Reflection Paper 1 Brainstorm

Book: A Black Theology of Liberation by James Cone

Section 1: Author’s thesis and purpose

  • God has a preference for the oppressed, thus God is Black

    • Black in a metaphorical sense, his identity changes based on the racial politics of the area

  • Whiteness must end, encourages violence

  • Christianity is a religion of liberation

Summary of text

  • Chapter 1 Main ideas

    • God identifies w/ the oppressed, false, white christianity denies this (This is biblical)

    • God chooses the Israelites in Exodus due to their oppression, gives them liberation

      • Jesus promotes the poor

      • Resurrection expands God’s favor from the Israelites to all oppressed people

    • Christians are a group of oppressed people who join God in his fight for liberation

    • Theology can never be colorblind

      • God has taken sides in the bible

    • White theology bastardizes God’s work of liberation to oppress people like the NAs

      • Believe Christianity is either separate from oppression or actively supports it

      • White theology focuses on nonviolence and nondisruptive protests

    • Black theology: uses Jesus’s message as a tool to liberate the oppressed

      • God’s revelation is to break free from the chains of oppression

      • Theology helps a community find the purpose of its existence

      • Theology of survival, god does not endorse the suffering of Black ppl

      • Black theology is a theology of passion

    • Bible is not infalliable; it must be interpreted

    • Establishes Blackness as a symbol

    • White people at any time could carry out a Black genocide, like they did w/ the NAs

      • Integration = assimilation

      • Law and order = target Black people

  • Chapter 2

    • Sources of Black theology: Black experience, history, culture, revelation, scripture, tradition

      • What helps form the scripture/theology

      • Purpose of BT is to make sense of the Black experience

      • Black power includes poisioning slavemasters, slave revolts

      • Bible is not the revelation, only Christ is

    • Norm of Black theology: Balance of the Black condition and biblical revelation, norm comes from the community

      • What must a source do to qualify as Black theology

      • Lens of analysis

    • White theology cannot be written for Black people

  • Chapter 3

    • General revelation: all persons know god, liberation is the work of god, oppression is against God

      • Relies again on Exodus

      • Faith required for the liberation to be a revelation

    • Special revelation: Through Christ Black ppl can perceive the nature of being Black and destroy forces of nonbeing

    • Goal is not to win, it’s to be in alignment with God

    • Speaks of God as a symbolic figure to help Black ppl survive oppression

    • BT must connect to the scripture and apply to modern problems

    • Revelation is only for the oppressed

    • Sin for Black people is complying with oppressor

  • Chapter Four

    • God is known in liberation, is not neutral

    • Calls White god an idol

    • White oppression = law and order

    • Black resistance: dangerous, sinful, illegitimate

    • Chose because they are suffering, not suffering due to god’s choices

    • Again refers to God as a symbol in response to atheist critiques

    • Christianity is the base of the Black liberation movement

      • Therefore they must keep God language

    • Must become one with the oppressed, not give to the oppressed

    • God is a balance between love and rightousness

      • Must keep biblical wrath (makes love and principles meaningful)

      • BT says God cannot love white people

    • Does not care about metaphysical debates about the power/existence of God

    • God exists at the center of oppression, didn’t just make Earth than go for milk

  • Chapter 5

    • human personhood discovered in the struggle against oppression

    • Humanity is not an abstract concept

    • Freedom is the center of personhood

    • Theology cannot ignore oppression

    • Cares more about God in the here and now, not proving the God of the Bible

    • First step to freedom is recognizing oppression, second step is throwing your lot with the oppressed

    • Focuses on collective sin, sin is denial of community

    • Sin for white people is participating in white identity

  • Chapter 6

    • Jesus only matters if his life/ministry/presence is read from the side of the oppressed

    • Jesus must be black

    • Historical Jesus is tied to the oppressed, the poor, the sinner

    • White Jesus is dangerous

    • Christ identifies with the suffering community

    • Salvation is liberation

      • Biblical examples of slavery → freedom

  • Chapter 7

    • Church cannot accept law and order

    • Gospel is liberation, Church must proclaim the gospel

    • Church is not the world, but it cannot be isolated

    • Prayer is to remind yourself of the gospel, like a mantra

    • Heaven is less important than the here and now

    • Argues slavemasters used heaven to justify slavery, freedom to do misdeeds now knowing enlightment waits after death

    • Heaven teachs Black people not to fear death in the fight for liberation

    • No elaborate speculation of the future

Critique of text

  • His perception of nonviolence

  • Idea that Black liberation must be Christian (not to negate the powerful institution of the Black Church)

  • Not intersectional

  • Very interested in monotheism, but not much other Christian doctrine

  • Does not adequately address divine providence, choses not to address this


Audience: Black Americans, wants them to come to racial consciousness, primarily for Black people

  • White people may read this book and reap some benefits, but they’re limited

Ideas

  • Religion eases the suffering of Black people

  • White people must want to become Black, end white identity to acheive liberation