In-Depth Notes on Medical Negligence and Legal Frameworks
Hypothetical Scenario of Medical Negligence
Dr. Solomon operated on Alicia’s spine.
Alicia became paralyzed from the chest down after the procedure.
Key questions for a negligence claim:
What must Alicia (or her lawyer) prove?
Who can Alicia sue?
What is the time limit for bringing her claim?
Framework of Medical Negligence
Key Components:
Duty of Care: Obligation of healthcare providers to their patients.
Breach of Duty: Failure to meet the required standard of care.
Causation: Link between breach and injury.
Injury/Damages: Proof of actual injury is required for a claim.
Duty of Care
Defined within tort law, relevant to all medical practitioners.
Example Case: Barnett v Kensington & Chelsea Management Committee (1969) - established duty of care.
Breach of Duty
Assessment of the physician's conduct against the standard of care expected.
Hunter v Hanley (1955): Experts' differing opinions do not automatically imply negligence, rather whether a reasonable doctor would have acted similarly.
Bolam Test (Bolam v Friern Hospital Management Committee, 1957): A doctor is not negligent if following a practice accepted by a responsible body of medical opinion.
Stages of a Medical Transaction
Diagnosis
Guided by the Bolam Test but incorporating case law (e.g., Maynard v West Midlands HA (1985)).
Pre-treatment (Risk Disclosure)
Treatment/Surgery
Follow Bolam Test with further elaborations (e.g., Whitehouse v Jordan, 1981).
Causation in Medical Negligence
But For Test: Establish causation by questioning if an injury would have occurred 'but for' the defendant’s actions.
Case Study: Barnett v Chelsea & Kensington HMC (1968) identifies that the burden of proof lies on the claimant.
Legal Framework of Liability
Injury, Duty, Breach, Causation are critical components in establishing claims in medical negligence.
Who is Sued?
Primary liability typically rests with:
The Doctor: Direct responsible party.
The Doctor’s Employer: Under vicarious liability, if actions occurred within their employment.
Limitation Period
Under the Limitation Act 1980, negligence claims must be filed within 3 years from when the injury occurred (or was discovered).
Special provisions apply for children; time starts upon turning 18.
Key Points for Alicia's Hypothetical Claim
Establish the framework of liability: injury, duty, breach, causation.
Apply the Bolam/Bolitho test for diagnosis and treatment.
Understand vicarious liability implications for lawsuits against employers.
Note the 3-year limitation period for filing a claim.
NHS Clinical Negligence Claims Overview
Between 2019 and 2024, claims have fluctuated yearly across various categories, including emergency medicine, obstetrics, orthopaedic surgery, and general surgery.
Academic Assessment Brief
Exam Format: 4000-word assessment worth 100%.
Answer two essay questions. Include OSCOLA referencing.
Submissions due by 22nd April before 1 PM; ensure to follow all guidelines for formatting and submission.
.