2.3-2.4 notes part 4

Chapter 2: Civil War and Reconstruction, 1861-77

Overview of the Period

  • Civil War and Reconstruction: The time frame of 1861-1877 marked significant challenges in preserving the Union post-Civil War, focusing particularly on the rights of African Americans.

Black Codes

  • Definition: The Black Codes were laws created in the South after the Civil War to restrict the rights of African Americans.

  • Purpose: They were intended to maintain white supremacy and control over the labor force by limiting the rights of newly freed slaves.

  • Comparison to Black Codes: They were unapologetically referenced as a means of political subjugation of African Americans.

Implications of Radical Reconstruction

  • Radical Republicans intended to enfranchise African Americans, but Southern legislatures employed various tactics to deny rights promised in the 14th and 15th Amendments.

  • Supreme Court Decisions (1873): The Court allowed states to set their own criteria for voting rights, leading to discriminatory practices like poll taxes and literacy tests which targeted black voters specifically.

  • Grandfather Clause: A law that allowed individuals to vote only if their grandfather had voted before, effectively excluding former slaves and their descendants from suffrage.

Ku Klux Klan and White Supremacist Violence

  • Formation: The Ku Klux Klan was formed in 1866, initially as an economic group but quickly evolved into a racist organization using violence to counteract African American progress.

  • Violent Tactics: The KKK used intimidation, threats, and violence to enforce Black Codes and prevent African Americans from voting.

  • Notable Figures: Nathan Bedford Forrest served as its leader, and the organization resorted to methods including lynching and racketeering.

  • Government Response: President Ulysses S. Grant utilized legislation, such as the 1870 Force Act, to combat KKK violence but struggled to curtail new groups that emerged.

Ulysses S. Grant's Presidency

  • Grant was initially supported by Radical Republicans but lacked the mandate to pursue aggressive Reconstruction policies due to political climate changes.

  • His presidency was marked by attempts to pass the 15th Amendment and enforce African Americans’ rights, faced significant challenges from increasing Democratic power in the South.

Political Landscape

  • Decline of Radical Republicanism: Inspired by a combination of scandals and exhaustive efforts, the radical momentum diminished.

  • In the 1874 midterm elections, Democrats regained control of the Senate, demonstrating waning support for Reconstruction and increased difficulty in enforcing reforms.

  • The Amnesty Act (1872) restored political rights to many former Confederates, indicating a trend towards reconciliation and abandonment of Radical policies.

Enforcement Acts and Civil Rights

  • Enforcement Acts of 1870-71: Aimed to implement protections for African Americans, enforce the 14th and 15th Amendments, and combat voter suppression.

  • Civil Rights Act of 1875: Intended to outlaw segregation but fell short of enforcement. Its constitutionality was later struck down by the Supreme Court in 1883.

The Compromise of 1877

  • Marked the end of Reconstruction; an agreement emerged after the contentious election of 1876 where disputed states and allegations of electoral fraud were prevalent.

  • Republican Rutherford B. Hayes needed 185 Electoral College votes to win. The breakdown in the election was as follows:

    • Electoral College Votes:

    • Rutherford B. Hayes (Republican): 165

    • Samuel J. Tilden (Democrat): 184

    • Undetermined: 20 (Florida, Louisiana, South Carolina)

  • Disputed Votes: Allegations of violence against black voters were rampant. In key states, conflicting results caused disputes over who rightfully held power.

  • The Commission: A bipartisan commission was formed to resolve disputes with mixed representation from the Parties, ultimately favoring Hayes' electoral win, signaling the end of Radical Reconstruction efforts.

Conclusion and Reflection

  • End of Reconstruction: By 1876, the South was largely governed by Redeemer governments, signaling a shift back to conservative control and a reluctance to enforce civil rights for African Americans.

  • The era after Reconstruction illustrated a national shift in priorities towards economic interests, ignoring ongoing racial violence and rights issues.