Anthropology: Systems of Exchange, Social Organization, and Religious Belief
Reciprocity and Systems of Exchange
- General Reciprocity Rules: Reciprocity generally involves an exchange of gifts between parties. In certain contexts, it must be given within a specific time period. This is considered a "freely given" gift.
- Parent-Child Example: A common example of reciprocity is the relationship between parents and children. Children receive gifts from parents, and while parents do not expect a return in the form of goods or services, there is an expectation of love or participation in gift-giving ceremonies.
- Potlatch Reciprocity: In groups like the Northwest Coast Indians, if one receives a gift at a potlatch, they are expected to return something of equal importance and value within a definite time period. Failure to do so results in a loss of face and status within the group.
- Negative Reciprocity: This occurs when two partners engage in a mutual exchange purely for the value of the goods themselves. Each party attempts to maximize their gain while minimizing what they give up.
* It does not imply any bond between individuals or a guarantee that the reciprocity will be repeated.
* Barter: The typical form of negative reciprocity. It involves the exchange of goods without money or symbolic value. Parties higgle or bargain until an agreement is reached.
* Silent Barter: An arrangement where parties do not meet face-to-face. Goods are left in a designated place; if the exchange is satisfactory, the parties take the provided goods and leave their own. An example is the exchange between Pygmies of the Ituri Forest and their Bantu agricultural neighbors (exchanging forest products for clothes, metal blades, knives, spear points, and agricultural food).
* Systematic Barter: A series of individual bartering episodes that move a product across long distances. For example, in the Middle Ages, silk from China was passed to India for spices, then through various traders until reaching Europe.
Redistribution and Market Economies
- Redistribution: This system exists in societies with a central authority, such as a chief or king.
* The authority has the legal power to collect surplus goods.
* The surplus is redistributed for public purposes or according to the ruler's will.
* It is based on inequality between the central authority (who determines the flow of goods) and the commoners.
- Market Economy: Characterized by several defining factors beyond just supply and demand.
* Money: The use of a symbolic substitute of value with a known worth.
* Prices: A general list of prices allows buyers and sellers to know the approximate value of goods (e.g., knowing that $1 cannot buy a house or a Cadillac).
* Multiple Partners: To be a true market, there must be multiple potential buyers and sellers. Without this choice, the system is a monopoly.
* Monopolies and Mergers: Increased consolidation (mergers) reduces consumer choice. For example, the merger between Sprint and AT&T offers no benefit to the consumer, as less choice allows for arbitrary price increases.
Social Organizations: Bands, Tribes, Chiefdoms, and States
- Composite Band: A collection of separate simple bands or extended family groups that join together temporarily for specific goals.
* Example: Plains Indians (Sioux, Cheyenne, Comanche) joined into composite bands to hunt seasonally available large game like buffalo.
* Hunting Techniques: They utilized more "hands on deck" to drive buffalo into box canyons, corrals, or water to dispatch them.
- Tribe: A group of horticultural or herding villages connected by "sodalities" (unifying factors).
* Sodalities: Includes shared language, religious rituals, common defense, and marriage rituals. Some societies have men’s or women’s societies that span multiple villages.
* Leadership: Informal and relatively equal. It may include councils or clan elders on a rotating basis. Examples include the Nuer, the Dinka, and the Cherokee.
* Cheyenne Warrior Societies: A specific sodality responsible for policing buffalo hunts to ensure no one started early; they could administer physical punishment to non-cooperative individuals.
- Chiefdom: An unequal society with ranking and status differences between chiefs/kings and the rest of the population.
* Structure: Includes a small noble class (relatives/associates) who serve as the redistributing center.
* Authority: The chief is the ultimate governing and legal authority in all matters.
- State: A large population group, sometimes reaching 1,000,000,000 people.
* Characteristics: Centralized governing/legal authority, highly productive agricultural/trading economy, and significant wealth and power differentiation.
* Bureaucracy: A group of administrators beholden to the central government who apportion public policies/benefits and determine eligibility.
* Economic Interaction: Even in communist countries where the government sets internal prices, they typically use market economic exchanges when dealing with other countries.
Detailed Study of the Potlatch
- Definition: A ceremonial, ritualized gift-giving ceremony between chiefs and followers, practiced by Northwest Coast Indians (such as the Salish).
- Subsistence Context: These groups were primarily sea mammal, clam, and shellfish eaters.
- Function: Chiefs commanded their groups to produce surplus goods, which were stored specifically for the potlatch.
- Balanced Reciprocity: Other chiefs and their people were invited to dance, sing, and receive gifts. Recipients were obligated to return a potlatch of equal or greater value within a specific time.
- Economic Insurance: The potlatch served as a "bank" for surplus; a chief who gives away goods now can rely on another chief’s potlatch for supplies later in times of need.
Mythology and the Origin of Cosmos
- Myth Definition: A sacred story believed to be true by those who share it. It accounts for the origin of the cosmos, social institutions, values, and behaviors, often involving culture heroes and gods.
- Creation ex nihilo: Creation "out of nothing." A deity brings the universe into existence through creative thought and words (e.g., "Let there be light").
- Cosmological Myths: Myths that account for the major physical parts of the universe (planets, sun, moon, stars, and Earth).
- Etiological Myths: Myths accounting for secondary phenomena.
* Examples: The origin of night, the creation of light versus darkness, or how death entered the world.
* The Message That Failed: A specific etiological myth type (e.g., the rabbit/hare and the turtle/tortoise) explaining the origin of mortality.
- Chartering Myths: Myths used to justify existing social institutions, particularly those that are unequal or discriminatory.
* Trobriand Islands: The myth of the pig clan justifies its status as the chiefly clan based on the behavior of clan totems when they emerged from the earth.
- Acculturation/Enculturation Myths: Myths meant to teach or reinforce critical values and beliefs.
* Phaethon (Greek Myth): Teaches the danger of hubris (arrogance). Phaethon’s failure to recognize human limits led to disaster.
* Jesus Stories: Parables like the Good Samaritan or the story of the adulterous woman serve as enculturation myths within Christianity.
Rituals: Types and Functions
- Ritual Definition: A stereotyped or repetitive sequence of acts, behaviors, object manipulations, and words carried out in a specific place to influence supernatural beings.
- Ideological Rituals: Meant to confirm basic values, customs, and beliefs to ensure social stasis (stability).
- Rites of Passage: Rituals that change an individual’s status in the community (e.g., baptism, funeral, marriage).
* Transition: Moves a person from one state (e.g., single) to another (e.g., married). The community acknowledges this change through events like wedding receptions.
- Rites of Social Intensification: Rituals meant to recommit individuals to group values.
* Simple: Pledge of Allegiance or saluting the flag.
* Complex: Memorial Day or Independence Day celebrations intended to reinforce beliefs in freedom and democracy.
- Salvation Rituals: Rituals intended to give an individual an increased sense of well-being or to "save the ego."
* Possession Rituals: Practiced in Voodoo; the individual hosts a god's consciousness, leading to increased self-confidence as the center of community attention.
* Pentecostalism: Speaking in tongues (Assembly of God) makes the individual the center of the group's attention, believed to be inspired by the Holy Spirit.
* Mysticism: Using meditation to merge with the consciousness of the universe to achieve centeredness and calmness.
Anthropology Vocabulary Review
- Cultural Anthropology: The comparative study of human customs, traditions, beliefs, and values in modern societies.
- Participant Observer: The research method where anthropologists participate in and observe the activities of the group they study.
- Ethnography: A long, written account of a society’s customs, traditions, beliefs, and values resulting from fieldwork.
- Archaeology: The study of past human societies through artifacts (tools, hearth sites, clothing, weapons) located in the strata of the earth.
- Ethnocentrism: The belief that one’s own culture is superior to all others. It often manifests as negative assessments of different hairstyles, languages, or clothing (e.g., turbans).
- Cultural Relativity: The anthropological stance that all cultures are equally valid responses to the environments in which they evolved.
- Linguistics: The study of language across different societies.
- Culture vs. Society: Culture is the learned behaviors and objects of a group; a society is the group of people sharing that culture in a specific place/time.
- Subculture: A group within a larger culture that shares main features but has unique customs.
- Emic vs. Etic:
* Emic: The viewpoint of the native person.
* Etic: The viewpoint of the outsider (anthropologist) trying to understand or judge a custom.
- subsistence and Population Control:
* Food Foraging: Hunting and gathering (Bands).
* Minimum Body Fat: In hunter-gatherer societies, women with body fat below a certain threshold (approximately 2%) have difficulty ovulating, which serves as a natural form of population control.
* Food Producing: Agricultural societies (Sedentism).
* Horticulture: Use of hand tools (hoes, digging sticks) in slash-and-burn/slidden agriculture.
* Intensive Agriculture: Uses improved techniques like plowing, irrigation, terracing, and fertilizing.
- Herding and Pastoralism:
* Animal Husbandry: Breeding and caring for animals.
* Pastoral Nomadism: Movement of herds on a seasonal basis (Transhumance).
* Sami People (Reindeer Herders):
* Extensive Herding: Traditional transhumance (seasonal north-south movement) now aided by snowmobiles.
* Intensive Herding: Keeping herds in fenced areas year-round with supplemental feed.
* Mongols: Horse-riding pastoral nomads led by Genghis Khan in the 12th and 13th centuries.