Stress Notes
Stress
Part 1 — The Physiology of Stress
General Adaptation Syndrome (GAS): Proposed by Selye (1936), suggests that stress aids adaptation to new situations through three stages:
Alarm Reaction: Immediate physiological response upon perceiving a stressor.
Increased activity of the sympathetic branch of the autonomic nervous system, as dictated by the hypothalamus.
Resistance: Body’s attempt to resist stressor by consuming energy resources during short-term stress. Increased activity in the parasympathetic branch occurs as stress becomes chronic to reduce heightened physiological responses.
Exhaustion: Original physiological symptoms return; energy resources are drained leading to immunosuppression and diseases of adaptation (e.g., cardiovascular disease (CVD), hypertension).
Animal Studies Evidence: Evidence supports the three stages of stress responses through studies on rats, exposed to stressors like extreme exercise. Findings showed similar responses across stressors within 6 to 48 hours, despite physiological differences between species.
Physiological Responses: Two types:
Acute Stress: Involves immediate stressors, with information sent via sensory neurons to the hypothalamus, increasing sympathetic activity.
Example effects include adrenaline and noradrenaline release, resulting in vasoconstriction, pupil dilation, and rectum contraction.
Once the immediate threat is gone, parasympathetic activity increases to decrease sympathetic effects (the ‘rest and digest’ response).
Chronic Stress: Activation of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal system (HPA), producing prolonged effects.
Corticotropin-releasing factor (CRF) leads to pituitary gland activity, releasing adrenocorticotropic hormone (ACTH), which prompts cortisol (the stress hormone) release.
a negative feedback system helps reduce cortisol levels by lowering ACTH and CRF output from the HPA system, preventing excessive damage.
Beta Bias in Research: Early studies predominantly used male lab mice, underestimating gender differences in stress response. Assumed that findings applicable to males also apply to females. Taylor et al (2006) introduced the 'tend and befriend' concept as an alternative strategy for females, emphasizing social bonding for stress management.
Real-Life Applications: Understanding stress responses has led to improved treatments, such as for Addison's Disease, characterized by inadequate cortisol secretion. Enhanced knowledge of cortisol's role in feedback systems could lead to effective cortisol replacement therapies.
Part 2 — The Role of Stress in Illness
Cortisol and Immunosuppression: Continuous cortisol release from the HPA leads to direct immunosuppression and increased risk of illness via lifestyle factors such as insomnia and disrupted eating habits.
Acute Stress Example (Kiecolt-Glaser et al, 1984): Exam pressure caused a reduction in natural killer and T killer cells in medical students during exams compared to pre-exam samples. This supports the link between HPA activity and immunosuppression.
Chronic Stress Example (Wilbert-Lampen et al, 2008): Studied football events, finding a 2.66 increase in myocardial infarction instances during the World Cup, suggesting chronic stress is a significant risk factor.
Differential Effects: Research by Dharbhar (2008) indicated that acute stress might enhance immune functioning in rats, hinting at nuance in stress effects.
Unrelated Diseases: Stress can also influence unrelated diseases like HIV; Pereira et al (2003) found correlation between stress experiences and pre-cancerous lesions in HIV-positive women.
Practical Implications: Public health guidelines could lower stress to reduce disease progression, impacting healthcare costs and treatment strategies.
Methodological Issues: Most studies utilize non-human animals exposed to stressors dissimilar to human experiences, affecting ecological validity. Individual variability can also skew results.
Part 3 — Sources of Stress: Life Changes
Life Changes and Stress: Positive and negative life changes necessitate adaptations, correlating increased adaptation demand with higher stress levels. Cumulative stress effects from multiple life changes are problematic.
Measuring Stress via SRRS: The Social Readjustment Rating Scale rates life events with Life Change Units (LCU). For instance, divorce LCU = 73; marriage LCU = 50. Holmes and Rahe (1967) found illness likelihood increased with higher LCU scores, particularly beyond a threshold of 300 LCU.
Prospective Studies (Rahe et al, 1970): Confirmed findings that US Navy personnel with high stressful life events pre-deployment had higher illness rates during deployment, indicating predictability of stress in relation to illness types.
Individual Differences in Life Changes: Byrne and Whyte (1980) argue that individual circumstances during life events must be considered, as they can affect stress perception directly.
Correlational Study Issues: Reliance on correlations limits claims about causation, further hindering the understanding of life changes as stress sources.
Daily Hassles vs. Life Changes: DeLongis et al (1988) emphasized distinguishing daily hassles from life changes. Their study suggested cumulative minor hassles induce greater stress than significant life changes.
Part 4 — Sources of Stress: Daily Hassles (Lazarus, 1980)
Characteristics of Daily Hassles: Frequent and predictable occurrences that directly cause stress, differentiated from life changes that lead to stress indirectly. These can be viewed as distal causes of stress.
Coping Process: Lazarus proposed a two-step appraisal process for daily hassles:
Primary Appraisal: Assessing the severity of the hassle.
Secondary Appraisal: Evaluating coping capacity regarding the hassle.
Kanner et al (1981) Study: Compared effects of daily hassles against major life changes, indicating daily hassles could be more stressful. Participants measured mental health symptoms and reported daily hassles.
Part 5 — Sources of Stress: Workplace Stress
Key Factors: Workload and control are central to workplace stress as proposed by the job demand-control model (Karasek, 1979). Control over work is more significant than workload.
Research Findings (Bosma et al, 1997): No correlation between stress-related illnesses and workload among 10,000 civil servants; instead, a strong negative correlation occurred between control and stress-related disorders.
Empirical Evidence (Johansson et al, 1978): Studied Swedish factory workers, showing finishers with low job control displayed higher stress markers than cleaners with more control, supporting Karasek’s model.
Confounding Variables: Whitehall studies lacked control over other relevant factors affecting workplace stress like pay, colleagues, and task pressures.
Self-Efficacy Influence: Meiser et al (2008) suggested self-efficacy perceptions could contribute to stress levels; individuals with high confidence may feel frustrated by little control.
Part 6 — Measuring Stress
Self-Report Measures: Main tools include Social Readjustment Rating Scale (SRRS) and Hassles and Uplift Scale.
SRRS: 43 items ranked on a scale of 1-43 based on LCU values derived from participant ratings.
Hassles Scale: Developed by Kanner et al (1981), consisting of 117 items of varying severity assessed on a three-point scale.
Uplift Scale: A polar measure assessing positive events countering stress, comprising 135 items.
Physiological Measures: Include skin conductance responses (SCR) recorded under stress-inducing conditions to provide objective stress assessment.
Validity Issues: Subjectivity in self-report measures can lead to varying interpretations; different participants may understand scales differently (e.g., ‘death of a friend’ varies in meaning).
Part 7 — Individual Differences in Stress - Personality Type
Personality Types and Health Outcomes: Certain types are linked to stress-related illnesses, primarily observed in Type A personalities, characterized by competitiveness and hostility, which correlate with coronary heart disease (CHD).
Friedman and Rosenman's Research: Among the study of 3000 men, 70% of those developing CHD had Type A traits.
Type B Personality is less competitive and more relaxed compared to Type A individuals, potentially indicating lower stress susceptibility.
Type C Personality: Proposed by Temoshok (1987) as individuals keen to please, often leading to emotional suppression often linked with depression.
Age as a Confounding Factor: Greer and Morris (1975) proposed age may obscure findings linking personality types to stress incidences post-50.
Part 8 — Individual Differences in Stress: Hardiness
Definition of Hardiness: Describes resilience and adaptability to daily changes, providing existential courage.
Three Hardiness Dimensions: Commitment, challenge, control correlate with stress resilience.
Research Evidence: Kobasa (1979) found managers displaying hardiness coped better with stress, with a notable relationship between hardiness and management outcomes.
Biofeedback Studies: Bartone’s Dispositional Resilience Scale (2000) may improve measurement levels of hardiness, highlighting the need for clearer metrics.
Part 9 — Managing and Coping with Stress: Drug Therapy
Medications: Primary drugs are Benzodiazepines (e.g., Xanax) and Beta Blockers (e.g., Propranolol).
Benzodiazepines: Act on GABA neurotransmitters altering neural excitability, reducing stress-related impulse transmission.
Beta Blockers: Prevent physiological symptoms of stress by blocking adrenaline/noradrenaline effects in the sympathetic pathways.
Placebo Effect Studies: Baldwin et al (2013) reinforced effectiveness of benzodiazepines against placebo, but concerns prevail over side effects and dependency.
Concerns: Dependence risks, tolerance effects, and severe side effects lead to recommendations for alternative treatments.
Part 10 — Managing and Coping with Stress: Stress Inoculation Therapy (Meichenbaum and Cameron)
Concept: Cognitive-based therapy aimed at changing perceptions of stress, requiring three stages: conceptualization, skills acquisition, real-world application.
Stage Process: Conceptualization identifies stressors; skills acquisition develops coping techniques, and real-life application involves practice and role-play.
Focus on flexibility allows tailored treatment approaches for individuals.
Advantages in treating chronic stress, as SIT equips individuals with long-term coping skills.
Critiques: Some argue a lack of emphasis on individual control perspectives, potentially classifying treatment less effective for those with perceived powerlessness.
Part 11 — Managing and Coping with Stress: Biofeedback
Objective: Enhance patient control over physiological stress responses through monitoring mechanisms (e.g., EEG, spirometer).
Process: Individuals learn to modify their physiological stress reactions to lower baseline levels using biofeedback.
Game Mechanism: Techniques are practiced in a stimulating format (e.g., completing games), reinforcing positive behavior.
Effectiveness Evidence: Contrada (1989) demonstrated biofeedback's ability to stabilize physiological responses, affirming integration as an effective therapy.
Limitations: Requires high individual motivation and commitment, focusing on a narrow type of personality may limit applicability.
Part 12 — Gender Differences in Coping with Stress
Coping Strategies: Men typically adopt problem-solving approaches (distal), while women engage in emotional-focused tactics (proximal).
Proof of Mechanisms: Peterson et al (2006) distinguished approaches in infertile populations across genders. Women exhibited blame acceptance; men, practical resolution seeking.
Tend and Befriend Effect: For women, Taylor et al (2000) described an evolutionary survival tactic focusing on social bonding instead of fight-or-flight responses.
Oxytocin's Role: Enhances social bonding effects in women, modulating HPA response differences based on testosterone impacts.
Retrospective Research Issues: Differences noted may stem from cognitive biases in identifying coping strategies—overestimating gender distinctions.
Part 13 — The Role of Social Support in Coping with Stress
Definition of Social Support: Emphasizes the importance of integrated social contacts and tight bonds for effective stress coping.
Types of Support: Three kinds identified: instrumental, emotional, and esteem support, which don't necessarily require physical presence in supporting contexts (e.g., sending cards).
Effectiveness Evidence: Cohen et al (2015) found hugs (emotional support) can strengthen immune response against common colds, showcasing the immunoenhancing effects.
Gender Differences in Use: Luckow et al (1998) illustrate that women engage social supports more actively, reflecting emotion-focused coping while men favor problem-solving.
Instability of Support: Social support may not always be beneficial; excessive or inappropriate support can aggravate stress.
Support Population Studies: Fawzy et al (1993) linked social support to improved survival and immunological factors in cancer patients, affirming supportive communal structures' importance in stress management.