Creation Stories and Cosmogony

Creation Stories Across Cultures

  • Most cultures have stories about creation or beginnings, often multiple and sometimes incompatible.
  • The featured texts are genealogically related, representing branches of ancient creation literature originating in Mesopotamia and flourishing in Greece and Rome.
  • Authors from Babylonia, Egypt, Hittites, Canaan, Israel, Greece, and Rome reworked traditional themes, enriching them with new elements.
  • Common motifs reveal kinship, contact, and mutual influence among ancient Mediterranean peoples.

Cosmogony and Theogony

  • Cosmogonies are stories about the birth of the cosmos, often starting with natural elements like Earth, Sky, primordial waters, Chaos, or the Void.
  • These elements may be presented as divine but generally lack anthropomorphic personalities.
  • Cosmogony is followed by theogony, which explains the birth and family relations of the gods and their power struggles.
  • This can lead to anthropogony (origin of humankind) and human genealogies.
  • These myths and legends provide a "brief history of time," with genealogical succession stretching from the poet's age to the origin of all things.
  • Transition from cosmic entities to anthropomorphic gods and then to humans parallels the perceived movement of the universe from simplicity to complexity.
  • The universe evolves from a less differentiated state to an orderly cosmos governed by gods and heroes in complex relationships.

Polytheism and Divine Rule

  • Creation myths are products of polytheist societies that worship many gods.
  • The pantheon often forms a divine family, such as the gods of Olympos.
  • Gods may also be political adversaries, as in the Baal Cycle.
  • Even the Hebrew Bible, a monotheist text, replaced a previous polytheist schema, traces of which survive in Genesis and some Psalms.
  • In theogonies, one god rules over the cosmos, imposing order, making heaven a monarchy.
  • The most powerful god is represented as a king whose position is accepted but often threatened.
  • Threats can come from sons (Kronos by Zeus), distant relations (Tiamat by Marduk), cupbearers (Anu by Kumarbi), or rival divine lords (Baal by Mot).
  • These contests are resolved by the accession of a new king and the emergence of a new order.
  • This divine hierarchy mirrored the monarchic regimes of the societies that produced these myths.
  • The chain of kings in heaven had a parallel in Near Eastern and Greek king lists, with the latter being shorter and corresponding to a single dynasty.
  • Euhemerists later argued that the gods were originally kings worshipped by their followers.

Succession Myths and Divine Conflicts

  • The governing god often fears losing control; struggles with rivals are a persistent feature.
  • This is sometimes called a "succession myth," exemplified in the Hittite Song of Birth and Hesiod's Theogony.
  • The king in heaven faces threats from rival gods and monsters created by them, like the giant rock Ullikummi and the serpent Hedammu in the Kumarbi Cycle, and Typhon/Typhoeus in the Theogony.
  • Conflicts can include savage acts such as castration (Kronos to Ouranos), swallowing genitals (Kumarbi with Anu), swallowing children (Kronos), or gobbling up a pregnant wife (Zeus to Metis).
  • These acts lead to unnatural births from male deities (Athena from Zeus' head, Teshub from Kumarbi).
  • Such acts represent attempts to interrupt the natural continuity of rule, control female procreation, and prevent succession.

Survival and Authority of Cosmogonic Texts

  • Surviving cosmogonic texts are a fraction of those produced, capturing only a small part of oral performance and religious knowledge.
  • The book of Genesis became part of scripture and remains a definitive account for many.
  • The Enuma Elish was recited as a hymn in honor of Marduk at the New Year's Akitu festival in Babylon.
  • The religious authority or canonical status of other texts is difficult to establish.
  • There were no mechanisms in Greece to establish religious uniformity or treat any one text as authoritative.

Authorship and Tradition

  • The composers of these texts are often unknown, especially in the Near East.
  • These works are literary versions of older, anonymous, oral traditions.
  • It is difficult to assess how much the writer departed from oral tradition or how their version compared to others.
  • Professional scribes, possibly commissioned by religious authorities, consolidated "standard" versions of myths.
  • Sometimes, scribes' names are known (Ilimilku and Sin-liqe-unninni for the Baal Cycle and Gilgamesh, respectively), but their role as "authors" is hard to evaluate.
  • Scholars believe some scribes had an independent poetic voice based on the quality and uniform style of their texts.

Evolution of Authorship

  • Beginning with Homer and Hesiod, literary works became more strongly identified with individual authors.
  • Greek and Roman authors like Apollonios, Virgil, and Ovid shaped their creations with knowledge of existing myths, adapting and innovating as they saw fit.
  • Hesiod's works quickly became canonical, although it's unclear if they represented contemporary Greek thought.
  • Subsequent Greek and Roman authors incorporated cosmogony, with new twists, into their epic poetry, comedy, and philosophy.

Decline and Shift in Religious Thought

  • The production of cosmogonies declined due to a shift in religious thought.
  • Neoplatonism promoted belief in an eternal world with a permanent metaphysical hierarchy, incompatible with cosmogony.
  • The rise of Christianity imposed a theological model with one unchanging God without rivals.
  • "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God" (John 1.1).
  • After the fourth century CE, the Father and the Son were declared the same deity, forestalling divine conflict.
  • Elaborations on God's creation and the role of Adam and Eve occupied a central place in Jewish and Christian texts outside canonical books.
  • Gnostic texts, Christian apocryphal texts, Jewish pseudepigrapha, Kabbalah, and the Dead Sea Scrolls proliferated due to new discoveries.

Mesopotamian Creation Epic: Enuma Elish

  • The narrative poem Eramu Elis, called Enuma Elish (