Study Notes on American Horror: Genre and History

Introduction to American Horror

  • Discussion on whether "American horror" is a tautology.

  • Leslie Fiedler's assertion in Love and Death in American Novel (1960) that American literature is fundamentally Gothic.

    • Gothic described as "nonrealistic and negative, sadist and melodramatic".

  • Overview of how the Gothic mode migrated from 18th-century Europe to America.

  • Argument that American horror is intertwined with the history and culture of America.

    • American history includes:

    • Atlantic slavery

    • Genocide of Indigenous peoples

    • White supremacy and murders rooted in racism

    • Class struggles and immigration conflicts

    • Imperial violence and fear of nonmale power

    • Societal anxieties regarding nonheterosexual desires

  • American writing reflects the dichotomy of the American Dream versus the American Nightmare.

    • Understanding of horror as a critique of the American nation-state's perceived exceptionalism.

Defining American Horror

  • Inquiry into whether horror is a universal concept within cultures aware of America’s contradictions or a distinct genre with its own codes.

  • The essays compiled in The Cambridge Companion to American Horror show a divergence in opinions on what horror truly is.

    • Texts that are clearly horror-oriented versus those that are not traditionally found in the horror category.

  • Fundamental belief that "American horror" describes a definable cultural object and a tone or affect.

    • It combines a canon and visual/verbal language.

Gothic versus Horror

  • Consideration of the distinctions and blurred lines between Gothic literature and horror.

    • Gothic literature is deemed respectable, while horror is often dismissed as subliterary.

  • Ann Radcliffe's influential distinction between horror and terror in her essay On the Supernatural in Poetry (1826):

    • "Terror and horror are so far opposite, that the first expands the soul, and awakens the faculties to a high degree of life; the other contracts, freezes, and nearly annihilates them."

  • Discussion of how the critical reception of Gothic and horror has evolved:

    • Gothic has gained academic respectability with numerous scholarly resources.

    • Horror has historically been seen as sensational and lacking depth.

Horror’s Critical Reassessment

  • The recent resurgence of serious academic and popular analysis of horror.

  • Examination of influential studies within film studies that take horror seriously, such as:

    • Barbara Creed's The Monstrous-Feminine (1993)

    • Carol J. Clover's Men, Women, and Chain Saws (1992)

  • The reclamation of horror by marginalized voices including women, nonwhites, and nonheterosexuals.

  • Horror, traditionally seen as lacking intellectual rigor, is increasingly recognized for its political and philosophical dimensions.

Complexity of Genre Definitions

  • Importance of recognizing the nuanced differences between Gothic and horror genres:

    • Gothic often correlates with psychological states and European aristocratic themes.

    • Horror tends to focus on immediate, corporeal experiences and contemporary socio-political issues.

  • Horror is characterized as emphasizing the physicality of violence and trauma, contrasting with the psychological preoccupations of Gothic narratives.

  • Example definitions by noted critics:

    • Fred Botting: Gothic literature encompasses disturbances of sanity and emotion, unlike horror which delves deeper into bodily suffering.

    • Jeffrey Weinstock: Gothic centers around the past, whereas horror is more immediate and corporeal.

    • Moto by Fredric Jameson: "History is what hurts," thus horror can be seen as the genre that reveals societal wounds.

The Forms of American Horror

  • Discussion of horror's liminal status in cultural literary studies.

  • Horror invokes taboo and provocative experiences, often excluded from formal literary canon.

    • Consideration of various innovative horror media:

    • Penny dreadfuls, comics, Grand Guignol, and video nasties.

  • Rise of "creepypasta" in the 1990s:

    • Collection of frightening stories spread through internet subculture.

    • Example of how digital culture revitalizes and reinterprets folklore.

Video Games as a Medium for Horror

  • Overview of horror video games that have evolved from earlier genres:

    • Notable series: Silent Hill, Resident Evil originating from 1990s gaming.

  • Innovative narratives and immersive experiences offered by games like:

    • P.T. (a Silent Hill teaser)

    • Limbo (2010) and Stories Untold (2017)

  • Recognition of video games as a legitimate cultural form worthy of study in horror.

The Limitations of Horror Interpretation

  • Horror often eludes straightforward interpretations, challenging traditional academic critiques.

  • Example from Edgar Allan Poe's The Man of the Crowd (1840):

    • Impossibility of clear reading, symbolizing horror's inherent complexity.

  • Fear and violence depicted in horror often resist rationalization and intellectual analysis.

  • Discussion of abjection as described by Julia Kristeva in Powers of Horror (1982):

    • Abjection embodies feelings that resist categorization and understanding.

Understanding Horror Through Various Lenses

  1. Thematic Approach: Texts address societal issues symptomatically without in-depth analysis.

  2. Analytical Approach: Texts diagnose and explain societal issues, often inviting allegorical readings.

  3. Transformative Approach: Texts create community and dialogue among audiences, fostering social collectivity and fandom.

    • This includes fan practices like fan fiction and cosplay.

  • Importance of acknowledging these approaches to fully appreciate horror's complexity.

The Politics of American Horror

  • Exploration of how horror illustrates tensions within Western centrist liberalism.

  • Historical context of American modernity characterized by global political upheavals in the late 18th century (e.g., the American Revolution, French Revolution, etc.).

  • Rise of three ideologies:

    1. Conservatism: Emphasizes tradition and social order.

    2. Socialism: Advocates for transformation and the rights of the laboring class.

    3. Centrist Liberalism: Aims for cautious political reform and equality, often creating new societal binaries.

  • Horror as a medium that explores themes of exclusion, inequality, and the failings of liberal ideals.

Contemporary American Horror’s Evolution

  • Current resurgence of horror showcasing diverse creators and audiences beyond traditional demographics.

  • Shift from white male creators to voices from women, trans, Black, Indigenous, and nonheterosexual communities.

  • Contemporary horror critiques modern liberalism and stands as a medium for societal reimagining and commentary.

Conclusion

  • Positioning The Cambridge Companion to American Horror as both a historical exploration and a guide to the evolving landscape of horror.

  • Hope for horror’s future as it engages with transformative cultural narratives, rooted in the collective struggle against systemic injustices.