Study Notes on American Horror: Genre and History
Introduction to American Horror
Discussion on whether "American horror" is a tautology.
Leslie Fiedler's assertion in Love and Death in American Novel (1960) that American literature is fundamentally Gothic.
Gothic described as "nonrealistic and negative, sadist and melodramatic".
Overview of how the Gothic mode migrated from 18th-century Europe to America.
Argument that American horror is intertwined with the history and culture of America.
American history includes:
Atlantic slavery
Genocide of Indigenous peoples
White supremacy and murders rooted in racism
Class struggles and immigration conflicts
Imperial violence and fear of nonmale power
Societal anxieties regarding nonheterosexual desires
American writing reflects the dichotomy of the American Dream versus the American Nightmare.
Understanding of horror as a critique of the American nation-state's perceived exceptionalism.
Defining American Horror
Inquiry into whether horror is a universal concept within cultures aware of America’s contradictions or a distinct genre with its own codes.
The essays compiled in The Cambridge Companion to American Horror show a divergence in opinions on what horror truly is.
Texts that are clearly horror-oriented versus those that are not traditionally found in the horror category.
Fundamental belief that "American horror" describes a definable cultural object and a tone or affect.
It combines a canon and visual/verbal language.
Gothic versus Horror
Consideration of the distinctions and blurred lines between Gothic literature and horror.
Gothic literature is deemed respectable, while horror is often dismissed as subliterary.
Ann Radcliffe's influential distinction between horror and terror in her essay On the Supernatural in Poetry (1826):
"Terror and horror are so far opposite, that the first expands the soul, and awakens the faculties to a high degree of life; the other contracts, freezes, and nearly annihilates them."
Discussion of how the critical reception of Gothic and horror has evolved:
Gothic has gained academic respectability with numerous scholarly resources.
Horror has historically been seen as sensational and lacking depth.
Horror’s Critical Reassessment
The recent resurgence of serious academic and popular analysis of horror.
Examination of influential studies within film studies that take horror seriously, such as:
Barbara Creed's The Monstrous-Feminine (1993)
Carol J. Clover's Men, Women, and Chain Saws (1992)
The reclamation of horror by marginalized voices including women, nonwhites, and nonheterosexuals.
Horror, traditionally seen as lacking intellectual rigor, is increasingly recognized for its political and philosophical dimensions.
Complexity of Genre Definitions
Importance of recognizing the nuanced differences between Gothic and horror genres:
Gothic often correlates with psychological states and European aristocratic themes.
Horror tends to focus on immediate, corporeal experiences and contemporary socio-political issues.
Horror is characterized as emphasizing the physicality of violence and trauma, contrasting with the psychological preoccupations of Gothic narratives.
Example definitions by noted critics:
Fred Botting: Gothic literature encompasses disturbances of sanity and emotion, unlike horror which delves deeper into bodily suffering.
Jeffrey Weinstock: Gothic centers around the past, whereas horror is more immediate and corporeal.
Moto by Fredric Jameson: "History is what hurts," thus horror can be seen as the genre that reveals societal wounds.
The Forms of American Horror
Discussion of horror's liminal status in cultural literary studies.
Horror invokes taboo and provocative experiences, often excluded from formal literary canon.
Consideration of various innovative horror media:
Penny dreadfuls, comics, Grand Guignol, and video nasties.
Rise of "creepypasta" in the 1990s:
Collection of frightening stories spread through internet subculture.
Example of how digital culture revitalizes and reinterprets folklore.
Video Games as a Medium for Horror
Overview of horror video games that have evolved from earlier genres:
Notable series: Silent Hill, Resident Evil originating from 1990s gaming.
Innovative narratives and immersive experiences offered by games like:
P.T. (a Silent Hill teaser)
Limbo (2010) and Stories Untold (2017)
Recognition of video games as a legitimate cultural form worthy of study in horror.
The Limitations of Horror Interpretation
Horror often eludes straightforward interpretations, challenging traditional academic critiques.
Example from Edgar Allan Poe's The Man of the Crowd (1840):
Impossibility of clear reading, symbolizing horror's inherent complexity.
Fear and violence depicted in horror often resist rationalization and intellectual analysis.
Discussion of abjection as described by Julia Kristeva in Powers of Horror (1982):
Abjection embodies feelings that resist categorization and understanding.
Understanding Horror Through Various Lenses
Thematic Approach: Texts address societal issues symptomatically without in-depth analysis.
Analytical Approach: Texts diagnose and explain societal issues, often inviting allegorical readings.
Transformative Approach: Texts create community and dialogue among audiences, fostering social collectivity and fandom.
This includes fan practices like fan fiction and cosplay.
Importance of acknowledging these approaches to fully appreciate horror's complexity.
The Politics of American Horror
Exploration of how horror illustrates tensions within Western centrist liberalism.
Historical context of American modernity characterized by global political upheavals in the late 18th century (e.g., the American Revolution, French Revolution, etc.).
Rise of three ideologies:
Conservatism: Emphasizes tradition and social order.
Socialism: Advocates for transformation and the rights of the laboring class.
Centrist Liberalism: Aims for cautious political reform and equality, often creating new societal binaries.
Horror as a medium that explores themes of exclusion, inequality, and the failings of liberal ideals.
Contemporary American Horror’s Evolution
Current resurgence of horror showcasing diverse creators and audiences beyond traditional demographics.
Shift from white male creators to voices from women, trans, Black, Indigenous, and nonheterosexual communities.
Contemporary horror critiques modern liberalism and stands as a medium for societal reimagining and commentary.
Conclusion
Positioning The Cambridge Companion to American Horror as both a historical exploration and a guide to the evolving landscape of horror.
Hope for horror’s future as it engages with transformative cultural narratives, rooted in the collective struggle against systemic injustices.