W1, L2

Incapacity: Persons of Unsound Mind (Mentally Disordered Persons)

  • This area of law is governed by both common law and statutes, with statutes taking precedence where they conflict.

  • General Principle: Under common law, a contract entered into by a person of unsound mind is voidable by that person, their representatives, or those with an interest in the contract.

  • Legal Requirements for Avoidance:

    • The person must have been incapable of understanding the general nature of what the contract was about (the Scott and Weiss principle).

    • The other party must have known, or ought to have known, that the person was of unsound mind (the heart against Oconor principle).

  • Distinction from Minors: Unlike minority status (which is absolute until age 1818), mental incapacity involves degrees and fluctuations, such as periods of lucidity or the transient effects of alcohol/substances.

  • Definitions:

    • Voidable: A contract that is valid and enforceable unless and until a party asks for it to be canceled/voided.

    • Void: A contract that is not enforceable at all from the outset.

Evolution of Leading Cases: From Archer and Cutler to heart against Oconor

  • Archer and Cutler (Historical Context):

    • Involved a 7272-year-old woman with dementia who sold land at a price below true value without legal advice.

    • It established two limbs: (1) if the other party knew of the unsound mind, and (2) whether the contract was objectively fair.

  • O'Connor against Harte (Privy Council - Current Leading Case):

    • The facts involved an 8484-year-old man with dementia selling family land; the family sought to set it aside after his death.

    • The Court of Appeal of New Zealand initially confirmed Archer and Cutler, but the Privy Council rejected the second limb (objective fairness).

    • The Principle: A contract is voidable if the other party knows or ought to have known of the unsound mind. However, if the person appears ostensibly sane and there is no unconscionable bargain (impropriety), the contract is enforceable even if the person lacked capacity.

    • Constructive Knowledge: Per Nicholson Jessup, knowledge of incapacity can be inferred if a deal is "too good to be true" or significantly unbalanced.

Determining Unsound Mind: Scott and Weiss

  • "Unsound mind" is a medical concept that lawyers must apply to legal capacity.

  • Legal Test: The central question is whether the person can understand the "general nature" of the particular transaction, not every complex detail.

  • Facts of Scott and Weiss:

    • A farmer in his 70s70s sold his farm to a trust at a government valuation (not commercial value) with an option for his grandson (Wise) to buy it, 100%100\% financed.

    • Scott was later found to have senile dementia and was admitted to hospital under the Mental Health Act 19691969.

    • The Court of Appeal ruled that because Scott could understand the general principle of the transaction (borrowing money/repayment/ownership) when explained, the transaction stood as a contract, not a gift.

Contracts vs. Gifts: Duck and broke

  • Gift Rule: Voluntary transactions or gifts made by a person lacking mental capacity are void at the instance of the person or their representative.

  • Duck and broke Case:

    • An 8787-year-old (Dach) with senile dementia signed a document allowing a defendant to live rent-free on his property until death.

    • Because there was no reciprocity (no consideration), it was ruled a gift.

    • Unlike a contract, there is no requirement to prove the person failed to understand the general nature; the lack of capacity alone allows it to be set aside.

Exceptions for Unsound Mind: Statute and Necessaries

  • Exception 1: Protection of Personal and Property Rights Act 19881988:

    • Under Section 5353, if a manager is appointed by the Family Court to handle a person's affairs, the manager can apply to have contracts set aside.

  • Exception 2: Contract of Necessaries:

    • Governed by Section 124(2)124(2) of the CCLA (Contract and Commercial Law Act).

    • A person of unsound mind must pay a "reasonable price" for goods supplied if they are "necessaries."

    • Definition of Necessaries: Goods suitable to the person's condition/station in life and their actual requirements at the time of sale and delivery.

    • Historical Case (Peter Flaming): A gold watch was considered a necessary for the son of a Member of Parliament to maintain his social status in 18401840.

    • Roads Case: Items are not necessaries if they were supplied as an act of charity.

Incapacity: Drunkenness and Substance Influence

  • The same general rules for unsound mind apply to those under the influence of alcohol or other substances.

  • Degree of Intoxication Rule:

    • Extreme Intoxication: Deprives a person of all reason and the ability to consent; the contract is void.

    • Loss of Business Sense: If the drunkenness only impairs judgment/business sense, the contract is at most voidable.

  • Case Law:

    • Peter Shimansky: Vendor with an alcohol problem was found to have understood the contract despite drinking because he could discuss fine print and details.

    • Kirk and McGavin: An alcoholic vendor was too drunk on the day an offer was made, but the court found he had sufficient "business sense" the next day when sobered up enough to negotiate, despite regretting it the following day.

  • Burden of Proof: The onus is entirely on the incapacitated person to provide factual evidence that they lacked capacity and that the other party took advantage.

Introduction to Victimization

  • Victimization is an umbrella common law doctrine covering: (1) Duress, (2) Undue Influence, and (3) Unconscionability.

  • It centers on the lack of "free and full consent" (vitiated consent).

  • Equity Influence: Equity provides remedies (voidability), but these must be sought quickly; a party cannot wait indefinitely after realizing their consent was missing.

  • Theoretical Basis: Classical contract theory (Will Theory) presumes parties contract with free will. While common law originally protected only those who could manage their own affairs (lords and landowners), equity provided protections for the "weaker party."

Duress: Person, Property, and Economic

  • Duress involves coercion or pressure that forces a party to contract against their will.

  • Types of Duress:

    • To the Person: Actual violence or threats of death, injury, or imprisonment (Barton against Armstrong, where a director signed under death threats).

    • To Goods: Unlawful seizure, damage, or destruction of goods (pressure must be "irresistible").

    • Economic Duress: Threats affecting economic interests or well-being. This is the most common modern form.

  • Economic Duress Case (Atlas Express Limited against CAFCO):

    • CAFCO had a vital contract to supply baskets to Woolworths.

    • Atlas Express (delivery) realized they miscalculated carton sizes and threatened not to deliver unless the contract was changed to their advantage.

    • CAFCO signed unwillingly because they had no reasonable alternative truckers and would lose the Woolworths deal.

    • The court ruled this was economic duress (voidable) because it was signed under compulsion and illegitimate pressure.

Criteria for Economic Duress

  • Univers Township of Monrovia against International Transport Worker Federation (House of Lords):

    • Involves two elements: (1) Compulsion of the will/Absence of choice; (2) Illegitimacy of the pressure.

  • Pharmacy care system against Attorney General (New Zealand Court of Appeal) Unpacked Elements:

    1. A threat or pressure.

    2. The threat/pressure must be improper (illegitimate).

    3. The victim's will must be overborne by improper pressure.

    4. The pressure induces manifestations of assent.

    5. The threat is grave enough to justify assent (no reasonable alternative).

    6. Resulting agreement is voidable.

    7. The victim has not affirmed the agreement (equity requirement).

  • SAS Case (Attorney General for England and Wales against R):

    • A soldier (R) claimed he signed an SAS non-disclosure agreement under duress because his only other choice was to leave the unit.

    • The court found the pressure was not illegitimate; a non-disclosure clause was standard for secret service work, and joining the SAS was a choice.

Framework for Analyzing Duress in Exams

  • Students must discuss three points when identifying a duress problem:

    1. Was there a threat or coercion of illegitimate pressure?

    2. Did that threat result in the victim being coerced (loss of free will) into the agreement?

    3. Did the victim affirm the agreement after the pressure was removed?

Questions & Discussion

  • Question: Regarding the Family Court orders, when does that situation apply?

  • Response: It applies once the order is active. If no order is in place, common law capacity rules apply.

  • Question: Are there tutorials today? My timetable says one at 33 PM but no one showed up.

  • Response: The lecturer is not the course coordinator and was unaware of tutor absences. She promised to check on the status of tutorials and problem questions related to victimization.

  • Question: In civil law vs. common law, is the focus more on positive law or natural law/morals?

  • Response: The lecturer finds the common law's mix of precedent and equity sometimes logically dissatisfying and points out that areas like employment law are often poorly geared to address power imbalances.

  • Question: What was the solution/remedy for the CAFCO case?

  • Response: Remedies typically involve financial compensation or putting parties back into their original positions (restitution), though it depends on whether the contract was voided and what damages occurred.