to establishing the general definition of the case, clarifying boundaries with regard to the time covered by the case study, relevant social groups, organizations, or geographic areas, the type of evidence to be collected, and the priorities for data collection and analysis.
•Yin, along with other methodologists, insists on "bounding" the case by time, activity, definition, and context to maintain a reasonable and feasible scope for the study.
•The notion of bounding the case from the outset is considered problematic as it aligns more fully with a neo-positivist and variance-oriented design, which predefines variables and hypothesizes relationships, than with the iterative approach typically associated with case studies.
Critique of Yin's Variance-Oriented Approach to Case Study Research
•Processual designs more common in qualitative work
•A priori efforts to "bound the case" rely on limited notions of context and comparison
•Yin's work emphasizes variance and a neo-positivist epistemology
•Yin applied positivist notions of validity to case study work
•Yin promoted a distinct notion of generalizability for single case studies
•Yin urged replication for multiple case studies to achieve external validity
•Yin's work understates the value of case studies in social science research
•Critique of Yin's variance-oriented approach to case study research
•Maintaining a historical perspective on research approaches
Comparative Research in Case Studies
•Even if historical (transversal) comparison is not the central focus of a CCS, it can provide essential background information for the study.
•The notion of context as historically produced and multi-scalar redirects the impetus to treat a case as "holistic" and hence as difficult to analyze.
•Questioning the need to "bound" the case, a priori, in any definitive sense, and promoting careful, evolving, iterative attention to the contours of the research design and how boundaries perceived by participants come to be meaningful.
•Differing from Yin in reliance on the concepts of validity, reliability, and generalizability, as these are not necessarily the most appropriate ways to apprehend the quality of a process-oriented study.
•Some scholars recommend a parallel framework of trustworthiness, with a focus on the adequacy of the data and interpretation, as more congruent with naturalistic research.
•Engagement in comparison other than by embracing a logic of replication, which runs counter to a process-oriented approach to comparison as advocated.
•Identifying a variance-oriented case study and analyzing its approach to context, culture, comparison, variance, quality, strengths, and weaknesses.
•Consideration of revising research questions to make them more appropriate for a variance-oriented approach and assessing the potential strengths and weaknesses of these revisions.
•Understanding participants' sense-making of events or phenomena.
•Emphasis on symbolic aspects of experience, asking how and why people act in certain ways.
Interpretivist Approaches to Case Studies
•Robert Stake's methods book, "The Art of Case Study Research" exemplifies interpretivist approaches to case studies
•Influenced by his background in psychometrics and educational assessment, as well as reading biography and ethnography
•Case study work is compared to creating art
•Stake addressed a range of interpretive orientations toward case study research
•Contemporary qualitative researchers hold that knowledge is constructed rather than discovered
•An emphasis on meaning, seeking out emic meanings held by the people within the case
•Promoted a flexible design that shifts in the course of research
•Cases might be valued for their "intrinsic" value or "instrumental" if they serve to provide theoretical insights or reconsider generalizations
•Divergence from Stake's interpretivist orientation in considering power relations and social structures
•Underemphasizing the power of cases to generate theoretical insights that transfer to other cases
•Misunderstandings of case studies and the question of generalizability
Case
•Falsification allows for understanding cases in a theoretical manner, as well as for transferring insights to different contexts.
•Qualitative researchers can create a case that "tells its own story", but this approach does not consider power dynamics, representation, or ethical engagement in research.
•Stake adopts a functionalist notion of cases as "bounded systems" with working parts and patterns of behavior.
•Stake's approach to the case may overlook context and comparison, as boundaries are made rather than found, and direct comparison can obscure knowledge about a particular case.
•Stake values thick description over direct comparison, as it focuses on the uniqueness and complexities of a case.
Understanding Multiple Case Studies
•Stake acknowledges the value of the multiple case study in his later publication
•The unique life of the case is interesting for what it can reveal about the quintain
•The concept of the quintain, as presented by Stake, remains rather confusing
•The quintain is what is being sought across cases
•Stake uses the Step by Step program as an example of the quintain
•Three main criteria for case selection: relevance to the quintain, diversity across contexts, and good opportunities to learn about complexity and contexts
•Analysis of comparative cases involves looking for correspondence, covariation, and correlation
•Comparison of multiple case studies illuminates larger phenomena and how context shapes social life
•CCS heuristic values multiple cases and encourages comparison across three axes: horizontal, vertical, and transversal
•Sharan Merriam's work on case studies is influential in some fields
Interpretivist Approach in Qualitative Research
•Qualitative research is based on the philosophical assumption that reality is constructed by individuals interacting with their social worlds.
•Researchers focused on understanding the meaning or knowledge constructed by people, and how they make sense of their experiences.
•Merriam emphasizes using inductive reasoning to derive analytical statements.
•The primary interest of qualitative researchers is to understand the process or causal explanations of impact or outcomes.
•There are three types of cases (particularistic, descriptive, and heuristic) and three purposes for them (descriptive, interpretive, and evaluative). This limited definition retains a reduced aspiration for greater theoretical import.
•There is a move away from a variance-oriented view of case study research to a more interpretivist approach.
Qualitative Case Studies and the Role of Holism
•Qualitative case studies are characterized by being holistic, empirical, interpretive, and empathic, as described by Stake.
•Holistic in this context refers to the interrelationship between the phenomenon (case) and its context, as explained by Merriam and Yin.
•Holism, as a concept, has been linked to a traditional notion of culture and a functionalist theoretical stance in classical ethnographies, leading to a claim to value holism that may conflate case and context.
•The contemporary notion of holism in interpretive case studies is limited to thick description, a dedication to "the particular," and a reduced notion of context that does not attend to broader processes and trends.
•Instead of bounding the case to the particular, the proposed approach suggests an iterative and contingent tracing of relevant factors, actors, and features.
•Exercise 2.2 instructs the reader to identify an interpretivist case study and evaluate how it addresses context, culture, comparison, meaning generated by participants, research quality, generalizability, significance, strengths, and weaknesses in relation to their own study topic and research questions.
Process-Oriented Approaches and the CCS Approach
•The CCS approach diverges from established approaches in several important ways, adopting what Maxwell called a process orientation.
•Process approaches tend to see the world in terms of people, situations, events, and the processes that connect these, with explanation based on an analysis of how some situations and events influence others.
•The CCS approach avoids the interpretive refusal to consider causation and the variance-oriented notion of causation, instead insisting on an emergent design, a hallmark of qualitative research.
•Qualitative researchers don't fully specify methods, theory, or data when they begin their research, starting with ideas, perspectives, or hypotheses, and conducting a systematic and rigorous scientific investigation.
•Heath and Street emphasized the need for researchers to make explicit "decision rules" in their fieldnotes and reproduce them as an "audit trail."
•The CCS approach does not start with a bounded case, and the degree of flexibility in a study will depend on its aims, the researcher's motivations, skills, interests, and available time and resources.
Comparative Case Studies Approach
•The comparative case studies approach seeks not to flatten cases by ignoring valuable contextual information or imposing concepts or categories taken from one site onto another.
•The approach aims to disrupt dichotomies, static categories, and taken-for-granted notions of what is going on.
•It features an iterative and contingent tracing of relevant factors, actors, and features to explore historical and contemporary processes that have produced a sense of shared place, purpose, or identity.
•An example of the study might compare how NGOs are operating in a particular region and contrast their interpretations of a policy with those of the NGO directors in the capital or to the NGOs’ donors in another country, challenging the traditional replication design concept.
•The approach aims to understand and incorporate, at least partially, the perspectives of social actors in the study, which is common to most qualitative research, especially ethnography and ethnographically-oriented studies.
•The CCS approach is also informed by a critical theoretical stance, guided by critical theory and its concerns and assumptions regarding power and inequality.
The CCS Approach to Critical Theory and Case Study Research
•Critical theory aims to critique inequality and change society.
•It studies the cultural production of structures, processes, and practices of power, exploitation, and agency.
•It reveals how hegemonic notions about the social world maintain disparities of various sorts.
•Attention to power and inequality is central to the CCS approach.
•Some interpretivist scholars focus only on local meanings and symbolic systems while downplaying historical and structural forces.
•Variance orientation is a poor fit for the case study research approach.
•The approach doesn’t address the “how” or “why” questions, fundamental to process-oriented case studies.
•The CCS approach unbounds culture while still seeking rich descriptions of the phenomenon of interest to the researcher.
•It is highly productive for the exploration of the cultural politics of policy at multiple scales.
•It calls on researchers to think about achieving cultural understanding of policy production and appropriation through shorter-term research in multiple sites across different scales.
•Both neo-positivist and interpretivist case study approaches miss a major opportunity by not integrating comparison more centrally into their work.
•The processual approach to comparison considers strings of relevant events and actors, eschewing staid notions of culture or context.
•The CCS approach is influenced by extended case methods, multi-sited ethnography, and actor network theory.
Global Connections and Multi-Level Research in Social Science
•Anna Tsing’s theorization of “global connections” emphasizes that seemingly global systems, like capitalism and democracy, operate in specific social contexts and through practical encounters.
•Tsing introduced the metaphor of friction to illustrate how global forces are produced through continuous social interaction and influence, resulting in new cultural and political forms that exclude and enable.
•The study of globalization requires simultaneous attention to multiple levels, including international, national, and local ones, and an examination of flows and frictions of influence, ideas, and actions through these levels.
•Qualitative research must consider the profound changes in the global economy and national politics, making national and international levels of analysis as important as the local.
•Comparative case studies are important for examining interconnections, de-centering the nation-state as the fundamental entity in research, and situating it within a globalized world.
•Multi-level research that situates the nation-state within a world marked by global agencies and agendas is essential, emphasizing the importance of analyzing local–national and local–global connections.
•The goal of comparative case studies research is to develop an in-depth understanding of the particular at each scale and to analyze the interpretations of the policy, problem, or phenomenon under study.
Conceptual Parallel Developments in Globalization
•Extended Case Method developed by Michael Burawoy focuses on individual strategies and tactics in everyday life to counter the excesses of both positivism and interpretivism.
•The method emphasizes participant observation, extension of observations over time and space, extension from micro processes to macro forces, and extension of theory through cases to critique existing theory and develop alternative hypotheses.
•The CCS approach draws on the extended case method to embrace critical theory, generalize theoretically, and compare theoretically similar work done on different topics in different places; however, they diverge from Burawoy in important ways.
•Multi-Sited and Multi-Scalar Ethnography has become a popular research approach, codified by George Marcus, describing how research approaches have become increasingly multi-sited over the past 20 years.
Multi-Sited Ethnography
•Multi-sited research involves following people, connections, associations, and relationships across space, collapsing the global into parallel, related local situations, and rejecting the notion of discrete and timeless cultures.
•Method of multi-sited ethnography involves a spatially dispersed field through which the ethnographer moves, and requires tracing across space and time. It reconceptualizes context to include a sense of places as socially produced across scales.
•Multi-sited ethnography was spurred by recognition of the flow of people, goods, and ideas across space, interconnectivity across dispersed locations, the larger political economic framework, and distributed knowledge systems and active knowledge making among participants in ethnographic studies.
•Possible tracking strategies in multi-sited ethnographic research include following the people, the thing, the metaphor, the plot, the life history, and the conflict.
•Multi-sited projects draw on a translocal formulation of a topic, emphasizing the importance of relationships between sites, which are discovered through the data collection process.
Research Methodology and Spatial Analysis
•The CCS approach reconceptualizes and recasts the notion of translocal in three ways, which include horizontal, vertical, and transversal comparisons to study multiple sites at a single scale, examine commonalities in national or international policymaking, and explore historical formations of horizontal and vertical connections.
•Example of studying school vouchers in Milwaukee requires participant observation, interviews, document analysis, archival work, and consideration of national educational policy politics, involving attention across multiple sites and research techniques.
•The CCS approach entails systematic comparison, emphasizing horizontal comparisons and contrasting sites, while also focusing on linkages between them, emphasizing the contingent and iterative tracing of all relevant factors, actors, and features.
•The research design must respond to regularly evolving cultural, political, and material conditions of the work, as well as collected data, urging qualitative researchers to adopt an interactive, iterative approach, remain flexible, and regularly change the design plan in response.
•The reconceptualization of space as socially produced suggests thinking of space as the product of interrelations, always under construction, requiring a rethinking of the global/local antinomy and moving away from traditional dichotomous views of space.
Global Structures and Ethnographic Methods
•Tsing (2005) and Feldman (2011) have noted a shift in the focus on how global structures influence local practices, and the decomposition of ethnographic location as traditional units of study are critiqued.
•Globalization and transnationalism challenge ethnographic methods of inquiry, prompting the need for new methodological approaches.
•Biao Xiang's concept of "multi-scalar ethnography" considers how social phenomena are constituted through actions at different scales, with smooth flows at one scale being disruptive at another.
•Social actors engage in "scale-making," developing and sustaining understandings of different scales and projecting possible futures.
•Researchers must be reflexive about their own scalar positionality and how it influences data collection and analysis, as scale influences what is observed and revealed.
•The act of scaling disrupts the idea of the stationary anthropological object of observation, and researchers must maintain critical reflexivity about their methodological decisions and impact on findings.
Importance of Considering Different Scales and Actor Network Theory
•Considering different scales and their intersections is important for tracking cultural production and exploring various sites and scales.
•Actor Network Theory (ANT) is a conceptual and methodological approach that enhances comparative case studies by studying connections and interactions among actors within networks.
•ANT focuses on dynamic actors and resources within assemblages, considering how they get invited, excluded, and enrolled in networks, and how social acts curtail or facilitate future actions.
•ANT insists on following ongoing processes made up of uncertain, fragile, controversial, and ever-shifting ties, rather than fitting actors and activities into bounded categories or geographical locations.
•ANT emphasizes the role of non-human actors, dissolving binaries by focusing on interactions among actors within networks rather than their location within it.
•Comparative case studies examine spatially non-contiguous assemblages of actors across scales, drawing from diverse places, epochs, and discourses.
•Anthropologist Kirsten Hastrup's study of climate change in the Arctic exemplifies how discussions and activities draw from numerous places, diverse epochs, and reigning discourses.
•Hastrup's fieldwork redefines the notion of field, considering it a plastic space where the fieldworker's attention may vary.
Comparative Case Study Heuristic
•Fields are emergent and mutable, taking different shapes and sizes based on different perspectives.
•Fieldwork must follow traceable connections before attempting to sum up the whole ingredients.
•Adequate case studies depend on the quality of questions posed and the methods used to address them, not just time in the field.
•Comparative case studies cannot be bounded from the start and looks across scales, considering how scales intersect.
•Actor network theory is one conceptual and methodological approach, emphasizing tracing across similar and contrastive cases, as well as historical comparison.
•Research questions suggest a particular design for conducting a comparative case study, including multi-sited, multi-scalar, and actor network theory utilization.
•It is recommended to start diagramming the study on a whiteboard to think creatively and expansively in the project development phase.
•The chapter examined and critiqued existing models of case study research, problematizing boundedness and reconsidering notions of context and culture.
Understanding Case Studies and Comparison
•Context should not be defined as place or location, but as something spatial and relational.
•Culture should be viewed as an ongoing, contested production rather than a static, bounded notion.
•The chapter showed how the CCS approach has been shaped by reading work on the extended case method, multi-sited and multi-scalar ethnography, and actor network theory.
•In the next three chapters, the CCS approach will be elaborated by taking up each of the three central axes—the horizontal, the vertical, and the transversal—in turn and illustrating their use with studies by doctoral students and more established scholars.
•Ragin emphasizes the use of variables and the relationships among them in most variable-oriented research.
•Yin acknowledges that the design of a unit of analysis may change over time based on discoveries during data collection.
•The use of "critical" in this study can be distinguished from other uses in the case study literature, denoting a somewhat typical case or considering factors, variables, or behaviors that are critical to the success or failure.
Case Studies and Ethnography
•Case studies are an examination of an activity or event and their outcomes
•The 'Extended Case Method' considers causal antecedents and actions by actors or agents contributing to the outcome
•Significant references in the field include Appadurai, Becker, Burawoy, and Coleman
•Ethnography is a research practice in the modern metropolis
•Multi-sited ethnography focuses on the translocation of research methods
•Research design encompasses qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods
•Actor-network theory is relevant in an educational context
•The interpretation of cultures in anthropology is a significant theme
•Scales of attention in fieldwork extend from global to local concerns
•Ethnography encompasses language and literacy research
•Walking, breathing, and knowing are associated with footprints through the weather-world
Perspectives on Ethnography and Education Research
•The text provides citations of various works by authors such as Koyama, Latour, Lincoln, Marcus, Marston, Massey, Maxwell, Merriam, Miles, Nespor, Ong, O'Reilly, Patton, Ragin, and Stake.
•Topics covered include qualitative research, naturalistic inquiry, ethnography, and educational scale-making.
•The authors discuss the generation and manipulation of data, while also addressing the social construction of scale and the emergence of multi-sited ethnography.
•Several works delve into case studies and qualitative data analysis, with attention to aspects like trustworthiness and authenticity in naturalistic evaluation.
•There is also a focus on comparative education and global assemblages, particularly in relation to technology, politics, and ethics as anthropological problems.
Ethnography and Case Study Research
•The text includes various books and articles related to ethnography and case study research.
•Authors like Stake, Trochim, Tsing, van der Veer, Wherry, Willis, Trondman, Xiang, and Yin are referenced.
•The focus is on topics such as multiple case study analysis, global situations, comparison, critical engagement with migration and social change, design and methods for case study research, and applications of case study research.