4 and 5

Resource Overexploitation

A. Introduction 

1. Renewable vs nonrenewable resources

  • renewable resources: natural resources that can be replenished naturally over short periods of time, e.g., sunlight, wind, forests, fisheries

  • nonrenewable resources: natural resources that are finite and cannot be regenerated on a human timescale once depleted, e.g. fossil fuels (coal, oil, natural gas), metals, minerals

 2. Definitions of overexploitation 

  • overexploitation: harvesting a renewable resource at a rate faster than it can be replenished, i.e., at a rate greater than the maximum sustainable yield ... or, simply using up nonrenewable resource

3. Centrisms = How we look at things

  • Anthropocentric : humans are at the top 

  • Biocentric: all living things have inherent value

  • Ecocentric : both living and nonliving parts have inherent value 

4. Logistic growth and maximum sustainable yield 


5. Humankind’s impact on the planet B. It’s Not Like We Weren’t Warned 

  1. Pliny the Elder :lamented the deforestation during the roman empire, earliest to document environmental degradation  

  2. Thomas Malthus, The Problem of  Population, 1798:  economist on the principle of population: dangers of population growth outpacing agricultural production: Point of crisis 

  3. George Perkins Marsh, Man and Nature, 1864 4. Jared Diamond and Collapse:  Man and nature, challenged the idea that earth’s resources were inexhaustible 

  4. Jared Diamond and Collapse1937 until now: Collapse: How societies Choose to fail or succeed: Norse greenlanders faced collapse due to their mismanagement of natural resources + importance of learning from history  because role of environmental degradation and resource depletion in the decline of civilizations

C. Overexploited resources (SWOF) 

1. Soil Degradation: loss of the land’s physical, chemical, biological and

ecological qualities 

  • Results in reduced crop yields, increased pollution and flooding, desertification

  • Compaction, salinization, acidification, dehumification, sedimentation

  • What’s missing from the chart? Urban expansion, industrial and mining activities

2. Water Challenges 

  • Water scarcity: lack of sufficient water supplies to meet water usage demands

    • natural causes = climate change, droughts, decreased rainfall

    • human causes = overuse, pollution, waste and

    • inefficient management practices

  • physical vs economic water scarcity

  • Impacts : 

  • Economic ... increased costs, loss of productivity

  • Environmental ... ecosystem degradation, loss of biodiversity

  • Humanitarian ... conflict, health issues, food scarcity

  • green water: water stored in soil and vegetation; used by plants

  • blue water: freshwater found in rivers, lakes, aquifers; available for human activities

3. Ocean Fisheries 

  • Global fish catch has increased  5x since the 1950s

• 90% of top predators have been fished out ☹

• Some practices (explosives, cyanide,muro-ami nets) are more harmful than others

bycatch: inadvertent capture of non-target species

• Substantial collective efforts needed to address this problem

4. Deforestation 

  • deforestation: complete removal of trees and conversion to another land use

• Commodity-driven deforestation ... agricultural

production, mining or energy infrastructure

• Urbanization ... cities and roads

forest degradation: thinning of the canopy, without

change in land use; temporary

• Forest production ... logging for timber, paper and pulp

• Shifting agricultural techniques ... subsistence farming

• Wildfires ... if no land conversion, forests can regrow




5. General Causes 

1. Pressing immediate needs

2. Lack of knowledge or understanding

3. Greed

4. Mental models, e.g., discounting the future

5. Lack of markets

6. tragedy of the commons: a situation in which shared resources

are overused and eventually depleted

D. What Can We Do? 

1. Wicked Problems (Redux) 

  • No definitive formulation 

  • Many possible solutions 

  • Constraints and resources change over time (dynamic)

  • Solutions are not “right/wrong” but rather “better/worse”

2. I=PAT Equation  

  • I = environmental impact = Population Affluence Tech impact 

    • I is measured in Kilotons of oil-equivalents 

    • A: (per person consumption of goods)

    • T( kilotons of equivalent oil / GDP ) 

    • Or  Ipad equation, Kaya equation 

3. Societal Solutions [NC] 

a. Cultural taboos 

b. Protected areas 

c. Regulation 

4. Individual Solutions [NC] 

a. Responsible consumption 

b. Role of ecolabels 

5. Business Solutions [NC] 

a. Wise management and regenerative agriculture 

b. Dematerialization and increased efficiency 

c. Circular economy