Schenck v US

Schenck v. United States (1919)

Background/Facts

  • Schenck and other defendants were charged under the Espionage Act with conspiring to obstruct military recruiting and enlistment during World War I.

  • They printed and distributed leaflets to men who had been called for military service, criticizing the draft and urging recipients to assert their rights and oppose it.

  • The defendants were convicted and argued that the First Amendment protected their freedom of speech.

Constitutional Issue

  • Whether the First Amendment’s protection of freedom of speech protected the defendants from criminal liability for distributing the anti-draft leaflets.

  • Specifically, whether the speech created a danger that Congress had the constitutional authority to prevent.

Rule/Legal Test or Doctrine

  • The Court asked whether the words were used in circumstances and were of such a nature as to create a clear and present danger of bringing about substantive evils that Congress had a right to prevent.

  • The Court described this as a question of proximity and degree.

  • Speech that might be constitutionally protected in ordinary times could be restricted depending on the circumstances in which it was used.

Holding

  • The Court upheld the defendants’ convictions.

  • The defendants’ distribution of the circulars could be punished because the circumstances, tendency, and intent supported finding that they were intended to obstruct the draft.

  • The judgments were affirmed.

Court’s Reasoning

  • The leaflets were intended to have an effect on people subject to the draft, and the Court found that effect could be to influence them to obstruct the draft.

  • The First Amendment does not provide identical protection for speech in every circumstance; the character of an act depends on the circumstances in which it occurs.

  • During wartime, speech that might be protected during peacetime could constitute a hindrance to the war effort.

  • Actual success in obstructing the draft was not required when the act, its tendency, and the intent were sufficient to fall within the statute.

Significance

  • Established the clear and present danger approach for evaluating whether certain speech could be restricted.

  • Emphasized that the constitutional protection of speech can depend on circumstances, tendency, intent, proximity, and degree.

  • Distinguished speech that might be protected in ordinary times from speech creating a danger Congress could prevent during wartime.

Key Terms

  • First Amendment

  • Freedom of Speech

  • Clear and present danger

  • Proximity and degree

  • Espionage Act

  • Wartime speech

Quiz-Ready Takeaway

  • Schenck = wartime speech + anti-draft leaflets + clear and present danger.

  • The Court focused on whether the speech, in its circumstances and context, created a clear and present danger of an evil Congress could prevent.

  • Speech that may be protected in ordinary circumstances can be restricted when its circumstances, tendency, and intent create the relevant danger.